What about the 483 USD exchange rate? This exchange rate does NOT mean that you will get 483 USD for your remaining bitcoins if you request payout in fiat. The amounts you enter for various currencies in the claim form are being converted into Japanese yen on the form. The exchange rate in the case of BTC is 50,058.12 yen. The exchange rates being used for all currencies are the rates on the day before the start of bankruptcy proceedings (April 23, 2014 Japan time) and at that time 50,058.12 yen was equivalent to 483 USD. For details, see "FAQs Regarding Filing, Etc. Bankruptcy Claims by MTGOX Bitcoin Exchange Users" (pp. 10-11) at
https://www.mtgox.com/.
So, if you claim 1 BTC this will be converted to JPY 50,058.12 on the form. These are just conversion rates for the form and don't imply that any currencies will actually be converted at the given rates or that you will somehow get a distribution in JPY using those rates. It's natural to think that the rates will also serve to help determine your pro rata share of the remaining assets, but this isn't certain either.
Thanks for taking time to address these questions. So to clarifiy there is no "better" strategy for people when making a claim whether that be fiat or BTC? or is that uncertain? because if you held BTC in gox when it went down and you pick to get paid in fiat there is a small chance your BTC share couldbe treated as a higher $ value vs current market value and you can gain an advantage vs other claims on the total assets?
We don't know for certain (again with the disclaimer
), but it appears that the remaining assets (and each creditor's share of that) are being determined in JPY. In the end your share of the remaining assets will be x amount of JPY and payouts in currency other than JPY will just be determined at the current exchange rates (NOT the rates given on the claim form). So the choice between getting your payout in fiat or BTC is probably just going to be the choice between getting paid in fiat or the equivalent amount of BTC.
However, it's a bit more complicated than that: According to information provided by the trustee in "Documents distributed at the third creditors’ meeting" (on
https://www.mtgox.com), it looks like the majority of remaining assets are currently in the form of bitcoin (approximately 80% at current BTC price). This means that if you have a BTC balance and you request payout in fiat, you are essentially asking the trustee to liquidate your bitcoins for you. Do you really want to have a bureaucratic entity decide how and when to liquidate your remaining bitcoins? Are you confident that you will get a good price that way? No offense to the trustee, but personally I'd rather make my own choice about when to liquidate my remaining BTC and at what price. Also, if you are a bitcoin advocate, you might think that the last thing bitcoin needs right now is another huge block of coins up for sale at auction or on the open market, especially if you have doubts about how well that sale might be handled.
I think the best outcome of this situation will be if the remaining bitcoin can be distributed in kind to creditors, but in order for that to happen, we need a lot of creditors to request payout in bitcoin. Is there a personal financial incentive to taking your payout in bitcoin or fiat though? This isn't clear, but if you are not confident in having the trustee liquidate your bitcoins for you, then this is another reason to choose a BTC payout.