I think the next big question which I'd like to see addressed is how is it possible that the stunt that Luke Jr. and Josh pulled is not considered an attempt to defraud bettors? It is quite obvious that what they did was premeditated and intended to deceive. And they succeeded in altering the outcome of the bet, costing those who would have won a large amount. The evidence is already out there, and I don't think they deny what they did.
Is it just a matter of someone making an accusation thread? What are the arguments against their actions being consistent with being labeled a 'scammer'?
I for one definitely don't understand why someone like Luke Jr who has personally invested so much in the bitcoin community would risk what he has built over the years. Especially considering he has claimed he was not involved in the bet, meaning he wouldn't not have anything to gain by doing this. Only everything to lose, so that is puzzling to say the least.
I would honestly love to hear a well reasoned argument why the 'claiming to ship, but not actually shipping', and the subsequent financial damage to both the bettors and BoB(despite their failure here, they lost both their commision and reputation) could not be considered an act worthy of a scammer title.
I agree that both Luke-Jr. and Josh should be saddled with scammer tags. Josh even admitted, over at the BFL forum, that this whole thing was just a stunt. He claimed that he was trying to make a point about Avalon having claimed they "shipped" when they gave that ASIC miner to the Bitcoin Foundation (was it jgarzik or something?).
Of course, it's much more likely that Josh personally bet on that proposition and that he couldn't stomach the idea of so much money being won by the "trolls" he so despises. If you read Josh's posts in Micon's betting thread you will see how tilted Josh must have been by the thought of Micon and friends cashing in on his own incompetence.
Luke has admitted that he talks to Josh almost every night from midnight-2:00 AM. It's now April 9th and it's clear that BFL is not going to be doing any actual shipping anytime soon. Luke-Jr. can claim that he "received" his "Little Single", but it's very obvious that this was just a gambit meant to cheat the anti-BFL bettors out of their winnings.
Coinjedi can plead incompetence, but I just don't believe that anyone can be that stupid. I think he had a stake in the outcome. He was either bribed/extorted, or he had placed a large pro-BFL wager (more likely). When these bets were placed, the BTC price was probably a lot lower, so the stakes got much higher. Also, the way in which coinjedi acted in Luke's delivery thread was suspect. He came into the thread and asked for opinions. Then he came back and very suddenly made a final, irreversible decision which completely ignored the requested feedback. It didn't make any logical sense. Maybe he had been assured by Josh that BFL shills would back him up in the thread, but they got drowned out in the general outrage. Anyway, it wasn't the actions of an objective, responsible judge. I still feel he also deserves a scammer tag.
Several bitcointalk posters keep lists of reputable, BTC gambling related websites. If anyone sees betsofbitco.in contained on such a list, please request that it be moved to the scammer category.