Well the "jackpot" would have to be pretty big, much bigger than a typical forging reward, so I would not call it synonymous with forging. However the point on people creating tons of accounts is valid and I hadn't considered that. I didn't say I had the best idea, just pointing out that I do more than "complain", which was the accusation I was responding to.
This is why it is important that NXT is an ecosystem, not simply a currency. The end-goal is not to have the highest price possible, but to have as many services ontop of NXT sending transactions. PoS/TF is ideal for this - PoW is simply too slow to accommodate a large transaction bandwidth. If one day we do in-fact achieve 1000 TPS (of course, a lot of work to get there), that's 60k transactions per block. And each of these transactions have a fee.
Also, Bitcoin mining is only profitable because of the gigantic subsidy. Take a look at this (the latest Bitcoin block):
https://blockchain.info/block-index/382205/000000000000000073a67bd8f462faaa3ea9f18dda19d44976ba718be9d442edThe subsidy is 20,600% larger than the transactions fees in the Bitcoin network. The problem with this subsidy is that Bitcoin holders are paying for it in the form of huge inflation (10% per year currently). And eventually, Bitcoin will have no subsidies, so it will have to be able to function off of fees as well.
However, you might still be able to counter the fragmentation problem by doing something like having a reasonable minimum balance
required for an account to be eligible to win the jackpot. You might also be able to make it so multiple accounts can't forge on a single computer. If they are splitting up forging accounts on multiple computers then that would only be good for the network and
would be a legitimate way to try and increase your odds.
Minimum balance had been discussed also. At what point do you draw the line? 100k? Then "poor NXTers" certainly cannot forge. Who controls this line? Will this line scale with price? (not possible via a decentralized method, by the way) Anyways, no matter where you draw the line, people will make as many accounts as their wallet allows.
A single person with 10000 accounts forging on 10000 computers is just as bad as having all of them on one computer. That one person is still in control of those 10000 nodes, which can all be relaying malicious information to other nodes. This is why hallmarked nodes exist to combat zombie nodes (there was a zombie attack in NXT's early days).
I think if we look back in the history of this thread, we will find this exact discussion somewhere. There should not be a gamable solution implemented into the core. This is why something like nodecoin can built on-top of NXT, so even if it is gamed, NXT-core will remain unaffected. Stake (NXT), which is guaranteed to be non-gamed, should be the basis for all other actions.
Pandaisftw