Bitcoin Forum>Other>Meta
Pages:
Author

Topic: [Updated August 2023] How many banned users have you merited? - page 4. (Read 2158 times)

tranthidung
legendary
Activity: 2310
Merit: 4085
Farewell o_e_l_e_o
Re: [Updated August 2023] How many banned users have you merited?
March 06, 2019, 08:59:58 AM
#7
Quote from: suchmoon on March 06, 2019, 08:51:42 AM
Also see: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=merit;stats=topsendban
It is normal to see many merit sources in the list of top senders to perma-banned users.
I don't doubt about the standpoint and strictly rules of merit sources on quality of posts before they send their sMerits to those ones.
I don't think merit sources abuse their allocated sMerits because they are the most reliable, well-known members of forum.
It's really scarce to see merit sources removed by theymos more than one year after the start of merit system.
It is probably that those newbies or those users (at higher ranks) tried making pseudo-quality posts to get merit, or at least only one merit.
Then, after that or during most of their time spent in the forum, they mostly made shitty one, and violate forum rules like plagiarism that in turn led them to bans.
suchmoon
legendary
Activity: 3654
Merit: 8909
https://bpip.org
Re: [Updated August 2023] How many banned users have you merited?
March 06, 2019, 08:51:42 AM
#6
Also see: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=merit;stats=topsendban
LoyceV
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
Re: [Updated August 2023] How many banned users have you merited?
March 06, 2019, 08:41:14 AM
#5
Quote from: tranthidung on March 06, 2019, 08:36:54 AM
Moreover, foserfox got permanent ban too.
In bold red:
Quote from: LoyceV on March 06, 2019, 07:10:37 AM
    1. 45 (43.26%) banned users merited by foserfox Banned! (details)
tranthidung
legendary
Activity: 2310
Merit: 4085
Farewell o_e_l_e_o
Re: [Updated August 2023] How many banned users have you merited?
March 06, 2019, 08:36:54 AM
#4
Appreciated, I got it.
Quote from: LoyceV on March 06, 2019, 08:15:39 AM
This means that user foserfox  has merited 45 users who are now banned, which is 43.26% of the total number of users he merited. From http://loyce.club/Merit/all_users_who_sent_Merit_2019-03-01_Fri_08.12h.txt:
Code:
   325. 141 Merit sent by foserfox (#485194) to 104 unique users in 108 transactions
Moreover, foserfox got permanent ban too.
Auto banned, more exactly.
https://bpip.org/profile.aspx?p=foserfox
Once again, you demonstrated that you have never drained out of constructive ideas.
LoyceV
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
Re: [Updated August 2023] How many banned users have you merited?
March 06, 2019, 08:15:39 AM
#3
Quote from: tranthidung on March 06, 2019, 07:48:31 AM
(1) How many of them got their first merit before the demotion of Junior Members in September last year?
(2) How many of those re-promoted to Junior Members got banned after that?
Too much to do Tongue

Quote from: LoyceV on March 06, 2019, 07:10:37 AM
    1. 45 (43.26%)
This means that user foserfox  has merited 45 users who are now banned, which is 43.26% of the total number of users he merited. From http://loyce.club/Merit/all_users_who_sent_Merit_2019-03-01_Fri_08.12h.txt:
Code:
   325. 141 Merit sent by foserfox (#485194) to 104 unique users in 108 transactions
tranthidung
legendary
Activity: 2310
Merit: 4085
Farewell o_e_l_e_o
Re: [Updated August 2023] How many banned users have you merited?
March 06, 2019, 07:48:31 AM
#2
Nice findings, LoyceV.
Around 11.3% of at-least-one-merit-earned users got banned actually not a high figure.
Quote from: LoyceV on March 06, 2019, 07:10:37 AM
In total, 26864 users received at least 1 Merit until last Friday's merit data dump, and 3024 of those (11.26%) have been banned. It's probably a bit higher, my list of banned users is incomplete.
As I raised a hypothesis earlier, it might be better if you can scrap data and get several statistics:
(1) How many of them got their first merit before the demotion of Junior Members in September last year?
(2) How many of those re-promoted to Junior Members got banned after that?
(3) How long it take from the days they got their first merits and promoted again to the days their accounts got banned?
For the third question, it might be more specific if you analyse only demoted Junior members that got promoted again and banned later.
Quote from: tranthidung on March 02, 2019, 02:51:06 AM
Of course, we need to look at data-evidence-based statistics.
For analysis, before digging deeply, I think you should take a quick analysis on their promoted days.
If most of newbies promoted in September last year, there is no reason to dig deeper.
I believe most of them promoted and got bans in September last year
Grin
Additionally, I still don't really get what you imply in those two figures.
You should make a note in the OP to state what they mean.
Quote from: LoyceV on March 06, 2019, 07:10:37 AM
    1. 45 (43.26%)
LoyceV
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
Re: [Updated August 2023] How many banned users have you merited?
March 06, 2019, 07:10:37 AM
#1
Update (August 2023): click.



This graph made me realize that many Newbies have been banned after receiving Merit:
Quote from: Coin-1 on March 01, 2019, 11:43:49 PM

My first thought:
Quote from: LoyceV on March 02, 2019, 02:42:01 AM
Now I'm curious who merited most banned Newbies

Note: banned users can still have good posts. Meriting them isn't necessarily a bad thing.

In total, 26864 users received at least 1 Merit until last Friday's merit data dump, and 3024 of those (11.26%) have been banned. It's probably a bit higher, my list of banned users is incomplete.

Local rules
no spam
no trolls (bye cryptohunter)

The data (click for the full version)
    1. 45 (43.26%) banned users merited by foserfox Banned! (details)
    2. 41 (11.38%) banned users merited by EFS (details)
    3. 35 (5.03%) banned users merited by paxmao (details)
    4. 34 (4.41%) banned users merited by dbshck (details)
    5. 34 (3.82%) banned users merited by OgNasty (details)
    6. 29 (5.06%) banned users merited by chimk (details)
    7. 28 (11.61%) banned users merited by teramit (details)
    8. 24 (21.23%) banned users merited by MalReynolds (details)
    9. 23 (3.69%) banned users merited by bones261 (details)
   10. 18 (10.28%) banned users merited by klarki (details)
   11. 17 (5.62%) banned users merited by xandry (details)
   12. 16 (69.56%) banned users merited by FinFx (details)
   13. 16 (2.84%) banned users merited by JayJuanGee (details)
   14. 16 (12.90%) banned users merited by TimeTeller (details)
   15. 15 (75.00%) banned users merited by lowbander80 (details)
   16. 15 (3.96%) banned users merited by The Pharmacist (details)
   17. 15 (3.48%) banned users merited by Jet Cash (details)
   18. 15 (20.00%) banned users merited by by rallier (details)
   19. 15 (2.35%) banned users merited by vapourminer (details)
   20. 15 (1.57%) banned users merited by suchmoon (details)
   21. 14 (32.55%) banned users merited by ancientcoins (details)
   22. 14 (3.80%) banned users merited by TMAN (details)
   23. 14 (2.78%) banned users merited by Vod (details)
   24. 14 (12.50%) banned users merited by mhanbostanci (details)
   25. 14 (11.86%) banned users merited by hugeblack (details)
   26. 14 (1.79%) banned users merited by LoyceV (details)
   27. 13 (6.34%) banned users merited by QuestionAuthority (details)
   28. 13 (11.92%) banned users merited by johhnyUA (details)
   29. 12 (9.67%) banned users merited by RodeoX (details)
   30. 12 (9.30%) banned users merited by WhiteManWhite (details)
   31. 12 (7.10%) banned users merited by Halab (details)
   32. 12 (6.70%) banned users merited by Vadi2323 (details)
   33. 12 (18.46%) banned users merited by dumbtool45 Banned! (details)
   34. 12 (18.46%) banned users merited by ekiller (details)
   35. 11 (61.11%) banned users merited by MoreFun (details)
   36. 11 (4.54%) banned users merited by xtraelv (details)
   37. 11 (4.45%) banned users merited by mindrust (details)
   38. 11 (3.20%) banned users merited by DdmrDdmr (details)
   39. 11 (28.94%) banned users merited by unamis76 (details)
   40. 11 (23.40%) banned users merited by Yury1 Banned! (details)
   41. 11 (17.46%) banned users merited by yo-blin (details)
   42. 11 (16.66%) banned users merited by MorpheWQ (details)
   43. 11 (11.22%) banned users merited by tokeweed (details)
   44. 10 (38.46%) banned users merited by mstfprcn Banned! (details)
   45. 10 (34.48%) banned users merited by lemonrabid (details)
   46. 10 (2.33%) banned users merited by qwk (details)
   47. 9 (6.29%) banned users merited by esmanthra (details)
   48. 9 (5.52%) banned users merited by STT (details)
   49. 9 (40.90%) banned users merited by ATMcoin Banned! (details)
   50. 9 (39.13%) banned users merited by cacucacok91 (details)
   51. 9 (37.50%) banned users merited by ladydark (details)
   52. 9 (31.03%) banned users merited by krisnt80 Banned! (details)
   53. 9 (29.03%) banned users merited by KosmoKisa (details)
   54. 9 (12.32%) banned users merited by Zz (details)
   55. 9 (10.97%) banned users merited by RegulusHr Banned! (details)
   56. 9 (10.84%) banned users merited by Slow death (details)
   57. 8 (72.72%) banned users merited by Charloz24 Banned! (details)
   58. 8 (7.47%) banned users merited by pandukelana2712 (details)
   59. 8 (61.53%) banned users merited by xsentus (details)
   60. 8 (50.00%) banned users merited by marcous (details)
   61. 8 (44.44%) banned users merited by roll on (details)
   62. 8 (42.10%) banned users merited by smutexar Banned! (details)
   63. 8 (36.36%) banned users merited by Criptomen Banned! (details)
   64. 8 (33.33%) banned users merited by Vinylriff (details)
   65. 8 (3.17%) banned users merited by krogothmanhattan (details)
   66. 8 (29.62%) banned users merited by 3x2 (details)
   67. 8 (21.05%) banned users merited by cryptolord2077 (details)
   68. 8 (2.46%) banned users merited by LFC_Bitcoin (details)
   69. 8 (15.38%) banned users merited by Moloch (details)
   70. 8 (14.81%) banned users merited by V1saya (details)
   71. 8 (12.50%) banned users merited by Vlad2Vlad (details)
   72. 8 (11.59%) banned users merited by PHI1618 (details)
   73. 8 (1.79%) banned users merited by DarkStar_ (details)
   74. 7 (9.09%) banned users merited by kryptqnick (details)
   75. 7 (8.13%) banned users merited by poptop (details)
   76. 7 (7.07%) banned users merited by seoincorporation (details)
   77. 7 (7.07%) banned users merited by Buchi-88 (details)
   78. 7 (63.63%) banned users merited by Liza Soberano Banned! (details)
   79. 7 (6.54%) banned users merited by iCEBREAKER (details)
   80. 7 (53.84%) banned users merited by Star_Bucks (details)
   81. 7 (46.66%) banned users merited by Gummybear67 Banned! (details)
   82. 7 (43.75%) banned users merited by Early_Waffle Banned! (details)
   83. 7 (4.72%) banned users merited by mole0815 (details)
   84. 7 (4.00%) banned users merited by marlboroza (details)
   85. 7 (36.84%) banned users merited by tema (details)
   86. 7 (35.00%) banned users merited by QellDroma Banned! (details)
   87. 7 (31.81%) banned users merited by BravO_o Banned! (details)
   88. 7 (29.16%) banned users merited by gileri Banned! (details)
   89. 7 (25.92%) banned users merited by PavelRostov (details)
   90. 7 (24.13%) banned users merited by ovcijisir (details)
   91. 7 (19.44%) banned users merited by snakey (details)
   92. 7 (18.42%) banned users merited by ui_zakharchenko Banned! (details)
   93. 7 (15.55%) banned users merited by fruit (details)
   94. 7 (14.58%) banned users merited by Slark (details)
   95. 7 (12.28%) banned users merited by AlyattesLydia (details)
   96. 7 (11.86%) banned users merited by BitcoinTurk (details)
   97. 6 (8.45%) banned users merited by odolvlobo (details)
   98. 6 (60.00%) banned users merited by magmar Banned! (details)
   99. 6 (6.59%) banned users merited by Gleb Gamow (details)
  100. 6 (50.00%) banned users merited by rolik2001 (details)
  101. 6 (50.00%) banned users merited by Kuala Lumpur Banned! (details)
  102. 6 (5.55%) banned users merited by Husna QA (details)
  103. 6 (5.17%) banned users merited by Piggy (details)
  104. 6 (5.08%) banned users merited by rickbig41 (details)
  105. 6 (46.15%) banned users merited by gunhell16 (details)
  106. 6 (40.00%) banned users merited by G.Butrik Banned! (details)
  107. 6 (40.00%) banned users merited by Webcelerator (details)
  108. 6 (4.37%) banned users merited by theyoungmillionaire (details)
  109. 6 (33.33%) banned users merited by Creol Banned! (details)
  110. 6 (31.57%) banned users merited by FiboNacchi Banned! (details)
  111. 6 (3.65%) banned users merited by pooya87 (details)
  112. 6 (3.31%) banned users merited by nutildah (details)
  113. 6 (28.57%) banned users merited by LiluSG (details)
  114. 6 (23.07%) banned users merited by aliyagiz207 (details)
  115. 6 (21.42%) banned users merited by BitmarkInvest (details)
  116. 6 (21.42%) banned users merited by Incognito01 (details)
  117. 6 (20.00%) banned users merited by slackovic (details)
  118. 6 (2.64%) banned users merited by mprep (details)
  119. 6 (2.60%) banned users merited by o_e_l_e_o (details)
  120. 6 (17.64%) banned users merited by Rinder Banned! (details)
  121. 6 (16.66%) banned users merited by Branko (details)
  122. 6 (16.21%) banned users merited by delfastTions (details)
  123. 6 (15.00%) banned users merited by Bolt Brownie (details)
  124. 6 (15.00%) banned users merited by el kaka22 (details)
  125. 6 (15.00%) banned users merited by explorder (details)
  126. 6 (14.28%) banned users merited by voteformeg (details)
  127. 6 (12.00%) banned users merited by leonello (details)
  128. 6 (11.76%) banned users merited by Ranyar (details)
  129. 6 (10.71%) banned users merited by examplens (details)
  130. 6 (10.52%) banned users merited by Daniel91 (details)
  131. 5 (9.61%) banned users merited by kzv (details)
  132. 5 (8.92%) banned users merited by Elwar (details)
  133. 5 (8.92%) banned users merited by diks (details)
  134. 5 (8.62%) banned users merited by SyGambler (details)
  135. 5 (71.42%) banned users merited by miha74 Banned! (details)
  136. 5 (7.46%) banned users merited by BrewMaster (details)
  137. 5 (7.46%) banned users merited by vlad230 (details)
  138. 5 (50.00%) banned users merited by Beefcake (details)
  139. 5 (50.00%) banned users merited by Afina_22 Banned! (details)
  140. 5 (5.61%) banned users merited by sapta (details)
  141. 5 (5.43%) banned users merited by philipma1957 (details)
  142. 5 (5.26%) banned users merited by Micio (details)
  143. 5 (5.20%) banned users merited by Wekkel (details)
  144. 5 (5.05%) banned users merited by BTCforJoe (details)
  145. 5 (45.45%) banned users merited by gorkem Banned! (details)
  146. 5 (41.66%) banned users merited by agentx44 (details)
  147. 5 (41.66%) banned users merited by craked5 (details)
  148. 5 (41.66%) banned users merited by myortvyje Banned! (details)
  149. 5 (4.54%) banned users merited by Searing (details)
  150. 5 (4.38%) banned users merited by krishnapramod (details)
  151. 5 (38.46%) banned users merited by hajimasan (details)
  152. 5 (38.46%) banned users merited by ymemey (details)
  153. 5 (33.33%) banned users merited by wnj4 (details)
  154. 5 (31.25%) banned users merited by mostkey (details)
  155. 5 (31.25%) banned users merited by cryptofrka (details)
  156. 5 (31.25%) banned users merited by YulyNov (details)
  157. 5 (3.96%) banned users merited by Raja_MBZ (details)
  158. 5 (3.96%) banned users merited by mdayonliner (details)
  159. 5 (3.90%) banned users merited by bitmover (details)
  160. 5 (3.67%) banned users merited by Coolcryptovator (details)
  161. 5 (3.33%) banned users merited by tyz (details)
  162. 5 (3.28%) banned users merited by gentlemand (details)
  163. 5 (3.24%) banned users merited by achow101 (details)
  164. 5 (3.18%) banned users merited by joniboini (details)
  165. 5 (3.10%) banned users merited by malevolent (details)
  166. 5 (26.31%) banned users merited by aoihs00 (details)
  167. 5 (25.00%) banned users merited by mastica (details)
  168. 5 (22.72%) banned users merited by reddish111 (details)
  169. 5 (21.73%) banned users merited by Winged13 (details)
  170. 5 (21.73%) banned users merited by bitpazari Banned! (details)
  171. 5 (20.00%) banned users merited by Topknotbam (details)
  172. 5 (2.97%) banned users merited by infofront (details)
  173. 5 (2.40%) banned users merited by iasenko (details)
  174. 5 (2.36%) banned users merited by Flying Hellfish (details)
  175. 5 (2.22%) banned users merited by d5000 (details)
  176. 5 (19.23%) banned users merited by sabx01 (details)
  177. 5 (19.23%) banned users merited by Gerhald (details)
  178. 5 (17.85%) banned users merited by ingiltere (details)
  179. 5 (15.62%) banned users merited by dannybrown (details)
  180. 5 (15.62%) banned users merited by winspiral (details)
  181. 5 (14.70%) banned users merited by Reid (details)
  182. 5 (14.70%) banned users merited by Rhego Banned! (details)
  183. 5 (13.88%) banned users merited by tyKiwanuka (details)
  184. 5 (13.51%) banned users merited by yussuf89 (details)
  185. 5 (12.82%) banned users merited by ophyrim (details)
  186. 5 (12.50%) banned users merited by ace4549 Banned! (details)
  187. 5 (12.19%) banned users merited by Trofo (details)
  188. 5 (11.90%) banned users merited by markiz73 (details)
  189. 5 (100.00%) banned users merited by timi33ooo33 Banned! (details)
  190. 5 (100.00%) banned users merited by Jamilowi (details)
  191. 5 (100.00%) banned users merited by Divere1996 Banned! (details)
  192. 5 (10.41%) banned users merited by zanzibar Banned! (details)
  193. 5 (10.20%) banned users merited by snipie (details)
  194. 5 (10.20%) banned users merited by nick777 (details)
  195. 5 (10.00%) banned users merited by Smartprofit (details)
  196. 5 (1.79%) banned users merited by Welsh (details)
  197. 4 (9.52%) banned users merited by kirreev070 (details)
  198. 4 (9.52%) banned users merited by Matthias9515 (details)
  199. 4 (9.30%) banned users merited by Paredao (details)
  200. 4 (80.00%) banned users merited by Cacaparg Banned! (details)
(click for the full version)

See [overview] LoyceV's useful data on Bitcointalk for more of my forum-related topics
Pages:
Bitcoin Forum>Other>Meta
Jump to: