now maybe i can help you learn? :
"one CPU one vote"
who said it?
Sakoshi Nakamoto said that, and I don't have any problem with it. It is the philosophy that underpins the Proof of Work algo, but it doesn't underpin the basis of money in general.
That's where we possibly differ.
POS coins are no different from plastic tokens at a funfair - valueless until adopted as an accepted token of monetary exchange, at which point they acquire monetary value, just the same as any other token would whether it be a tally stick, funfair token, govpaper, or chewing gum card.
If you're saying that the fact that POS breaks the one CPU one vote principle is the basis for your accusation of "scam", then I think you're on very weak ground, for 2 reasons:
- that principle only applies in the domain of POW crypto currencies
- the common understanding of the word "scam" is an unequal exchange. i.e. I take your money and in exchange give you a commodity of significantly less value that you are **not able to trade away**
That's where I think you are unjustified in maligning other cryptocurrencies on this basis, because this is demonstrably not the case and has never been so.
indeed my rational sock puppet friend. is it ok if i call you that? it seems like "EvilDave" was the "friendly" sock puppet the other one was the "threatening" one ha ha, and you are the "rationalizing" one?
so you are trying to "rationalize" that :
1 Billion NXT units given to 73 addresses is ok?BLOCK : 2680262203532249785
Timestamp : 24.11.2013 13:00:00
Height : 0
Next Block : 6556228577102711328
Previous Block : 0
Pay Load Length : 9344 B
Num. Transactions : 73
Total Fee : 0
Base Target : 100.00 %
Total Amount : 1,000,000,000 NXT
Generator Account : 1739068987193023818
Generator RS : NXT-MRCC-2YLS-8M54-3CMAJ
Version : -1
Perma Link : Show
Block SIgnature : 69d426c498b70ac6d1678180356527c1fee030ad732fbf7672c2266d166a4c08cf8fdeb4524fd1b 496bbcaab03fa6e67760f6da452251402249015486c487211
Generation Signature : 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
Previous Block Hash : n/a
Payload Hash : 72c8a92efffbd8695a866eabb13ca460a2f7cdf3283b82efb163360d6eec9469
what i'm saying is that PoW distribution that tries to adhere to the "one CPU one Vote" principal obviously avoids this sort of obvious scam.
you are trying to somehow confuse and "Rationalize" in PoS -
where i'm not talking about PoS at all, its flawed indeed but thats not what is at issue here.
i'm talking about making 1 Billion units of something and "fake" giving it to yourself. then doubling down and making your own exchange (Wall St Style) and bidding it up.