Ser, you're nit-picking. Why do you choose October 2023's price point when EVERYONE had a GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY to buy the actual DIP under the 200-Weekly SMA from June 2022 to March 2023. That's almost ONE YEAR of continued opportunity, THEN the price DIPPED under the line again during August 2023.
Sure we could use August 2023 or even a year ago, yet what is significant about October 2023 is that there were quite a few people (including you) who were expecting and cheering for down and saying that you could not buy BTC because you were waiting for more down.. Yet, in October 2023, the BTC market turned and the price pretty much shot up from $26k/$27k-ish and went all the way up to $73k in March 2024.. so yeah, a lot of the folk, probably including yourself got left out on that stepladder .. and we likely are not going back down anywhere close to those kind of prices.
And, your waiting strategy and fucking around with holding BTC hoping for more down before up may well end up with similar kinds of results in current prices.
Maybe that works for you, yet I even have my doubts if your waiting strategy has been working for you, and hopefully not too many newbies, or even guys in their first cycle of BTC accumulating are following such a waiting strategy rather than just figuring out ways to ongoingly, persistently and consistently buy within their budget, and maybe after they make it through a whole cycle or cycle and a half, then maybe at that point they can reassess whether they might need to (or want to) adapt their BTC accumulation strategy to incorporate buying on dips (and possible waiting) rather than mostly focusing on ongoing BTC accumulation that does not incorporate waiting strategies that might cause them to end up buying less BTC than what they would have had otherwise.
This is actually once again translating into time in the market > timing the market. I mean sure somebody will always get lucky and then argue that waiting was the superior choice, but then false conclusions could be drawn because that person might think it was smart to wait. Instead it was lucky that it turned out to be successful. As your example describes, those hoping to go down from 26k to maybe 15k only to then see BTC go to 73k probably learned their lesson.
I don't know if they learn their lesson. It is like dumb ideas are embedded in their brains and they cannot stop doing the same thing that does not work. Wind_FURY's a great example of this idea of waiting to buy the dip, and he keeps repeating it, even though he should realize from his October 2023 experience that his waiting to buy the dip did not work out for him very well.. but he still believes it, practices it and spouts it out as if it is a great and broadly applicable idea that works, especially for poor people.
Part of my problem remains his emphasis that poor people need to do something like this, which seems to make even less sense for poor people to use waiting as their investment strategy.
Personally, I think that part of his problem is a kind of mixing up of the meaning of disposable income and mixing up the idea of investing money that you cannot afford to lose. So he is actually investing with money that he needs rather than what he can afford to use, so it is mixing up his cashflow management because he is likely using money that he needs rather than money that is extra.
Surely, I understand that there are poor people around the world who barely have any discretionary income, so it makes it hard for them to invest into bitcoin or into anything else, and truly folks who don't have disposable income should not be investing, yet how else are they going to get ahead? They have to figure out ways to increase their income and/or to cut their expenses.. .. which truly if they are used to living hand to mouth and never having any savings or investment at all, if they end up being able to invest $520 ($10 per week) into bitcoin for a year, and then all of a sudden it goes up 2x or 3x, they won't be able to resist except to tap into that money, which might make it nearly impossible for them to ever get ahead if they cannot both invest into bitcoin and to let their investment ride for 4-10 years or longer.
Another question is if someone has a weekly budget (DCA), but instead decides to wait for some mysterious reason that BTC could go down further, will that person be disciplined and put the budget aside to accumulate a potential lump sum for a later entry point? Will the weekly budget during the waiting period be consumed for other, irrelevant stuff?
I agree that is another problem with letting the cash build up, and maybe even worse for someone who hardly has any bitcoin. On the other hand, if such person already has a decent stash of bitcoin, then maybe it is not as BIG of a problem to let the cash build up, even if they end up using the cash on something else.. .. but yeah, if their real goal is to be building up their BTC stash, they might not realize how much disadvantaged they are becoming by not making the commitment to just buy BTC regularly rather than letting the fiat stash build up and run risks of getting tempted into using such cash for some other non-bitcoin purpose..
That's why time in the market could outcompete timing the market even at seemingly unfavorable prices. If someone says they invest $100 per week only if BTC goes below 40k and they don't invest for 10 weeks because it took until then for BTC to go below 40k, then the question is whether the money is still there that was supposed to be invested into BTC via a DCA method. If instead that person bought $100 BTC all the time and it went sideways, but now goes to 65k, it is still a gain of a little less than 20%.
Yep. it is true that the DCA buyer is quite likely going to end up with a higher average cost per BTC as compared with the successful buyer of the dip, yet there are some circumstances in which the BTC price does not dip to the levels of the intended buy, so then that person who is waiting gets stuck in a trap of waiting and waiting and if the BTC price goes up, there could be questions regarding if it might become more practical to raise the waiting level BTC price to that such buying on the dip becomes more likely to fill. So frequently the buying on the dip becomes way too tentative and way too whimpy, and not really reinforcing buying practices that will also contribute towards more enthusiasm and interest in studying and learning about bitcoin rather than passively waiting and not doing anything for potentially weeks, months and very extended periods of time that might even result in psychological blockages in regards to the value of holding bitcoin that might even contribute to feelings of prematurely selling rather than ongoingly buying to reinforce beliefs in bitcoin.
Sure, the ongoing buyer may likely run into another problem which is running out of money when the BTC price is dipping, so there could be some value for the ongoing buyer to hold some value aside for buying on dips so that he does not feel as bad when the BTC price drops and he might not have any money remaining to be able to buy more.
I am a strong believer of the "time in the market" approach. And this perfectly goes hand in hand with DCA. The only question someone has to answer for themselves is whether they believe in the technology and its long term potential or not. All the number crunching as to how much the return would be if instead of 55k someone enters at 40k is a waste of time. Again, the August 2023 - March 2024 example is only one of many.
Yep. They happen quite frequently in bitcoin, and we might not know when they are going to happen or how to exactly to prepare for them, yet when they happen, the best place to be is "in" rather than "out." It is like the example of BTC price moves to the upside happen about 10 or so days each year, and if you are not into bitcoin on those 10 days (that are not known in advance) then you lose most of your gains for the year. In other words, you gotta be in it to win it, and also you should always make sure that you are prepared for up, even if you might choose to sell some or to fail to buy or to wait, you should also consider that whatever decision that you make that is taking away from your preparation from up, nonetheless, are you still sufficiently/adequately prepared for up at all times, just in case? Each of us are responsible to answer that question for ourselves, and if we fuck up, then no one is going to rescue us. We are responsible for our own actions that include our failures/refusals to act.
So far, time in the market + DCA held true. Of course you could always zoom in on a time window and see that it did not work out, but that's kind of manipulative to your own detriment. Truth is that BTC with its up and downs performed extraordinarily well. And after all, even if BTC does not go to the moon within a year or two and someone is accumulating all the time, there is is still valuable BTC in the wallet.
Yep. time in the market tends to be much better than timing the market, and so whenever we are making our DCA buys while we are accumulating BTC, we buy BTC with the belief that it is good to get in and to get more BTC. Personally, I think that there can be some times in which it takes a while for the BTC price to work itself out, and so there could be extended periods of time in which our portfolio holdings are in the negative, yet I have my doubts that there are many folks who are in the negative after a few years of ongoing DCA. Yeah, sure the more problematic portfolios would have been the ones who made decently large BTC purchases towards the top of the BTC price range, and then his subsequent DCAs at lower prices were not enough to overcome the earlier lump sum buys at higher prices, so there surely can be some BTC portfolios that might take a while to get back into profits, even after several years of ongoing BTC buying.
Most of us also recognize and appreciate that there are no guarantees in BTC that it will end up being profitable, so we likely consider bitcoin as an asymmetric bet to the upside in which the most that we can lose is 100%, so in that regard, we should be choosing our BTC investment size in accordance with our weighing of these various considerations as well as considering our other
8-9 personal factors.