Actually, I really really really don't think people hodl much in this space. As far as my personal experience tells me, the more people say hodl, the less they've actually done so. It's just the mentality they have to tell others to hodl so they can sell at the high.
Like you said, the signs are when they start blaming other things/people/companies for manipulation but they don't complain when the same people are manipulating to make prices go up.
All those who are asking to hold, really they are holding? maybe or not, two types of investors are common in cryptocurrency, one is the whale investor who can manipulate the entire market. Another is the general investor who moves depending on the market conditions. Those who say to hold they are part of the general investors. Actually whale don't say anything they just take the opportunity and do their thing. Whale investors have already started their holdings while ordinary investors are forced to sell for various reasons.
Definitely I think you're missing at least one other type of "investor". There is also the speculator who thinks he's investing but really he is gambling. Unfortunately I believe this to be the biggest portion of everyone active in this space.
Then, there is the other type. Who are noisy and active on this forum and social media. Talk all about holding and Bitcoin adoption and what not, but actually they don't even use or buy Bitcoin. Just talk a lot on signature campaigns to get their bounty of altcoins. Want to see them? Just look at this thread lol
It may seem as if there is irony, hypocrisy and various internal contradictions with other members that appears to be gambling rather than investing and telling others to do something different from what they are doing, yet the situation of people are different.
Each of us should be attempting to tailor our bitcoin investment approach to our own circumstances, and actual view of bitcoin's anticipated price performance as compared to where it is at is ONLY one of the factors, and may well not be a big factor in terms of inabilities to really assess it in the short-term anyhow, so in that regard, the other factors become much more important.. and maybe I should just list them out in order to be more specific to my references.
Individual considerations include but are not limited to cashflow, other investments, view of bitcoin as compared with other investments, timeline, risk tolerance, and time, skills, goals (investment/lifestyle targets) and abilities to strategize, plan, research and learn along the way including tweaking strategies from time to time to consider trading, reallocating, use of leverage and/or financial instruments.
Accordingly, if I have been into bitcoin for nearly 9 years, and I spent my first 1-3 years building my bitcoin position, then I have way more flexibility than a newbie because my average cost per BTC may well be below $1k, so even if the BTC price drops from $69k to $19.5k, I could be telling the newbie to be buying the whole time, even though I might be buying and selling.. depending on other considerations that i have. I am not dumping on them merely because I might be selling when I am telling them to buy. If the newbie has no bitcoin or very little bitcoin, but s/he has a lot of value (an investment portfolio) in other assets, then it is quite likely the best thing for them to "need" to get into bitcoin, when I am either flexible or even considering that it is o.k. for me to reallocate which might even mean that I am selling at times that would be great investment prices for anyone who is either a no coiner or a low coiner.
I think that part of the reason that in the real world, I am almost always giving similar advice (to the extent that I would concede it to be advice) to no coiners/low coiners no matter the BTC price is because I am frequently talking to no coiners/low coiners, and the advice is to get started and figure out how to get some kind of a BTC allocation, and then once they spend years establishing their BTC accumulation levels, then it may well (or at least should) become more clear how to manage that allocation and figure out if more allocation is needed, are they in a maintenance stage or have they moved into a liquidation stage... and we may see ourselves moving back and forth between these kinds of stages depending on our circumstances an maybe depending on how solidly we are able to build our BTC holdings in order to feel that we have flexibility in regards to what to do.. even though right now, it does not seem like a great time to be selling bitcoin, even if any of us might be in 20x to 100x profits, but we would still have more flexibility to decide whether or not to sell any at these prices if we have been in for a while and we have built our bitcoin stash in order to help to bolster our flexibilities in terms of potentially having a variety of options in terms of choosing which assets to spend from to cover our monthly expenses - whether they are discretionary expenses or not.
Most Bitcoin users are scared because they don't understand the charts with Bitcoin movements. When people start to panic, they choose to sell to release stress. However, they only regretted it once again when Bitcoin started to rebound. Then they will ask if the time is right to buy. After Bitcoin started rebounding and moving forward with a bull run, I saw a lot of questions like this one. But sadly, no one is considering taking shortcuts in the Bitcoin world.
If they don't start learning bitcoin movement charts and understand them, they will never sell on ATH because they are always afraid to make decisions and won't know anything.
They will be confused to determine when to buy and sell because they only follow what the people out there say.
They will also doubt their ability to learn how to trade correctly because they are afraid to start.
We should avoid this and start to learn and keep learning because that is the way to get good skills in trading.
As Ratimov already mentioned, merely because we can identify a price cycle that exists within bitcoin's history, there is no need to contemplate any need to be good at trying to figure out such cycle with such specificity in order to feel some kind of need to get good at trading upon it... except maybe just realizing that it may well not be a good idea to sell when the price goes down, and it maybe be good to buy more and/or to hold in the event that you might not feel that you have enough money to buy more.
In any event learning trading skills would not be a pre-requisite to being good at investing in bitcoin, especially if any of us can hold through the cycles and maybe even buy more along the way, if we have sufficiently long investment timelines, we may be in a much better position by not even attempting to trade and just buying, holding and just accumulating bitcoin through the years and figuring out sometime later down the road if we need to transition from buying and holding to selling and even living off of our longer term investment, which may involve some attempts to time the price, but if we have built enough bitcoin through the years, we might become a bit less price sensitive in terms of how we deal with our BTC holdings.
Yep 4 year cycles are still valid. We’re in the first year of a bear market, 2023 will also be bearish. Expect green shoots of recovery in 2024 as we move towards the halving. Things start to move up Q3 & Q4 of 2024 followed by epic up during 2025.
You might be right, but I would not expect that cycles are as set in stone as you are making them out to be.