The benefits of creating quality topics is very simple;
1. You'll gain more knowledge.
2. You can apply it in different applications.
3. You will get a strong reputation and credentials because you are making an effort to make a quality threads.
To compose a guide, user have to spend more time than simply reply to a post. My statement excludes shit guides that only are created for merit hunting, without any new knowledge or contributions.
To make a good guide, you have to have knowledge at fundamental level, at least; then using more to search for available topics on the same issue on the forum. After all, spending more time to compose a good guide, both in contents, and grammar. They all contributed to grow composers up.
So my advice to all aspiring posters of quality soon, always think about your posts, it's better not to rely on the thread of others.
It is not right. The forum is built for discussions, so please not self-restrict yourself from interesting discusions.
Sometimes it's easier to discuss about something you've learned well because you're going to build a successful conversation that serves a forum function.
Discussions can be started by yourself or by the others but at the ends they are discussions.