Pages:
Author

Topic: Fiat Currency Always Fails - page 5. (Read 2060 times)

hero member
Activity: 742
Merit: 526
September 07, 2018, 05:38:27 AM
See:

There Is No Escaping History.  Fiat Currency Eventually Fails.

Notice that this is a critique of fiat money -- not a critique of state-issued money under a gold/silver or other standard.  Fiat money is a rare occurrence in modern history.  (We live in strange times!)  As we can see, the examples found by the author are a small number of short periods here and there.

I have my own critique of gold/silver standards, but that's another issue.
Fiat money is money that has no intrinsic value (material value). He only keeps extrinsic value, namely the recognized exchange rate and obtains legality from the state.

I understand what you want to say and in most cases it is quite reasonable to assume that fiat doesn't have any intrinsic value. However, technically, money, any money for that matter, has a certain intrinsic value for just being money, for being used as money. It is specific to an object being money, not the object itself. This is called transactional utility, which essentially comes down to advantages that money provides over direct exchange of things, in other words, barter. And this utility can be measured in money terms too, i.e. in the same money (understanding that is not quite straightforward, though). It is called the price of money, and it typically considered to match the overnight interest rates that large banks use to borrow and lend from each other in the interbank credit market.
STT
legendary
Activity: 4004
Merit: 1428
☠ ☠ ☠ メメ
September 07, 2018, 02:45:23 AM
The problem is that now all the money issued by countries is fiat after the United States went out of the gold standard in 1971 which means that if the main fiat currency around the world the dollar were to collapse that could in theory collapse the entire economy of the world.

Dollar itself has adjusted from a proper link to some kind of unknown backing and is entering its final stage of no backing at all except the willpower of foreign creditors to keep buying debt despite a long term trade imbalance and a potential trade sanction war to discourage trade.      Its all adding up to make dollar prospects unlikely to best over any solid alternative.

The point is these things happen gradually, for example with the USA dropping gold at Nixon's command it still left some standards left for a few years after like the Swiss held a gold backed currency for decades until the end of the century.   They recently voted to return to a gold standard but instead dropped a policy of duplicating EURO money printing which helped restore some value to their national currency.

Other countries will not collapse from just one country.   I dont even think USA will cease for the idea of paper, alternatives will be found and BTC is just one of many hence why its most important it be made as easy to use as possible for a diverse population.   Other possibles are commodity backed currency such as Canada or Australia which in the main are large land masses with centuries of assets to back the worth of a national note.  USA can justify returning from a dollar failure, it just be a hiccup not the grand melt down some might fear.   We will be better of without false dollar value, collapse is not the result but unsuppressed growth.   This is presuming we dont do silly stuff like go to war, debt failing can produce some angry people
newbie
Activity: 158
Merit: 0
September 06, 2018, 09:02:23 PM
See:

There Is No Escaping History.  Fiat Currency Eventually Fails.

Notice that this is a critique of fiat money -- not a critique of state-issued money under a gold/silver or other standard.  Fiat money is a rare occurrence in modern history.  (We live in strange times!)  As we can see, the examples found by the author are a small number of short periods here and there.

I have my own critique of gold/silver standards, but that's another issue.
Fiat money is money that has no intrinsic value (material value). He only keeps extrinsic value, namely the recognized exchange rate and obtains legality from the state.
sr. member
Activity: 882
Merit: 258
★Bitvest.io★ Play Plinko or Invest!
September 06, 2018, 07:25:20 PM
Although I agree that fiat currency always fails, it will still continue to exist. Somehow, fiat is a bit like bitcoin in the sense that the exchange rate goes up and down quite frequently. Plus I do not think that there is and should be a competition between fiat and cryptocurrency, right?
yes, right, competition between fiat and crypto does not need to be precisely the two must work together as a way to increase the second value of the money.
Yes in the first place, crypto amd fiat are very different from each other. Characteristics and even its value they are just both a curremcy which people need. Fiat will always be fiat even it fails unlike to crypto that when it fail it will be useless to people who have it.
newbie
Activity: 182
Merit: 0
September 06, 2018, 07:19:24 PM
There is no fiat that failed, so far Fiat has been very helpful in the community. fiat has existed since a long time ago, maybe now we can say that fiat failed because the economy is increasingly pressing so it raises the assumption of another currency.
sr. member
Activity: 532
Merit: 253
September 06, 2018, 06:39:29 PM
See:

There Is No Escaping History.  Fiat Currency Eventually Fails.

Notice that this is a critique of fiat money -- not a critique of state-issued money under a gold/silver or other standard.  Fiat money is a rare occurrence in modern history.  (We live in strange times!)  As we can see, the examples found by the author are a small number of short periods here and there.

I have my own critique of gold/silver standards, but that's another issue.
This is true but the big problem here is not that fiat currency fails but the terrible effects it has in the economy in general and in the economy of each person, when the fiat currency fails it tends to sink the country and everyone becomes poorer because of it and then you need to trust that the government is going to finally get it right when they issue a new currency.

Yes, fiat money being not back by anything, lets governments off the leash and gives them an instrument to abuse, and it's not surprising that most of politicians do abuse it following their selfish goals.
member
Activity: 406
Merit: 10
WPP ENERGY - BACKED ASSET GREEN ENERGY TOKEN
September 06, 2018, 06:31:23 PM
I think it was not born to fight. So there will be no failure. The main purpose is to promote the economy and give people economic exchanges. The appearance of it has centuries of currency. So there will be no battle to fail. It is the existence that exists in this life. That is my opinion.
hero member
Activity: 2884
Merit: 794
I am terrible at Fantasy Football!!!
September 06, 2018, 01:48:01 PM
See:

There Is No Escaping History.  Fiat Currency Eventually Fails.

Notice that this is a critique of fiat money -- not a critique of state-issued money under a gold/silver or other standard.  Fiat money is a rare occurrence in modern history.  (We live in strange times!)  As we can see, the examples found by the author are a small number of short periods here and there.

I have my own critique of gold/silver standards, but that's another issue.
This is true but the big problem here is not that fiat currency fails but the terrible effects it has in the economy in general and in the economy of each person, when the fiat currency fails it tends to sink the country and everyone becomes poorer because of it and then you need to trust that the government is going to finally get it right when they issue a new currency.
newbie
Activity: 266
Merit: 0
September 06, 2018, 01:35:08 PM
Although I agree that fiat currency always fails, it will still continue to exist. Somehow, fiat is a bit like bitcoin in the sense that the exchange rate goes up and down quite frequently. Plus I do not think that there is and should be a competition between fiat and cryptocurrency, right?
yes, right, competition between fiat and crypto does not need to be precisely the two must work together as a way to increase the second value of the money.
sr. member
Activity: 462
Merit: 515
September 06, 2018, 01:33:22 PM
Some of you guys in this forum are full-time dumbos. So you think that when dollar falls that means that it is over for the whole world and that Bitcoin and other crypto currencies will come and take over ? Sounds like something only a dumb person would say. How can you be thinking that? Whenever dollar falls, the value of Yen and Euro will appreciate. Bitcoin is not a real currency, it’s just like something else made to be on its own and when you’re using it you’re in complete control of your money and not the government being in control.

Well, I agree and disagree with you on that point at the same time, about Bitcoin not being a real currency. I agree that at the moment Bitcoin can hardly be considered a genuine currency on purely practical reasons. You can't buy things with it directly, that means Bitcoin doesn't circulate but this is what the term itself (currency) stands for. On the other hand, there is nothing which would prevent Bitcoin from becoming a currency, there is nothing in it inherently which would not allow it to become one. It may not be a very good currency overall due to its deflationary nature (and a few other issues), but this is a completely different story.
Nothing at all will make bitcoin stop from being a currency as long as its real life usage starts becoming more pronounced.
On the issue of fiat failing, I would not say it totally does, but we all know how much fiat has been weakened several times and still keep getting weak due to all the manipulations and controls by the government,  which at a point, I seriously hope it does not end up imploding. That will be too much to assume anyway but in this case we are not just talking about USD, but fiats in general.

Yes, fiats fail eventually, but their downfalls don't come about entirely on their own. It is the downfall of the state which ultimately leads to the collapse of its money, not the other way round.

Regarding Bitcoin becoming a currency, you just said what can be called a tautology of sorts. Being a currency already means real life usage, by definition. In other words, if Bitcoin is used, it is already a currency. Or to put it differently, being a currency suggests being widely used in real life as a means of exchange. It is just two different descriptions or definitions of the same thing. But whether Bitcoin will actually become used globally (on par with fiat monies) is a different story, though.
newbie
Activity: 1
Merit: 0
September 06, 2018, 12:12:51 PM
Very nice Smiley
member
Activity: 336
Merit: 12
September 06, 2018, 11:57:30 AM
I think fiat and cryptocurencies have more in common than we generally assume because they both rely exclusively on trust and the law of offer and demand. That said fiat are also indirectly backed by networks of banks and central banks and many other institutions yes. What I like  the most in crypto is the transparency of the rules (codes) and the endless possibilities in the real of smart economies and digital scapes.
newbie
Activity: 112
Merit: 0
September 06, 2018, 11:46:47 AM
I like both fiat currencies and cryptocurrencies. The rise and fall of either fiat and bitcoin are nothing to go away from. I see it to be a same level currencies though fiat is known to fail. I don't dispute that fact.
member
Activity: 322
Merit: 23
September 06, 2018, 11:43:13 AM
Fiat currencies are considered far more stable than commodity-backed currencies. That's because the value of a commodity is based on its stability, and its price will tend to fluctuate based on its physical reserves. It has a high risk of eventually becoming devalued and worthless as a result of economical inflation. A fiat currency system comes into existence as a result of excessive debt and the resulting hyperinflation.
jr. member
Activity: 196
Merit: 4
September 06, 2018, 11:03:13 AM
Although I agree that fiat currency always fails, it will still continue to exist. Somehow, fiat is a bit like bitcoin in the sense that the exchange rate goes up and down quite frequently. Plus I do not think that there is and should be a competition between fiat and cryptocurrency, right?
sr. member
Activity: 490
Merit: 251
September 06, 2018, 10:05:37 AM
The ramifications of the occurrence in the money depreciated state he needs to pay more for items and administrations from abroad, though abroad individuals will be more items and administrations from nations debased in their monetary standards. This is a genuine shamefulness, on account of the failure of the legislature to keep up the estimation of its cash, because of the utilization of fiat cash.
full member
Activity: 504
Merit: 100
September 06, 2018, 09:46:09 AM
The presence of bitcoin is a good thing for the future of the currency system, with bitcoin then we can transact faster and easily so I hope bitcoin will soon become an international currency.

I love Bitcoin and I believe that it can become an international currency but I am also sure we will never get rid of fiat. The traditional money is very convenient no Internet is needed.
member
Activity: 350
Merit: 10
September 04, 2018, 07:20:09 AM
See:

There Is No Escaping History.  Fiat Currency Eventually Fails.

Notice that this is a critique of fiat money -- not a critique of state-issued money under a gold/silver or other standard.  Fiat money is a rare occurrence in modern history.  (We live in strange times!)  As we can see, the examples found by the author are a small number of short periods here and there.

I have my own critique of gold/silver standards, but that's another issue.

The article you shared explains only paper money which is in history was not backed by gold that's why it fails. In recent generation of currencies, Fiat is a strong testament that a countries economy is growing or falling.
hero member
Activity: 966
Merit: 550
September 04, 2018, 07:04:27 AM
Some of you guys in this forum are full-time dumbos. So you think that when dollar falls that means that it is over for the whole world and that Bitcoin and other crypto currencies will come and take over ? Sounds like something only a dumb person would say. How can you be thinking that? Whenever dollar falls, the value of Yen and Euro will appreciate. Bitcoin is not a real currency, it’s just like something else made to be on its own and when you’re using it you’re in complete control of your money and not the government being in control.

Well, I agree and disagree with you on that point at the same time, about Bitcoin not being a real currency. I agree that at the moment Bitcoin can hardly be considered a genuine currency on purely practical reasons. You can't buy things with it directly, that means Bitcoin doesn't circulate but this is what the term itself (currency) stands for. On the other hand, there is nothing which would prevent Bitcoin from becoming a currency, there is nothing in it inherently which would not allow it to become one. It may not be a very good currency overall due to its deflationary nature (and a few other issues), but this is a completely different story.
Nothing at all will make bitcoin stop from being a currency as long as its real life usage starts becoming more pronounced.
On the issue of fiat failing, I would not say it totally does, but we all know how much fiat has been weakened several times and still keep getting weak due to all the manipulations and controls by the government,  which at a point, I seriously hope it does not end up imploding. That will be too much to assume anyway but in this case we are not just talking about USD, but fiats in general.
sr. member
Activity: 462
Merit: 515
August 31, 2018, 12:34:00 PM
See:

There Is No Escaping History.  Fiat Currency Eventually Fails.

Notice that this is a critique of fiat money -- not a critique of state-issued money under a gold/silver or other standard.  Fiat money is a rare occurrence in modern history.  (We live in strange times!)  As we can see, the examples found by the author are a small number of short periods here and there.

I have my own critique of gold/silver standards, but that's another issue.


Any particular fiat currency can fail, and there is a long track record of failure, but fiat currency as a concept is actually just fine, and in fact the most useful way to sort out trade, because it is simply too inefficient to go back to a pure bartering system. On the other hand, technology is deflationary, the cost of goods and services goes down with respect to the total amount of money in the system.

Countries got out of the depression in the exact order in which they left the gold standard. A growing economy needs an ever growing stock of money for transactions.

Yes, this is how matters stand with fiat vs. so-called hard currencies backed up by gold, silver, or any other tangible asset. But it is hard for many or even most people to understand that as they see the value of their money being constantly eaten away by inflation. In the majority of countries around the world annual inflation is two digits anyway, and in some like Venezuela it is outright ruinous. But it is not the fault of fiat money conceptually, it is rather the failure of the government that runs that currency. It is like a potent drug which can save your life but it can also lead to devastating consequences if misused or abused.
Pages:
Jump to: