Pages:
Author

Topic: 2013-06-13 Latest from FinCEN - page 5. (Read 6963 times)

sr. member
Activity: 476
Merit: 250
June 14, 2013, 11:18:45 AM
#50
I suppose if you have built your world around the idea that the government is an evil institution who's secret plans are to get you, then you will read this as evidence of their scheming.

The evidence of their scheming is the fact that the US govt. has just admitted to the largest spying operation, on its own citizens, in history.

Quote
f your problem is that any regulation is unwelcome, then stick to shitcoins.

If you don't like BTC, why do you hang around this forum?
sr. member
Activity: 283
Merit: 250
June 14, 2013, 11:17:13 AM
#49
I'll just say I'm happy I live on the european continent and have no chosen intermediaries of mine having to report to the FINCEN.

I counted the times that child exploitation was mentioned in a speech AGAINST, not for virtual currencies and just left it at that.

There may be people who cannot see what she truly is communicating but I know what my opinion of this american posse move is and it is not "positive in overall" at all. A war and hunt clearly was initiated evenso if it will be impossible as bitcoin is a global hydra.

Finally, with the spying scandal of NSA and bonus with america using rape of enemy territory teenage girls as an experimental weapon which was filmed for study, the integrity of the country is in my book a full round zero.

Simple as that, my BTC0.00000002.
hero member
Activity: 950
Merit: 1001
June 14, 2013, 10:28:46 AM
#48
Think of the children!

Now please keep paying the inflation tax so we can start more wars. And keep paying bankers to evict families out of their bubble-priced homes. And support our drug laws that make medicine expensive and encourage underage drug mules.
legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 2106
June 14, 2013, 10:24:42 AM
#47
I suppose if you have built your world around the idea that the government is an evil institution who's secret plans are to get you, then you will read this as evidence of their scheming.
Here in the real world a document like this is a welcomed addition to the legal precedent. It is the most positive document I have yet seen from a regulatory body. You can all send FinCen a tip from the profit you are about to realize due to this.

If your problem is that any regulation is unwelcome, then stick to shitcoins. Under no legal scenario are you going to be able to make fiat money off bitcoin and not pay taxes. The moment you turn your BTC into $USD you are using THEIR money and must play by THEIR rules.  You can't have it both ways.

+1

with a few sentences they could have done much harm to the bitcoin price, which is in some critical phase anyway. and they know that. if they would want to destroy it anyway, there would be no need for this soft talk. they decided not to destroy/fight/harm it. that is a good sign. there is some protection/pro bitcoin lobbying going on already. maybe the governments actually welcome this new competitor to old-fashioned banking. bankers have lots of political power. sometimes it is not really clear who is the one with more power: bankers or politicians. politicians know that we know and that is emberrassing. if a competitor for the banking moloch is rising, it can be used by politicians as a tool to regain some influence. if there is a power you are struggling with, anything that weakens your opponent is welcome. the higher ranking a politician is the more strategic his views are. going after bitcoin only because some traditonal bankers say so would be a terrible strategy for anyone who feels the power of the bankers daily.

this does not mean that all the bankers hate bitcoin. most of them think in terms of profit. if they can profit with bitcoin they will do so. bookshops sell kindle devices. banks will sell/handle bitcoin. they will be happy to dig their own gaves as long as they get payed for...
legendary
Activity: 974
Merit: 1000
June 14, 2013, 10:16:59 AM
#46
I'm fine with this - but what will it be then? Paypal light?
legendary
Activity: 3066
Merit: 1147
The revolution will be monetized!
June 14, 2013, 09:57:15 AM
#45
I suppose if you have built your world around the idea that the government is an evil institution who's secret plans are to get you, then you will read this as evidence of their scheming.
Here in the real world a document like this is a welcomed addition to the legal precedent. It is the most positive document I have yet seen from a regulatory body. You can all send FinCen a tip from the profit you are about to realize due to this.

If your problem is that any regulation is unwelcome, then stick to shitcoins. Under no legal scenario are you going to be able to make fiat money off bitcoin and not pay taxes. The moment you turn your BTC into $USD you are using THEIR money and must play by THEIR rules.  You can't have it both ways.
hero member
Activity: 854
Merit: 500
June 14, 2013, 09:46:24 AM
#44
translation is get rid of tin foil hats and chinese whispers. read the regulations about FIAT and realise they can only control the FIAT. so get regulated if you are touching FIAT.

bitcoin unaffected, pools unaffected bitcoin-QT unaffected.

....cut

I totally agree with you on this, but the value can't be kept crypto/virtual forever. Merchants have to pay their bills, Miners their energy and so on.

They can pay their bills in Bitcoin. This is why it was so important when Bitcoin suppliers started popping up instead of just sellers, because it's important to have a closed loop without fiat. Supplier -> Reseller -> Customer -> Wages
legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 2106
June 14, 2013, 09:43:50 AM
#43
overall very positive.

they just want to regulate the exchanges.

users/miners unaffected.

I read it a little differently. It sounds like they're claiming a wide territory:

Quote
Those who are intermediaries in the transfer of virtual currencies from one person to another person, or to another location, are money transmitters that must register with FinCEN as MSBs, unless an exception applies.

Right, an intermediary, or a third party is a money transmitter.  A miner moving Bitcoin to an exchange has no middleman.  A miner purchasing goods directly from a store uses no third party.  It's the intermediary that has to register, not the miner.

that is how i understand it. miners get rewarded for the computing power they contribute. the reward is in bitcoin. no third party.
cho
full member
Activity: 155
Merit: 100
Boar with me
June 14, 2013, 09:19:09 AM
#42
I found it disturbing to read a lot of bitcoin-related headlines being cited in this document, while the body doesn't even mention bitcoin.
The message, to my hears, is :
1. "We know this virtual currency thing is mostly about bitcoins"
2. "We will not confirm or deny we are currently working on regulating bitcoin"
Which is quite disturbing to me. Maybe they want to keep all options on the table while they try to find ways to regulate bitcoins behind their "closed doors". Maybe they're not sure if they can or cannot, technically speaking, at this time.
legendary
Activity: 3472
Merit: 1721
June 14, 2013, 08:48:26 AM
#41
translation is get rid of tin foil hats and chinese whispers. read the regulations about FIAT and realise they can only control the FIAT. so get regulated if you are touching FIAT.

just those innovative teentrepreneurs (teenage amateur entrepreneurs)wanting to exchange fiat for other currencies GET REGULATED.

Sure, just provide the money necessary for the paper-shuffling beaurocracy, time wasted (because time = money) and to cover the alternative cost of having less clients.
legendary
Activity: 974
Merit: 1000
June 14, 2013, 08:36:27 AM
#40
translation is get rid of tin foil hats and chinese whispers. read the regulations about FIAT and realise they can only control the FIAT. so get regulated if you are touching FIAT.

bitcoin unaffected, pools unaffected bitcoin-QT unaffected.

....cut

I totally agree with you on this, but the value can't be kept crypto/virtual forever. Merchants have to pay their bills, Miners their energy and so on.
legendary
Activity: 4214
Merit: 4458
June 14, 2013, 08:26:52 AM
#39
translation is get rid of tin foil hats and chinese whispers. read the regulations about FIAT and realise they can only control the FIAT. so get regulated if you are touching FIAT.

bitcoin unaffected, pools unaffected bitcoin-QT unaffected.

just those innovative teentrepreneurs (teenage amateur entrepreneurs)wanting to exchange fiat for other currencies GET REGULATED.

thier defineition of virtual currency is the difital database balance which resemble FIAT. such as 10.00 which can be cashed out as $10 bank note.. not facebook credits. world of warcraft gold, linden's, bitcoin, litecoin.

so chill out guys gavin andressen has no plans to make logging into bitcoin-qt a manditory registration process involving birth certificates. neither do any of the pools or merchants accepting bitcoin.

just the bitcoin-fiat exchanges.
legendary
Activity: 974
Merit: 1000
June 14, 2013, 07:24:00 AM
#38
Quote
However, I would like to close with a challenge to our great innovators: extend your focus to devising creative solutions for preventing the abuse of virtual currencies by criminals, such as those who would exploit children. We all stand to benefit from such innovation, and the related transparency and integrity to our financial system.

this is warspeak. The translation is:

Make us a proposal about the conditions of your surrender.
hero member
Activity: 496
Merit: 500
June 14, 2013, 06:48:23 AM
#37
Office of Terrorism? Isn't that just CIA?

LOL

Here is my theory (it was revealed to me in a dream). They want to amass more bitcoins via market manipulation err regulation so that they can fund more terrorism (through the Office of Terrorism of course) so that they can in turn push for more regulation. In the mean time they want complete records of MtGox database so that they can track down large bitcoin holders around the world and extort their bitcoins by fabricating fake sex charges against them (http://youtube.com/watch?v=hl4NlA97GeQ at 5:07). In order to achieve their ends they pretend to look as friendly as possible and all wear smiley shirts (google George Carlin smiley shirts, http://youtube.com/watch?v=eWhdDypWJPs at 5:50).
legendary
Activity: 1552
Merit: 1047
June 14, 2013, 06:39:21 AM
#36
Quote
Those who are intermediaries in the transfer of virtual currencies from one person to another person, or to another location, are money transmitters that must register with FinCEN as MSBs, unless an exception applies.
Pretty depressing really.

Quote
Liberty Reserve operated as an online money transmitter deliberately designed to avoid regulatory scrutiny and tailored its services to illicit actors looking to launder their ill gotten gains.

According to the allegations contained in a related criminal action brought by the U.S. Department of Justice, those illicit actors included criminal organizations engaged in credit card fraud, identity theft, investment fraud, computer hacking, narcotics trafficking, and most relevant for today’s purposes, child pornography.
The action taken by FinCEN was designed to protect the financial system from the risk posed by Liberty Reserve an online, virtual currency, money transfer system that was conceived and operated specifically to allow and encourage illicit use because of the anonymity it offers.
They could replace "Liberty Reserve" with "Bitcoin" and it would still be just as accurate, more so actually.

Quote
I recently heard a banker say that there is a reason that financial institutions have to obtain licenses. It is a great bestowal of trust that enables banks to be part of the U.S. financial system, to be part of the global financial system.
Yeah... "A great bestowal of trust". It has nothing to do with preventing competition. no no.

The saddest thing about this entire document is that they never mentioned that foreign companies / individuals are exempt as long as they do not deal with US.

Guess nobody is really exempt from the almighty world police of USSA.

Quote
I would like to close with a challenge to our great innovators: extend your focus to devising creative solutions for preventing the abuse of virtual currencies by criminals, such as those who would exploit children
The "think of the children" card, honestly, it's getting kind of old.

Quote
We all stand to benefit from such innovation, and the related transparency and integrity to our financial system
Oh, the sweet sweet irony.
sr. member
Activity: 352
Merit: 250
https://www.realitykeys.com
June 14, 2013, 06:30:03 AM
#35
Wow, that was super interesting and positive. Clearly FinCen is not trying to kill bitcoin. Hell, they seem almost fond of the idea.  Shocked

My theory is that most of the actual humans who work in financial regulation - these are smart people working in a huge, inefficient machine of byzantine rules designed for another era - totally love Bitcoin.

There's a bit in one of the P J O'Rourke books - I think it's Parliament of Whores - when he talks about going to meet the motor vehicle regulators and finding they all loved to tinker with cars, and feeling like he'd gone to the DEA and found them making bongs. I bet loads of people in FinCen and other financial regulators hold Bitcoins, and a lot more think it's awesome.
sr. member
Activity: 298
Merit: 250
Play2Live pre-sale starts on January 25th
June 14, 2013, 06:08:47 AM
#34
overall very positive.

they just want to regulate the exchanges.

users/miners unaffected.

I read it a little differently. It sounds like they're claiming a wide territory:

Quote
Those who are intermediaries in the transfer of virtual currencies from one person to another person, or to another location, are money transmitters that must register with FinCEN as MSBs, unless an exception applies.

Right, an intermediary, or a third party is a money transmitter.  A miner moving Bitcoin to an exchange has no middleman.  A miner purchasing goods directly from a store uses no third party.  It's the intermediary that has to register, not the miner.

Correct, this just means that miners would have to go through an exchange if they want to convert their btc to fiat. However, this seems to mean that even individuals that convert btc to fiat must register as MSB.
vip
Activity: 1316
Merit: 1043
👻
June 14, 2013, 06:06:18 AM
#33
Office of Terrorism? Isn't that just CIA?
member
Activity: 74
Merit: 10
June 14, 2013, 06:01:13 AM
#32
Wow, that was super interesting and positive. Clearly FinCen is not trying to kill bitcoin. Hell, they seem almost fond of the idea.  Shocked

legendary
Activity: 1148
Merit: 1018
June 14, 2013, 05:31:09 AM
#31
Wow, this is SO bullish you can't even imagine...

Bitcoin rising Cheesy

Pages:
Jump to: