We've had this argument before... I presented the fact that atheists are less likely to be criminals than christians... you rejected the evidence in lieu of your preconceived notion that christians must be better people than atheists... because... well, no because... you didn't present an actual reason or evidence... just a claim that the Federal Bureau of Prisons must be wrong, and you are right... then proceed to unload 5+ more lies/propaganda for me to debunk... not gonna do it... wasting your/my time
We had this argument at least twice now... stop lying
I present evidence, you reject it and make false claims without backing anything up with a source, link, scientific study... it's just nonsense... I don't have time for your bullshit... I really don't... I'm done responding to your stupid nonsense
If you want an argument... present a case, link sources, and maybe I'll read it (you have been on ignore for 2 years, occasionally i click hide/show post to see what you're blathering about)
Stop trolling, stop derailing this thread
Moloch you really are quite entertaining.
Moloch "SHOW ME WHERE I LIED"
CoinCube (Quotes provably false statement from Moloch)
Moloch "I AM NOT GOING TO RESPOND TO YOU... YOU LIAR YOU LETS TALK ABOUT PRISONERS"
Ok Moloch we can talk about prisoners. I did not actually post any evidence that disproves your claims about atheists in prisons. I only pointed out that your explanation is not the only one that could explain the data.
You provided data that prisoners are less likely to self report as atheists then members of the general population. About 10 times less likely if my brief google search on the topic was accurate.
Three possibilities that explain this data spring to mind:
1) Atheists commit less crimes then then general population and thus may be less likely to end up in prison
2) Prisoners are lying about their religious status
3) The data is bad
The data comes from the government and probably is not bad so #3 seems unlikely.
#1 May be true. I discussed in the Health and Religion thread that above average IQ may be correlated with atheism as it makes individuals more prone to question their upbringing. If this correlation is a real one then atheists may be more adapt at avoiding prison due to higher average IQ.
#2 May also be true. One of the major criteria parole boards consider is whether or not a prisoner is remorseful when deciding whether to allow early release or otherwise ameliorate the terms of the sentence for serious crimes. Prisoners may have self-interested reasons to "find God" when attempting to build a case for parole.
Probably the reality is a combination of the two. If you really want to look at the effect of religion you need to control for other variables including poverty, education levels and IQ.
Since you
claim to like data here is some data highlighting the protective effect of religion.
Race and the Religious Contexts of Violence: Linking Religion and White, Black, and Latino Violent Crime.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/24976649/
Research has demonstrated that concentrated disadvantage and other measures are strongly associated with aggregate-level rates of violence, including across racial and ethnic groups. Less studied is the impact of cultural factors, including religious contextual measures... Results suggest that (1) religious contextual measures have significant crime-reducing associations with violence, (2) these associations are race/ethnic-specific, and (3) religious contextual measures moderate the criminogenic association between disadvantage and violence for Blacks.
Race/Ethnicity, Religious Involvement, and Domestic Violencehttp://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/1077801207308259The authors explored the relationship between religious involvement and intimate partner violence... They found that: (a) religious involvement is correlated with reduced levels of domestic violence... this protective effect is stronger for African American men and women and for Hispanic men, groups that, for a variety of reasons, experience elevated risk for this type of violence.
Alcoholism Risk Moderation by a Socio-Religious Dimensionhttp://www.jsad.com/doi/abs/10.15288/jsad.2007.68.912Results: Findings indicated that (1) parental alcohol history robustly predicted increased offspring alcohol-dependence symptoms, (2) religious rearing appeared protective (offspring exhibited fewer alcohol-dependence symptoms), (3) religious differentiation accounted for most of the protective effect, (4) other religious variables did not account for the differentiation effect, and (5) black religious adolescents were more frequently raised with differentiating affiliations and exhibited greater protective effects.