Pages:
Author

Topic: [Unofficial] New Global Moderator Election - [Discussion] - page 3. (Read 11225 times)

legendary
Activity: 3808
Merit: 7912
Is the spreadsheet no longer being updated?

 I see 34 votes for Lauda and 33 votes for Mitchell but the post above shows quite a different outcome.
You're looking at the wrong sheet. The one above are votes after-elimination. This is the sheet that you should be looking at:



 Ah!  Thank you.  I see it now, we're tabulating the results as if the race is over before it's over and eliminating other candidates until one has a majority.
I guess since the voting has tapered off, this is okay but does this lead would-be voters down the proverbial garden path?   I mean let's say I wanted to vote for Xandry (hypothetically - this isn't electioneering) as my first choice but I already know he is eliminated and I want my vote to count, it could change the way I order my selections consciously or subconsciously.  Maybe the race is so close and I really don't want the current leader to win, it allows me to place my vote strategically in an attempt to subvert the election.  Just thinking out loud.
 
legendary
Activity: 2674
Merit: 2965
Terminated.
Is the spreadsheet no longer being updated?

 I see 34 votes for Lauda and 33 votes for Mitchell but the post above shows quite a different outcome.
You're looking at the wrong sheet. The one above are votes after-elimination. This is the sheet that you should be looking at:

legendary
Activity: 3808
Merit: 7912
Is the spreadsheet no longer being updated?

 I see 34 votes for Lauda and 33 votes for Mitchell but the post above shows quite a different outcome.
legendary
Activity: 4522
Merit: 3183
Vile Vixen and Miss Bitcointalk 2021-2023
Two candidate preferred vote:
|
   Lauda (47.4%) ▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓█▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓ (52.6%) Mitchell
|
Lauda: 45
Mitchell: 50
Exhausted: 18

Swing-o-meter:
|
   Lauda (-0.5%) ░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░████░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░ (+0.5%) Mitchell
|
The election race slows down with only a single additional vote since yesterday. There's not much to say about it. Mitchell looks set to win by a slim margin.
legendary
Activity: 2674
Merit: 2965
Terminated.
It is all fine now as we have internally solved the conflict in addition to dserrano's list wiping itself. There have been pretty much no more votes today.
copper member
Activity: 1498
Merit: 1528
No I dont escrow anymore.
What's an idiot like franky1 even doing in DT anyway?

Thatd be a question for dserrano5. Seems to be unrelated to this "election" though. Im sure it will blow up somewhere else in meta or reputation soon.

Code:
$ cat trust.txt | grep franky1
dserrano5->franky1
Welsh->franky1
worthyou->franky1
legendary
Activity: 4522
Merit: 3183
Vile Vixen and Miss Bitcointalk 2021-2023
What's an idiot like franky1 even doing in DT anyway?
Vod
legendary
Activity: 3668
Merit: 3010
Licking my boob since 1970
Yes they do. Check their trust page for a rating by 'franky1'.

I find it unnerving that one single negative rating can override many positive ratings.   Undecided
legendary
Activity: 2352
Merit: 1267
In Memory of Zepher
Lauda receiving red trust, will it effect on global mod election ?
I can't imagine so. If Lauda had voted - which they didn't - their vote would have been invalidated, though receiving a negative trust doesn't change that they are a Staff member that is eligible to be promoted to Global.

I don't think that Lauda has any neg from a member in DT,.
Yes they do. Check their trust page for a rating by 'franky1'.
legendary
Activity: 1638
Merit: 1010
https://www.bitcoin.com/
I got my vote in.

Lauda receiving red trust, will it effect on global mod election ?
I don't think that Lauda has any neg from a member in DT,.
In my opinion he is one of the most active staff members on the forum, sometimes maybe a little harsh in his comments but he just tells it how it is.
Its easy for others to judge but we all have different personalities and at the end of the day i always find Lauda's decisions fair
Mderating a forum is not as easy as some would think.
legendary
Activity: 1163
Merit: 1005
Lauda receiving red trust, will it effect on global mod election ?
legendary
Activity: 4522
Merit: 3183
Vile Vixen and Miss Bitcointalk 2021-2023
Two candidate preferred vote:
|
   Lauda (47.9%) ▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓█▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓▓ (52.1%) Mitchell
|
Lauda: 45
Mitchell: 49
Exhausted: 18

Swing-o-meter:
|
   Lauda (+0.7%) ░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░█████░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░░ (-0.7%) Mitchell
|
The gap between Lauda and Mitchell continues to narrow, with just 4 votes separating them. But with only 3 days remaining in this election, will Lauda be able to catch up? It's worth noting that 4 of the exhausted ballots had all 3 preferences. These could have potentially changed the outcome had more than 3 preferences been allowed.



You can check the edit history of the spreadsheet.
Huh No, I can't. It would have been easier if I could.
legendary
Activity: 3556
Merit: 9709
#1 VIP Crypto Casino
Just made my vote, glad to participate in my own little way. Good luck to those in the reckoning.
legendary
Activity: 3514
Merit: 1280
English ⬄ Russian Translation Services
No idea. Some people wanted to delete their votes Huh

Because it cuts both ways

As I said above, theymos appointing someone as a new global moderator who is not proclaimed as such by the mob would be effectively neglecting the choice of the forum members (that's why I come to think that there will be no new global moderator, at least, for the time being). But people aren't quite happy when they are neglected, though they understand in general that their opinion should not have been asked at all in the first place. Obviously, folks don't want to get involved in this affair any more, and after giving it a second thought, they decided to remove their votes altogether
staff
Activity: 3458
Merit: 6793
Just writing some code
Foxpup, Lauda here is what happened.

I removed redsn0w, he was on there twice. Apparently he voted twice, so both were removed. He did edit his vote, and I let that slide since he only added someone to his vote and that was before I said that the multiple vote rule was not retroactive. However it was brought to my attention that he had deleted his original vote and voted again, so he was removed.

You can check the edit history of the spreadsheet.
legendary
Activity: 2674
Merit: 2965
Terminated.
Yes, and that used to be case, but it isn't now.
[1] I have updated the sheets and added everyone back with reasoning for vote invalidation. I'll wait for Achow to double-check.

I could have sworn I saw Yuuto's post earlier. But it's gone now. What the Hell's going on here?
No idea. Some people wanted to delete their votes Huh

Updated post.
legendary
Activity: 4522
Merit: 3183
Vile Vixen and Miss Bitcointalk 2021-2023
IMO deleting it from the spreadsheet is wrong. As long as votes get changed/removed they should be kept there with a comment (and obviously invalidated if appropriate).
Yes, and that used to be case, but it isn't now.

From my own findings, the following votes are invalid and can not be found in the voting sheet:
wazzap (negative rating)
Gunthar (electioneering?)
Docnaster (Unknown?)
Quickseller(negative rating)
Don't forget vindicare (electioneering).

This votes are present in the sheet but have been deleted (no post exists):
Quote
Yuuto   - Achow, Mitchell, Dabs
Seansky - Dabs, Achow, Mitchell
I could have sworn I saw Yuuto's post earlier. But it's gone now. What the Hell's going on here?
legendary
Activity: 2674
Merit: 2965
Terminated.
Wait, that can't be right. Docnaster's vote isn't in my list of mprep preference flows. Neither of us were counting it in the first place. (Oops. Embarrassed) Looking at the raw numbers, I see I have an extra primary vote for Mitchell that isn't on the spreadsheet (but it definitely was, because the numbers used to match). And I wasn't keeping track of the primary votes since I was relying on the spreadsheet for that. It must have been deleted from both the thread and the spreadsheet.
IMO deleting it from the spreadsheet is wrong. As long as votes get changed/removed they should be kept there with a comment (and obviously invalidated if appropriate). From my own findings, the following votes are invalid and can not be found in the voting sheet:
wazzap (negative rating)
Gunthar (electioneering?)
Docnaster (Unknown?)
Quickseller(negative rating)

This votes are present in the sheet but have been deleted (no post exists):
Quote
Yuuto   - Achow, Mitchell, Dabs
Seansky - Dabs, Achow, Mitchell
legendary
Activity: 4522
Merit: 3183
Vile Vixen and Miss Bitcointalk 2021-2023
EDIT: After manually recounting all the votes, I've discovered that Docnaster's vote has vanished,
Wait, that can't be right. Docnaster's vote isn't in my list of mprep preference flows. Neither of us were counting it in the first place. (Oops. Embarrassed) Looking at the raw numbers, I see I have an extra primary vote for Mitchell that isn't on the spreadsheet (but it definitely was, because the numbers used to match). And I wasn't keeping track of the primary votes since I was relying on the spreadsheet for that. It must have been deleted from both the thread and the spreadsheet.
legendary
Activity: 2674
Merit: 2965
Terminated.
I counted a vote for Mitchell from redsn0w since he was allowed to change it.
I do not think he was allowed to change it though. Nobody is allowed to change their vote excluding people that have voted prior to the addition to Hostfat, thus redsn0w's vote is now invalid if I'm correct.


I remember this distinctly because it caused me a great deal of confusion when I didn't notice it was changed and my results were off by one vote. That vote is no longer on the spreadsheet, and there's no explanation of where it went, as there was the previous times votes were deleted. Another vote has vanished, and I'm still trying to determine whose, though it must have been a vote for Mitchell (after preferences) since I checked my results when I posted and they matched the spreadsheet at the time.

I hope achow101 can shed some light on this troubling development. Undecided
I'll double check every existing vote from the thread, just hold up until I clear up some backlog. Maybe someone deleted theirs, since you are technically allowed to delete your vote but any follow up vote would be invalid.
Pages:
Jump to: