[Constructive criticism]
GOOD! though I don't agree with you, but let's debate it a bit.
And let me make the point that I am essentially supporting BURST, but pointing out why it seems to be failing right now. That's why I'm thinking about new ideas to implement in coins.
I fully disagree with constant hashrate block reward. Gold has value because it is hard to mine, and is limited. It also has physical value. USD, well, it has no value other than perceived value. It can only come from one source.
Gold has value because there's a demand for it. The limited supply obviously comes into play, but without the demand it would be worthless. I think there are many things that are hard to get, and yet they have no value.
With the gold example, take into account that you need to spend some money on security, it's not like you can have a ton of gold in your living room, tell everybody about it, and have expectations not to get killed. With BTC, that security comes from the miners, it's really bizarre to me how it can be provided for just the 25 btc reward.
BTC is worth a lot because of the fact that it is limited.
Are you certain of this? My view is that it has value because people use it to transfer money, somewhat anonymously. ...(to buy drugs
, which is a billion dollar business)
Wow man, it's not like with wheat at all. Wheat will always take up a few square cm's of soil to grow. You simply can't just make the wheat more compact. It requires effort and good weather to grow. Also, it is used up. Whenever we grow wheat, we eat it.
Well, mining blocks takes TeraBytes of good hard drives, you simply cant make them any more compact (not overnight anyway), and you need a bit of good luck with the deadlines too.
Using it up, I already made that point. Burn coins when tx is made. Burn even more coins when old inputs are used in transactions. Like wheat, I don't think 100 year old wheat is any good. lol.
BTC, well, every btc out there is still there. It will never disappear. Constant hashes block reward is useless IMO.
BTC may just not always be there, if nobody's mining 51% attack will happen, and kaboom. That's why we have to give incentive to miners. I am truly amazed that mining pools didn't start raising the tx fees for which they process. Somehow mining might still be profitable. I really don't get it, I wouldn't invest in ASIC or cex.io shares etc.
Burst has only mined 1/4 of all coins, but I do agree that perhaps 5% a month is not a perfect amount(I think the main thing is 10k was a little high to start).
Kinda pump-and-dumpish. Though not the worst out there
Yea with btc that's why it's good, because it decreases a lot more slowly. But the theory was that it would drive prices up and increase tx fees. At least the part with tx fees we didnt really see. But ultimately this deflationary model was good for advertising, get all the trader-invester-gamblers in there, get the ball rolling. But then that was with bitcoin, maybe we can do better nowadays.
BTC's biggest flaw is that it is ASIC prone. There is nothing worng with asics, but the thing is, every new asic makes an old asic useless. This is wasteful. Burst however, nothing like that(you have already expressed that the algo is good, so won't dwell here).
the best take on an anti-gpu solution I've seen so far. most gpu-resistant coins go to hell when gpu miner is released. even at like 4x advantage. it's like the gpu guys already are in the hole after the asics came, and then the scrypt asics came, and now they must be stealing electricity, and they already have the hardware, otherwise they'd be losing money on it really.
As for it "Just being an alt"....couldn't agree less. Burst has alot of features which could see it as the standard way of trading all over the world. Mixing I think would be easy with an AT, and it would be trustless. No need for another coin.
The AE helps Burst to have a consistent value, as it provides a sort of reserve for the coin. A company listed can't be removed, and so provides always buy pressure. I believe we should market our AE way better.
Forgive my ignorance, what is AT, AE, and how exactly would you implement trustless mixing, have you thought about it? As I suggested earlier, BURST with trustless mixing would be something of my liking, I'd code that, but how exactly do we do it?
I will probably built a payment processor for Burst soon....if no one else beats me to it, and Crowetic and I are brainstorming ideas on an online store to accept Burst, but in a way which would not require that we back every purchase(to prevent dumping). If we achieve this there will be a good reason to hold and spend Burst. There are a lot of products which could easily be offered, including web design, graphic design etc. (shouldn't be too hard finding people to work for the store).
ATM i suppose I just am worried that there are so few AE options, which causes a problem with trust. I suggest everyone with a good idea list an asset for it. NXT hasn't got an issue with this, they've got quite a few lovely assets(even coffee shops
)
[/criticism]
Now people, let's push burst forward!!! Rather than worry about price, rather push new features, make use of our ae and smart contracts, and give donations to the devs and PR efforts.
P.S. A USD exchange would be damn kewl, perhaps a little early, but burst has everything it needs to take over btc, with some of the new features which are coming ready to take over USD as well.
P.S.S The HardStaker thing is pretty kewl, as long as there is an easy backup ofption(didn't read a lot sorry), but if i can easily hand a freind a little card(encrypted) which he can then look after for me in case my place burns down, i'd be damn happy
Well, what I dislike about burst is the lack of anonymity
I might be wrong about the deflationary model, but I guess we should go back to this discussion a few month later. That's my prediction, that's why I'm thinking of ways to mitigate the problem, otherwise I'd just mine it and wouldn't worry about a thing.
PS: In a way you're right about wheat, these coins more like marijuana... my bad
PS(2): better yet. you grow WEED, you get HASH