Author

Topic: [ANN][BURST] Burst | Efficient HDD Mining | New 1.2.3 Fork block 92000 - page 203. (Read 2170648 times)

hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 500
sr. member
Activity: 1204
Merit: 486
why the bear market? it seems an interesting project.
hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 500
haitch, thanks for taking a look at this argument! Perhaps he should have thought about it one minute more Wink
hero member
Activity: 539
Merit: 500
So far, from all the devs i have spoken to, they all say burst is flawed. The core dev hasn't shown his face in a while, and devs have only left this coin. Why would I stick around? I have never been paid, and tbh i'm not much good anyway. It's a shame that burstcoin.biz doesn't has an asset explorer....but that's all i've managed to achieve. The burstcoin.info is about as crap as a site gets. I dunno guys, can you tell me why I should stick around without a whitepaper? I am not good enough to be able to review the algo.

All your efforts are apperciated. I'm sure they'll often go un-noticed by many but
I really apperciate all that you've added to this coin and the community as a whole.

A few other guys here are also great and all lots of value to this coin!

We've just got to push through these rough times together.

I would still like a clear explanation of exactly what it is you think is flawed in PoC.

To my knowledge it has been tested to see if it can be exploited, and every attempt has either failed, or been completely pointless... such as trying to mine on GPU. It would be completely pointless to try because a great GPU would only equate to a very small amount of HDD space and thus be extremely ridiculous in power consumption VS HDD...

But yea, I don't know exactly what you're worried about with this flaw theory.

I think you should stick around because this is not the end, by far. Just because the few active devs we had have decided to move on, doesn't mean we can't get new ones, and in fact I'm already prepared if need-be.

I'm going to wait a while for the main dev to show up again before making any executive decisions, but it is entirely possible to re-boot the coin, new OP, new devs, and pick up where the other left off, if we need to.

People are acting like he has been gone forever, when in reality I spoke to him personally on the first of August. That's less than a month of actually not being around. Is this really enough time for people to lose their minds?

if PoC is flawed in some way, I would like to know what way you think that is, so it can be documented and fixed.

Only criticism I remember seeing leveled at BURST:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/2tukar/cryptocurrency_burst_makes_smart_contracts_a/co2fywm

And by the authors own logic, the weakness does not exist.

Quote
"* In order for the algo to be storage-bound and for a shortcut attack involving recomputing everything not to exist, we need reading from the hard drive to take less time than recomputing the data. But then we want a 1000x safety margin if we want that condition to hold true against potential ASIC implementations, hence reads need to be 1000x cheaper than the plot computation step. Hence, reading more than one time would have a marginal incremental cost of only 0.1%."

So if reading is 1000x faster than plotting, there's no shortcut attack.

So lets take a look at some numbers.

I took a look at my plot files, and each 500GB plot - 2,097,152 sets of 4096 nonces took 4 hours to plot using dual GPU's. So around 3.5 Million nonces/minute. So to be safe from attack we'd need mining that plot to occur at greater than 3.5 Billion nonces/minute.

I just checked one of my miners, and it read 34TB in 77 seconds, so 26.5TB minute. 26.5TB/min = 455 Billion nonces/minute.

455 Billion nonces/minute is a little higher than the 3.5 Million nonces/minute we need to be safe from attack.

Rather than the 1000x cheaper we need to be safe, reads are more than 100,000x cheaper ....

Now that is based on the time it took to write to disk all those nonces, an attacker doesn't need to write them, so can calculate them faster. So:

Based on the time taken to mine, we're processing around 120M nonces/minute. Each verification step requires 2 shabal256 calculations, so around 240M/min. But lets be generous and call it 500M/minute.

A no storage attacker needs to do 4097 shabals per deadline they're potentially submitting, which equates to around 125,000 plots, or 32GB of storage.

So this theoretical ASIC 1,000x faster than a GPU would do around 32TB.

The theoretical ASIC that's 1,000 times faster than the extremely generous performance specs we give to a high performance GPU could come close to the mining performance of hard disks, but will not match it. And as SSDs get bigger and cheaper (Samsung is planning on launching a 128TB SSD in 2018) the performance gap will only grow.

And that's for a theoretical ASIC; as it stands today, you'd need over 1,000 high performance GPU's, to match the mining capacity of 10 off the shelf SATA drives.

I think we're safe.

H.
sr. member
Activity: 378
Merit: 250
hero member
Activity: 539
Merit: 500

This project isn't about becoming rich in a year. This project is about the FUTURE. The future of mining, the future of blockchain tech, the future of crypto in general, and if you don't believe that, and/or don't give a shit, then go mine a pnd coin or buy a scam coin IPO, wait for the initial pump, sell off with hope that you profit, and rinse repeat.

I would not say Burst is the future of mining. Unless something is done to adapt Burst to utilize the hard drive space for something I doubt Burst will be able to compete with other up and coming storage based solutions. I can't remember who it was that was also on the same page and commented about that with this idea.  In my opinion it would be something I would donate toward if it was possible or a plan put in motion for that. I have mined Burst for most of the last year as well and have recently stopped. The all-in-one wallet/mining/plotting solution is a great step forward but just not enough to make a big enough difference where people are coming in.

Besides the assets and a dice/horse racing game, how many other things can you spend Burst on?? What good is having it if you cannot spend it? That is part of the problem.

You've not visited the marketplace? http://burstcoin.info/market/

H.
newbie
Activity: 21
Merit: 0
I just placed a buy back order for 46.5 Burst for 5k assets. thats for small holders that wants to cashout without pn.

Big holders please use pn. i cant place a complete buy back order for all issues assets, because i would kill with such an order the asset trading, also i need this burst for daytrading to earn the interests that i have to payout.

if the 5k order was executed, i will place one again.

But keep in mind, the asset is still the most profitablest investment in the burstcoin world!

Regards
boba

i have cashed out using your placed buy orders. thanks for the fast reply.
hero member
Activity: 785
Merit: 500
BURST got Smart Contracts (AT)
Congratulations: 400 registered miners at burst.ninja

Current time: 2015-08-28 09:09:03 UTC
Block: 136,544
Difficulty: 8,993

BURST.MiningHere.com
Pool balance: 64,989
Registered Miners: 280

burst.ninja
Pool balance: 21,529
Registered Miners: 400

burst.poolto.be
Pool balance: 4,242
Registered Miners: 254

cryptomining.farm
Pool balance: 83,292
Registered Miners: 1,860

DevPool v2
Pool balance: 586,062
Registered Miners: 551

mining.tompool.org
Pool balance: 1,370
Registered Miners: 56

pool.blago
Pool balance: 2
Registered Miners: 112

pool.burstcoin.de
Pool balance: 24,964
Registered Miners: 119

pool.burstcoin.it
Pool balance: 37
Registered Miners: 52
sr. member
Activity: 355
Merit: 250
If our dev left this project maybe we could ask him about change dev? Maybe Horizon dev team could help us? HZ i also NXT clone, the distribution of HZ end in few weeks maybe they will be intrested?
hero member
Activity: 785
Merit: 500
BURST got Smart Contracts (AT)
I just placed a buy back order for 46.5 Burst for 5k assets. thats for small holders that wants to cashout without pn.

Big holders please use pn. i cant place a complete buy back order for all issues assets, because i would kill with such an order the asset trading, also i need this burst for daytrading to earn the interests that i have to payout.

if the 5k order was executed, i will place one again.

But keep in mind, the asset is still the most profitablest investment in the burstcoin world!

Regards
boba

I think it should be done with an asset transfer (maybe with Escrow, if they want), so that it does not influence the trades.
hero member
Activity: 785
Merit: 500
BURST got Smart Contracts (AT)
elmit, if you are selling financial products in germany you need to fullfill the requirements for example of § 34f / § 34g. this has nothing to do with being a bank.

Mr Marco Feindler stated in his sales document:

Instant Cashout without loss! Also you can cashout anytime. I will buy back the assets from you. Therfore i will place a buy order for every sold asset with a price of 50 Burst. The price what i pay for the payback will decrease 1% every month. Buywall will be created instantly after the first sales and adapted every first day of the month.

there was no adapted buy order in august. please take a look at the asset orderbook...that is classic scam in my opinion.



I called him out myself, honestly I never trusted or liked the guy very much. Nonetheless I supported his project, now it seems he is thieving from everyone. Very upsetting and yet another scar on BURST.

Honestly it is quite ridiculous. I say go after him if you can, if you're in the same country. He has yet to respond to my call out.

Hear, hear, ...
I think Bobafett does a lots more than you think for Burst. He is not hiding his identity, makes ads in Germany for Burst out of his own pocket. He is not crying for  coins to be donated(, to be then later declared as stolen). His web site has an "Impressum" as the German law requires, with all details included. He said he will make a German web site, and he did it within reasonable time (days)!

As more I read of who you like and not like, I get the feeling, that the missing coins have another drain hole.
hero member
Activity: 619
Merit: 500
I just placed a buy back order for 46.5 Burst for 5k assets. thats for small holders that wants to cashout without pn.

Big holders please use pn. i cant place a complete buy back order for all issues assets, because i would kill with such an order the asset trading, also i need this burst for daytrading to earn the interests that i have to payout.

if the 5k order was executed, i will place one again.

But keep in mind, the asset is still the most profitablest investment in the burstcoin world!

Regards
boba
hero member
Activity: 619
Merit: 500
elmit, if you are selling financial products in germany you need to fullfill the requirements for example of § 34f / § 34g. this has nothing to do with being a bank.

Mr Marco Feindler stated in his sales document:

Instant Cashout without loss! Also you can cashout anytime. I will buy back the assets from you. Therfore i will place a buy order for every sold asset with a price of 50 Burst. The price what i pay for the payback will decrease 1% every month. Buywall will be created instantly after the first sales and adapted every first day of the month.

there was no adapted buy order in august. please take a look at the asset orderbook...that is classic scam in my opinion.



I called him out myself, honestly I never trusted or liked the guy very much. Nonetheless I supported his project, now it seems he is thieving from everyone. Very upsetting and yet another scar on BURST.

Honestly it is quite ridiculous. I say go after him if you can, if you're in the same country. He has yet to respond to my call out.

Sorry Guys,
I was not online for the last weeks, because i was on a business trip and im back on monday.
Next payout will be again 2%. Eerybody who wants to cash out, pn me.

Regards
Boba
legendary
Activity: 3136
Merit: 1116
So far, from all the devs i have spoken to, they all say burst is flawed. The core dev hasn't shown his face in a while, and devs have only left this coin. Why would I stick around? I have never been paid, and tbh i'm not much good anyway. It's a shame that burstcoin.biz doesn't has an asset explorer....but that's all i've managed to achieve. The burstcoin.info is about as crap as a site gets. I dunno guys, can you tell me why I should stick around without a whitepaper? I am not good enough to be able to review the algo.

All your efforts are apperciated. I'm sure they'll often go un-noticed by many but
I really apperciate all that you've added to this coin and the community as a whole.

A few other guys here are also great and all lots of value to this coin!

We've just got to push through these rough times together.

I would still like a clear explanation of exactly what it is you think is flawed in PoC.

To my knowledge it has been tested to see if it can be exploited, and every attempt has either failed, or been completely pointless... such as trying to mine on GPU. It would be completely pointless to try because a great GPU would only equate to a very small amount of HDD space and thus be extremely ridiculous in power consumption VS HDD...

But yea, I don't know exactly what you're worried about with this flaw theory.

I think you should stick around because this is not the end, by far. Just because the few active devs we had have decided to move on, doesn't mean we can't get new ones, and in fact I'm already prepared if need-be.

I'm going to wait a while for the main dev to show up again before making any executive decisions, but it is entirely possible to re-boot the coin, new OP, new devs, and pick up where the other left off, if we need to.

People are acting like he has been gone forever, when in reality I spoke to him personally on the first of August. That's less than a month of actually not being around. Is this really enough time for people to lose their minds?

if PoC is flawed in some way, I would like to know what way you think that is, so it can be documented and fixed.

Only criticism I remember seeing leveled at BURST:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/2tukar/cryptocurrency_burst_makes_smart_contracts_a/co2fywm
hero member
Activity: 868
Merit: 1000
So far, from all the devs i have spoken to, they all say burst is flawed. The core dev hasn't shown his face in a while, and devs have only left this coin. Why would I stick around? I have never been paid, and tbh i'm not much good anyway. It's a shame that burstcoin.biz doesn't has an asset explorer....but that's all i've managed to achieve. The burstcoin.info is about as crap as a site gets. I dunno guys, can you tell me why I should stick around without a whitepaper? I am not good enough to be able to review the algo.

All your efforts are apperciated. I'm sure they'll often go un-noticed by many but
I really apperciate all that you've added to this coin and the community as a whole.

A few other guys here are also great and all lots of value to this coin!

We've just got to push through these rough times together.

I would still like a clear explanation of exactly what it is you think is flawed in PoC.

To my knowledge it has been tested to see if it can be exploited, and every attempt has either failed, or been completely pointless... such as trying to mine on GPU. It would be completely pointless to try because a great GPU would only equate to a very small amount of HDD space and thus be extremely ridiculous in power consumption VS HDD...

But yea, I don't know exactly what you're worried about with this flaw theory.

I think you should stick around because this is not the end, by far. Just because the few active devs we had have decided to move on, doesn't mean we can't get new ones, and in fact I'm already prepared if need-be.

I'm going to wait a while for the main dev to show up again before making any executive decisions, but it is entirely possible to re-boot the coin, new OP, new devs, and pick up where the other left off, if we need to.

People are acting like he has been gone forever, when in reality I spoke to him personally on the first of August. That's less than a month of actually not being around. Is this really enough time for people to lose their minds?

if PoC is flawed in some way, I would like to know what way you think that is, so it can be documented and fixed.

Good that we have passionate people like u in crypto. Hope we will celebrate 2nd year anniversary for Burst next year
legendary
Activity: 2282
Merit: 1072
https://crowetic.com | https://qortal.org
So far, from all the devs i have spoken to, they all say burst is flawed. The core dev hasn't shown his face in a while, and devs have only left this coin. Why would I stick around? I have never been paid, and tbh i'm not much good anyway. It's a shame that burstcoin.biz doesn't has an asset explorer....but that's all i've managed to achieve. The burstcoin.info is about as crap as a site gets. I dunno guys, can you tell me why I should stick around without a whitepaper? I am not good enough to be able to review the algo.

All your efforts are apperciated. I'm sure they'll often go un-noticed by many but
I really apperciate all that you've added to this coin and the community as a whole.

A few other guys here are also great and all lots of value to this coin!

We've just got to push through these rough times together.

I would still like a clear explanation of exactly what it is you think is flawed in PoC.

To my knowledge it has been tested to see if it can be exploited, and every attempt has either failed, or been completely pointless... such as trying to mine on GPU. It would be completely pointless to try because a great GPU would only equate to a very small amount of HDD space and thus be extremely ridiculous in power consumption VS HDD...

But yea, I don't know exactly what you're worried about with this flaw theory.

I think you should stick around because this is not the end, by far. Just because the few active devs we had have decided to move on, doesn't mean we can't get new ones, and in fact I'm already prepared if need-be.

I'm going to wait a while for the main dev to show up again before making any executive decisions, but it is entirely possible to re-boot the coin, new OP, new devs, and pick up where the other left off, if we need to.

People are acting like he has been gone forever, when in reality I spoke to him personally on the first of August. That's less than a month of actually not being around. Is this really enough time for people to lose their minds?

if PoC is flawed in some way, I would like to know what way you think that is, so it can be documented and fixed.
sr. member
Activity: 275
Merit: 250
So far, from all the devs i have spoken to, they all say burst is flawed. The core dev hasn't shown his face in a while, and devs have only left this coin. Why would I stick around? I have never been paid, and tbh i'm not much good anyway. It's a shame that burstcoin.biz doesn't has an asset explorer....but that's all i've managed to achieve. The burstcoin.info is about as crap as a site gets. I dunno guys, can you tell me why I should stick around without a whitepaper? I am not good enough to be able to review the algo.

All your efforts are apperciated. I'm sure they'll often go un-noticed by many but
I really apperciate all that you've added to this coin and the community as a whole.

A few other guys here are also great and all lots of value to this coin!

We've just got to push through these rough times together.
sr. member
Activity: 302
Merit: 250
"The provided video of the new windows wallet is just pure advertisement for one pool. I cannot promote it! I have to make my own ads (video)." - Elmit

Well, I released the Windows client with one pool because we needed a working all-in-one solution as fast as possible - for everyone! Crowetic tested, helped me and made a video for it so I decided for his pool.

It seems you never used my software because there is a clear message for pool owners:



And actually one (!) guy contacted me and send me the configs for the italian pool and it will be included in the next release. To that point I had no experience with uray's pool code so it was necessary. Elmit, you could help beta-testing (pm).

About the whitepaper:
It will be done, even if I have to write it myself. But that would take months...
I don't understand irontiga's vague words about flaws. There is no 'inside' information he is referring to. The code is available on gitihub - open source. The work of burstdev speaks for itself.

About the tech and usage of Burst:
As I mentioned weeks ago there is no reason to implement some kind of cloud functionality. Burst IS the shadow price /opportunity costs of free space lying around unused. What we don't have yet is a working market.

At the moment Burst is almost 600 times more efficient per transaction (at 5% network capacity) than Bitcoin (at 70% network capacity). If you see the same potential and you want to be part of it, you can contact me.

"You can't climb the ladder of success with your hands in your pockets" - A. S.
legendary
Activity: 2282
Merit: 1072
https://crowetic.com | https://qortal.org
elmit, if you are selling financial products in germany you need to fullfill the requirements for example of § 34f / § 34g. this has nothing to do with being a bank.

Mr Marco Feindler stated in his sales document:

Instant Cashout without loss! Also you can cashout anytime. I will buy back the assets from you. Therfore i will place a buy order for every sold asset with a price of 50 Burst. The price what i pay for the payback will decrease 1% every month. Buywall will be created instantly after the first sales and adapted every first day of the month.

there was no adapted buy order in august. please take a look at the asset orderbook...that is classic scam in my opinion.



I called him out myself, honestly I never trusted or liked the guy very much. Nonetheless I supported his project, now it seems he is thieving from everyone. Very upsetting and yet another scar on BURST.

Honestly it is quite ridiculous. I say go after him if you can, if you're in the same country. He has yet to respond to my call out.
legendary
Activity: 2282
Merit: 1072
https://crowetic.com | https://qortal.org

This project isn't about becoming rich in a year. This project is about the FUTURE. The future of mining, the future of blockchain tech, the future of crypto in general, and if you don't believe that, and/or don't give a shit, then go mine a pnd coin or buy a scam coin IPO, wait for the initial pump, sell off with hope that you profit, and rinse repeat.

I would not say Burst is the future of mining. Unless something is done to adapt Burst to utilize the hard drive space for something I doubt Burst will be able to compete with other up and coming storage based solutions. I can't remember who it was that was also on the same page and commented about that with this idea.  In my opinion it would be something I would donate toward if it was possible or a plan put in motion for that. I have mined Burst for most of the last year as well and have recently stopped. The all-in-one wallet/mining/plotting solution is a great step forward but just not enough to make a big enough difference where people are coming in.

Besides the assets and a dice/horse racing game, how many other things can you spend Burst on?? What good is having it if you cannot spend it? That is part of the problem.

Think you got something wrong, BURST uses the drive space for precalculated hashes, there is no way to use it for other data.
BURST is the ONLY coin using drive space for mining, other solutions / coins rewad you for sharing space / bandwidth ... thats something completely different.


The person that came up with the idea previously (can't remember the forum user) thought that in addition to storing the hashes that people could set aside additional storage space and be paid in Burst for using that space.  So the trade off with Burst seems to be..... save energy, waste space. The point is that the hard drive space will become a commodity in these other solutions and thriving ecosystems will be based around them. What will make someone decide that using that space for Burst is a better decision......for what? It has been a year and there are only a few gambling solutions that accept it, and no merchants. Even though the all in one wallet is much easier, what makes a person WANT Burst?

I am not trying to troll. I have been a Burst user from the very beginning and have enjoyed learning the system but I am just being real here. It is on the edge of dying because of the lack of core Dev updates to the wallet or any type of communication that shows there is a future for this.  Crowetic and Luxe along with others have done a ton for Burst to keep pushing it forward but that only goes so far being community members and not driving ongoing development.

One way or another there WILL be core updates. Either the dev will come back, or another will be appointed. I have everything lined up just in case. It will not disappear, it will not die.

There are many platforms that can be built around BURST tech, that will allow for reasons to use the coin. I'm working on a few ideas. One of which would be a front end for the marketplace, making a decentralized eBay, dBay. heh. (that isn't necessarily what it will be called, but I think that is hilarious.)

There are many uses for Automated Transactions too, that can be built on top of BURST.

Everything will work out, things will continue, BURST will survive and thrive.

Jump to: