Topic: Coinmarketcap or Coingecko? - page 17. (Read 4626 times)
Coingecko can be more honest exchnage due to it independancy
I have never considered the ranking of exchanges on CMC to be reliable. Currently I use coinmarketcap for the sole purpose of looking at the prices of coins, and it's more of a habit than because of me. want to use it....
We got used to using CMC already, so even if there's a new one, still we will be using CMC as we don't actually look for a more detailed information, we just look at the CMC to see the current price and we go to the other site or this forum to check the reason on the price movement. 
I have never considered the ranking of exchanges on CMC to be reliable. Currently I use coinmarketcap for the sole purpose of looking at the prices of coins, and it's more of a habit than because of me. want to use it....
Yes, but in looking at the price of coins in coinmarketcap we also have to consider which exchange is the most volume of coins we see, because people who are experienced and already know a good exchange will certainly trust the volume that is there even though the exchange is not is in the top rank in coinmarketcap. 
I have never considered the ranking of exchanges on CMC to be reliable. Currently I use coinmarketcap for the sole purpose of looking at the prices of coins, and it's more of a habit than because of me. want to use it....
We got used to using CMC already, so even if there's a new one, still we will be using CMC as we don't actually look for a more detailed information, we just look at the CMC to see the current price and we go to the other site or this forum to check the reason on the price movement. 
I have never considered the ranking of exchanges on CMC to be reliable. Currently I use coinmarketcap for the sole purpose of looking at the prices of coins, and it's more of a habit than because of me. want to use it....
I use both only to see the price of coins, I do not care about the exchange rate because I prioritize the price of coins rather than volume exchanges 
Just like you, I only use them to track prices and see if the exchanges are listing the altcoins I'm interested in. I never use coinmarketcap or coingecko to track volumes because it is inaccurate, and I also know which exchanges are good and which ones are bullshit. I use both only to see the price of coins, I do not care about the exchange rate because I prioritize the price of coins rather than volume exchanges
Same here and I see most posters here have the same thought. CMC but only for reference cause, CMC's exchange volume is dogshit unless coming from reputation exchange like Binance.
I use both simultaneously, but I never tried to use both of them as a refference for me to trade or to invest. When I am trading I will use the trading chart to paint my strategy and I use some media for fundamental analyst such as cointelegraph and CCN coin. Also I use them for my investment strategy, find the website of the coin first before I spend money for investing.
What they do is that some exchanges filter out fake volume which is very obvious on some of these exchanges. I was told most of these exchanges do wash trade. I think what CMC has done is to stat providing liquidity depth which I think is a good thing to do because most of these Asian exchanges are scams
Maybe this is one of the very reason why Binance overtook CMC because of their continuous supporting websites that obviously manipulating trades and faking volume this is rampant in many BS exchanges I dont believe that CMC is not aware of this they are just ignoring to filter this kind of problems better to shift to Coingecko.
I use both only to see the price of coins, I do not care about the exchange rate because I prioritize the price of coins rather than volume exchanges
Yes, and everyone has different things to use both, some use only to monitor the price of coins and some use both to see the volume of exchange along with the prices of tokens that are in Coinmarketcap and Coingecko. 
For example, I heard lot that P2PB2B is one of the bullshit exchanges because it has fake volume, but why on coinmarketcap can in the top 3?
Whereas on Coingecko P2PB2B is ranked 114, Does coingecko know if it's bullshit exchange? so it's not in the top 3 like in coin marketcap
So which one do you trust more?
P2PB2B is a bullshit and fake volume exchange. It deceived the coinmarketcap API and that's why it was in the top 3 coinmarketcap. I regularly use coinmarketcap because it has more features and I can see more projects. But I don't believe in the volume that coinmarketcap is listing Whereas on Coingecko P2PB2B is ranked 114, Does coingecko know if it's bullshit exchange? so it's not in the top 3 like in coin marketcap
So which one do you trust more?
I always visited Coinmarket when I was checking the price of the coins and the checling the rank and I see also the exchanges site there.
Maybe they have reason why that exchanges is in the rank 3 Im a trader on that exchange sites that you mentioned.
But even they have different ranking it depends to you where you trade a coin.
Maybe they have reason why that exchanges is in the rank 3 Im a trader on that exchange sites that you mentioned.
But even they have different ranking it depends to you where you trade a coin.
I use both only to see the price of coins, I do not care about the exchange rate because I prioritize the price of coins rather than volume exchanges
Same here and I see most posters here have the same thought. CMC but only for reference cause, CMC's exchange volume is dogshit unless coming from reputation exchange like Binance. well to me i don't really like P2Pb2b because is the most bullshit exchange..
but any token listed on CMC is the most trusted one, so what ever you are doing consider the one CMC though most time any token listed on P2PB2B i don't waste time going to trade it over there because it's wasted time and effort.
Forkdelta is even more trusted and has volume to those that P2PB2B.
I personally use both of these sites depending on needs, I only use those sites to see price statistics and coin data. not that I don't believe both, but as users we must be wiser and more careful about the coin data, prices, any exchanges displayed on the CMC or Coingecko site.
Well most of this data driven site (Meaning where the data is carry over from other's database/website) can be use as references but not fully depending on it
Look at multiple perspectives
We wouldn't really know if one site's data are purely transparent or rigged unless you can deeply explore into the exchange and monitor all of the data
However since not everyone is that tech savvy, its fine to use multiple sites as references to cross comparison or etc
Although i only uses CMC as i don't really see the volume because from most of the trading history in most exchanges, you can actually see that its manipulated
I uses Coinmarketcap mainly to see what's the recent hot coins
Trading volume can be fake, but price can be real if the volume did bulk up
Therefore, trading is not that easy because people need to identify if trading volume/trading pattern is false or true
Look at multiple perspectives
We wouldn't really know if one site's data are purely transparent or rigged unless you can deeply explore into the exchange and monitor all of the data
However since not everyone is that tech savvy, its fine to use multiple sites as references to cross comparison or etc
Although i only uses CMC as i don't really see the volume because from most of the trading history in most exchanges, you can actually see that its manipulated
I uses Coinmarketcap mainly to see what's the recent hot coins
Trading volume can be fake, but price can be real if the volume did bulk up
Therefore, trading is not that easy because people need to identify if trading volume/trading pattern is false or true
I use both only to see the price of coins, I do not care about the exchange rate because I prioritize the price of coins rather than volume exchanges
I'm using coinmarketcap just for the sake of reference and to check certain coins price. If those coins are listed on shit exchanges then it's not the coinmarketcap fault because said site is just collecting the data on one place, I don't know why people seems to hate CMC as it's just for reference.
I prefer using CoinMarketCap rather than other statistic crypto websites. It has all the data I need. As of Exchanges, they have Liquidity filter which shows the real volume on Exchanges.
Choosing between depends from how you understand the functionalities of each services, though most of the time there's seems to be manipulatedresults from CMC but if you already knows how to sort things out and brings out the things or informations that you've needed there's no problem
working on it and use it to base your next decision making.
Yes, you are right, they are not bothering about the people because many exchanges are using the bots in order to generate the volumes. Legally generated volumes are going down their ranking in CMC, that's why people should be very careful with both these CMC and Coingecko, a company which can eliminate bots will be preferred by the community members.
Jump to: