This comment is effectively meaningless.
What I have seen so far.
1. One complains about being banned and losing earnings
My service is almost fully automated, if they would of earned anything they would of been paid. They didn't lose any earnings since they were not earned. The complainer also runs a competing ad service.
2. Owner being very cryptic about what the problem was. No clear answer.
This is a private matter not a public one. As stated earlier we do not engage n dispute resolution in public forums since it is none of your armchair business.
3. One correctly claims that if the clicks were "bad" the profit should be returned to the advertiser instead of charity
In your opinion.
4. Owner doesn't have a clear stance to the: "If the clicks were not "bad" then no ban should have occured. If they were bad, then money should be returned to advertiser."
5. Owner draws our attention to the terms of service
6. Owner says "If you don't like the service, don't use it, very simple." effectively meaning OK you got me. Stop using it now you know and let me do the same to others
7. I'm quoting this from the terms "The Service may terminate your access to all or any part of the Website at any time, with or without cause, with or without notice, effective immediately." In my opinion cancelling a service without reason and keeping the earnings, is not at all a rational term.
Let me quote to you Google's Adsense Terms:
Program Participation. Participation in the Program is subject to Google’s prior approval and Your continued compliance with the Program Policies ("Program Policies"), located at
https://www.google.com/adsense/policies, and/or such other URL as Google may provide from time to time.
Google reserves the right to refuse participation to any applicant or participant at any time in its sole discretion.As I stated earlier this policy is industry standard practice.
I find the owner's stance too negative and a bit suspicious. Same with the TOS. Although as far as I'm concerned the above are more than enough for me to stop using the service, I do hope this clears up, to protect others if the service is indeed fraudulent or clear the owner's name, if the service is logical and legitimate.
You allege to have used the service, since I do not have partners forum information it is just as likely you just made that up to spread more FUD.