Pages:
Author

Topic: Philipma1957's attempt to rate current Manufacturers of Asic . Results in. (Read 11488 times)

legendary
Activity: 4116
Merit: 7849
'The right to privacy matters'
Buying an Avalon 4 doesn't make you look fair and balanced. Let us be honest the Avalon 4's, as people have said here, are over priced and inefficient.

There is a reason for that they are BEHIND the design curve and were very late with this chip when you do a side by side comparison to what else is being offered by the competition. They are not in the same league and I suspect given how far behind they are and the past issues of fraud and delays commercial sales will be non-existent given the competitors products available now and what is planned.

Is this now a product thread review? I thought it was about the poll and consumer sentiments not a single person doing reviews of all the fabricators offerings... bit confused.


You are correct this is not a review thread
I am not posting a review here.
I mentioned I will review the avalon 4
In order to not clog this very long thread with excess info I will close it.

I will review the avalon 4 when it arrives.    new  thread one
I will show my experiences with
4 pieces of gear
Avalon 4
S-5
Sp20
asic miner prisma                                      new thread two

I will do a new poll of gear                         new thread three.






What about attempting to rate the current manufacturers?


_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________

Perspective and on topic.  I can't rate them without a demo of gear.

I did sp20------------------------ I paid for the review model and did that thread on my own I paid more then 700 use for it
 
I did prisma --------------------mostly on crazy guy's thread I paid for the review model returned it once fire danger was found out


I did s-5------------------------ A free review model

Avalon 4 ----------------------- A free review model still waiting.

_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________
_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________


Avalon is not the company you want to do any deals with given their history.

There are better companies. Better prices and better equipment out there.

Given that you can't make anything mining at home why bother?

Seriously if you are doing it for a hobby put some coins into a company that hasn't basically killed a whole swath of open hardware designers single handedly like Avalon.

There is a reason to avoid them make the right choice.


If people were strictly concerned with the ideology of home mining and not ROI'ing, they would just buy a dozen or less Bitmain U3's or a couple old S3's to underclock and get that warm fuzzy feeling inside. Doesn't change the fact that it makes no more sense than buying an Avalon 4 though. Huh  Surely the U3's/S3's would be quiet too, and you would lose less of your money. Avalon project/Canaan missed the boat with this one, it was clear to see all the way back in the fall (too little too late).




PS Has anyone buying these even run models?  Even with 0% difficulty increase, $0.05/KWh and $300/BTC price (all quite unrealistic atm except maybe power cost), they would take over 200 days to ROI.  Give your head a shake people.  Anyone that is promoting these quite obviously has something to gain, and it's not your hand in friendship  Undecided.

I got a S5, 2 S1, I had mutiple usb miner and now I got a Avalon4. We try to make the best evaluation of all miners.
The S5 is lound as hell but with modification you can reach something nice.

I have my miners in my livingroom so I need something quiet. Right now, the Avalon4 is really quit. I also mine on solar power and I mine to be part of the bitcoin system not to get rich. If I can do money over it well good.

I do agree that the Avalon4 is right now not cheap but its a good miner for home miners that dont want to modify anything.

Cheer

Valkir  Wink


I am going to close this particular thread off once I get the avalon 4.

 I do not want to say Much more about avalon4 since I do not have one in hand.

Bick it is really hard to be neutral about gear and companies. I am making that effort.


Thread is locked.   look for  a new thread on this in about 4-5 weeks
hero member
Activity: 924
Merit: 1000
Buying an Avalon 4 doesn't make you look fair and balanced. Let us be honest the Avalon 4's, as people have said here, are over priced and inefficient.

There is a reason for that they are BEHIND the design curve and were very late with this chip when you do a side by side comparison to what else is being offered by the competition. They are not in the same league and I suspect given how far behind they are and the past issues of fraud and delays commercial sales will be non-existent given the competitors products available now and what is planned.

Is this now a product thread review? I thought it was about the poll and consumer sentiments not a single person doing reviews of all the fabricators offerings... bit confused.

What about attempting to rate the current manufacturers?


_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________

Perspective and on topic.  I can't rate them without a demo of gear.

I did sp20------------------------ I paid for the review model and did that thread on my own I paid more then 700 use for it
 
I did prisma --------------------mostly on crazy guy's thread I paid for the review model returned it once fire danger was found out


I did s-5------------------------ A free review model

Avalon 4 ----------------------- A free review model still waiting.

_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________
_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________


Avalon is not the company you want to do any deals with given their history.

There are better companies. Better prices and better equipment out there.

Given that you can't make anything mining at home why bother?

Seriously if you are doing it for a hobby put some coins into a company that hasn't basically killed a whole swath of open hardware designers single handedly like Avalon.

There is a reason to avoid them make the right choice.


If people were strictly concerned with the ideology of home mining and not ROI'ing, they would just buy a dozen or less Bitmain U3's or a couple old S3's to underclock and get that warm fuzzy feeling inside. Doesn't change the fact that it makes no more sense than buying an Avalon 4 though. Huh  Surely the U3's/S3's would be quiet too, and you would lose less of your money. Avalon project/Canaan missed the boat with this one, it was clear to see all the way back in the fall (too little too late).




PS Has anyone buying these even run models?  Even with 0% difficulty increase, $0.05/KWh and $300/BTC price (all quite unrealistic atm except maybe power cost), they would take over 200 days to ROI.  Give your head a shake people.  Anyone that is promoting these quite obviously has something to gain, and it's not your hand in friendship  Undecided.

I got a S5, 2 S1, I had mutiple usb miner and now I got a Avalon4. We try to make the best evaluation of all miners.
The S5 is lound as hell but with modification you can reach something nice.

I have my miners in my livingroom so I need something quiet. Right now, the Avalon4 is really quit. I also mine on solar power and I mine to be part of the bitcoin system not to get rich. If I can do money over it well good.

I do agree that the Avalon4 is right now not cheap but its a good miner for home miners that dont want to modify anything.

Cheer

Valkir  Wink


I am going to close this particular thread off once I get the avalon 4.

 I do not want to say Much more about avalon4 since I do not have one in hand.

Bick it is really hard to be neutral about gear and companies. I am making that effort.
legendary
Activity: 4116
Merit: 7849
'The right to privacy matters'
What about attempting to rate the current manufacturers?


_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________

Perspective and on topic.  I can't rate them without a demo of gear.

I did sp20------------------------ I paid for the review model and did that thread on my own I paid more then 700 use for it
 
I did prisma --------------------mostly on crazy guy's thread I paid for the review model returned it once fire danger was found out


I did s-5------------------------ A free review model

Avalon 4 ----------------------- A free review model still waiting.

_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________
_______________________________________________________________________________ _____________________


Avalon is not the company you want to do any deals with given their history.

There are better companies. Better prices and better equipment out there.

Given that you can't make anything mining at home why bother?

Seriously if you are doing it for a hobby put some coins into a company that hasn't basically killed a whole swath of open hardware designers single handedly like Avalon.

There is a reason to avoid them make the right choice.


If people were strictly concerned with the ideology of home mining and not ROI'ing, they would just buy a dozen or less Bitmain U3's or a couple old S3's to underclock and get that warm fuzzy feeling inside. Doesn't change the fact that it makes no more sense than buying an Avalon 4 though. Huh  Surely the U3's/S3's would be quiet too, and you would lose less of your money. Avalon project/Canaan missed the boat with this one, it was clear to see all the way back in the fall (too little too late).




PS Has anyone buying these even run models?  Even with 0% difficulty increase, $0.05/KWh and $300/BTC price (all quite unrealistic atm except maybe power cost), they would take over 200 days to ROI.  Give your head a shake people.  Anyone that is promoting these quite obviously has something to gain, and it's not your hand in friendship  Undecided.

I got a S5, 2 S1, I had mutiple usb miner and now I got a Avalon4. We try to make the best evaluation of all miners.
The S5 is lound as hell but with modification you can reach something nice.

I have my miners in my livingroom so I need something quiet. Right now, the Avalon4 is really quit. I also mine on solar power and I mine to be part of the bitcoin system not to get rich. If I can do money over it well good.

I do agree that the Avalon4 is right now not cheap but its a good miner for home miners that dont want to modify anything.

Cheer

Valkir  Wink


I am going to close this particular thread off once I get the avalon 4.

 I do not want to say Much more about avalon4 since I do not have one in hand.

Bick it is really hard to be neutral about gear and companies. I am making that effort.
hero member
Activity: 924
Merit: 1000
What about attempting to rate the current manufacturers?

Perspective and on topic.

Avalon is not the company you want to do any deals with given their history.

There are better companies. Better prices and better equipment out there.

Given that you can't make anything mining at home why bother?

Seriously if you are doing it for a hobby put some coins into a company that hasn't basically killed a whole swath of open hardware designers single handedly like Avalon.

There is a reason to avoid them make the right choice.


If people were strictly concerned with the ideology of home mining and not ROI'ing, they would just buy a dozen or less Bitmain U3's or a couple old S3's to underclock and get that warm fuzzy feeling inside. Doesn't change the fact that it makes no more sense than buying an Avalon 4 though. Huh  Surely the U3's/S3's would be quiet too, and you would lose less of your money. Avalon project/Canaan missed the boat with this one, it was clear to see all the way back in the fall (too little too late).




PS Has anyone buying these even run models?  Even with 0% difficulty increase, $0.05/KWh and $300/BTC price (all quite unrealistic atm except maybe power cost), they would take over 200 days to ROI.  Give your head a shake people.  Anyone that is promoting these quite obviously has something to gain, and it's not your hand in friendship  Undecided.

I got a S5, 2 S1, I had mutiple usb miner and now I got a Avalon4. We try to make the best evaluation of all miners.
The S5 is lound as hell but with modification you can reach something nice.

I have my miners in my livingroom so I need something quiet. Right now, the Avalon4 is really quit. I also mine on solar power and I mine to be part of the bitcoin system not to get rich. If I can do money over it well good.

I do agree that the Avalon4 is right now not cheap but its a good miner for home miners that dont want to modify anything.

Cheer

Valkir  Wink
legendary
Activity: 1484
Merit: 1004
If people were strictly concerned with the ideology of home mining and not ROI'ing, they would just buy a dozen or less Bitmain U3's or a couple old S3's to underclock and get that warm fuzzy feeling inside. Doesn't change the fact that it makes no more sense than buying an Avalon 4 though. Huh  Surely the U3's/S3's would be quiet too, and you would lose less of your money. Avalon project/Canaan missed the boat with this one, it was clear to see all the way back in the fall (too little too late).




PS Has anyone buying these even run models?  Even with 0% difficulty increase, $0.05/KWh and $300/BTC price (all quite unrealistic atm except maybe power cost), they would take over 200 days to ROI.  Give your head a shake people.  Anyone that is promoting these quite obviously has something to gain, and it's not your hand in friendship  Undecided.

I got a S5, 2 S1, I had mutiple usb miner and now I got a Avalon4. We try to make the best evaluation of all miners.
The S5 is lound as hell but with modification you can reach something nice.

I have my miners in my livingroom so I need something quiet. Right now, the Avalon4 is really quit. I also mine on solar power and I mine to be part of the bitcoin system not to get rich. If I can do money over it well good.

I do agree that the Avalon4 is right now not cheap but its a good miner for home miners that dont want to modify anything.

Cheer

Valkir  Wink
hero member
Activity: 924
Merit: 1000
We've been though this, Canaan Creative is NOT Avalon.

Avalon renamed themselves to Canaan Creative after their Gen 1 shit-storm.

Irrespective of history, the current Avalon products are not price/performance competitive, at all, with SPTech or Bitmain.

Call it pudding when it is actually dogshit doesn't make it pudding.

As everyone is pointing out. Avalon is not the units you are looking for.
legendary
Activity: 4116
Merit: 7849
'The right to privacy matters'



 The sp20 is great gear I have 9 of them.  It is too loud .

The S-5 needs lots of mods to be quiet.

The avalon4 in theory  is quieter  and needs no mods to run  as a space heater just set it to 400 watts and 800 gh.

   If it can do this then it has a spot on the table of home miners.  I am still waiting for the test model to reach me.
  I will do a comparison to the two current models sp20 and s-5.  Give my opinion if it is viable as a space heater replacement.
I am pretty much independent user and miner of gear for Bitcoin. I never used avalon  to be fair I want demo this gear as I see a spot for it.
legendary
Activity: 1022
Merit: 1003
If people were strictly concerned with the ideology of home mining and not ROI'ing, they would just buy a dozen or less Bitmain U3's or a couple old S3's to underclock and get that warm fuzzy feeling inside. Doesn't change the fact that it makes no more sense than buying an Avalon 4 though. Huh  Surely the U3's/S3's would be quiet too, and you would lose less of your money. Avalon project/Canaan missed the boat with this one, it was clear to see all the way back in the fall (too little too late).




PS Has anyone buying these even run models?  Even with 0% difficulty increase, $0.05/KWh and $300/BTC price (all quite unrealistic atm except maybe power cost), they would take over 200 days to ROI.  Give your head a shake people.  Anyone that is promoting these quite obviously has something to gain, and it's not your hand in friendship  Undecided.
legendary
Activity: 1652
Merit: 1067
Christian Antkow
We've been though this, Canaan Creative is NOT Avalon.

Avalon renamed themselves to Canaan Creative after their Gen 1 shit-storm.

Irrespective of history, the current Avalon products are not price/performance competitive, at all, with SPTech or Bitmain.
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
The Avalon is too pricey and requires a controller..silent is nice and all, but 0 chance to make any profit.  Also they did sorta screw the mining community really bad...

We've been though this, Canaan Creative is NOT Avalon. CC has sold out of hand only for about 16 months now.
legendary
Activity: 2128
Merit: 1119
The Avalon is too pricey and requires a controller..silent is nice and all, but 0 chance to make any profit.  Also they did sorta screw the mining community really bad...
legendary
Activity: 1666
Merit: 1183
dogiecoin.com
Don't buy Avalon... just a simple mantra.

Why is that?

I'm about to buy a piece to put it beween sp20 and s3+(maybe s5 soon)

Ethically this company is one that people should avoid given they cost consumers millions in lost revenue with their chip fiasco.


 This piece of gear I get will be the first one I ever had from them.

Most every builder has had fuckups.

Asic Miner -------------The prisma
Bitmaintech -----------The first s-2's
Sp-Tech ----------------The sp30

Reading the forums some felt they got the correct  fixes some say no.

No point to buying an Avalon given it is less efficient than competition and you will heavily mod it to meet your local needs. Just get an SP20 or S5 or next offering and do the same. Why support this company that price gouged and lost our community a fair number of good open source hardware teams?  Perplexing.

Eh? The Avalon4 is the one miner out of the S5 + SP20 + Avalon4 trifecta that DOESN'T require modding to run at home. Both others often require intervention to get them quiet enough to run at home while the Avalon4 is infinitely quieter.
legendary
Activity: 1484
Merit: 1004
If you guys want to try the Avalon4 let me know, I got small discount.

Cheer

Valkir  Wink
legendary
Activity: 4116
Merit: 7849
'The right to privacy matters'
I can't make any miner work at my power costs, .13 kwh  Roll Eyes

How the hell are you guys making it work,I see 12-16 month ROI after power costs  Cry  If the diff stays around 50 billion................


I am able to use the heat from my miners to help keep the home warm in the winter.  thus my 13 cent power drops to 9.5 or 10 cents.

I will have to sell all my miners int early May.

I also host 2 here:

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=934581.0;all

I may expand to 3 or 4 soon.  I will keep these for a while longer.
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 1001
I can't make any miner work at my power costs, .13 kwh  Roll Eyes

How the hell are you guys making it work,I see 12-16 month ROI after power costs  Cry  If the diff stays around 50 billion................
hero member
Activity: 924
Merit: 1000
Don't buy Avalon... just a simple mantra.

Why is that?

I'm about to buy a piece to put it beween sp20 and s3+(maybe s5 soon)

Ethically this company is one that people should avoid given they cost consumers millions in lost revenue with their chip fiasco.


 This piece of gear I get will be the first one I ever had from them.

Most every builder has had fuckups.

Asic Miner -------------The prisma
Bitmaintech -----------The first s-2's
Sp-Tech ----------------The sp30

Reading the forums some felt they got the correct  fixes some say no.

No point to buying an Avalon given it is less efficient than competition and you will heavily mod it to meet your local needs. Just get an SP20 or S5 or next offering and do the same. Why support this company that price gouged and lost our community a fair number of good open source hardware teams?  Perplexing.
legendary
Activity: 2128
Merit: 1119
...
Also, the SP20s initially had a problem with boards coming loose during shipping because they wasn't secured properly.
...
Correct. We refunded for the delay and RMA defective SP20.

Also SP responded immediately not after 2 months of being ignored.
donator
Activity: 1414
Merit: 1051
Spondoolies, Beam & DAGlabs
...
Also, the SP20s initially had a problem with boards coming loose during shipping because they wasn't secured properly.
...
Correct. We refunded for the delay and RMA defective SP20.
legendary
Activity: 826
Merit: 1004
We refunded for the spec miss.
(BMT had an issue with PSUs on the first batches of the S4 as well)

From what I remember, there was a lot of fuss about the compensation not being adequate.

Also, the SP20s initially had a problem with boards coming loose during shipping because they wasn't secured properly. Like Philip said, everyone has had some form of issues.
donator
Activity: 1414
Merit: 1051
Spondoolies, Beam & DAGlabs
Don't buy Avalon... just a simple mantra.

Why is that?

I'm about to buy a piece to put it beween sp20 and s3+(maybe s5 soon)

Ethically this company is one that people should avoid given they cost consumers millions in lost revenue with their chip fiasco.


 This piece of gear I get will be the first one I ever had from them.

Most every builder has had fuckups.

Asic Miner -------------The prisma
Bitmaintech -----------The first s-2's
Sp-Tech ----------------The sp30

Reading the forums some felt they got the correct  fixes some say no.
We refunded for the spec miss.
(BMT had an issue with PSUs on the first batches of the S4 as well)
Pages:
Jump to: