Topic: [AMD] New AMD RX Graphics Cards of 2019 - RX 5700 / XT, RX 600 - page 14. (Read 23318 times)
Can anyone mine cryptonightgpu with the 5700XT version?
new drivers guys 19.7.3
has any one test it
has any one test it
Seems like whattomine is stating that ryo is the most profitable coin to mine at the moment for most Nvidia cards.
the hashrate for cryptonightgpu on a nvidia 2060 is comparable to amd 5700 at the moment
the hashrate for cryptonightgpu on a nvidia 2060 is comparable to amd 5700 at the moment
Compiled all my main kernels... well, need to say bye-bye to writing any code using OpenCL from now xD Results are bad for complex kernels and playing in game "compiler, please, don't spill so many registers" is not fun anymore.
what do you mean The only way your going to get any good performance out of this architecture is with ASM kernels...which people are already running privately of course
Compiled all my main kernels... well, need to say bye-bye to writing any code using OpenCL from now xD Results are bad for complex kernels and playing in game "compiler, please, don't spill so many registers" is not fun anymore.
what do you mean
Compiled all my main kernels... well, need to say bye-bye to writing any code using OpenCL from now xD Results are bad for complex kernels and playing in game "compiler, please, don't spill so many registers" is not fun anymore.
Can you compile any of your CL kernels for 5700 ? so that they at least work 
Yep, and compute power of this card is pretty good, close to Vega56/Vega64 with lower power consumption(can say about simple blake2b and bmw512 speeds) 
But... I don't understand this random nature of how it works xD Here some mind blowers:- first time I see loop not unrolled: the optimizer was unable to perform the requested transformation... for some kernels
- in some cases compiler just throwing error when structure data types used and stop compile kernel
- simple sha256 kernel fails with AMD HSA Code Object loading failed... wtf %)
Yes, computing part should be even faster than on Vega64, or at least this is what the numbers say
RDNA looks good on 'paper', time will show is this the case in practice.I don't have a 5700 card but when i tried to fix some of my kernels blindly, and compile them offline, the compiler was so friendly that it just said 3 errors found, but it won't tell me what are those
Can you compile any of your CL kernels for 5700 ? so that they at least work
Yep, and compute power of this card is pretty good, close to Vega56/Vega64 with lower power consumption(can say about simple blake2b and bmw512 speeds) But... I don't understand this random nature of how it works xD Here some mind blowers:- first time I see loop not unrolled: the optimizer was unable to perform the requested transformation... for some kernels
- in some cases compiler just throwing error when structure data types used and stop compile kernel
- simple sha256 kernel fails with AMD HSA Code Object loading failed... wtf %)
Yes, computing part should be even faster than on Vega64, or at least this is what the numbers say
RDNA looks good on 'paper', time will show is this the case in practice.I don't have a 5700 card but when i tried to fix some of my kernels blindly, and compile them offline, the compiler was so friendly that it just said 3 errors found, but it won't tell me what are those
Can you compile any of your CL kernels for 5700 ? so that they at least work
Yep, and compute power of this card is pretty good, close to Vega56/Vega64 with lower power consumption(can say about simple blake2b and bmw512 speeds) But... I don't understand this random nature of how it works xD Here some mind blowers:- first time I see loop not unrolled: the optimizer was unable to perform the requested transformation... for some kernels
- in some cases compiler just throwing error when structure data types used and stop compile kernel; upd: found a problem, it's "tricky" pointer logic, not structure data types
- simple sha256 kernel fails with AMD HSA Code Object loading failed... wtf %)
Got my own 5700 XT and what can I say... drivers are f*cking disaster %) They have finally implemented volatile keyword correctly for OpenCL, this is some kind of "plus", but this removed possibility to control register allocation a bit while compiling OpenCL kernels. reqd_work_group_size broken now, in some cases it can just crash compiler with error "ran out of registers". Memory operations... 10x times slower than on RX series ) AMD once again made dumb as hell OpenCL compiler, so developers should switch to GCN/RDNA assembler(or Vulkan at least), and showed how bad their driver team no matter what for so many years xD
Can you compile any of your CL kernels for 5700 ? so that they at least work
Well, that's a bad news 
Got my own 5700 XT and what can I say... drivers are f*cking disaster %) They have finally implemented volatile keyword correctly for OpenCL, this is some kind of "plus", but this removed possibility to control register allocation a bit while compiling OpenCL kernels. reqd_work_group_size broken now, in some cases it can just crash compiler with error "ran out of registers". Memory operations... 10x times slower than on RX series ) AMD once again made dumb as hell OpenCL compiler, so developers should switch to GCN/RDNA assembler(or Vulkan at least), and showed how bad their driver team no matter what for so many years xD
My kilowatt wall meter said around 150w or 170w stock. I'm not too good at undervolting so I used the wattman auto undervolt template to get to 150w. doesn't seem to effect the hashrate too bad.
the memory clock can be increased to raise the hashrate to 1750h/s but the watts gets around to 230w at that point
Use the Afterburner instead, enable voltage control and you can start to play with undervolting and OC.the memory clock can be increased to raise the hashrate to 1750h/s but the watts gets around to 230w at that point
Are you sure that you adjusted only memory clocks? Higher memory clocks will need some extra power, but definitely not 80W more...
Ill take another look when I get home today.
I believe I took the mem clock from 1750 to 1850 and thats when the jump happened. Ill do another test with afterburner instead and see if i get different results.
there was a video of few + rx5700 doing ~1600-1700 and you say the same for one without screens not info, and just troll
thats my 5700
Looks pretty good.
How much power?
My Vega 56 do 1800 each but are fairly power hungry.
My kilowatt wall meter said around 150w or 170w stock. I'm not too good at undervolting so I used the wattman auto undervolt template to get to 150w. doesn't seem to effect the hashrate too bad.
the memory clock can be increased to raise the hashrate to 1750h/s but the watts gets around to 230w at that point
What drivers and settings are you using in your config? I have tried using xmr stak a few times in the past week and have not had any success getting it to mine at all on a 5700 XT.
*hmmm I noticed GPUz has you on 19.7.1 and I'm on 19.7.2
I downloaded the latest drivers from AMD for the rx 5700 card.
I used XMR STAK auto config for crypto gpu and it started to hash around 1300 h/s
I then went into the AMD config file and doubled the thread to 2. which increased the hashrate to around 1600h/s.
Im surprised the XT is not functioning the exact same way or better.
after new lower prices this is not a bad variant i guess
there was a video of few + rx5700 doing ~1600-1700 and you say the same for one without screens not info, and just troll
thats my 5700
Looks pretty good.
How much power?
My Vega 56 do 1800 each but are fairly power hungry.
My kilowatt wall meter said around 150w or 170w stock. I'm not too good at undervolting so I used the wattman auto undervolt template to get to 150w. doesn't seem to effect the hashrate too bad.
the memory clock can be increased to raise the hashrate to 1750h/s but the watts gets around to 230w at that point
What drivers and settings are you using in your config? I have tried using xmr stak a few times in the past week and have not had any success getting it to mine at all on a 5700 XT.
*hmmm I noticed GPUz has you on 19.7.1 and I'm on 19.7.2
My kilowatt wall meter said around 150w or 170w stock. I'm not too good at undervolting so I used the wattman auto undervolt template to get to 150w. doesn't seem to effect the hashrate too bad.
the memory clock can be increased to raise the hashrate to 1750h/s but the watts gets around to 230w at that point
Use the Afterburner instead, enable voltage control and you can start to play with undervolting and OC.the memory clock can be increased to raise the hashrate to 1750h/s but the watts gets around to 230w at that point
Are you sure that you adjusted only memory clocks? Higher memory clocks will need some extra power, but definitely not 80W more...
there was a video of few + rx5700 doing ~1600-1700 and you say the same for one without screens not info, and just troll
thats my 5700
Looks pretty good.
How much power?
My Vega 56 do 1800 each but are fairly power hungry.
My kilowatt wall meter said around 150w or 170w stock. I'm not too good at undervolting so I used the wattman auto undervolt template to get to 150w. doesn't seem to effect the hashrate too bad.
the memory clock can be increased to raise the hashrate to 1750h/s but the watts gets around to 230w at that point
Looks pretty good.
How much power?
My Vega 56 do 1800 each but are fairly power hungry.
He said 150W at wall. GPU-Z can't probably measure much more, it not even shows clocks. They added RX 5700 only preliminary.How much power?
My Vega 56 do 1800 each but are fairly power hungry.
Could you post more details maybe config? I've added your post to OP. Thx.
BTW Afterburner can set RX 5700 voltages, so if you didn't play with voltages already, you can do it with that.
https://www.guru3d.com/files-details/msi-afterburner-beta-download.html
there was a video of few + rx5700 doing ~1600-1700 and you say the same for one without screens not info, and just troll
thats my 5700
Looks pretty good.
How much power?
My Vega 56 do 1800 each but are fairly power hungry.
Looks like i won't be able to fix anything without having a card
Btw, what clocks and settings on a V56 for 1800h/s on Xmr Stak?
there was a video of few + rx5700 doing ~1600-1700 and you say the same for one without screens not info, and just troll
thats my 5700
Looks pretty good.
How much power?
My Vega 56 do 1800 each but are fairly power hungry.
Jump to: