Author

Topic: Silk road and Bitcointalk. How it played a role in its rise and fall. (Read 910 times)

legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1926
฿ear ride on the rainbow slide
There is some evidence of multiple DPRs

https://freeross.org/proof-of-multiple-dprs/
https://reason.com/2016/12/01/a-dread-pirate-roberts-was-using-a-silk/

The DPR account was used after Ulbricht was arrested.
Someone logged into the DPR account on Silk Road's forum on November 18, 2013.
Ulbricht had been in jail since Oct 1.

There were also some theories who the other DPR was.



https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4516868-U-S-20v-20-Roger-20-Clark-20-Indictment.html
copper member
Activity: 2926
Merit: 2348
Ulbright’s lawyers admitted in his trial that Ross created Silk Road (but claimed he subsequently sold it to an unknown person). Further the person who created Silk Road left an email address with Ross’s name asking for help coding Silk Road and there was later additional unconnected evidence that Ross created Silk Road.

The evidence is pretty strong that Ross created Silk Road. In theory, they could have partnered with Ross, but I would have thought the government would have uncovered some evidence to support this on Ross’s laptop or the SR servers, which I believe they didn’t. Further, the moderation policy of the forum at the time seems to indicate theymos didn’t have an interest in SR.
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1926
฿ear ride on the rainbow slide
Craig Wright accused Martti Malmi and Theymos in open court to be the masterminds behind Silk Road.
Accusations made in a courtroom are covered by absolute privilege and cannot be used for defamation proceedings.



Martti replied:

Again, it would be great to know if Wright's statements had truth behind them or not:

Of course not, do you really need to ask?

 - I was made a forum admin in 2011, after Satoshi left. (Silk Road also appeared after Satoshi left.) I didn't have any special access to bitcoin.org until around 2013, and in fact I didn't even have any access to the bitcointalk.org DNS until 2013.
 - I've never bought or sold anything on Silk Road, Hydra or similar sites; nor did I have anything whatsoever to do with their operation; nor AFAIK did I even have interactions with anyone involved in running these sites. While I am opposed to drug laws, I have never used illicit drugs, and in fact I also abstain from alcohol & nicotine. Furthermore, since the beginning I have warned over and over again that Tor is not secure against active government attacks: I wouldn't be found dead running one of these sites.
 - I never had any interaction with CSW. I don't have any keys related to CSW's (probably fictitious) SSS thing.

CSW's whole shtick is to just lie constantly. He's so brazen about it that some people think, "there must be some truth there," but really it's 100% nonsense.

I admit I was a little tempted to troll the world by roleplaying CSW's allegations as totally true...
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1926
฿ear ride on the rainbow slide
UPDATE:
Silk Road Administrator Libertas Plea bargain- Guilty plea.

Gary Davis, an Irishman known as ‘Libertas’ on Silk Road who was extradited to the United States in July has pled guilty to: "conspiring to distribute narcotics".

Quote
Authorities claim that Davis received weekly remittances from Ulbricht exceeding $1,000 during 2013 in exchange for his work as part of a three-man team that is believed to have operated the anonymous market on behalf of its founder, Ross Ulbricht. Davis served as a forum moderator from May 2013 up to June 2013 for Silk Road, and as a site administrator from June 2013 up until Oct. 2, 2013.

https://news.bitcoin.com/silk-road-libertas-guilty/

Davis is due to be sentenced on January 17, 2019.
full member
Activity: 378
Merit: 102
It is very interesting, that is, a former agent who is serving a sentence, with each increase in the rate of bitcoin his term of imprisonment increases? Grin
full member
Activity: 490
Merit: 123
The thread is shocking, interesting and about legendary topic . Thanks for sharing and makeing this post in hronological manner.
It seems that there is much more to this story rather than just arresting and justly sentecing a drug dealer.
jr. member
Activity: 139
Merit: 1
This is quite interesting. I recently heard about This story in a podcast... and such an amazing story too. A guy without any programming background made such an advanced website.

If only his efforts were in a more productive direction.
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1926
฿ear ride on the rainbow slide


Apparently making a post about Silkroad and advocating for free speech on the internet makes me a drug dealer according to this now banned former member of bitcointalk.  Grin

Using that logic I think I need to make a post about geniuses and bitcoin billionaires.
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1926
฿ear ride on the rainbow slide
Back when SR was open, talking about Silk Road was somewhat taboo, I have read that people were banned for talking about it (this likely included the posting of links to SR).

Bitcoin was largely still in its infancy when SR1 was running and except for the last few months before shutting down, law enforcement had no idea who was running it. I believe I have read that theymos at one point was suspected as being behind SR, which logically would have contributed to SR being taboo.

Yes- I noticed that when doing the research. There were a few post and threads that "disappeared".

copper member
Activity: 2926
Merit: 2348
Back when SR was open, talking about Silk Road was somewhat taboo, I have read that people were banned for talking about it (this likely included the posting of links to SR).

Bitcoin was largely still in its infancy when SR1 was running and except for the last few months before shutting down, law enforcement had no idea who was running it. I believe I have read that theymos at one point was suspected as being behind SR, which logically would have contributed to SR being taboo.
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1926
฿ear ride on the rainbow slide
March 1, 2011 User “silkroad” advertises Silk Road on bitcointalk.org.
https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=3984.0
Wow! Is this really for real? It's shocking to know that silkroad was advertised here in the forum. But I'm just wondering how this kind of stuff is allowed here despite of its bad influence and this thread is still open until now. They sell illegal drugs, take note, illegal and IMO it's not healthy for the forum. I foresee that selling of such stuffs are yet to come and it's very alarming, I hope that mods will take action regarding this.

You didn't check the post before writing such a comment here.
Here is a quote from theymos in that post-
Quote
This topic was briefly removed due to the "illegal trading" policy, but I decided that since you're not actually selling drugs in this thread, it's OK. (Maybe some other moderator/admin will disagree with my later decision, though.) Sorry about that.
Agree with that. He was not selling anything here.



Thanks for pointing that out. It confirms my opinion as to why it wasn't removed and I've added it to the thread. I agree with theymos.

Tolerated with some reluctance. On the basis of free speech.

member
Activity: 205
Merit: 29
Love yourself.
March 1, 2011 User “silkroad” advertises Silk Road on bitcointalk.org.
https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=3984.0
Wow! Is this really for real? It's shocking to know that silkroad was advertised here in the forum. But I'm just wondering how this kind of stuff is allowed here despite of its bad influence and this thread is still open until now. They sell illegal drugs, take note, illegal and IMO it's not healthy for the forum. I foresee that selling of such stuffs are yet to come and it's very alarming, I hope that mods will take action regarding this.

You didn't check the post before writing such a comment here.
Here is a quote from theymos in that post-
Quote
This topic was briefly removed due to the "illegal trading" policy, but I decided that since you're not actually selling drugs in this thread, it's OK. (Maybe some other moderator/admin will disagree with my later decision, though.) Sorry about that.
Agree with that. He was not selling anything here.
full member
Activity: 504
Merit: 185
March 1, 2011 User “silkroad” advertises Silk Road on bitcointalk.org.
https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=3984.0
Wow! Is this really for real? It's shocking to know that silkroad was advertised here in the forum. But I'm just wondering how this kind of stuff is allowed here despite of its bad influence and this thread is still open until now. They sell illegal drugs, take note, illegal and IMO it's not healthy for the forum. I foresee that selling of such stuffs are yet to come and it's very alarming, I hope that mods will take action regarding this.

Wow if you read the fucking rules you would know but you are a motherfucking signature spammer

It is only illegal if it is illegal in the sellers country
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1926
฿ear ride on the rainbow slide
March 1, 2011 User “silkroad” advertises Silk Road on bitcointalk.org.
https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=3984.0
Wow! Is this really for real? It's shocking to know that silkroad was advertised here in the forum. But I'm just wondering how this kind of stuff is allowed here despite of its bad influence and this thread is still open until now. They sell illegal drugs, take note, illegal and IMO it's not healthy for the forum. I foresee that selling of such stuffs are yet to come and it's very alarming, I hope that mods will take action regarding this.

It is very hard to "police" something like this. There is also a certain amount of "free speech" involved. Bitcointalk evolved from the cypherpunk movement so there is a reluctance to censor too much. Silk road advertising on bitcointalk was limited to stating "Silk Road is an anonymous online market." It didn't detail any illegal activities.

Considering that Silk road at that stage was just starting as an experiment it also wasn't doing anything illegal ...yet.

I've been a moderator on a forum that got bombarded with 10000+ scam and spam messages a day. It is easy to overlook one or mistake it for a genuine post. As someone from a reasonably sheltered background I find it extremely interesting to read about - while I would not partake in the drug culture myself. I think it is a brave stance not to censor too much.
full member
Activity: 1232
Merit: 186
March 1, 2011 User “silkroad” advertises Silk Road on bitcointalk.org.
https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=3984.0
Wow! Is this really for real? It's shocking to know that silkroad was advertised here in the forum. But I'm just wondering how this kind of stuff is allowed here despite of its bad influence and this thread is still open until now. They sell illegal drugs, take note, illegal and IMO it's not healthy for the forum. I foresee that selling of such stuffs are yet to come and it's very alarming, I hope that mods will take action regarding this.
newbie
Activity: 39
Merit: 0
Pretty interesting read, and as you can see the government can do whatever they want, legal or not.
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1926
฿ear ride on the rainbow slide
This is a work in progress. Comments, additions and corrections welcome.

June 09, 2010, [POST] A Heroin Store (Thread subject of a subpoena)
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/a-heroin-store-175
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.3900 (anonymous guest post)



February 2011 Silk Road is launched.



March 1, 2011 User “silkroad” advertises Silk Road on bitcointalk.org.
https://bitcointalk.org/?topic=3984.0









June 2011 Chicago Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) agent Jared Der-Yeghiayan starts investigating Silk Road.

June 5, 2011 Senator Chuck Schumer calls for “crackdown” on Silk Road and use of Bitcoin.

June 08, 2011, Silk Road Account for sale!
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/silk-road-account-13709



June 09, 2011 Bitcointalk user Silkroad posts:
The journal was divided up into multiple files, neatly organized in different directories by year. Later iterations of the journal were organized by quarter, by month, and by week. The 2010 journal—before Silk Road was launched—came in the form of a long, literary rumination. By 2013, the journal had broken down into short, terse, daily logs of activity on Silk Road.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahjeong/2015/01/22/the-dread-pirates-diary/#6ec000d542cf

February 4, 2015 Ross is found guilty on all counts.

March 31, 2015 Corruption of Silk Road investigation revealed.
“The complete scope of what former SA’s Force and Bridges were able to accomplish with the illicit access they gained to the Silk Road website, and its impact on this case, has yet to be determined.” – Joshua Dratel, lead trial attorney

April 16, 2015 Dratel files motion for new trial (and this one too) based on the fact that AUSA Turner hid corrupt agent Bridges from the defense and the judge.

April 27, 2015 Judge Forrest denies motion for new trial.

May 26, 2015 Ross writes sentencing letter addressed to Judge Forrest pleading to leave him his old age.

“Silk Road was supposed to be about giving people the freedom to make their own choices, to pursue their own happiness, however they individually saw fit.” – Ross in sentencing letter to Judge Forrest

May 29, 2015 Sentencing. Double life plus 40 years, without the possibility of parole, on five non-violent charges.
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/silk-road-founder-ross-ulbricht-sentenced-to-life-in-prison-1074337

June 9, 2015 Government issues a grand jury subpoena/gag order to Reason.com to turn over identities of people who commented on Ross’s sentence.

June 18, 2015, Ex-U.S. federal Agents Charged With Bitcoin Theft to Plead Guilty
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/2015-06-18-ex-us-agent-charged-with-bitcoin-theft-to-plead-guilty-1093358
https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/former-federal-agents-charged-bitcoin-money-laundering-and-wire-fraud

January 14, 2016 Appeal submitted to Second Circuit.

Jan 28, 2016 Bridges arrested again trying to flee the country to avoid jail sentence.

February 20, 2016 Edward Snowden publicly states that we should assume that the NSA was involved in gathering evidence in Ross’s case.

March 15, 2016 Appeal brief joined by six amici:
National Association. of Criminal Defense Lawyers
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Edward Snowden: NSA was involved in Silk Road investigation
Drug Policy Alliance — Law Enforcement Against Prohibition — JustLeadershipUSA — Former Federal Judge Nancy Gertner


May 15, 2016 SILK ROAD 3.0 – Back Online and Open For Business
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/silk-road-30-back-online-and-open-for-business-1473248



November 29, 2016 Tampering of evidence announced.
“That my son — or anyone — would receive a life sentence based on such vulnerable evidence, especially when there is proof of corruption and tampering, is a travesty of justice.” – Lyn Ulbricht

December 1, 2016 Log-in by Dread Pirate Roberts after Ross arrested announced.

December 02, 2016, Free Ross-A-Thon Livestream for Silk Road Appeal Case
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/free-ross-a-thon-livestream-for-silk-road-appeal-case-1700974
   
May 28, 2017 [SOLD] SILK ROAD .999 SILVER BITCOIN WALLET
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/sold-silk-road-999-silver-bitcoin-wallet-1936765


May 29, 2017 Appeal denied.

July 14, 2017 Ross moved to USP Florence, CO, a maximum security penitentiary.

July 31, 2017 Petition to Second Circuit to re-hear appeal filed.
First Amendment violations at sentencing
Unconstitutional warrants
Warrantless surveillance


August 15, 2017,Secret Service agent, corrupted by Silk Road case, admits to second heist
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/secret-service-agent-corrupted-by-silk-road-case-admits-to-second-heist-2092664

August 29, 2017 Petition to re-hear denied by Second Circuit without comment.

November 04, 2017, [WTS] 1 BTC - Silk Road memorabilia! "Carl Mark Force IV" business card for sale !
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/wts-5-btc-silk-road-memorabilia-carl-mark-force-iv-business-card-2358801


November 08, 2017,  Ex-agent in Silk Road probe gets more prison time for bitcoin theft.
The initial theft was valued at $359,005 in 2015 but have been re-valued at $11.3 million in 2017.
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/2017-11-07-ex-agent-in-silk-road-probe-gets-more-prison-time-for-bitcoin-theft-2374117

December 22, 2017 Defense led by Kannon Shanmugam files petition for Writ of Certiorari asking Supreme Court to review the decision of the lower courts.

February 5, 2018 Petition for writ joined by the following amici (21 organizations):
American Black Cross
Drug Policy Alliance — Law Enforcement Action Partnership
United States Supreme Court Building
Downsize DC Foundation — Conservative Legal Defense and Education Fund — Gun Owners Foundation — Gun Owners of America — Restoring Liberty Action Committee
National Lawyers Guild — American Conservative Union Foundation Center for Criminal Justice Reform — FreedomWorks — Human Rights Defense Center — Judge Nancy Gertner — National Coalition to Protect Civil Freedoms — Partnership for Civil Justice Fund — People’s Law Office
Reason Foundation — Cato Institute  — Competitive Enterprise Institute — R Street Institute


February 5, 2018 Judge Forrest denies unopposed motion to extend deadline to submit newly-discovered evidence.
Judge Forrest denies motion for her to recuse herself.


March 7, 2018 Defense Attorney Paul Grant files petition for Writ Of Mandamus to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.

March 20, 2018 Defense led by Kannon Shanmugam files reply to government in support of Supreme Court cert petition.

Silkroad personalities:

Silkroad Founder: DPR:
Silkroad 1 = Ross Ulbricht
Silkroad 2 = SilkRoad 1 user StExo and / or SilkRoad 1 user Defcon = Blake Benthall
Silkroad 3 = ?

Dread Pirate Roberts 2 once made the fatal mistake early on during Silk Road 2 of signing a message with St.Exo’s PGP key..  DPR2 quickly realized his mistake and edited his post.

Ross Ulbricht used a real photograph of himself for a fake ID to rent servers.
He stated in his linkedin profile: that he was ‘creating an economic simulation’ designed to ‘give people a first-hand experience of what it would be like to live in a world without the systemic use of force’ by ‘institutions and governments’.
In March 2012, a user registered on the coding Q&A site Stack Overflow with Ulbricht’s email address and the username 'Ross Ulbricht'. He then proceeded to post the question “How can I connect to a Tor hidden service using curl in php?”
He sought contacts in courier firms, presumably to work out how to best ship things from his international multimillion dollar drugs marketplace, on Google+, where his real name, real face and real YouTube profile were visible
- Altoid mentions Silk Road: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.42670 (deleted the original message but his quote is still there)
- Altoid identifies as Ross Ulbricht: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.568744.
The real IP of the silk road server was emitted via a lighthttpd config error
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/01/the-incredibly-simple-story-of-how-the-govt-googled-ross-ulbricht/



Defcon (Blake Benthall) he registered the silk road 2.0 servers with the email address [email protected]

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/11/fbi-arrests-blake-defcon-benthall-alleged-operator-of-silk-road-2-0/


Mentor: Variety Jones (allegedly - Roger Thomas Clark) (Alt: Cimon, Plural of Mongoose)
Who is "Variety Jones"?

Moderators:
Andrew Michael Jones  -  Inigo - USA
Gary Davis – Libertas -  Ireland
Peter Phillip Nash - Samesamebutdifferent  (Chief moderator) - Australia (Alts = Batman73, Symmetry, and Anonymousaashit)

Site admin chronicpain (Alt:Flush) , the target of an alleged murder-for-hire plot, was identified in 2013 as Curtis Clark Green.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/ryanmac/2013/11/08/meet-the-silk-road-employee-that-the-dread-pirate-roberts-allegedly-tried-to-murder/#427ad601412c

Brian Richard Farrell = Silk Road 2.0. administrator called “DoctorClu”.
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/hand-man-silk-road-2-0-creator-arrested-feds-article-1.2086750

Mike Wattier =  Smed, or Smedley (Alt:Charger)
Steven Lloyd Sadler  & Jenna White = Nod (USA) (Alt: PaythePiper (bought from another user), Poundsign)
Peter Ward, = PlutoPete (UK)
Cei William Owens = Johnny Alpha (UK)

But, although DPR was technically the head of Silk Road, chat logs found in the accessed email account show that Variety Jones and Smed were a real driving force behind the projects and Silk Road more generally. The pair discussed ideas and plans with each other, rather than simply reporting to DPR.

Smed, using his alternate handle, spoke with Variety Jones about developments to the site, such as adding bulk transactions and updates to the forums.

When it came to those discussions, it was as if Variety Jones was Smed's boss, not DPR. "What timeframe do you envision?" Smed asked Variety Jones of one project.

Variety Jones also appears to have funded large parts of Smed's work and expenses. "10k, 36k, 20k, that rounds up nicely to 90, and we'll cover all of your travel expenses for the trip, how does that sound," Variety Jones writes to Smed.

Arrests page



Main source:
https://freeross.org/case-timeline/
A large part of the timeline was obtained from this site and only slightly modified.

Other sources:
https://antilop.cc/sr/
https://allthingsvice.com/2015/05/27/silk-road-from-the-inside-moderator-ssbd-tells-his-story/
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/silk-road-trail-of-1132989btc-310600
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/silk-road-anonymous-marketplace-feedback-requested-3984
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/the-most-iconic-bitcointalk-threads-history-on-bitcointalk-4322078
https://www.wired.com/2015/12/variety-jones-alleged-silk-road-mentor-arrested-in-thailand/
https://www.dailydot.com/layer8/silk-road-3-blake-benthall/
https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/pgajmv/these-are-the-two-forgotten-architects-of-the-silk-road

This is a work in progress. Comments, additions and corrections welcome.
Jump to: