Topic: AMD Rebrand - RX570 / RX580 - Official Thread - page 20. (Read 173429 times)

Quote from: centurionMiner on June 05, 2017, 05:06:09 AM

Quote from: Eliavres on June 05, 2017, 07:52:17 PM

The rx560...seriously? How many MH can it pull in ETH?

15.5mhs with 1300/2100 clocks at 60w, basicly half a RX470

tweaked 570 = 27Mh/s @ 91w at the wall (64w on gpu-z). Could be >29Mh/s >100w but my elpida does not clock enough.

Model and memory?

asus expedition. Elpida (1850mhz max).

eth only= 1090/1850mhz @ 831mv = 91w (wall)

Dual mining = 1130/1850mhz @ 831mv = 118w (wall)

I have Elpida Stritx OC 570. Will try your settings. I have 26.5 Mhz and hihger power consumption. Also it is the hottest GPU in my rig with %100 fans all the time.

I really need to tweak it. Which strap? Any special strap value? @831mV for GPU or MEM undervolt?

Thanks.

Like Mattthev said, depends on your chip quality and temperatures. I've seen people here with less than 800mv on rx580!

Here's the bios I use (the strap I use is selected and visible).

About the fans being 100% all the time, it was happening to me too on my temporary case.
These "open" GPU's are blowing hot air in every direction. Make sure your cards are not blowing hot air in the direction of the motherboard, because that hot air will bounce back and heat up the neighbor GPU's, which in turn will heat their neighbors even more.

Glad to see someone else notice...

WHY DO THEY HAVE SUCH TERRIBLE COOLING SOLUTION!!

I have to design my rigs in closed boxes with fans in back and front to make a all air beeing pulled out and away from the hardware.
This is really frustratingto me.
Ive seen a few models where they use the good old nvidia solution with 1 single exhaust in the butt... i love that.

This blow-hot-air-randomly-all-around is really really really annoying.

spyshagg

full member

Activity: 176

Merit: 100

asus expedition. Elpida (1850mhz max).

eth only= 1090/1850mhz @ 831mv = 91w (wall)

Dual mining = 1130/1850mhz @ 831mv = 118w (wall)

I heard the Asus Dual cards have really bad cooling, but what about the Expedition? The cooler seems to be the same.

Currently I have a choice between one of these three cards:

Asus RX570 Expedition 4Gb
Asus RX 480 DUAL OC 4Gb
Msi RX 480 ARMOR OC 4Gb

Which one should I get? The purpose is not only mining but also some gaming on the side. Also, which of them do you think will have a greater resale value in 6mo/1yr, a 480 or a 570?

the cooling is not the best, but its ok if you give them space. In this image the second gpu is catching heat from the first one.

I havent tested any of the others. But this Expedition has bad memory (1850mhz max). I would go with Rx480

Eliavres

jr. member

Activity: 58

Merit: 10

Quote from: spyshagg on June 05, 2017, 10:22:14 AM

asus expedition. Elpida (1850mhz max).

eth only= 1090/1850mhz @ 831mv = 91w (wall)

Dual mining = 1130/1850mhz @ 831mv = 118w (wall)

I heard the Asus Dual cards have really bad cooling, but what about the Expedition? The cooler seems to be the same.

Currently I have a choice between one of these three cards:

Asus RX570 Expedition 4Gb
Asus RX 480 DUAL OC 4Gb
Msi RX 480 ARMOR OC 4Gb

Which one should I get? The purpose is not only mining but also some gaming on the side. Also, which of them do you think will have a greater resale value in 6mo/1yr, a 480 or a 570?

smaxz

sr. member

Activity: 430

Merit: 253

VeganAcademy

Quote from: oup59 on June 05, 2017, 10:04:03 AM

Also when one finds a sweetspot for undervolt mV value, is applying this mV value to all GPU speedssets other than the first set (300 Mhz-750 mV) best practice?

The difference is so small (750 -> 831) that you gain nothing by making voltage steps. Also, this is mining, so you will be always in the last state.

some algos switch between less intensive iterations though so I belive the last and second last states should be modified just to be on the safe side.

gaato77

newbie

Activity: 37

Merit: 0

any model in particular of this 570 GPU?

Mattthev

sr. member

Activity: 966

Merit: 359

👉MINING-BIOS.eu💲⛏

Quote from: budiselich on June 05, 2017, 10:19:47 AM

Hi, can I mix RX580 and RX480 on one rig?

Sure you can, RX 470/480/570/580 no problem, if you are running windows you can also use Nvidia and AMD.
Right now I have R9 380, RX 470 and RX 480.

oup59

sr. member

Activity: 382

Merit: 251

Quote from: budiselich on June 05, 2017, 10:19:47 AM

Hi, can I mix RX580 and RX480 on one rig?

You should. I already have 5 RX 570 and 1 RX 470 on the same rig.

spyshagg

full member

Activity: 176

Merit: 100

Quote from: oup59 on June 05, 2017, 10:04:03 AM

Also when one finds a sweetspot for undervolt mV value, is applying this mV value to all GPU speedssets other than the first set (300 Mhz-750 mV) best practice?

The difference is so small (750 -> 831) that you gain nothing by making voltage steps. Also, this is mining, so you will be always in the last state.

budiselich

newbie

Activity: 13

Merit: 0

Hi, can I mix RX580 and RX480 on one rig?

oup59

sr. member

Activity: 382

Merit: 251

Quote from: spyshagg on June 05, 2017, 09:56:19 AM

About the fans being 100% all the time, it was happening to me too on my temporary case.
These "open" GPU's are blowing hot air in every direction. Make sure your cards are not blowing hot air in the direction of the motherboard, because that hot air will bounce back and heat up the neighbor GPU's, which in turn will heat their neighbors even more.

Thank you for the settings. I will post my results as well.

I have one gpu on the mobo and 5 on the risers. My rig case is 7 gpu capable on the shelf.

I will distribute gpus as much as I can to improve air flow.

As another measure I will put Asus into a position where it breathes the freshest air from the front.

Right now it is it in between other gpus.

But as far as I see MSI has better temps and cooling overall.

Also when one finds a sweetspot for undervolt mV value, is applying this mV value to all GPU speedssets other than the first set (300 Mhz-750 mV) best practice?

spyshagg

full member

Activity: 176

Merit: 100

Quote from: oup59 on June 05, 2017, 08:28:03 AM

Quote from: centurionMiner on June 05, 2017, 05:06:09 AM

Quote from: oup59 on June 05, 2017, 08:28:03 AM

The rx560...seriously? How many MH can it pull in ETH?

15.5mhs with 1300/2100 clocks at 60w, basicly half a RX470

tweaked 570 = 27Mh/s @ 91w at the wall (64w on gpu-z). Could be >29Mh/s >100w but my elpida does not clock enough.

Model and memory?

asus expedition. Elpida (1850mhz max).

eth only= 1090/1850mhz @ 831mv = 91w (wall)

Dual mining = 1130/1850mhz @ 831mv = 118w (wall)

I have Elpida Stritx OC 570. Will try your settings. I have 26.5 Mhz and hihger power consumption. Also it is the hottest GPU in my rig with %100 fans all the time.

I really need to tweak it. Which strap? Any special strap value? @831mV for GPU or MEM undervolt?

Thanks.

Like Mattthev said, depends on your chip quality and temperatures. I've seen people here with less than 800mv on rx580!

Here's the bios I use (the strap I use is selected and visible).

About the fans being 100% all the time, it was happening to me too on my temporary case.
These "open" GPU's are blowing hot air in every direction. Make sure your cards are not blowing hot air in the direction of the motherboard, because that hot air will bounce back and heat up the neighbor GPU's, which in turn will heat their neighbors even more.

Mattthev

sr. member

Activity: 966

Merit: 359

👉MINING-BIOS.eu💲⛏

I have Elpida Stritx OC 570. Will try your settings. I have 26.5 Mhz and hihger power consumption. Also it is the hottest GPU in my rig with %100 fans all the time.

I really need to tweak it. Which strap? Any special strap value? @831mV for GPU or MEM undervolt?

Thanks.

You never know what voltages your card can do... Also memory can't be undervolt only memory controller. Performance timings is the key.
My Strix RX 470 has 29Mh/s, could be 30 with better quality Elpida memory.
I pretty love Strix cooling. It's very quiet and I don't have any trouble with temperetures. Asus Dual has very bad cooling.

oup59

sr. member

Activity: 382

Merit: 251

Quote from: centurionMiner on June 05, 2017, 05:06:09 AM

Quote from: Xardas2014 on June 05, 2017, 07:09:03 AM

The rx560...seriously? How many MH can it pull in ETH?

15.5mhs with 1300/2100 clocks at 60w, basicly half a RX470

tweaked 570 = 27Mh/s @ 91w at the wall (64w on gpu-z). Could be >29Mh/s >100w but my elpida does not clock enough.

Model and memory?

asus expedition. Elpida (1850mhz max).

eth only= 1090/1850mhz @ 831mv = 91w (wall)

Dual mining = 1130/1850mhz @ 831mv = 118w (wall)

I have Elpida Stritx OC 570. Will try your settings. I have 26.5 Mhz and hihger power consumption. Also it is the hottest GPU in my rig with %100 fans all the time.

I really need to tweak it. Which strap? Any special strap value? @831mV for GPU or MEM undervolt?

Thanks.

Mattthev

sr. member

Activity: 966

Merit: 359

👉MINING-BIOS.eu💲⛏

Quote from: Mattthev on June 05, 2017, 06:58:51 AM

When you know stable clocks you can set them in bios as default.

It is pretty fucking hard to find the best stable low wattage settings to hard code into the bios when you can't use something like Trixx or Afterburner to try different things Roll Eyes

I didn't mean set static voltages of course Shocked

After you test what clocks are stable you can set it in bios with dynamically voltages for clocks and flash it. Not saying it's best option but then you don't need to bother with profiles in Afterburner.

gaato77

newbie

Activity: 37

Merit: 0

will be possible to see a modded bios for RX570 to get <100 and higher rates of mhs?

spyshagg

full member

Activity: 176

Merit: 100

Quote from: centurionMiner on June 05, 2017, 05:06:09 AM