Author

Topic: [NEM] NEM -New Economy Movement - No Envy Movement - Updates+Discussion thread - page 447. (Read 661525 times)

sr. member
Activity: 258
Merit: 250
DRAMA: Dumb Retards Asking More Attention

Could there be a small "lucky" part where a part of the transaction fee goes into a pot and once in a while the pot is given to some random wallet?

I suggested something like this for NXT but it was ignored.  It kind of like a bonus lottery...


I would like to implement such that block forgers cannot include their own transactions for free; where if they want to send transactions in a block they forge, then they perform the following:

1) determine the lowest fee paid for a transaction in the previous block generated.  Trasactions belonging the block forger that he wants to include in the block must have at lease this fee assigned, or higher if selected.

2) use a defined algorithm (TBD) to select an account out of the previous 10 blocks that paid fees for transactions.  multiple transactions with 1 account doesnt give you multiple chances, so if you had just 1 transaction you have equal chance of being selected as someone with 1000

3) the block forger takes the number of transaction of his own that he wants to include in the block and then multiplies by the figure obtained in #1 (or a higher fee than that if he desires, but at least that amount), and includes a transaction sending that amount of NXT to the account selected in #2.  all his own transactions in this block must set the fee to value obtained in #1 (or higher if desired), as those will be returned to him if he does indeed forge that block.  So as long as the math works out between these steps, the network will validate the block he forges.

4) if your own account is selected to send the fees to then the algorithm chooses a different account.  This is to reduce the chance that exchanges with their high volume get their own free fees

This structure effictively removes fee forging and makes a cool/fun little bonus lottery that encourages people to use transactions since then they become eligible for the lottery.

I had to analyse this a little but looks like a very nice system indeed !
sr. member
Activity: 258
Merit: 250
DRAMA: Dumb Retards Asking More Attention

Imho it'd be better to keep the systems as is regarding distribution of coins i.e. finite number and fees. An infinite number of coins will create inflation like crazy and people probably won't buy into it in the first place.
Obviously we then need the fees to reward people for forging.

POS/PON in general i think are great ideas. I think it'll be important to find the right balance between POS and PON. E.g. how long will it take me to forge a block with little or no NEM but a node that is running 24/7 ?
I think this could also eliminate the complaints from people that the rich get ritcher with the current Nxt - POS implementation.

Just to through out numbers to start a discussion - I think 40 % POS / 60 % PON could be fair. I think this would reflect that you're helping NEM more by running a node than hoarding your coins.

Thoughts ?

I agree with you therefore i have written that the concept should be partially adapted
as the number of coins in NEM is finite. Part of the forging fee should go to nodes that are securing the netowrk using PON.
The best POS / PON ratio yet shuld be found.

+1 to your advice 40 % POS / 60 % PON or something in that range to avoid hoarding.

+1 for a POS/PON combination, however the distribution between them is a difficult decision.
I have been thinking alot about the forging but personally I can't make up my mind about my opinion.
The more POS , the more people will want to hold on to their share which in its turn will provide stability and better market price. (ref stability NXT!)
On the other hand, we need to make it attractive for everyone in order to easily attract new people.

Obviously the PON is also a good idea to make the network stable and to make a statement about equality...

Hmm , difficult Smiley

full member
Activity: 238
Merit: 100

Could there be a small "lucky" part where a part of the transaction fee goes into a pot and once in a while the pot is given to some random wallet?

I suggested something like this for NXT but it was ignored.  It kind of like a bonus lottery...


I would like to implement such that block forgers cannot include their own transactions for free; where if they want to send transactions in a block they forge, then they perform the following:

1) determine the lowest fee paid for a transaction in the previous block generated.  Trasactions belonging the block forger that he wants to include in the block must have at lease this fee assigned, or higher if selected.

2) use a defined algorithm (TBD) to select an account out of the previous 10 blocks that paid fees for transactions.  multiple transactions with 1 account doesnt give you multiple chances, so if you had just 1 transaction you have equal chance of being selected as someone with 1000

3) the block forger takes the number of transaction of his own that he wants to include in the block and then multiplies by the figure obtained in #1 (or a higher fee than that if he desires, but at least that amount), and includes a transaction sending that amount of NXT to the account selected in #2.  all his own transactions in this block must set the fee to value obtained in #1 (or higher if desired), as those will be returned to him if he does indeed forge that block.  So as long as the math works out between these steps, the network will validate the block he forges.

4) if your own account is selected to send the fees to then the algorithm chooses a different account.  This is to reduce the chance that exchanges with their high volume get their own free fees

This structure effictively removes fee forging and makes a cool/fun little bonus lottery that encourages people to use transactions since then they become eligible for the lottery.
sr. member
Activity: 602
Merit: 268
Internet of Value
Quote
We have a no reserve rule to combat fraudsters.

I am not trying to make a reserve spot, I want to invest the NXT now before it goes up.  I just want to make sure it's ok with you that I am using this account to invest the NXT on behalf of someone else.

sorry we stick by 1 account/ 1 share.

So by what I understand: Make NXT account for friend > send NXT there > make another bitcointalk account > invest NXT and post on new account.

I am not trying to be a "fraudster".   I am invested in NXT already and am running 2 nodes for NXT.  I am spreading word about NEM but most of the people I know are not very cryptocurrency knowledgeable but are very interested in crypto since I've been mentioning it to them.
I like the idea of fair, that's how I run my life in real world.  I am a very balanced and fair person.
I have an account in nextcoin.org under LemonAndFries where I make most of my posts if you'd like to check.

Yes that should be the way because your friend represents the new account. So make a new account for him and reserve a stake. you can send NXT from the same address as well (maximum 2 stake per address).

1 NEM share would have > 1 million NEM. So there are many to share. No need to buy a lot of stakes. Thanks for supporting NEM.

sr. member
Activity: 602
Merit: 268
Internet of Value
The new stake complain thread is here https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/nem-nem-stake-complaint-questions-etc-450200.

I will be manning that thread and answering questions. Any stake question should be directed there to keep this thread on update/ development related.

Thanks

UP
hero member
Activity: 834
Merit: 524
Nxt NEM
....

My name has also disappered from the stake holder list
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AlidWok7hW0DdDZ0amZpM00wQXhrR2lJM3pCOGRhNFE#gid=1

It has been there many days,
since 1 - 2 days after these:

Sent 250 NXT
TX : ...


Edit:  ...     11152111273892066130



http://87.230.14.1/nxt/nxt.cgi?action=2000&tra=11152111273892066130

And where it was came from:
7773992198041886861

Thanks



What has happened?
hero member
Activity: 980
Merit: 1001
Should we maybe have a thread dedicated to problems and complaints about stake registration ?
I feel like important and interesting discussion in this thread drown in questions regading stakes and stuff.

Just a suggestion.
newbie
Activity: 52
Merit: 0
Quote
We have a no reserve rule to combat fraudsters.

I am not trying to make a reserve spot, I want to invest the NXT now before it goes up.  I just want to make sure it's ok with you that I am using this account to invest the NXT on behalf of someone else.

sorry we stick by 1 account/ 1 share.

So by what I understand: Make NXT account for friend > send NXT there > make another bitcointalk account > invest NXT and post on new account.

I am not trying to be a "fraudster".   I am invested in NXT already and am running 2 nodes for NXT.  I am spreading word about NEM but most of the people I know are not very cryptocurrency knowledgeable but are very interested in crypto since I've been mentioning it to them.
I like the idea of fair, that's how I run my life in real world.  I am a very balanced and fair person.
I have an account in nextcoin.org under LemonAndFries where I make most of my posts if you'd like to check.
sr. member
Activity: 729
Merit: 251
ok here it is:

Quote
Deleted Post
« Sent to: therealbigcoin on: February 04, 2014, 01:05:52 PM »
   Reply with quoteReply with quote Remove this messageDelete
A reply of yours, quoted below, was deleted by the starter of a self-moderated topic. There are no rules of self-moderation, so this deletion cannot be appealed. Do not continue posting in this topic if the topic-starter has requested that you leave.

You can create a new topic if you are unsatisfied with this one. If the topic-starter is scamming, post about it in Scam Accusations.

Quote
I like Utopia, hope you dont use this Name for a scam (you already got min 20 btc hope your not loving to get it over the mountains ^^)

Anyway im in and that 40 $ Investment is done Wink

Proof: e6d25587911ed4f6f6e8aacbe81a2dffe7f4c417e4b8877ecd7cdab528f1e4d6

So how does this go on? Do i receive some coins soon , or do i now hold shares of your Project?

Greetings
Report To Admin
sr. member
Activity: 602
Merit: 268
Internet of Value
I cant find me in the stakeholder list but paid 0.05 BTC whats wrong?

Where is your post?

my post got deleted:

Quote
I like Utopia, hope you dont use this Name for a scam (you already got min 20 btc hope your not loving to get it over the mountains ^^)

Anyway im in and that 40 $ Investment is done Wink

Proof: e6d25587911ed4f6f6e8aacbe81a2dffe7f4c417e4b8877ecd7cdab528f1e4d6

So how does this go on? Do i receive some coins soon , or do i now hold shares of your Project?

Greetings

I don't think I ever delete any veteran account's contribution.

So why do bitcointalk send me this "deleted" message?
I dont understand ^^

Greetings

Can you post the whole message here. I will check the hash against my record.
sr. member
Activity: 729
Merit: 251
I cant find me in the stakeholder list but paid 0.05 BTC whats wrong?

Where is your post?

my post got deleted:

Quote
I like Utopia, hope you dont use this Name for a scam (you already got min 20 btc hope your not loving to get it over the mountains ^^)

Anyway im in and that 40 $ Investment is done Wink

Proof: e6d25587911ed4f6f6e8aacbe81a2dffe7f4c417e4b8877ecd7cdab528f1e4d6

So how does this go on? Do i receive some coins soon , or do i now hold shares of your Project?

Greetings

I don't think I ever delete any veteran account's contribution.

So why do bitcointalk send me this "deleted" message?
I dont understand ^^

Greetings
sr. member
Activity: 602
Merit: 268
Internet of Value
Quote
We have a no reserve rule to combat fraudsters.

I am not trying to make a reserve spot, I want to invest the NXT now before it goes up.  I just want to make sure it's ok with you that I am using this account to invest the NXT on behalf of someone else.

sorry we stick by 1 account/ 1 share.
full member
Activity: 238
Merit: 100
+1
Please make addresses with some sort of error correction built in.

When I read what you guys are planing and saying I truly believe there is extremely bright future for NEM. I'm translating and hoping to join the community as a stake holder soon. I don't have money but I hope translating will suffice to enter.

Question: How come price of NXT is so stable?
I see that Vertcoin went up significantly in the past few days and what it brings to the table is not comparable at all what nxt has now.

Vertcoin jumped because it was added to cryptsy.  imagine what NXT will do when it gets added to cryptsy.
newbie
Activity: 52
Merit: 0
Quote
We have a no reserve rule to combat fraudsters.

I am not trying to make a reserve spot, I want to invest the NXT now before it goes up.  I just want to make sure it's ok with you that I am using this account to invest the NXT on behalf of someone else.
sr. member
Activity: 602
Merit: 268
Internet of Value
I cant find me in the stakeholder list but paid 0.05 BTC whats wrong?

Where is your post?

my post got deleted:

Quote
I like Utopia, hope you dont use this Name for a scam (you already got min 20 btc hope your not loving to get it over the mountains ^^)

Anyway im in and that 40 $ Investment is done Wink

Proof: e6d25587911ed4f6f6e8aacbe81a2dffe7f4c417e4b8877ecd7cdab528f1e4d6

So how does this go on? Do i receive some coins soon , or do i now hold shares of your Project?

Greetings

I don't think I ever delete any veteran account's contribution.
sr. member
Activity: 729
Merit: 251
I cant find me in the stakeholder list but paid 0.05 BTC whats wrong?

Where is your post?

my post got deleted:

Quote
I like Utopia, hope you dont use this Name for a scam (you already got min 20 btc hope your not loving to get it over the mountains ^^)

Anyway im in and that 40 $ Investment is done Wink

Proof: e6d25587911ed4f6f6e8aacbe81a2dffe7f4c417e4b8877ecd7cdab528f1e4d6

So how does this go on? Do i receive some coins soon , or do i now hold shares of your Project?

Greetings
sr. member
Activity: 602
Merit: 268
Internet of Value
update: our doge subreddit ad has come online for a while Smiley

Here is a few statistics

date                   impressions   clicks   click-through (%)   
2014-02-05 00:00 -0500   32   0   0   
2014-02-05 01:00 -0500   1,042   23   2.207   
2014-02-05 02:00 -0500   3,541   59   1.666   
2014-02-05 03:00 -0500   711   10   1.406   
2014-02-05 04:00 -0500   573   13   2.269   
2014-02-05 05:00 -0500   715   10   1.399   
2014-02-05 06:00 -0500   1,345   34   2.528   
TOTAL *              7,959   149   1.872%


and comments


SUCH FUN Smiley make some noises but be polite  Smiley we want more dog-er with us Smiley

I view it live now http://www.reddit.com/r/dogecoin/?ad=t3_1wq6wj

I think you're unlikely to get any positive responses on the Dogecoin subreddit, if I'm brutally honest. With luck people will click on the link and find out what NEM is about for themselves rather than reading the 'criticisms' in the comments section.

It is more like spreading awareness campaign. It doesn't matter to me if we get a lot of negative comments because we will still be in the front row Smiley  Click-though rate is at 1.87%. that's good enough for now. If you think it is fun then make a comment because there is a strong miner's attitude there. It would be just a nice conversation not a shouting war.
sr. member
Activity: 478
Merit: 250
Maybe you should give the option to buy in with dogecoin now that reddit ads are live.
sr. member
Activity: 602
Merit: 268
Internet of Value
@utopianfuture : So I think I read somewhere you went up to page 20 to list investors yet I am not listed.
I am on page 13:
Quote
sent 400 NXT
transaction 4102152512080007945

Also, I have another person that might be interested but I won't get to discuss NEM with that person until tomorrow, I was wondering if I could reserve and invest on that person's behalf since they are not active on this forum but would still like to become an investor.

We have a no reserve rule to combat fraudsters.
newbie
Activity: 52
Merit: 0
@utopianfuture : So I think I read somewhere you went up to page 20 to list investors yet I am not listed.
I am on page 13:
Quote
sent 400 NXT
transaction 4102152512080007945

Also, I have another person that might be interested but I won't get to discuss NEM with that person until tomorrow, I was wondering if I could reserve and invest on that person's behalf since they are not active on this forum but would still like to become an investor.
Jump to: