So, what we have:
- They just transfer their platform onto blockchain, no innovations, just upgrade
- They completely rely on Steam, and if Valve changes its mind on third-party platforms, WAX will collapse at once
- Strange and shady changes of terms with no proper explication
WAX, do you even care about your reputation? Explain yourself.
Please find below answers to your questions:
1) They just transfer their platform onto blockchain, no innovations, just upgrade
Answer: The WAX Platform will allow
millions of traders to create their own virtual stores on one decentralized platform. No other company is doing this. The WAX Platform unites everyone and provides instant payments, security, and trust services that will bring millions of new participants into a growing ecosystem.
Based on blockchain technologies, WAX Tokens will enable
1.8 billion gamers worldwide to quickly and easily harness the power of a fully developed, highly complex virtual goods exchange that provides escrow, liquidity through access to a large number of buyers and sellers, and other complex parts of a well functioning marketplaces.
By decentralizing these exchanges, vastly more trading in the already sizeable $50 billion video game virtual goods trading market is possible.2) They completely rely on Steam, and if Valve changes its mind on third-party platforms, WAX will collapse at once
Answer: WAX is not requiring publisher integration. And keep in mind, WAX can facilitate the trading of any digital item, whether it be web based or mobile. WAX is designed to serve the entire video gaming and digital asset trading ecosystem.
And regarding the "third-party platform": OPSkins is the #1 digital marketplace in the world which is 10 times bigger than the closest competitor!
3) Strange and shady changes of terms with no proper explication
Answer: WAX team did not make the decision to move this deadline lightly and we're really sorry for any inconveniences it caused. When it was decided, the announcements was made as quickly as possible. Nevertheless many video gamers - the core audience we are aiming for - as part of the token sale. Since many of these individuals are first time crypto currency adopters, it has understandably taken more time for them to get educated about WAX. In our judgement, it was better to give this core community more time to participate.
Read detail in the blog post:
https://medium.com/waxtoken/the-pre-sale-and-gamer-sale-dates-have-been-extended-d2f13689c856More answers in reddit AMA with William Quigley (CEO) and Malcolm CasSelle (President):
https://www.reddit.com/r/WAXtoken/comments/7a4gzg/the_wax_ama_with_william_quigley_ceo_and_malcolm/The updated information is provided in White Paper as well.
4) Skins are stocked on Valve servers. They own them both physically and legally. Let's imagine, I bought a skin on your platform, and you suddenly have been cut from Valve servers for some reason. How would I take away the skin in your opinion? Valve is just gonna say me 'sorry bro, you should have used our marketplace'.
Answer: Please read 2. Please also keep in mind that WAX platform is a marketplace and not the owner of the skins (like Amazon is not the owner of all the items that are traded there). Transfer agents are responsible for the transfer of values between users in the games.
I'd like to state it once again, any game from any platform or publisher that allows trading will be tradeable on WAX.
5) How do you expect in-game items to be tradable within your platform? Again, let's imagine a situation. I'm a game developer who wants items from my game be tradable for your coin. What should I do?
Answer: The game should be interesting to the audience. Anyone can submit a proposal for a guild spot, and WAX Token holders will vote for them based on what they see in their proposals. Token holders can only vote for so many, and since the WAX token holders make a cut off guild fees, it's in their best interest to vote for the most trusted ones. Guilds receive a percentage of the fees on lists, transfers, and Contracts and as a WAX Token holder you can pledge these guilds - in turn earning a percentage of the earned guild fees (see the sections Guilds in white paper for more details).