Well well, good thing I saw this and got some advice from a friend who is a Muslim. Most of what is written next is thanks to him so I cannot take credit for it....
Last year Halal Coin came on to the scene making all the right noises but it sank without a trace:
Halal Coin
https://www.halal-coin.org/Will
this Halal Exchange go the same way as
that Halal Coin?
Any exchange claiming to be Shariah compliant is no more no less Shariah compliant than most other exchanges.
It seems people behind Adab Solutions are trying to corner the Islamic investors market by promoting Shariah as its unique selling point but there is nothing more or less Shariah compliance in its format than that of most exchanges out there.
The process is virtually the same regardless of which non-FIAT exchanges people use and regardless of which FIAT based exchanges are used.
Non-FIAT exchange:Customer sends crypto to the exchange and then converts to other crypto, buys/sells and withdraws to his desktop/mobile wallet
FIAT exchange:
Customer sends crypto to the exchange and then converts to other crypto, buys/sells and withdraws to his desktop/mobile wallet
orCustomer sends crypto to the exchange and then converts to other crypto, buys/sells and withdraws cash to his bank account
- Where is the Shariah compliant part in any of the above processes?
- Where is the non-Shariah compliant part in any of the above processes?Will the OP actually explain which part of the processes of the exchange make it Shariah compliant by being
Halal (acceptable practice in Islam, permissible) and which part of the processes of the exchange make it
Haraam (not allowed or acceptable in Islam, forbidden)
Until or unless I see the evidence provided by from the "team" behind this exchange, from what I see the people behind this exchange are opportunistic trying to pull in investors from the Muslim community by not explaining to them exactly how their core business is Shariah compliant.
Please can somebody from the team post back here explaining the following:
- Which branch of Islam does each and every Muslim on the board/team of this exchange belong to (Sunni or Shia or anything else and which denomination of those branches) so it will allow investors to know if the people behind the project are in fact Muslim sharing the same interpretation of Qur'an and Hadith as investors or those that claim to be Muslim but have nothing about Islam within them. Which school of thought (Maliki, Hanifi, Sha'fi, Hanbali) does each and every board member and team member that claims to be Muslim actually follow? Or do they follow some other school of thought?
- Would you expect a Sunni Muslim following say for example the teaching of Imam Malik to invest in a project that is operated by your "team" if you are all Mirza Qadiani followers? Please write your reply. What are the "team" doing to make checks that the investment coming in will be from halal sources?
- If your "team" consists of for example Sunni Muslim following the teaching of Imam Abu Hanifa will you accept investment from followers of Mirza Qadiani? Please write your reply. If you accept the investment will your project remain Shariah compliant? What are the "team" doing to make checks that the investment coming in will be from halal sources?
- Why is the "team" having an ICO without making it clear that the project will never be Shariah compliant if the investors are using Haraam money to fund this project? What are the "team" doing to make checks that the investment coming in will be from halal sources? Please explain if accepting money from those sources will make this project anti-Shariah?
- What checks are the "team" making to ensure that those people who advocate harm against the Muslim community and promote Islamophobia are not funding this project? Please explain if accepting money from those sources will make this project anti-Shariah?I can ask more questions to show you will not be Shariah compliant but please do reply to the above questions and prove me wrong, I will be the first to take my hat of to you and congratulate you.
Please also explain if your Bounty program will be Halal and Shariah compliant, if it will be please explain how? What will make it Halal. Thank you