Topic: Germany League - Bundesliga Prediction Thread - page 172. (Read 636238 times)

Basically, Kompany has succeeded when he became head coach of Burnley, but when Burnley played in the second division of the Premier League or called championship. Because at that time Kompany managed to make Burnley a Premier League promotion team but unfortunately, when playing in the Premier League in fact Kompany actually failed to make Burnley get good results. Because anyway, at the end of the season that Burnley was relegated again.

With these results, then I personally will still doubt Kompany, although at Bayern Munich of course have better finances and squad compared to mediocre teams like Burnley. But, because Kompany failed to make Burnley survive in the Premier League then I would really doubt Kompany at Bayern Munich. Because after all, to make Burnley not relegated too it has been a difficult job for Kompany, even more so to make Bayern Munich get a trophy amid difficult competition in the Bundesliga. Therefore, I personally include people who really doubt Kompany's ability, because I think Kompany is still not good enough for more difficult competition in the team that plays in the top division.

Most people may still doubt Vincent Kompany because they haven't seen his achievements as a coach so far, but again, if we look at the achievements of other great coaches, of course at the start of their careers, the same thing is always doubted, so it's natural and won't stop him. Vincent Kompany's move is also because he will not continue his current job, namely making Munich dominate the Bundesliga again in the new season, at least this achievement is more than enough and he doesn't have to push to reach the UCL final next season, let alone win the UCL trophy.

Shopping for the players that Kompany wants must also get financial support so that there are no obstacles whatsoever and at least this can enable this team to achieve the desired target next season. I don't know what agreement was reached by Vincent Kompany and Munich management whether it must achieve important targets. like the UCL it seems that it will take time and will definitely be difficult, it is not that easy for Vincent Kompany to adapt to the players who are still in the main squad at the moment, let alone the new players who will be recruited, one season is not enough.

Bayern Munich is the top of the line. They're tough on newbies. No "cute" relegation escape artist tactics. They want massive wins. Kompany performed well with Burnley, but this is Bayern Munich, not a scrappy underdog. Hes into the majors.

Bayern always has options. A few coaches declined? So what? This is Bayern Munich! Like a supermodel being rejected for a date, there's always another guy. This seems like a desperate gamble on a manager whose claim to fame is not failing. It could work, who knows? However, this appears risk and uncertain. Kompany maybe the winner, but Im not holding my breath.

My take is that, when you take a look at the previous coach Thomas Tuchel and who's lined up to replace him, you'll see that it doesn't make sense up in the head. Also, if we're to judge him ( Vincent Kompany ) from what his side did last season in the Premier League Competition, I'd say no, but he had a good time with Burnley in the Championship as they went ahead to tittle that season. After that season, most of his core players also left for other clubs who won trophies this season. Adli in Bayern Leverkusen has got to be one of these names who moved.

In my head, I feel like Pep Guardiola has a hand in this one way or the other because he also thinks, Vincent Kompany can one day be a great manager for Manchester City in the Premier League Competition.

Also, I always talk to myself and ask if he is tactically better than Xabi Alonso, can he successfully snatch the Bundesliga League Competition from Bayern Leverkusen next season? I'm already tipping them to defend it again successfully.


Stuggart being consistent is something honestly don't see happening. I'm not being certain but there's a long way to go this season. They have already sold out the name Serhou Guirassy to Borrussia Dortmund completely this week. He was the highest goalscorer for them last season, I wonder how they'd be coping without him in his absence.

Bayern Munich are not making these signatures all because of Vincent Kompany, they're making these signatures because of long term plans and purposes. The move for Michael Olise has to be one smart one for the future. Solid Competition for Leroy Sane m

Maybe there is a philosophy that makes many new coaches refuse to manage Bayern Munich. This is certainly a big target for management for Bayern Munich every season so it is not quite possible that many coaches refuse to become head managers. Maybe on the one hand Kompaney is trapped in an agreement that makes he was unable to bring Bayern Munich to compete in the Domestic League, of course this is a season of decline for Bayern Munich, it doesn't matter anything about the players that Bayern Munich has, they are also considered mediocre and none of them are even able to play a role even though they have good attackers.

Bringing in Harry Kane is something that in my opinion does not have any impact on the club, even though they always have difficulties in the Domestic League and Champions League, so looking for a good coach is the right step for Bayern Munich because Kompaney is not very suitable in formulating the current squad at Bayern Munich. This.

I think people don't consider this a mistake but a dubious condition because Kompany has not had any notable achievements as a coach so the doubts are clearly greater than the confidence he has and this is a fairness because after all a new coach is doubtful is a fairness for a big club that has an extraordinary history and of course this is a challenge for the coach to prove that he deserves to be at a big club including for Kompany who is at Bayern at this time.

We can't blame something that we haven't even seen what the results will be like but for doubt it is normal because with what Bayern have so far and with Kompany's minimal experience, it is natural that there will be a lot of skewed views on Bayern's decision.

As long as any team can have the strength to boost their desired performance, they will do whatever they want and here Bayern Munich is very right to bring in Joao Palhinha. However, he is an ideal midfielder who is currently what Bayern Munich needs. If Joao Palhinha still stays at Fulham then it will bury his potential and Bayern Munich will see his potential before another team takes him.

Breaking Leverkusen's record seems quite impossible, especially since the only coach is Vincent Kompany, so it seems like it's still too soon to talk about records with Bayern Munich's initial plans. For Stuttgart, it is natural for them to do that because basically they are not a big club and they still need additional funds for club operations so selling players is one of the solutions they have. The competition will remain interesting as long as the Bundesliga teams do not give in to each other and that is a point they must maintain next season.

We would never know if it's a mistake or not, the season will tell and it he's giving time, the season after that. What we do know is that it's an unusual decision. Bayern don't offen hire legend managers but at least they go for people that have done well in top level football. Kompany hasn't done that and only time will tell.
He has the right ideas, because he tried it with Burnley but we also do not know if he'll be able to execute it with better players at Bayern Munich.

I don't believe Bayern did not have any other choice. A couple of coaches rejected them, but that doesn't mean they didn't have a job. If they wanted they could have kept looking for a manger that would take the job if they didn't want to go with Kompany. A club like Bayern Munich won't hire a manger like Kompany just because they don't have a choice.
And also, those other managers rejected probably because of a clause in the contract.

Bayern Munich management certainly had strong reasons when appointing Vincent Kompany as their team's new coach, regardless of Vincent Kompany failures in the previous team, perhaps there is a similarity in the mission and vision for the game or tactics of Vincent Kompany which is considered suitable for the Bayern Munich team by management, we don't know that but what is certain is that Bayern management has been building this team quite seriously so far so it is appropriate for us to continue to believe in the process they have gone through to make the team even better.

Regarding the many people who doubt Vincent Kompany, I think that's normal.
And I am personally quite optimistic that Vincent Kompany will be successful next season, now Bayern management is fully supporting him for the players he wants, that is a positive thing.

I don't doubt the quality of the Munich midfielder, but the management move to bring in João Palhinha adds to the Munich midfield options. Kompany was building the Munich army to fit the character he wanted. Of course, Kompany is expected to break Xabi's record streak with Leverkusen. In addition, I am actually interested in Stuttgart. They also made a surprise this season. There are a lot of good players who could probably leave. But I hope the Bundesliga remains in the competition of many clubs who will make the match more interesting.

There are many good coaches who would take the job of Bayern coaches. The mistake started with the dismissal of Julian Nagelsmann who was doing a good job and was fired in a humiliating way, then they made another mistake by firing Thomas Tuchel who led to Bayern winning the Bundesliga and now they are hiring a coach who had a great performance in the premier league. It doesn't matter if he was with a small team or not, it's a fact that he performed poorly in the premier league. So Bayern's management is saying that a coach who performed poorly in the Premier League is better than these two great coaches who were fired, which is completely absurd, Tuchel knows the German league well, but Kompany doesn't know anything about the league German, he didn't win big titles, he didn't coach any big team. I honestly see Leverkusen winning the Bundesliga again


The management of the Stuttgart club are not fighting for the title, they are fighting to stay in the Bundesliga and whenever they have any chance of making a profit by selling players, they sell. they are the same as dortmund and other teams in the bundesliga, it seems that in the bundesliga they have already placed bayern as the fixed winner, and the rest of the teams are playing to stay in the bundesliga and sell players, leverkusen was lucky to find a good coach and the management decided to change the way of thinking that they should only play for permanence and sale of players and not fight for the title.


In my opinion we will see a disaster for Bayern next season. they have already hired the João Palhinha


source: https://x.com/FabrizioRomano/status/1810951341105168430

Maybe with this signing Bayern's new coach wants to improve the attack. the balls need to reach the attackers. Bayern has problems in defense too

What do you mean Bayern had no other choice? This is not the right opinion, there is always another choice, they just rushed at that moment, because it seemed that there were no good coaches available and they needed to have time to choose from what was available right now. But if you look at those coaches who are currently without a team, there are quite a lot of them, which means that Kompany’s choice was deliberate and there was no rush. His appointment attracted so much attention because this is a big team, I want to believe that he will succeed.

Many people think Bayern Munich made a mistake when they hired Kompaney in this team because he is not experienced and he cannot be a good coach in Bayern Munich based on the last performance we saw from this coach but the fact about Bayern Munich and Kompaney is we still didn't see anything from this coach and there is the chance for him to have a good performance there in Bayern Munich. On the other hand, Bayern Munich had no other choice than Kompany because many other coaches rejected an offer from Bayern Munich.

I don't remember the other options back then honestly. But maybe bringing back Joachim Löw?  

He won a World Cup with Germany in 2014 you know. I liked his system those times. I think the same system would fit the current dynamism of the team.


I didn't actually mean the quality of his services there, you got me wrong my friend.  

The thing I meant was that it would be better for Nagelsmann's career development if he continued managing a club rather than national team. Because he is going to play games much less in number compared to managing a club. I don't think this is a good thing for a young manager.

Their decision was definitely unexpected, perhaps they hope that Kompany is capable of the same miracle as Alonso did at Bayer, but there is a big difference between them, because Alonso played in the Bundesliga for a long time and knows very well how everything works here, but for Kompany this is new championship. Actually, the hopes of the Bayern management are built only on expectations, they simply decided to trust the young coach, and perhaps the opinion of Guardiola, but does such a team have the right to leave room for doubt when it comes to appointing a head coach?

Experience is one of the major factor that should be considered in every dimension, even in things outside soccer people always values experience perhaps that's actually the reasons why clubs normally go for the coaches that has a lot of coaching experience so that he will use the experience he has gotten to make the club more better perhaps that is why we have so many coaches but few are the most valued coach do to the  fact that they have a lot of experience and things to offer than every others, though we cannot totally dispute the fact that most coaches that doesn't have experience are not good because there are some coaches that started with a less knowledge about coaching but as time goes by they started growing and became better.

Sure this is also applicable with players because the more they are actually playing for different teams that is how there experiences is growing and learning new things, however even Ronaldo for instance became the best because of experience, I could remember when he started playing with Manchester United and by then his performance was good but not actually good enough but the moment he joined other teams his experience started growing and from there he became unstoppable.

Not so, recruiting a coach who does not have much experience and achievements is a big gamble made by Byern Munich management.
This is not meant to belittle Vincent Kompany, but let's just look at it realistically, he just failed in the Premier League with Burnley, so it's natural that there are now many doubts about Vincent Kompany.

Bayern management certainly looks at it from a different perspective on their decision to recruit Vincent Kompany and anything is still possible now and I see it as a balanced percentage between being able to rise or getting worse.

Believe me, the current Munich decision is the wisest choice than forcing a professional coach that's hard to get. And for now we're not something we don't know why the management of Munich chose the Kompany but I believe there's something we do not know behind this all.
The giant bundesliga team today has some very professional players and it's just about time to wait for the Kompany to prove if he can bring the team to compete with the other top board teams. But to regain the dominance of the Bundesliga title as it used to be, it seems the Kompany will take longer.

That's true, but Bayern Munich's management seems to have made an ambiguous decision that will have a negative impact on the team's performance in competing at the top of the standings. Usually Bayern Munich always makes decisions that might make sense, as Tezic also has quite a lot of experience in the Bundesliga. But what is clear is that we have not seen the results that the Bavarians have obtained with Kompany and maybe time will tell. I also really respect Kompany but I am very pessimistic that he will be able to bring Bayern Munich back to control of the Bundesliga.

In my opinion, the risk is not as big as coaching a big club because coaching a mid-table club will not place too high demands on him, he will proceed slowly, just like Xabi Alonso who coached Leverkusen.
As we know, Leverkusen has never won the Bundesliga title but thanks to his skill he was able to make his club appear impressive and break the dominance of Bayern Munich and ultimately made his coaching career successful and many people sought his signature.
It doesn't matter that even if he reaches the level of Bayern Munich his digital footprint will never disappear or if he has the prestige of coaching a mid-table club he could become a coach of a big club from another league but yes, it doesn't seem like that at the moment because he is now more comfortable coaching a national club.