I got my S1 today and connected it with this 600W PSU. It had one PCI-Express 6 PIN cable and i was cutting the other 12V and GND cables.
But when I've turned the antminer on, the fan was not moving. I've checked it and tried it on a motherboard and the fan was working. But it did not work on the antminer slots. But other fans were working on the antminer. But those fans were too weak so I've installed a heavy and strong fan which is connected directly to an electric power socket (this fan had even the same size but is for walls).
Then i was setting up the miner via browser. Changed the ip, checked DHCP...everything ok. Connected it with my router (Thomson TG585) and was able to see the connected Antminer on my router page.
But the miner did not start to mine. It was drawing 67 Watt at start and some minutes later 105 Watt. I thought it is a problem with my PSU.
So i've tried it with my 525 Watt Enermax PSU and connected it to the miner with two PCI-Express 6 PIN Cables.
But the same problem. Does not start to mine. But draws 59Watt at start and 101Watt some minutes later. By coincidence i've discovered that the basic fan is working if i connect only the Blade without the controller to the PSU. But does not work reverse.
I've no experience with this and i don't think it is my PSU. Did I miss something or is my Antminer broken? Or is it my PSU?
TL:DR
S1 is not mining. Draws not enough power. Fan is moving only when the PSU is single-connected to the blade without the controller.
I can't find specs for your first PSU, but the second one has 3 12v rails that split the 480w available at 12v, so that could be why you're not getting enough power. Look under the specifications tab on the link you posted. Ideally you should use a PSU with one rail for 12v with enough power.
Are you using two separate pcie wires or one wire with two connectors? You should use one dedicated wire for each blade.