The moon is a dead rock. Mars is a PLANET with WATER. A base on the moon probably couldn't be self-sufficient for a long time, a base on mars could be the start of an entire secondary planet. They could terraform the planet, access the water supply, grow plants, turn it into a second earth more or less... the moon is mainly just strategic value.
Once a colony was established on Mars after some initial setup and supply periods it could easily become self-sustaining and even profitable. You wouldn't have to harvest materials and send them back to earth to make a return on the investment and please let's NOT DO THAT anyhow. What, we strip this planet dry and then rape another planet? That's not a good plan and then what happens when we strip mars dry? Better to learn how to make do with what we have, improve recycling and environmental cleanup technologies, etc.
A colony on Mars could do all kinds of other work that don't require delivery of a physical product in order to pay back the setup costs. They could write code, do research, etc... think a little wider than just "we take shiny metal from ground!"
Once a colony was established on Mars after some initial setup and supply periods it could easily become self-sustaining and even profitable. You wouldn't have to harvest materials and send them back to earth to make a return on the investment and please let's NOT DO THAT anyhow. What, we strip this planet dry and then rape another planet? That's not a good plan and then what happens when we strip mars dry? Better to learn how to make do with what we have, improve recycling and environmental cleanup technologies, etc.
A colony on Mars could do all kinds of other work that don't require delivery of a physical product in order to pay back the setup costs. They could write code, do research, etc... think a little wider than just "we take shiny metal from ground!"
NASA-Funded Scientists Detect Water on Moon's Surface that Hints at Water Below
PASADENA - NASA-funded lunar research has yielded evidence of water locked in mineral grains on the surface of the moon from an unknown source deep beneath the surface. Using data from NASA's Moon Mineralogy Mapper (M3) instrument aboard the Indian Space Research Organization's Chandrayaan-1 spacecraft, scientists remotely detected magmatic water, or water that originates from deep within the moon's interior, on the surface of the moon.
The findings, published Aug. 25 in Nature Geoscience, represent the first detection of this form of water from lunar orbit. Earlier studies had shown the existence of magmatic water in lunar samples returned during NASA's Apollo program.
M3 imaged the lunar impact crater Bullialdus, which lies near the lunar equator. Scientists were interested in studying this area because they could better quantify the amount of water inside the rocks due to the crater's location and the type of rocks it held. The central peak of the crater is made up of a type of rock that forms deep within the lunar crust and mantle when magma is trapped underground.
"This rock, which normally resides deep beneath the surface, was excavated from the lunar depths by the impact that formed Bullialdus crater," said Rachel Klima, a planetary geologist at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory (APL) in Laurel, Md.
"Compared to its surroundings, we found that the central portion of this crater contains a significant amount of hydroxyl - a molecule consisting of one oxygen atom and one hydrogen atom -- which is evidence that the rocks in this crater contain water that originated beneath the lunar surface," Klima said.
In 2009, M3 provided the first mineralogical map of the lunar surface and discovered water molecules in the polar regions of the moon. This water is thought to be a thin layer formed from solar wind hitting the moon's surface. Bullialdus crater is in a region with an unfavorable environment for solar wind to produce significant amounts of water on the surface.
"NASA missions like Lunar Prospector and the Lunar Crater Observation and Sensing Satellite and instruments like M3 have gathered crucial data that fundamentally changed our understanding of whether water exists on the surface of the moon," said S. Pete Worden, center director at NASA's Ames Research Center in Moffett Field, Calif. "Similarly, we hope that upcoming NASA missions such as the Lunar Atmosphere and Dust Environment Explorer, or LADEE, will change our understanding of the lunar sky."
The detection of internal water from orbit means scientists can begin to test some of the findings from sample studies in a broader context, including in regions that are far from where the Apollo sites are clustered on the near side of the moon. For many years, researchers believed that the rocks from the moon were bone-dry and any water detected in the Apollo samples had to be contamination from Earth.
"Now that we have detected water that is likely from the interior of the moon, we can start to compare this water with other characteristics of the lunar surface," said Klima. "This internal magmatic water also provides clues about the moon's volcanic processes and internal composition, which helps us address questions about how the moon formed, and how magmatic processes changed as it cooled."
The Moon Mineralogy Mapper was selected as a Mission of Opportunity through the NASA Discovery Program. NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, Calif., designed and built the Moon Mineralogy Mapper and is home to its project manager, Mary White. JPL managed the program for NASA's Science Mission Directorate, Washington. Carle Pieters of Brown University, Providence, R.I., was the principal investigator. Joshua Cahill and David Lawrence of APL and Justin Hagerty of the U.S. Geological Survey's Astrogeology Science Center in Flagstaff, Ariz., co-authored the paper. The Chandrayaan-1 spacecraft was constructed, launched, and is operated by the Indian Space Research Organisation.
http://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/news.php?release=2013-262
