Topic: Bitmain's Released Antminer S9, World's First 16nm Miner Ready to Order - page 291. (Read 531298 times)
July 01, 2016, 01:05:34 PM
Why does B1-B1 state +7% at the wall efficiency, but B5 state 1,172w + 12%? If true, then even at the lower hash rate it's less efficient?
July 01, 2016, 12:02:21 PM
notlist3d did some testing on a bunch of pools with a B1.
http://s100.photobucket.com/user/notlist3d/library/S9?sort=3&page=1
I went back and looked and antpool hashrate was slightly better than some of the others but not drastically and certainly not 20%.
http://s100.photobucket.com/user/notlist3d/library/S9?sort=3&page=1
I went back and looked and antpool hashrate was slightly better than some of the others but not drastically and certainly not 20%.
I did a decent amount of testing different pools for fun to see if any difference. During it I tested F2, Antpool, Kano.is, BTCC, Slush.
Just to compare two here is Antpool (1 day):
Here is Kano.is (2 day)
So when I tested I got 2 pretty close numbers. So I wont speculate about "ASIC boost" as I just do not have any knowledge about it. I can say I did quite a few different pools from big to small, very different in my eyes, and never got near a 20 percent difference. I welcome others to compare and see what they get to. I think you will have same result's.
July 01, 2016, 11:42:39 AM
notlist3d did some testing on a bunch of pools with a B1.
http://s100.photobucket.com/user/notlist3d/library/S9?sort=3&page=1
I went back and looked and antpool hashrate was slightly better than some of the others but not drastically and certainly not 20%.
http://s100.photobucket.com/user/notlist3d/library/S9?sort=3&page=1
I went back and looked and antpool hashrate was slightly better than some of the others but not drastically and certainly not 20%.
Yes but kano made his remark before s9 went out i believe.. Which could have allowed them time to reflash .. But ya.. its def a shot in the dark. Save a lot of time hassle and speculation if they just open sourced the bmminer code. what they have to hide? And certainly i see no advantage to close sourced unless they have some advantage cooked into it.
Best Regards
d57heinz
July 01, 2016, 11:34:45 AM
notlist3d did some testing on a bunch of pools with a B1.
http://s100.photobucket.com/user/notlist3d/library/S9?sort=3&page=1
I went back and looked and antpool hashrate was slightly better than some of the others but not drastically and certainly not 20%.
http://s100.photobucket.com/user/notlist3d/library/S9?sort=3&page=1
I went back and looked and antpool hashrate was slightly better than some of the others but not drastically and certainly not 20%.
July 01, 2016, 10:53:19 AM
For grins I scp'd a copy of bmminer from my S9 so that I could poke around with it. This is from a stock B3 unit without any firmware upgrade.
I used the strings command and searched for "midstate_change". I could not find it. Although it's clear from reviewing some of the function names that bmminer is a modified cgminer (as many have suspected).
Does anyone know what else to look for to get a sense of whether or not ASIC boost is included in this binary? Maybe someone knows how to disassemble the miner software? I'm a software engineer but have to admit that I'm better at writing code than reversing it.
I used the strings command and searched for "midstate_change". I could not find it. Although it's clear from reviewing some of the function names that bmminer is a modified cgminer (as many have suspected).
Does anyone know what else to look for to get a sense of whether or not ASIC boost is included in this binary? Maybe someone knows how to disassemble the miner software? I'm a software engineer but have to admit that I'm better at writing code than reversing it.
One thing i love about the internet. in time the truth is always revealed. Someone soon will come with this info. What really grinds my gears is that its not like bitmain needs this advantage at all.
Phil that spike could have been them playing with the combination of 16 nm and asic boost.. Was a heck of a spike back then ehh!!
Best Regards
d57heinz
July 01, 2016, 10:29:33 AM
For grins I scp'd a copy of bmminer from my S9 so that I could poke around with it. This is from a stock B3 unit without any firmware upgrade.
I used the strings command and searched for "midstate_change". I could not find it. Although it's clear from reviewing some of the function names that bmminer is a modified cgminer (as many have suspected).
Does anyone know what else to look for to get a sense of whether or not ASIC boost is included in this binary? Maybe someone knows how to disassemble the miner software? I'm a software engineer but have to admit that I'm better at writing code than reversing it.
I used the strings command and searched for "midstate_change". I could not find it. Although it's clear from reviewing some of the function names that bmminer is a modified cgminer (as many have suspected).
Does anyone know what else to look for to get a sense of whether or not ASIC boost is included in this binary? Maybe someone knows how to disassemble the miner software? I'm a software engineer but have to admit that I'm better at writing code than reversing it.
July 01, 2016, 10:17:31 AM
There's a reddit post today indicating that the S9 supports ASIC boost. The thread included the stratum command for enabling it:
Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
Code:
{"id": 0, "method": "mining.midstate_change", "params": ["0x00000004", "0x04000004","0x08000004","0x0C000004"]}Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
yea good luck with any word from them.. All i see from them is announcements of the next batch. No help here whatsoever. But hey there's a new batch come and get it. uffff
Edit and if you think about it.. i remember an article about asic boost being 20% or thereabouts. So take bitmain 12 ths/ miner and add 20 % .. they sell it as a 14 for more btc and then i seen kano post about it only working on antpool.. Looks like there is def credibility behind kano post.!
Best Regards
d57heinz
July 01, 2016, 10:04:58 AM
One of my batch 1 miners had a hard time hashing at 14th. It's since been fixed with a firmware upgrade. One thing I noticed while troubleshooting is it always hashed at around 14 while mining on antpool. I thought it was a fluke until reading about asic boost.
July 01, 2016, 10:02:59 AM
There's a reddit post today indicating that the S9 supports ASIC boost. The thread included the stratum command for enabling it:
Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
Code:
{"id": 0, "method": "mining.midstate_change", "params": ["0x00000004", "0x04000004","0x08000004","0x0C000004"]}Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
Well if the boost is 20% it makes antpool the only choice. a lot of details will be needed for this.
I have 5 s-9's so it mining at antpool makes my 65 th become 78th it will be very hard to not use antpool.
Maybe other pools will need to adopt the boost.
The questions are:
how big is the boost?
what pools have the boost?
can any pool get the boost?
Ahh I see you all catching on to their implementation of "ASIC Boost". Selling a miner that may take a hair cut if this gets hard forked out of btc code which I've seen some talks of already. Maybe Phil this is the boost we keep seeing on the network. Them turning this boost on and off on pools that support it. Just a wild guess:)
Very astute guess, the spike has come and gone since November 2015. You could be right. If true the game is going to change a lot way more then just the ½ing .
Not so sure I like this.
July 01, 2016, 09:59:38 AM
There's a reddit post today indicating that the S9 supports ASIC boost. The thread included the stratum command for enabling it:
Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
Code:
{"id": 0, "method": "mining.midstate_change", "params": ["0x00000004", "0x04000004","0x08000004","0x0C000004"]}Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
Well if the boost is 20% it makes antpool the only choice. a lot of details will be needed for this.
I have 5 s-9's so it mining at antpool makes my 65 th become 78th it will be very hard to not use antpool.
Maybe other pools will need to adopt the boost.
The questions are:
how big is the boost?
what pools have the boost?
can any pool get the boost?
Ahh I see you all catching on to their implementation of "ASIC Boost". Selling a miner that may take a hair cut if this gets hard forked out of btc code which I've seen some talks of already. Maybe Phil this is the boost we keep seeing on the network. Them turning this boost on and off on pools that support it. Just a wild guess:)
July 01, 2016, 09:55:51 AM
There's a reddit post today indicating that the S9 supports ASIC boost. The thread included the stratum command for enabling it:
Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
Code:
{"id": 0, "method": "mining.midstate_change", "params": ["0x00000004", "0x04000004","0x08000004","0x0C000004"]}Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
Well if the boost is 20% it makes antpool the only choice. a lot of details will be needed for this.
I have 5 s-9's so it mining at antpool makes my 65 th become 78th it will be very hard to not use antpool.
Maybe other pools will need to adopt the boost.
The questions are:
how big is the boost?
what pools have the boost?
can any pool get the boost?
July 01, 2016, 09:54:24 AM
Looks like my B4 is on time and at destination facility (MO) for delivery today by FedEx 
Yep I am out for delivery!
So am I
July 01, 2016, 09:50:51 AM
Looks like my B4 is on time and at destination facility (MO) for delivery today by FedEx
Yep I am out for delivery!
July 01, 2016, 09:45:04 AM
Actually, it came FedEx.
July 01, 2016, 09:39:10 AM
There's a reddit post today indicating that the S9 supports ASIC boost. The thread included the stratum command for enabling it:
Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
Code:
{"id": 0, "method": "mining.midstate_change", "params": ["0x00000004", "0x04000004","0x08000004","0x0C000004"]}Apparently it only gets enabled on pools that support it. If there's any truth to this then I assume that ant pool enables ASIC boost.
There's a fair amount of negativity around ASIC boost in general. If the S9 uses patented technology to mine faster for Bitmain or ant pool users than anywhere else then people are not going to be happy.
Not that it will stop anyone from buying. If people are willing to buy without a hope of ROI I doubt that a theoretical philosophical issue will stop them. Bitmain is the only game in town...
Please note that I have no idea if the reddit post is accurate. Probably a good idea to wait before taking out the pitchforks. It would be good to get an official statement from Bitmain, but I doubt that will happen.
July 01, 2016, 09:30:23 AM
Looks like my B4 is on time and at destination facility (MO) for delivery today by FedEx
Congrats to you and all those who used UPS!!!
I have NO IDEA about mine (DHL) -- it shows nothing since it left China other than it passed customs in Cincinnati. No actual arrival scan whatsoever in the US. When I click on a + sign -- I do get the following message:
Quote
Unless there is an adhoc exam or a stop by another regulatory authority the shipment will proceed to delivery
So -- MAYBE -- DHL doesn't update you anymore once it leaves China? I'm cautiously optimistic -- and have everything laid out for a quick install once it gets here -- if...
July 01, 2016, 09:20:35 AM
Hi Guys,
Have 2x S9's running for over a week now, but I mentioned something strange...
I spotted some screenshots of other peoples S9's and Fan1 always runs slower than Fan2.
But here it is different? My Fan1 is running -faster- than Fan2 on the back?
Fan1= 3850 rpm Fan2=3360 rpm.
What do you think? Little mistake by Bitmain or more people having noticed this with batch 2?
Have 2x S9's running for over a week now, but I mentioned something strange...
I spotted some screenshots of other peoples S9's and Fan1 always runs slower than Fan2.
But here it is different? My Fan1 is running -faster- than Fan2 on the back?
Fan1= 3850 rpm Fan2=3360 rpm.
What do you think? Little mistake by Bitmain or more people having noticed this with batch 2?
The S9 uses a different fan configuration than the S7. It has a 6000rpm fan on the front (also used in the S7-F1's) and the usual 4800rpm fan on the back of the unit.
I can only assume this is due to more heatsinks and the longer case needing more air movement. On the plus side I find the S9's run a bit cooler than my S7's in the same environment. Albeit a touch more loudly.
July 01, 2016, 08:49:55 AM
Looks like my B4 is on time and at destination facility (MO) for delivery today by FedEx
July 01, 2016, 07:43:48 AM
Any specific details.....price......wattage.....?
*a variation of 7% can be expected.
11.85 TH/s* -7% = 11 TH/s miner
Batch1
Hash Rate: 14.0TH/s ±5%
Power Consumption: 1375W + 7%
Batch4
Hash Rate: 12.93TH/s ±5%
Power Consumption: 1275W + 7%
Batch5
Hash Rate: 11.85TH/s ±7%
Power Consumption:
July 01, 2016, 07:08:56 AM
Hi Guys,
Have 2x S9's running for over a week now, but I mentioned something strange...
I spotted some screenshots of other peoples S9's and Fan1 always runs slower than Fan2.
But here it is different? My Fan1 is running -faster- than Fan2 on the back?
Fan1= 3850 rpm Fan2=3360 rpm.
What do you think? Little mistake by Bitmain or more people having noticed this with batch 2?
Have 2x S9's running for over a week now, but I mentioned something strange...
I spotted some screenshots of other peoples S9's and Fan1 always runs slower than Fan2.
But here it is different? My Fan1 is running -faster- than Fan2 on the back?
Fan1= 3850 rpm Fan2=3360 rpm.
What do you think? Little mistake by Bitmain or more people having noticed this with batch 2?
Jump to: