Author

Topic: [XMR] Monero Speculation - page 1883. (Read 3314343 times)

legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 1198
May 30, 2015, 05:06:07 PM
Also, I know Monero has adaptive block size. I was commenting that Monero still needs to hard fork to implement permanent inflation rewards, and that maybe MP will be bellyache/troll similar to how he has over increasing bitcoin block size. It's kind of a scarcity issue along the same lines I think.

Interestingly enough here's your answer: http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=27-05-2015#1146160

Worth quoting because I agree with his monetary view. However, I think he is wrong with respect to a proof-of-work cryptocurrency which is not only a financial system but also a device that has the function in a certain way including mining incentives. For the later, a positive rate of inflation is superior.

Quote from: MP
fixed inflation is not fundamentally different from zero inflation just as long as the inflation is known

Fiat money has more or less fixed inflation which is done by the European Central Bank inflation targetting.

No it isn't fixed. It is subject to change at their discretion, which is generally done to favor one particular interest group over another.

A preprogrammed rate of inflation doesn't really differ from a fixed supply, as MP explained, as long as the schedule is fully known to everyone in advance. If we enter into a contract where you agree to pay me 100 units next year, if we both know the inflation rate will be 2% we can instead agree on 102 units instead, which represents the same constant value.

The problem comes in when we agree on 102 based on an expectation of 2% and then the ECB decides that 3% or 1% is better. Then they are favoring either you or me in our contract.

Take Bitcoin, which is non-inflationary by design. One bitcoin is equal to 1/21m of the total. As long as we know what the total is going to be, we can simply agree to transact in units of 1/21m of the total instead of transacting in 1 BTC. There is no real difference. With fiat, you can't even do that, really, because the total money supply is not only not fixed or on a fixed schedule, but isn't even transparent. The best we can do are estimates made after the fact and then often revised.

It made more of a difference when adjusting prices was difficult (required changing product packaging, price stickers, etc.). But in the electronic age that doesn't apply any more.
sr. member
Activity: 514
Merit: 258
May 30, 2015, 04:57:48 PM
Also, I know Monero has adaptive block size. I was commenting that Monero still needs to hard fork to implement permanent inflation rewards, and that maybe MP will be bellyache/troll similar to how he has over increasing bitcoin block size. It's kind of a scarcity issue along the same lines I think.

Interestingly enough here's your answer: http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=27-05-2015#1146160

Worth quoting because I agree with his monetary view. However, I think he is wrong with respect to a proof-of-work cryptocurrency which is not only a financial system but also a device that has the function in a certain way including mining incentives. For the later, a positive rate of inflation is superior.

Quote from: MP
fixed inflation is not fundamentally different from zero inflation just as long as the inflation is known

Fiat money has more or less fixed inflation which is done by the European Central Bank inflation targetting.
If there is an inflation rate, it really doesn't differ from fiat money (unless you do not consider a distribution mechanism which is different in crypto and the modern type of fiat money which is created in two ways: 1) by central bank the initial money supply 2) Commercial banks by credit expansion - the latter being more significiant factor).

hmmz,
I thought inflation = expanding the money supply, whatever the inflation-target is, whatever the actual rise in prices is... fiat-money has no fixed inflation, central banks can print at will as per Ben Bernanke, Mario Draghi, Kuroda, etc... Fixed inflation (as is with btc, monero... as is with gold and silver) differs a whole lot from being able to print whatever amount of currency...

fractional reserve banking with fixed-inflation-money will fail when there's a too big a bank run (the money can't be printed at will), FRB in a fiat-currency-system doesn't need to fail, the central banks can print at will...

best regards





Monero hasn't "fixed inflation" neither, the correct economic term is http://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/disinflation.asp

Not sure, that's where the bankers try to confuse us i guess...

what is your definition of inflation? Is it rising prices as the effect of an expanding money-supply, or is it just an expanding money-supply, wether some prices are rising or not?

As I understand: disinflation is a slowing rate of rising prices... it's not a slowing rate in expanding the money supply... so monero doesn't have disinflation, monero has a fixed inflation rate (as in can't be adjusted at will).

interesting discussion, but maybe off topic over here...
sr. member
Activity: 350
Merit: 250
May 30, 2015, 04:48:48 PM
Also, I know Monero has adaptive block size. I was commenting that Monero still needs to hard fork to implement permanent inflation rewards, and that maybe MP will be bellyache/troll similar to how he has over increasing bitcoin block size. It's kind of a scarcity issue along the same lines I think.

Interestingly enough here's your answer: http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=27-05-2015#1146160

Worth quoting because I agree with his monetary view. However, I think he is wrong with respect to a proof-of-work cryptocurrency which is not only a financial system but also a device that has the function in a certain way including mining incentives. For the later, a positive rate of inflation is superior.

Quote from: MP
fixed inflation is not fundamentally different from zero inflation just as long as the inflation is known

Fiat money has more or less fixed inflation which is done by the European Central Bank inflation targetting.
If there is an inflation rate, it really doesn't differ from fiat money (unless you do not consider a distribution mechanism which is different in crypto and the modern type of fiat money which is created in two ways: 1) by central bank the initial money supply 2) Commercial banks by credit expansion - the latter being more significiant factor).

hmmz,
I thought inflation = expanding the money supply, whatever the inflation-target is, whatever the actual rise in prices is... fiat-money has no fixed inflation, central banks can print at will as per Ben Bernanke, Mario Draghi, Kuroda, etc... Fixed inflation (as is with btc, monero... as is with gold and silver) differs a whole lot from being able to print whatever amount of currency...

fractional reserve banking with fixed-inflation-money will fail when there's a too big a bank run (the money can't be printed at will), FRB in a fiat-currency-system doesn't need to fail, the central banks can print at will...

best regards





Monero hasn't "fixed inflation" neither, the correct economic term is http://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/disinflation.asp
sr. member
Activity: 514
Merit: 258
May 30, 2015, 04:38:43 PM
Also, I know Monero has adaptive block size. I was commenting that Monero still needs to hard fork to implement permanent inflation rewards, and that maybe MP will be bellyache/troll similar to how he has over increasing bitcoin block size. It's kind of a scarcity issue along the same lines I think.

Interestingly enough here's your answer: http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=27-05-2015#1146160

Worth quoting because I agree with his monetary view. However, I think he is wrong with respect to a proof-of-work cryptocurrency which is not only a financial system but also a device that has the function in a certain way including mining incentives. For the later, a positive rate of inflation is superior.

Quote from: MP
fixed inflation is not fundamentally different from zero inflation just as long as the inflation is known

Fiat money has more or less fixed inflation which is done by the European Central Bank inflation targetting.
If there is an inflation rate, it really doesn't differ from fiat money (unless you do not consider a distribution mechanism which is different in crypto and the modern type of fiat money which is created in two ways: 1) by central bank the initial money supply 2) Commercial banks by credit expansion - the latter being more significiant factor).

hmmz,
I thought inflation = expanding the money supply, whatever the inflation-target is, whatever the actual rise in prices is... fiat-money has no fixed inflation, central banks can print at will as per Ben Bernanke, Mario Draghi, Kuroda, etc... Fixed inflation (as is with btc, monero... as is with gold and silver) differs a whole lot from being able to print whatever amount of currency...

fractional reserve banking with fixed-inflation-money will fail when there's a too big a bank run (the money can't be printed at will), FRB in a fiat-currency-system doesn't need to fail, the central banks can print at will...

best regards



legendary
Activity: 1092
Merit: 1000
May 30, 2015, 04:06:09 PM
Also, I know Monero has adaptive block size. I was commenting that Monero still needs to hard fork to implement permanent inflation rewards, and that maybe MP will be bellyache/troll similar to how he has over increasing bitcoin block size. It's kind of a scarcity issue along the same lines I think.

Interestingly enough here's your answer: http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=27-05-2015#1146160

Worth quoting because I agree with his monetary view. However, I think he is wrong with respect to a proof-of-work cryptocurrency which is not only a financial system but also a device that has the function in a certain way including mining incentives. For the later, a positive rate of inflation is superior.

Quote from: MP
fixed inflation is not fundamentally different from zero inflation just as long as the inflation is known

Fiat money has more or less fixed inflation which is done by the European Central Bank inflation targetting.
If there is an inflation rate, it really doesn't differ from fiat money (unless you do not consider a distribution mechanism which is different in crypto and the modern type of fiat money which is created in two ways: 1) by central bank the initial money supply 2) Commercial banks by credit expansion - the latter being more significiant factor).
legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 1198
May 30, 2015, 03:32:25 PM
Also, I know Monero has adaptive block size. I was commenting that Monero still needs to hard fork to implement permanent inflation rewards, and that maybe MP will be bellyache/troll similar to how he has over increasing bitcoin block size. It's kind of a scarcity issue along the same lines I think.

Interestingly enough here's your answer: http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=27-05-2015#1146160

Worth quoting because I agree with his monetary view. However, I think he is wrong with respect to a proof-of-work cryptocurrency which is not only a financial system but also a device that has the function in a certain way including mining incentives. For the later, a positive rate of inflation is superior.

Quote from: MP
fixed inflation is not fundamentally different from zero inflation just as long as the inflation is known
newbie
Activity: 57
Merit: 0
May 30, 2015, 02:34:18 AM
Circle is giving $5/~0.021 BTC for new users, which is about ~11.29 XMR at current prices Cheesy

https://twitter.com/circlebits/status/604001124258037761

You have to give some basic info, verify your e-mail and phone for 2fa, takes about 5-10 minutes.

Thanks for the tip, that took about 2-3 minutes. Nice and easy.

Does it work though? I withdrew to a random wallet and still nothing.

yes i withdrew just fine. however it looks like they ran out of funds for the promo already.



Lol. That didn't take long.
sr. member
Activity: 350
Merit: 250
May 30, 2015, 02:16:13 AM
Also, I know Monero has adaptive block size. I was commenting that Monero still needs to hard fork to implement permanent inflation rewards, and that maybe MP will be bellyache/troll similar to how he has over increasing bitcoin block size. It's kind of a scarcity issue along the same lines I think.

Interestingly enough here's your answer: http://log.bitcoin-assets.com/?date=27-05-2015#1146160
sr. member
Activity: 770
Merit: 250
May 29, 2015, 05:25:20 PM
Circle is giving $5/~0.021 BTC for new users, which is about ~11.29 XMR at current prices Cheesy

https://twitter.com/circlebits/status/604001124258037761

You have to give some basic info, verify your e-mail and phone for 2fa, takes about 5-10 minutes.

Thanks for the tip, that took about 2-3 minutes. Nice and easy.

Does it work though? I withdrew to a random wallet and still nothing.

yes i withdrew just fine. however it looks like they ran out of funds for the promo already.



Hmm I withdrew but nothing came up in the bitcoin address.
legendary
Activity: 1610
Merit: 1004
May 29, 2015, 05:23:15 PM
Circle is giving $5/~0.021 BTC for new users, which is about ~11.29 XMR at current prices Cheesy

https://twitter.com/circlebits/status/604001124258037761

You have to give some basic info, verify your e-mail and phone for 2fa, takes about 5-10 minutes.

Thanks for the tip, that took about 2-3 minutes. Nice and easy.

Does it work though? I withdrew to a random wallet and still nothing.

yes i withdrew just fine. however it looks like they ran out of funds for the promo already.

sr. member
Activity: 770
Merit: 250
May 29, 2015, 04:41:51 PM
Circle is giving $5/~0.021 BTC for new users, which is about ~11.29 XMR at current prices Cheesy

https://twitter.com/circlebits/status/604001124258037761

You have to give some basic info, verify your e-mail and phone for 2fa, takes about 5-10 minutes.

Thanks for the tip, that took about 2-3 minutes. Nice and easy.

Does it work though? I withdrew to a random wallet and still nothing.
legendary
Activity: 1610
Merit: 1004
May 29, 2015, 02:30:52 PM
Circle is giving $5/~0.021 BTC for new users, which is about ~11.29 XMR at current prices Cheesy

https://twitter.com/circlebits/status/604001124258037761

You have to give some basic info, verify your e-mail and phone for 2fa, takes about 5-10 minutes.

Thanks for the tip, that took about 2-3 minutes. Nice and easy.
hero member
Activity: 723
Merit: 503
May 29, 2015, 05:21:51 AM
Bittrex volume is starting to increase. 17 btc of XMR were traded there today. Thats quite a lot compared to the usual volume.

https://bittrex.com/Market/Index?MarketName=BTC-XMR
hero member
Activity: 795
Merit: 514
May 29, 2015, 02:09:29 AM
Monero attracts all kinds of people around it. We even had a self-confessed bankster agent joining our nightlife in Berlin! Think about that for a moment Smiley

Heh, I was just in cypher's thread yesterday explaining how Monero enables defections that Bitcoin cannot.

Was just thinking a bit earlier while watching that exchange, I think his mentoring to me inadvertently is making me act the same way with Monero as he did with Bitcoin way back when. And I never did get to mine BTC, but I can proudly say that I was a MRO miner.

I felt like part of history cracking pre-ASIC BTC blocks, but MRO's difficulty started too high for me to get more than a couple.

Thanks for reminding me I should be equally as proud of them!    Grin   Grin   Grin

I still get a mild dopamine rush when seeing the letters MRO.  Cool

Don't forget it started with "BMR." I actually mined quite a bit of BMR from my two desktops.
hero member
Activity: 714
Merit: 504
May 29, 2015, 02:04:31 AM
Monero attracts all kinds of people around it. We even had a self-confessed bankster agent joining our nightlife in Berlin! Think about that for a moment Smiley

Heh, I was just in cypher's thread yesterday explaining how Monero enables defections that Bitcoin cannot.

Was just thinking a bit earlier while watching that exchange, I think his mentoring to me inadvertently is making me act the same way with Monero as he did with Bitcoin way back when. And I never did get to mine BTC, but I can proudly say that I was a MRO miner.

I felt like part of history cracking pre-ASIC BTC blocks, but MRO's difficulty started too high for me to get more than a couple.

Thanks for reminding me I should be equally as proud of them!    Grin   Grin   Grin

I still get a mild dopamine rush when seeing the letters MRO.  Cool

Kinda the same sensation as you would get when seeing money on the street, or scoring a three-pointer basketball shot without the ball hitting the rim or backboard.

Swisssshhh!
legendary
Activity: 2156
Merit: 1072
Crypto is the separation of Power and State.
May 29, 2015, 01:45:49 AM
Monero attracts all kinds of people around it. We even had a self-confessed bankster agent joining our nightlife in Berlin! Think about that for a moment Smiley

Heh, I was just in cypher's thread yesterday explaining how Monero enables defections that Bitcoin cannot.

Was just thinking a bit earlier while watching that exchange, I think his mentoring to me inadvertently is making me act the same way with Monero as he did with Bitcoin way back when. And I never did get to mine BTC, but I can proudly say that I was a MRO miner.

I felt like part of history cracking pre-ASIC BTC blocks, but MRO's difficulty started too high for me to get more than a couple.

Thanks for reminding me I should be equally as proud of them!    Grin   Grin   Grin
donator
Activity: 1722
Merit: 1036
May 29, 2015, 12:55:42 AM
Monero attracts all kinds of people around it. We even had a self-confessed bankster agent joining our nightlife in Berlin! Think about that for a moment Smiley
Even Nazis.  Wink

By Nazis, do you mean NSDAP? Or the ashkenazi who have projected their own actions to what Nazi stands for to most of people these days? Also is everyone who calls themselves Jew actually a Jew? Khazars in Israel are sterilizing the Ethiopian Jews (who have a longer history of being a part of the Jewry than the Khazars themselves!). Forced sterilization was taught to me to be a Nazi practice, so perhaps Israel=Nazi actually..

No offence if any of the readers supports Israeli policies but you gotta be clueless to condemn the NSDAP for the same actions!
sr. member
Activity: 337
Merit: 250
May 29, 2015, 12:26:46 AM
Any ideas on why Monero is lower than Bytecoin - have they had development or something going on over there?

I'm not the XMR evangelist many of you are in this thread but.  When I see Bytecoin surpass it - strikes me as a bullish signal for Monero ... I picked more up o.O

Monero is the premier Cryptonote currency.  Not sure exactly what you are talking about.
legendary
Activity: 1722
Merit: 1217
May 29, 2015, 12:26:01 AM
Any ideas on why Monero is lower than Bytecoin - have they had development or something going on over there?

I'm not the XMR evangelist many of you are in this thread but.  When I see Bytecoin surpass it - strikes me as a bullish signal for Monero ... I picked more up o.O

Bytecoin has the vast majoirity of the units held by a single entity. So only a tiny fraction of it is trading on the market. Yet the market capitalization is a function of the last agreed upon price times the entire currency supply. So its basically a trick and the market capitalization value is completely meaningless. If the big holder sold even a tiny fraction of his holding he would drive the price down to one over infinity. So basically, the market cap of bytecoin couldn't possibly be more meaningless. May as well consult an astrologer.
legendary
Activity: 1256
Merit: 1009
May 29, 2015, 12:16:17 AM
Any ideas on why Monero is lower than Bytecoin - have they had development or something going on over there?

I'm not the XMR evangelist many of you are in this thread but.  When I see Bytecoin surpass it - strikes me as a bullish signal for Monero ... I picked more up o.O
Jump to: