I think the LN is going to evolve in a way MUCH like the internet. Is the internet centralized or not?
Yes.
The internet is centralized: Yes.
Is the internet centralized by design: No.
Of course, centralization has a lot of nice features: it's damn easy and convenient.
Of course that is at a cost: privacy and freedom.
In case of centralized actors turn evil, can the users show the middle finger and turn away? Yes.
Lightning network is similar, not all systems are built this way. The banking system is centralized (every dollar exchanged in the world has to go through the NY FED), and you cannot basically escape from it.
This is a relevant feature.
Exactly. My thoughts with the quoted post are just that the centralization of the internet is kind of up to the user. Thre are arguably fundamental points of centralization such as TLDs, but even then TOR and i2p solve these issues (at least somewhat).
So, you can use the internet in a VERY decentralized way, like using fedarated social media servers (mastadon), and TOR and VPNs etc... Or you can just plug straight into Google.
And for some things I want the latter.
It will be the same for lightning. There will be ways to use it in a centralized way and ways not to.
I will tell you this... I have thought about taking my family on the holy trip of the Bitcoiner to El Zonte in ES for a vacation. If I do I will be taking at least two lighting wallets. I will try to primarily use my own node (with Zeus), but I would also load up my Wallet of Satoshi to have as a standby. in case something went screwy with my node.
That is a perfect example on the simplest level of using decentralization and centralization to my advantage.