Topic: Philipma1957's attempt to rate current Manufacturers of Asic . Results in. - page 6. (Read 11561 times)
January 28, 2015, 08:11:49 PM
^5!
January 28, 2015, 08:08:37 PM
It has tracked just about the same each time I have looked. SP-tech is number 1 and bitmaintech is number 2.
BTW dogie rated sp-tech over bitmaintech. Which is correct in my opinion for today Jan 28th 2015.
I have been making pdf copies of it every 4 or 5 votes just to see if some one tries to poison or skew it off by doing a dozen false votes.
Personally I don't think anyone will bother to do that.
If this poll was done in august when the sp30 came out sp-tech would not have fared as well.
If this poll was done when the s-5's lowered the price down to 310 usd bitmaintech would have fared better then they have done so far.
One of the reasons I agreed to do this was I wanted a current method of knowing what gear is hot. A way for builders to be judged.
I did not really need the fee and it will be sent to wiki as they take btc donations. Guy has told me will send it on monday.
I am looking to run this pool again in early march say the 9th. I may do it every 45 days or so. Biffa if you are willing to help in march let me know. I will show the survey from Jan 28th and may tweak it a bit. do the same thing again.
BTW dogie rated sp-tech over bitmaintech. Which is correct in my opinion for today Jan 28th 2015.
I have been making pdf copies of it every 4 or 5 votes just to see if some one tries to poison or skew it off by doing a dozen false votes.
Personally I don't think anyone will bother to do that.
If this poll was done in august when the sp30 came out sp-tech would not have fared as well.
If this poll was done when the s-5's lowered the price down to 310 usd bitmaintech would have fared better then they have done so far.
One of the reasons I agreed to do this was I wanted a current method of knowing what gear is hot. A way for builders to be judged.
I did not really need the fee and it will be sent to wiki as they take btc donations. Guy has told me will send it on monday.
I am looking to run this pool again in early march say the 9th. I may do it every 45 days or so. Biffa if you are willing to help in march let me know. I will show the survey from Jan 28th and may tweak it a bit. do the same thing again.
January 28, 2015, 08:05:00 PM
The graphical result is pretty 
January 28, 2015, 08:00:02 PM
January 28, 2015, 07:14:38 PM
It's just cross my mind that you can ask other member here who want to contribute like Biffa(or you can choose) to create poll here one poll per member. I believe it's will work
January 28, 2015, 04:16:41 PM
Paid to advertise is ok in my book. People that
follow the threads know the posters intent
but kudos for stating this in op. Same thing as
running banner ads apply. Thanks philipma1957.
follow the threads know the posters intent
but kudos for stating this in op. Same thing as
running banner ads apply. Thanks philipma1957.
January 28, 2015, 11:11:47 AM
I voted #13
But in fairness I have only bought from two vendors on the list and ran only three different manufactures equipment. So I have to lean toward the equipment I know.
But in fairness I have only bought from two vendors on the list and ran only three different manufactures equipment. So I have to lean toward the equipment I know.
yeah i was number 4 the voting and on what will i buy next i put avalon.
is it because i think they are better the sp20 or s-5 no it is because i don't own one and I am curious .
now if AM came out with its new lower watt gear tomorrow. i would end up buying it before the avalon.
is this because i like avalon or am better then sp-tech or bitmaintech no it is about what gear is best for my home mining setup.
right now only the sp20 can do this and give me 1100gh at .52 watts a gh
the photo below is the most important fact for me.
BTW if sp-tech makes an sp50 with the right numbers and i can side mount it in place of the six sp20's it would jump to next gear. I am trying for current gear builders with stuff worth buying now.
January 28, 2015, 10:43:48 AM
...
That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
We'll donate 2 btc for a cause philipma1957 will choose.That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
On a side note, I believe that the current poll after the drama Dogie organized will be severely skewed.
Especially, since anyone with gmail account can vote now.
Guy
after 11 voters it seems okay.
@ guy it is wed we will keep pool running until monday. we will post it here then ask biffa to close it.
At that time I will ask for your company to send the 2 btc to wiki.
The previous ones on the forum didnt run long enough for other manufacturers customers to make an impact either. Plus the poll I put on gdrive isn't searchable on google, you have to have the URL to use it and the URL is only available here. I don't see much difference tbh other than the format is neater and you only need one form for all the questions.
But hey..
took me like 10 minutes to do and cost me zilch so if you don't want it then no problemo Keep it. Let's see.
Yes and the same thing could be said about the poll here, just have to sign up to the forum to vote.
January 28, 2015, 10:39:06 AM
...
That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
We'll donate 2 btc for a cause philipma1957 will choose.That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
On a side note, I believe that the current poll after the drama Dogie organized will be severely skewed.
Especially, since anyone with gmail account can vote now.
Guy
after 11 voters it seems okay.
@ guy it is wed we will keep pool running until monday. we will post it here then ask biffa to close it.
At that time I will ask for your company to send the 2 btc to wiki.
The previous ones on the forum didnt run long enough for other manufacturers customers to make an impact either. Plus the poll I put on gdrive isn't searchable on google, you have to have the URL to use it and the URL is only available here. I don't see much difference tbh other than the format is neater and you only need one form for all the questions.
But hey..
took me like 10 minutes to do and cost me zilch so if you don't want it then no problemo Keep it. Let's see.
Yes and the same thing could be said about the poll here, just have to sign up to the forum to vote.
January 28, 2015, 10:35:56 AM
...
That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
We'll donate 2 btc for a cause philipma1957 will choose.That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
On a side note, I believe that the current poll after the drama Dogie organized will be severely skewed.
Especially, since anyone with gmail account can vote now.
Guy
after 11 voters it seems okay.
@ guy it is wed we will keep pool running until monday. we will post it here then ask biffa to close it.
At that time I will ask for your company to send the 2 btc to wiki.
The previous ones on the forum didnt run long enough for other manufacturers customers to make an impact either. Plus the poll I put on gdrive isn't searchable on google, you have to have the URL to use it and the URL is only available here. I don't see much difference tbh other than the format is neater and you only need one form for all the questions.
But hey..
took me like 10 minutes to do and cost me zilch so if you don't want it then no problemo Keep it. Let's see.
January 28, 2015, 10:33:31 AM
...
That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
We'll donate 2 btc for a cause philipma1957 will choose.That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
On a side note, I believe that the current poll after the drama Dogie organized will be severely skewed.
Especially, since anyone with gmail account can vote now.
Guy
after 11 voters it seems okay.
@ guy it is wed we will keep pool running until monday. we will post it here then ask biffa to close it.
At that time I will ask for your company to send the 2 btc to wiki.
The previous ones on the forum didnt run long enough for other manufacturers customers to make an impact either. Plus the poll I put on gdrive isn't searchable on google, you have to have the URL to use it and the URL is only available here. I don't see much difference tbh other than the format is neater and you only need one form for all the questions.
But hey..
took me like 10 minutes to do and cost me zilch so if you don't want it then no problemo January 28, 2015, 10:28:59 AM
...
That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
We'll donate 2 btc for a cause philipma1957 will choose.That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
On a side note, I believe that the current poll after the drama Dogie organized will be severely skewed.
Especially, since anyone with gmail account can vote now.
Guy
after 11 voters it seems okay.
@ guy it is wed we will keep pool running until monday. we will post it here then ask biffa to close it.
At that time I will ask for your company to send the 2 btc to wiki.
January 28, 2015, 10:26:42 AM
I voted #13
But in fairness I have only bought from two vendors on the list and ran only three different manufactures equipment. So I have to lean toward the equipment I know.
But in fairness I have only bought from two vendors on the list and ran only three different manufactures equipment. So I have to lean toward the equipment I know.
January 28, 2015, 10:23:53 AM
...
That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
We'll donate 2 btc for a cause philipma1957 will choose.That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
On a side note, I believe that the current poll after the drama Dogie organized will be severely skewed.
Especially, since anyone with gmail account can vote now.
Guy
after 11 voters it seems okay
January 28, 2015, 10:22:15 AM
...
That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
We'll donate 2 btc for a cause philipma1957 will choose.That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
On a side note, I believe that the current poll after the drama Dogie organized will be severely skewed.
Especially, since anyone with gmail account can vote now.
Guy
after 11 voters it seems okay.
@ guy it is wed we will keep pool running until monday. we will post it here then ask biffa to close it.
At that time I will ask for your company to send the 2 btc to wiki.
January 28, 2015, 10:21:28 AM
I think that the poll should be open only to forum members. There is good chance it will be skewed now.
Guy
Guy
Guy that boat has long sailed.
Update the OP.
This is what you should have done, IMHO:
Ask Theymos or the global mods to move the survey questions threads from trash to Archival and update the OP links.
Guy we are only human guess its why song's like Billy Joel's 'We didn't start the fire it was always burning" become hits.
I posted what my fee would have been for this in the op. I think I will ask you to donate it to wiki
https://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Ways_to_Give#bitcoin
they take bitcoin.
https://www.coinbase.com/checkouts/44aa9355518928151be736fbd043236c
January 28, 2015, 10:19:59 AM
...
That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
We'll donate 2 btc for a cause philipma1957 will choose.That gear was about 2 btc in value.
...
On a side note, I believe that the current poll after the drama Dogie organized will be severely skewed.
Especially, since anyone with gmail account can vote now.
Guy
January 28, 2015, 10:19:25 AM
I think that the poll should be open only to forum members. There is good chance it will be skewed now.
Guy
Guy
Guy that boat has long sailed.
Update the OP.
This is what you should have done, IMHO:
Ask Theymos or the global mods to move the survey questions threads from trash to Archival and update the OP links.
Guy we are only human guess its why song's like Billy Joel's 'We didn't start the fire it was always burning" become hits.
I posted what my fee would have been for this in the op. I think I will ask you to donate it to wiki
https://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Ways_to_Give#bitcoin
they take bitcoin.
https://www.coinbase.com/checkouts/44aa9355518928151be736fbd043236c
As of now there are 11 votes in the poll.
January 28, 2015, 10:12:29 AM
I think that the poll should be open only to forum members. There is good chance it will be skewed now.
Guy
Guy
Guy that boat has long sailed.
This is what you should have done, IMHO:
Ask Theymos or the global mods to move the survey questions threads from trash to Archival and update the OP links.
January 28, 2015, 10:08:49 AM
I think that the poll should be open only to forum members. There is good chance it will be skewed now.
Guy
Guy
Oh I don't know, any poll can be skewed even the ones here if you put enough effort into it.
I made the gdrive one so you could only vote once (per google account)
Jump to: