All is not quite lost, Bakal. [Info From R1 below]
UPDATE: They're forcing USD refunds on people that didn't request them if you missed that in the CH forum yesterday. If this is forced on us, we are *not* cashing this refund check worth about 1/8th of our orig. BTC sent for R1-4, and will consult with our legal team.
It was a major PITA to get all the evidence in place, and in chronological order for our attorneys but HashFast heard from our attorneys yesterday and we have an official support ticket in the system, FWIW. It's also been a drain on the co-op's energy to have to fight this in the middle of the move/expansion.
We're doing our best to get full BTC refunds for everyone that bought into R1-4 with Bitcoin (except for R2, which was orig. bought via Wire Transfer by someone else so it will be in USD; the upgrade R2B was paid in BTC).
To fight to get this full BTC refunds for us and to make sure we were represented by a battle tested legal team, we plan on deducting the legal costs among the 4 rounds. We estimate this cost to be about $250-300 at this time (could go up if we go to arbitration).
That would work out to about $2.50-$3 per R1-4 share (which includes upgrades for R1-2). The upside is: for those that bought GB shares with bitcoin, if we get our full BTC back from HashFast, even with this small deduction for legal expenses you'd be refunded 6-9x your USD value back from your original BTC purchase amount(s) depending on when you bought your GB shares.
If you paid in USD, these refund terms and legal fees don't apply, and we will send back the original USD amount(s) sent when our full refund arrives.
Hi DZ,
I must say I am disappointed in a refund in USD. I paid via eBay/Paypal for 2 shares - and paid for 1 upgrade via BTC. But what I paid for (and paid overprice for vs BTC rate at the time) was DZ services to convert the $165 into 1.55 BTC at the time. The group-buy documents says and I quote "I (DZ) do not intend to make a profit on it - I am doing this as a service". But taking the 6+? shares sold via Paypal and "confiscate" currency gains in the period for own the the rest of the Group Buy's profit - goes against the general line of agreement when it was done. Taking 6 shares x 1.55 BTC = 10 BTC from some GB owners - and distribute to ONE person or the rest of the group - would give those persons a comparable PROFIT on the transaction.
I think to be fair - any refunds should be refunded in the % of what we own of the GB. Not what we initially paid. We have ALL taken the EXACT VALUE same risk for the exact same time. If we get USD back - I'm happy getting refund in USD for my shares on equal footing with other owners even if that means a loss for me. If the GB gets BTC back - everyone has gotten the BTC currency gain - and everyone should be rewarded equally. Anything else would not be fair - and that refund policy would be in line with the language and intent used in the GB.
When we do site orders, we refund in the form that was sent for accounting purposes, whether that was USD or BTC, as that's what's expected in the world of commerce, that you get what you sent. This *is* a special case however. I will take this under advisement with the other co-op leaders because I don't rule this co-op as a dictatorship among the leaders, even though I founded it; we'd have to agree on this. I can't promise anything and we'd need a majority vote for this to carry.
I'll also note a couple of things I mentioned in the R15/16 thread: we've already paid hundreds each out of our own pockets to get a battle tested legal team that's not afraid of HF's lawyer (who seems to in, intimidate people on the CH HF forum thread) to represent us. After half a year of doing this and offering the lowest cost GB shares around: It literally *costs* me money to offer these low cost GB shares to co-op members as the management fees that I've made on 8 rounds in 6 months of co-op operations don't even cover these legal fees I already incurred just for the refunds. I meant what I said about not price gouging my fellow miners when I founded the co-op, and I've purposely had a tiny cut of the management fee to help keep share price and hosting costs as low as possible.
If things fall apart and we go to arbitration those are also some massive upfront costs related to that we haven't tried to fundraise funds for. In this case, we'd probably team up with other forum members to do a mass arbitration action to spread the pain of this expensive proposition.
DZ, thats why buying from companies who have 0 track record is a risky deal.
They came with a too good to be true story, we all fell for it but lets put things into perspective.
At the time of the original offer, we agreed to compensate "you" for the price charged in BTC in your national currency (USD). I will have to agree with kaz911 that we put our faith in you to take our money and exchange it to BTC as you agreed. This is the part of escrow that you handled for a fee.
The product purchased was listed in BTC, we agreed to that price and bought shares. At that time there was no website, no TOS.
Using your logic, I should be refunded BTC for the R2 as thats what I put in as most people did.
You are also a shareholder in both of these GB's so as I see it you have already lost 100's of dollars.
I also agree that legal costs should not be paid out of your pocket nor should it be charged to those wise people who did not invest in HashFast technologies. Using the same reasoning there is no reason for anyone other then the HashFast investor sub-group should profit from any gains we make with a refund.
As co-op members we have the right to determine how our collectively purchased equipment will be managed.
Example, if we had bought and received equipment in October as promised and "I" decided that it would be a good idea to sell our boxes now (Jan 2014) and start mining BBQ coins on my drunk uncles i386 that we could buy with the proceeds, the investor group that invested in the baby jets would probably vote me down.
I doubt that anyone who bought KnC shares would want to be bothered with that vote as they have no dividend from our equipment.
People who did not invest in hashfast equipment have no say, sorry but they do not pay me and I am not interested in there opinion as anything more then advise.
People who did invest in Hashfast equipment and want a refund should join together and have a vote per share. This includes you DZ, myself, philipma1957, firsttimeuser, etc..
If you feel that you should be compensated for the extra work, headache, expense and logistics involved I would agree but we can work that out together.