Author

Topic: [ANN] Bancor | Protocol for Smart-tokens, solving the liquidity problem - page 310. (Read 375744 times)

sr. member
Activity: 672
Merit: 274
can someone post a good explanation on why BNT is sinking every day?

It's because there is a flaw in the Bancor model and it's allowing the whales to game the system & take profits. Whales are buying at the exchange and selling to the contract small bit by bit due to the price discrepancy.

This drop will continue till the 120k ETH floor is completely gone. Then nobody knows what will happen. BNT can go into a free fall and never recover or it can start rising again. Nobody knows for sure because nobody can predict the market.
It is not a flaw.  This is how Bancor model works.  Arbitrage is supposed to even out the discrepancy between the exchanges and the smart contract.

One things I do not understand is why they are doing it bit by bit.  That part puzzles me.

That 120k ETH floor is the flaw. There is a huge incentive for the whales to crash the exchange price below 0.01 ETH and keep buying cheap BNT to sell to the contract because they know the contract price cannot go below 0.01 ETH. Any whale can put up a huge sell wall at 0.01 ETH to make sure the price doesn't go over that while they stock up on BNT.

I feel this is just the beginning, the worst is yet to come.

If the wall was not there, the whales would have pushed the price way below the 0.01 ETH mark already, bought up the coins cheaply and pumped the price to heaven. Now there is very little room for them to push it downwards, except if they can convince weak hands to go against the wall on their behalf. The 120k ETH floor is not the flaw, the flaw is people who are stupid enough to sell their BNT for less than 0.01 ETH in the open market. If the weak hands prevail, the price will eventually go below the 0.01 ETH mark. The whales will then have a feeding frenzy. Once they've bought up the coins cheaply, they will start pumping it like there is no tomorrow. Many of the weak hands will try to get back in, but at much higher prices.

Weak hands would sell on exchanges below ICO prices also because at the moment it's complicated to sell to the contract. Once the Bancor team releases their app to buy/sell this should not happen any more. I mean, you must be very stupid to sell cheap on one platform when you could easily sell higher on another one.

True. There is no excuse to sell below the ICO price, especially after Bancor posted this: https://blog.bancor.network/price-floor-smart-contract-deployed-621871bd09ca
sr. member
Activity: 672
Merit: 274
The price is going down because it's a scam. And the people that run it have already made their profits and moved on. It'll continue to drop until it becomes yet another scam ICO with a good enough sales pitch to convince people to pump $150M into it.

How exactly is it a scam? How exactly have they "already made their profits and moved on"? They are still frequently providing us with updates (e.g. https://blog.bancor.network/price-floor-smart-contract-deployed-621871bd09ca). Why would they even bother if they "have already made their profits and moved on"? Why would they allow people to sell BNT at a minimum price of 0.01 ETH until 120 000 ETH are gone? Wouldn't it be better to just take all the ETH and run?  Cool



Because the people involved and the ones that are behind this ICO deal with binary options, CFD and forex trading and that's exactly what they do. This ICO is just another way to lure innocent investors who think they can become early adopters of something that will be big and profitable in the future and in the meanwhile clean up on the invested monies. BNT had already reached $2.7 - that's a 90% drop in the past 7 days - the 4th biggest drop in all currencies according to coinmarketcap.com. You'd have to be practically delusional to assume it'll bounce back and live up to the fantasies it presented.

1. Where is your proof that they deal with binary options?

2. The ICO price was at 0.01 ETH. The current price is now 0.010303 ETH. Not exactly a 90% drop. In addition, many of the other cryptos have dropped in price as well as expressed in USD. Based on your logic, all of those must be scams, right? Roll Eyes

3. Why would they allow people to sell BNT at a minimum price of 0.01 ETH until 120 000 ETH are gone? Wouldn't it be better to just take all the ETH and run?  Cool

4. They are still frequently providing us with updates (e.g. https://blog.bancor.network/price-floor-smart-contract-deployed-621871bd09ca). Why would they even bother if they "have already made their profits and moved on"?

Please provide answers to the above questions.
sr. member
Activity: 1148
Merit: 307
can someone post a good explanation on why BNT is sinking every day?

It's because there is a flaw in the Bancor model and it's allowing the whales to game the system & take profits. Whales are buying at the exchange and selling to the contract small bit by bit due to the price discrepancy.

This drop will continue till the 120k ETH floor is completely gone. Then nobody knows what will happen. BNT can go into a free fall and never recover or it can start rising again. Nobody knows for sure because nobody can predict the market.
It is not a flaw.  This is how Bancor model works.  Arbitrage is supposed to even out the discrepancy between the exchanges and the smart contract.

One things I do not understand is why they are doing it bit by bit.  That part puzzles me.

That 120k ETH floor is the flaw. There is a huge incentive for the whales to crash the exchange price below 0.01 ETH and keep buying cheap BNT to sell to the contract because they know the contract price cannot go below 0.01 ETH. Any whale can put up a huge sell wall at 0.01 ETH to make sure the price doesn't go over that while they stock up on BNT.

I feel this is just the beginning, the worst is yet to come.

If the wall was not there, the whales would have pushed the price way below the 0.01 ETH mark already, bought up the coins cheaply and pumped the price to heaven. Now there is very little room for them to push it downwards, except if they can convince weak hands to go against the wall on their behalf. The 120k ETH floor is not the flaw, the flaw is people who are stupid enough to sell their BNT for less than 0.01 ETH in the open market. If the weak hands prevail, the price will eventually go below the 0.01 ETH mark. The whales will then have a feeding frenzy. Once they've bought up the coins cheaply, they will start pumping it like there is no tomorrow. Many of the weak hands will try to get back in, but at much higher prices.

Weak hands would sell on exchanges below ICO prices also because at the moment it's complicated to sell to the contract. Once the Bancor team releases their app to buy/sell this should not happen any more. I mean, you must be very stupid to sell cheap on one platform when you could easily sell higher on another one.
newbie
Activity: 3
Merit: 0
The price is going down because it's a scam. And the people that run it have already made their profits and moved on. It'll continue to drop until it becomes yet another scam ICO with a good enough sales pitch to convince people to pump $150M into it.

How exactly is it a scam? How exactly have they "already made their profits and moved on"? They are still frequently providing us with updates (e.g. https://blog.bancor.network/price-floor-smart-contract-deployed-621871bd09ca). Why would they even bother if they "have already made their profits and moved on"? Why would they allow people to sell BNT at a minimum price of 0.01 ETH until 120 000 ETH are gone? Wouldn't it be better to just take all the ETH and run?  Cool



Because the people involved and the ones that are behind this ICO deal with binary options, CFD and forex trading and that's exactly what they do. This ICO is just another way to lure innocent investors who think they can become early adopters of something that will be big and profitable in the future and in the meanwhile clean up on the invested monies. BNT had already reached $2.7 - that's a 90% drop in the past 7 days - the 4th biggest drop in all currencies according to coinmarketcap.com. You'd have to be practically delusional to assume it'll bounce back and live up to the fantasies it presented.
hero member
Activity: 658
Merit: 500
can someone post a good explanation on why BNT is sinking every day?

It is simple, ICO flippers are selling to enter into another big project. Bancor is a long term project and token holders will surely benefit from this

Really I think an ICO that goes up 400% the first day, is a lot better than one that goes down 20% like BNT

huge disappointment...

ETH = $3,80 at ICO, now $3  Sad

GNO = $35 at ICO, well over $100 after a few days...

Why are you expressing it in dollars? They sold it at 0.01 ETH during the  ICO. The current price is 0.010284 ETH. How does that represent a 20% drop?
Be patient is just the beginning,I am sure of this project and i will sell its x3 even more at the price of $ 10
Do not equate Banchor with GNO which has a fair amount of Coin Supply so reasonable if the GNO price is high enough now


$10 per token will give it over a billion USD valuation. In theory that should be the market cap but the team need to walk their talk first, the project has been attacked by several people and some people are saying it can easily be gamed. I know some black hackers will be looking for these loop-holes.
sr. member
Activity: 672
Merit: 274
The price is going down because it's a scam. And the people that run it have already made their profits and moved on. It'll continue to drop until it becomes yet another scam ICO with a good enough sales pitch to convince people to pump $150M into it.

How exactly is it a scam? How exactly have they "already made their profits and moved on"? They are still frequently providing us with updates (e.g. https://blog.bancor.network/price-floor-smart-contract-deployed-621871bd09ca). Why would they even bother if they "have already made their profits and moved on"? Why would they allow people to sell BNT at a minimum price of 0.01 ETH until 120 000 ETH are gone? Wouldn't it be better to just take all the ETH and run?  Cool

sr. member
Activity: 1022
Merit: 252
can someone post a good explanation on why BNT is sinking every day?

It is simple, ICO flippers are selling to enter into another big project. Bancor is a long term project and token holders will surely benefit from this

Really I think an ICO that goes up 400% the first day, is a lot better than one that goes down 20% like BNT

huge disappointment...

ETH = $3,80 at ICO, now $3  Sad

GNO = $35 at ICO, well over $100 after a few days...

Why are you expressing it in dollars? They sold it at 0.01 ETH during the  ICO. The current price is 0.010284 ETH. How does that represent a 20% drop?
Be patient is just the beginning,I am sure of this project and i will sell its x3 even more at the price of $ 10
Do not equate Banchor with GNO which has a fair amount of Coin Supply so reasonable if the GNO price is high enough now
sr. member
Activity: 672
Merit: 274
I don't understand investors of you get in this game and decided to invest in and ICO which is highly unpredictable in every term, why don't you give a little more time? Why people rushing to sell it becase it is not 10x more as they have espected to be on start? My advice is to wait , and not to fall under this presure..I will buy some, and i will wait. Wink

It is because most are not investors. They are speculators. They are the weak hands who are now off loading BNT close to the ICO price as expressed in ETH. They are the weak hands that are off loading at a loss as expressed in USD. They have little to no faith in the project itself - most don't even know what it is about, especially after Clif High left those remarks at twitter (https://twitter.com/clif_high).

Personally, like you, I will continue to hold mine, because I believe in this project despite claims that the "code is flawed" and what have you. Is it guaranteed to succeed? No, but I will take my chances.
newbie
Activity: 3
Merit: 0
The price is going down because it's a scam. And the people that run it have already made their profits and moved on. It'll continue to drop until it becomes yet another scam ICO with a good enough sales pitch to convince people to pump $150M into it.
sr. member
Activity: 672
Merit: 274
can someone post a good explanation on why BNT is sinking every day?

It's because there is a flaw in the Bancor model and it's allowing the whales to game the system & take profits. Whales are buying at the exchange and selling to the contract small bit by bit due to the price discrepancy.

This drop will continue till the 120k ETH floor is completely gone. Then nobody knows what will happen. BNT can go into a free fall and never recover or it can start rising again. Nobody knows for sure because nobody can predict the market.
It is not a flaw.  This is how Bancor model works.  Arbitrage is supposed to even out the discrepancy between the exchanges and the smart contract.

One things I do not understand is why they are doing it bit by bit.  That part puzzles me.

That 120k ETH floor is the flaw. There is a huge incentive for the whales to crash the exchange price below 0.01 ETH and keep buying cheap BNT to sell to the contract because they know the contract price cannot go below 0.01 ETH. Any whale can put up a huge sell wall at 0.01 ETH to make sure the price doesn't go over that while they stock up on BNT.

I feel this is just the beginning, the worst is yet to come.

If the wall was not there, the whales would have pushed the price way below the 0.01 ETH mark already, bought up the coins cheaply and pumped the price to heaven. Now there is very little room for them to push it downwards, except if they can convince weak hands to go against the wall on their behalf. The 120k ETH floor is not the flaw, the flaw is people who are stupid enough to sell their BNT for less than 0.01 ETH in the open market. If the weak hands prevail, the price will eventually go below the 0.01 ETH mark. The whales will then have a feeding frenzy. Once they've bought up the coins cheaply, they will start pumping it like there is no tomorrow. Many of the weak hands will try to get back in, but at much higher prices.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 1026
I don't understand investors of you get in this game and decided to invest in and ICO which is highly unpredictable in every term, why don't you give a little more time? Why people rushing to sell it becase it is not 10x more as they have espected to be on start? My advice is to wait , and not to fall under this presure..I will buy some, and i will wait. Wink
sr. member
Activity: 672
Merit: 274
can someone post a good explanation on why BNT is sinking every day?

It is simple, ICO flippers are selling to enter into another big project. Bancor is a long term project and token holders will surely benefit from this

Really I think an ICO that goes up 400% the first day, is a lot better than one that goes down 20% like BNT

huge disappointment...

ETH = $3,80 at ICO, now $3  Sad

GNO = $35 at ICO, well over $100 after a few days...

Why are you expressing it in dollars? They sold it at 0.01 ETH during the  ICO. The current price is 0.010284 ETH. How does that represent a 20% drop?
sr. member
Activity: 672
Merit: 274
i didn't follow this whole bancor-thing so pls take it easy with me,
one question: one of the main selling points is the liquidity if i got that right but not even eth itself provides good liquidity as seen by the coinbase flash-crash so whats the point again? is this a promise for the future or something? thx!

To claim that "not even eth itself provides good liquidity" is simply not true. A high volume of activity in the market or high liquidity led to the temporary hiccup at ETH. See the posts above to learn how Bancor intends to ensure liquidity across their network despite the popularity (or lack thereof) a single smart token enjoys.
full member
Activity: 186
Merit: 100
It's not like people say, just on the line, trading fell to the bottom
hero member
Activity: 1876
Merit: 512
Pretty funny part is that right now with price being lower than ICO, you can spend less USD and gotten more out of than the ICO and skip all the craziness.   Undecided


I think ICO is about entering its bearish market like last year, where ICO tokens start dropping when it hit the market. ICN, GOLEM, SNGL, Antshares etc all dumped when they all hit market.
legendary
Activity: 1694
Merit: 1003
It got over bough and bitcoin price is falling so many of the altcoin/token are also taking a dive some are selling Bancor to recuperate.
hero member
Activity: 742
Merit: 500
The revolutionary trading ecosystem
can someone post a good explanation on why BNT is sinking every day?

In most easy and simple word it can be explained as accumulation all what is happening right now. If you are holder then keep holding and don't shake your hands now as good times are coming soon. It is big project which will not fall like this easy.
Accumulation? I do not think so everybody had a chance to get involved and it seems that sometimes most successful ICO is not best in terms of investment returns.. But still it is too early for this kind of talk. This is all because of fear and dubts.

There is no accumulation theory here, because the ICO riased alot of funds and the 3 hours period extension allowed alot of investors to get into the game. This is going to be a long term investment in my opinion, anyone looking to flip his profit should better get out now before more price dip
sr. member
Activity: 347
Merit: 250
Activity: 2017
can someone post a good explanation on why BNT is sinking every day?

In most easy and simple word it can be explained as accumulation all what is happening right now. If you are holder then keep holding and don't shake your hands now as good times are coming soon. It is big project which will not fall like this easy.
Accumulation? I do not think so everybody had a chance to get involved and it seems that sometimes most successful ICO is not best in terms of investment returns.. But still it is too early for this kind of talk. This is all because of fear and dubts.
hero member
Activity: 1638
Merit: 507
The snake which cannot cast its skin has to die

Ether opened up at $2.83, dropped  to $0.64 after a few days.....but now at $299.00!

If you're insinuating that what happened to ETH's $ price will happen to BNT's $ price then I hope you're right. I'm contemplating buying BNTs. My only concern though is the Ethereum network doesn't seem to be able to handle large & concentrated transactions. We've seen it with the BNT & the Status ICOs, whereby the network stopped working or was extremely slow. Since BNT is built to work on top of the Ethereum network, how will the Ethereum's apparent lack of capacity affect BNT in the long run? And therefore affect BNTs $ price?

speed of the network only affects speed of transactions, no real correlation to price, unless the market mentality feels the value of the coin should reflect that technical drawback.
Otherwise, BNT's transfers will remain limited by ETH's functional capacity, unless the team decides to make BNT it's own network separate from ETH. But afaik ETH has some new features coming awaiting activation that should improve ETH's performance.
newbie
Activity: 7
Merit: 0

Ether opened up at $2.83, dropped  to $0.64 after a few days.....but now at $299.00!

If you're insinuating that what happened to ETH's $ price will happen to BNT's $ price then I hope you're right. I'm contemplating buying BNTs. My only concern though is the Ethereum network doesn't seem to be able to handle large & concentrated transactions. We've seen it with the BNT & the Status ICOs, whereby the network stopped working or was extremely slow. Since BNT is built to work on top of the Ethereum network, how will the Ethereum's apparent lack of capacity affect BNT in the long run? And therefore affect BNTs $ price?
i don't think every coin can like ether have such succeed
Jump to: