What a boogie woogie without replay protection.. 
The lack of replay protection would be a major problem for the B2X network, not for BTC!
Topic: Wall Observer BTC/USD - Bitcoin price movement tracking & discussion - page 16241. (Read 26609878 times)
October 04, 2017, 04:52:01 PM
The lack of replay protection would be a major problem for the B2X network, not for BTC!
October 04, 2017, 04:43:53 PM
Mhhh, so I think the best way to split your B2X coins would be to create a transaction very early after the split to an address which you control. It will probably be included in a >1 MB block in the B2X chain, thus making it incompatible anymore on the real chain.
Is my thinking correct ?
Edit: Nvm, I think I am not correct. The transactions after that could still be replayed on both chains.
Is my thinking correct ?
Edit: Nvm, I think I am not correct. The transactions after that could still be replayed on both chains.
With 0 BTC fee, but you will have to wait for B2X confirmed and BTC not (you will have to make new transaction and add FEE in BTC transaction)
October 04, 2017, 04:42:49 PM
I think the declining BTC value of BCH indicates the market is pricing in the increasing odds of 2MB Bitcoin blocks becoming reality.
Most likely. There are two separate beliefs that could lead to this:
1) the belief that 2MB is good enough, thereby reducing the advantage of 8MB; and
2) the belief that the sum of the value of S1X and the value of S2X at time = t0+ will be greater than that of the SonlyX at t=0- (much like the BCH split resulted previously in a larger aggregate value).
I think the declining BTC value of BCH (I suppose that's the altcoin you meant) indicates that a certain gang thinks their money is best burned supporting the next attack, so BCH purchases are being phased out.
I doubt it, but I must admit it is plausible.
October 04, 2017, 04:39:34 PM
You don't understand what you're talking about, do you? The bolded part above and the "small" difference remark is indicative you're clueless.
Do not bother.
October 04, 2017, 04:37:35 PM
Mhhh, so I think the best way to split your B2X coins would be to create a transaction very early after the split to an address which you control. It will probably be included in a >1 MB block in the B2X chain, thus making it incompatible anymore on the real chain.
Is my thinking correct ?
Edit: Nvm, I think I am not correct. The transactions after that could still be replayed on both chains.
What a boogie woogie without replay protection..
Is my thinking correct ?
Edit: Nvm, I think I am not correct. The transactions after that could still be replayed on both chains.
What a boogie woogie without replay protection..
October 04, 2017, 04:34:55 PM
I think the declining BTC value of BCC indicates the market is pricing in the increasing odds of 2MB Bitcoin blocks becoming reality.
I think the declining BTC value of BCH (I suppose that's the altcoin you meant) indicates that a certain gang thinks their money is best burned supporting the next attack, so BCH purchases are being phased out.
Yep. Pretty much you sum it up.
RIP BCH. Hello B2X.
Next free money drop, please!
I'm not sure it is "Next free money drop, please!".
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
Why should I care what is happening on B2X network or on any other Bitcoin [put-some-extra-word-here] network that is trying to mimic Bitcoin network? I simply take what they give me and dump it for bitcoins. Case solved.
They share same keys, same addresses. If you dump at B2X then they dump your BTC. (it is same network, the difference is small -> block size ) ... there is not replay protection
1) if you dump BTC then your transaction will apear on BTC2X and you lose BTC2X
2) if you dump BTC2X then there is a chance that your dump will be replayed on BTC
You don't understand what you're talking about, do you? The bolded part above and the "small" difference remark is indicative you're clueless.
October 04, 2017, 04:32:19 PM
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
That's by design, for maximum disruption. A hostile takeover attempt by any reasonable standards.I think splitting BTC-B2X will require mixing freshly mined coins into one's transactions. The landing chain of the transaction will be the chain where the fresh coins were mined. I still have to figure out how to do that.
There seems to be a different way invoving timelocked transactions - but I won't have a clue about this bit of magic until I research the matter. BTW, for the technically knowledgeable: pointers would be welcome
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/segwit2x-vs-1-mb-2237232
Ah! Fluidjax has one more trick to share. Thanks Odalv!
I'm not sure his trick is working :-) Be aware.
Yes, I noticed immediately and edited my post. Thanks for the heads up anyway!
October 04, 2017, 04:28:30 PM
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
That's by design, for maximum disruption. A hostile takeover attempt by any reasonable standards.I think splitting BTC-B2X will require mixing freshly mined coins into one's transactions. The landing chain of the transaction will be the chain where the fresh coins were mined. I still have to figure out how to do that.
There seems to be a different way invoving timelocked transactions - but I won't have a clue about this bit of magic until I research the matter. BTW, for the technically knowledgeable: pointers would be welcome
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/segwit2x-vs-1-mb-2237232
Ah! Fluidjax has one more trick to share. Thanks Odalv!
I'm not sure his trick is working :-) Be aware.
October 04, 2017, 04:27:15 PM
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
That's by design, for maximum disruption. A hostile takeover attempt by any reasonable standards.I think splitting BTC-B2X will require mixing freshly mined coins into one's transactions. The landing chain of the transaction will be the chain where the fresh coins were mined. I still have to figure out how to do that.
There seems to be a different way invoving timelocked transactions - but I won't have a clue about this bit of magic until I research the matter. BTW, for the technically knowledgeable: pointers would be welcome
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/segwit2x-vs-1-mb-2237232
Ah! Fluidjax has one more trick to share. Thanks Odalv!
EDIT: oops - the 3BITxxxxxxxxx address in Fluidjax's example is valid on both chains. No worky.
October 04, 2017, 04:23:29 PM
I think the declining BTC value of BCC indicates the market is pricing in the increasing odds of 2MB Bitcoin blocks becoming reality.
I think the declining BTC value of BCH (I suppose that's the altcoin you meant) indicates that a certain gang thinks their money is best burned supporting the next attack, so BCH purchases are being phased out.
Yep. Pretty much you sum it up.
RIP BCH. Hello B2X.
Next free money drop, please!
I'm not sure it is "Next free money drop, please!".
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
Why should I care what is happening on B2X network or on any other Bitcoin [put-some-extra-word-here] network that is trying to mimic Bitcoin network? I simply take what they give me and dump it for bitcoins. Case solved.
They share same keys, same addresses. If you dump at B2X then they dump your BTC. (it is same network, the difference is small -> block size ) ... there is not replay protection
1) if you dump BTC then your transaction will apear on BTC2X and you lose BTC2X
2) if you dump BTC2X then there is a chance that your dump will be replayed on BTC
October 04, 2017, 04:18:58 PM
I think the declining BTC value of BCH indicates the market is pricing in the increasing odds of 2MB Bitcoin blocks becoming reality.
Which actually makes zero sense, because in the minds of BCH supporters if 2MB blocks are just ok then 8MB blocks are even better. Which Bitcoin Cash already has, right now. And apparently they could give two shits about SegWit support, bug fixes or enhancements, replay protection, real mining support, merchant support, exchange support, real economic majority support, or anything else to support... ya' know, an entire $70B cryptocurrency ecosystem.
But let's be real: their goal was never to create a 'better Bitcoin'. It was to hijack and derail Bitcoin. And until that goal is achieved, the forks will just keep a comin'.
October 04, 2017, 04:16:48 PM
I think the declining BTC value of BCC indicates the market is pricing in the increasing odds of 2MB Bitcoin blocks becoming reality.
I think the declining BTC value of BCH (I suppose that's the altcoin you meant) indicates that a certain gang thinks their money is best burned supporting the next attack, so BCH purchases are being phased out.
Yep. Pretty much you sum it up.
RIP BCH. Hello B2X.
Next free money drop, please!
I'm not sure it is "Next free money drop, please!".
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
Why should I care what is happening on B2X network or on any other Bitcoin [put-some-extra-word-here] network that is trying to mimic Bitcoin network? I simply take what they give me and dump it for bitcoins. Case solved.
October 04, 2017, 04:11:30 PM
Nope...
The other guy looked like the "Trolololol" russian guy opera singer.
LOL!
Btw, interesting tweet from CEO of Goldman Sachs: https://www.coindesk.com/goldman-sachs-ceo-no-conclusion-bitcoin-yet/
Quote
Lloyd Blankfein
✔
@lloydblankfein
Still thinking about #Bitcoin. No conclusion - not endorsing/rejecting. Know that folks also were skeptical when paper money displaced gold.
8:09 PM - Oct 3, 2017
✔
@lloydblankfein
Still thinking about #Bitcoin. No conclusion - not endorsing/rejecting. Know that folks also were skeptical when paper money displaced gold.
8:09 PM - Oct 3, 2017
October 04, 2017, 04:10:59 PM
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
That's by design, for maximum disruption. A hostile takeover attempt by any reasonable standards.I think splitting BTC-B2X will require mixing freshly mined coins into one's transactions. The landing chain of the transaction will be the chain where the fresh coins were mined. I still have to figure out how to do that.
There seems to be a different way invoving timelocked transactions - but I won't have a clue about this bit of magic until I research the matter. BTW, for the technically knowledgeable: pointers would be welcome
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/segwit2x-vs-1-mb-2237232
October 04, 2017, 04:07:56 PM
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
That's by design, for maximum disruption. A hostile takeover attempt by any reasonable standards.I think splitting BTC-B2X will require mixing freshly mined coins into one's transactions. The landing chain of the transaction will be the chain where the fresh coins were mined. I still have to figure out how to do that.
There seems to be a different way invoving timelocked transactions - but I won't have a clue about this bit of magic until I research the matter. BTW, for the technically knowledgeable: pointers would be welcome
October 04, 2017, 04:04:22 PM
Nope...
The other guy looked like the "Trolololol" russian guy opera singer.
*edit(0):
October 04, 2017, 04:03:43 PM
I was wondering about replay attacks in general, and how any bitcoin clone from the past differentiates their transactions by coin such that nodal confusion doesn't get all messy. Can't people just make replay a possibility with any little shitty small fork targeted at a specific wallet client? Did this happen in the past?
October 04, 2017, 04:01:44 PM
wait...so the trend line from 14 July to 15 September is NOT STEEP ENOUGH for you greedy motherfuckers??? 
Gotta zoom out a little bit more fellow greedy.
October 04, 2017, 04:00:32 PM
next stop $3400 ?
I believe this is impossible. We have to pass 4100,4000,3900,3800,3700,3600,3500 for this to happen. It's not witch craft
I doubt that it is analytically helpful to look at every single $100 increment as if it were an area of support, because then we will become too overwhelmed with information.
So currently we are bouncing between about $4150 and $4300.. more or less, so it seems that our next area of support is at about the $4000 territory, and this one would not be too difficult to break below - because we are only recently out of that one.
However, the next area of support would be around $3,600, and that one should prove a bit more difficult to break through.
If we break below $3600, then we will be back to testing the earlier level of the dip, which is around $3k. Thereafter $2500-ish.. etc.. etc...
I personally think $3600 is reasonable, with maybe nearly a 40% chance.. and harder to predict beyond that.. and sure we gotta get down there first... and there is a decent chance that we could go up from here, anyhow, perhaps in the 50/50 territory.
October 04, 2017, 03:58:56 PM
I think the declining BTC value of BCC indicates the market is pricing in the increasing odds of 2MB Bitcoin blocks becoming reality.
I think the declining BTC value of BCH (I suppose that's the altcoin you meant) indicates that a certain gang thinks their money is best burned supporting the next attack, so BCH purchases are being phased out.
Yep. Pretty much you sum it up.
RIP BCH. Hello B2X.
Next free money drop, please!
I'm not sure it is "Next free money drop, please!".
Your BTC transaction will be replayed on BTC2X.
Jump to: