This project needs more devs and less of the gimmick crap... You all know i'm quite blunt and frank at times. I'll remain consistent and state an observation.
Gimmick is sneaking into this project...again.
The ShadowBay is not viable or feasible in the current state of its team makeup! Just be realistic about what you expect and what you encourage others to expect about that kind of gimmik crap this early. (My message to the community)
The team clearly stated it is looking into ShadowBay as an idea from the mass of the shadow community. But most people here, a week later started to change that story and started saying its happening within a month or so. (making me vomit) Personally i don't see it as something that will be viable nor will it be close to completion this year. Its a gimik that most projects tried to use to justify price increase. It was and has always been driven by communities who think they know what they want and need. And i fear that its a pipedream of most to become a launchpad to "the moon". It is not a launchpad in this case and never will be unless there is sufficient talent, resource and motivation to fund devtime to completion. Besides, the core is not even working consistently across all platforms yet.
Many of you may think we need it now but i argue that its fools errand and that we do not. You will burn out the current team then the project will die.... I will stake my life on that!
Ryno, Techno need and want more devs interested in the tech. Not the gimmick shit most of you want to justify a rise in value.
The focus here should be recruiting dev talent and appealing to them. Leave the gimmick wet fart to xc, xst and the rest of those trash communities please.
The review will be good but not for what most of you think it will be good for.. It should not justify some price rise... It will and should be considered to be ip added to the project. It should be considered as somewhat of a tarmac paved road for devs to understand and be exposed to the tech. This is great tech that not many people in this field know about yet. Professionals want white paper facts, stats and cohesive reports on the tech. They have no time for promises, gimmicks and communities of trader only, influenced decisions. The focus here should be dev talent and exposure not through gimmick but through cold hard stats and facts!
The cold hard truth is; I can easily tell that the devs are burnt out already. The tech is great and the future is possibly extremely bright. However, the project should be put into beta mode so that it is very clear that the wallet is not completely bug free. Which, as you all know, it isnt. There should be a dev entry point and i strongly advise time and effort be focused less on gimmick bullshit and more on crawling before we walk and by that i mean focus more on ryno, techno's support. They need more devs and the tech needs more debate and scrutiny.
There is to much pressure on them to serve the trader and not enough support for them to actually go back and refine what they already have so it actually works.
I'm appalled that the marketplace has taken place of file voice and video support. Kim Dot Com and the rest of the world is going to show you just how important and relevant that stuff is, to both devs and mainstream.
Anyhow..thats my rant. I just encourage you, the community, to go back and rehash this whole marketplace stuff and the expectations you are laying on it.
I and anyone with half a nut can see this projects foundations have not yet been finished. It wont handle any kind of weight and its fast becoming yet another house of cards; doomed to join ranks with the rest of the ditched projects that actually had potential in this space. Because, as you know, its insanity to see the same moves and decisions being made and expecting it to be any different to them.
Yay, L&S is back
You are much missed in this community my friend. Even ryno himself said he misses you and everyone wishes you were more active in the community again. You seem super smart and I'm glad to have you on team Shadow. I really appreciate your criticisms. Its like a sporting team sometimes needs a nice kick in the rear by their coach to get moving.
I agree with much of your post, there is much truth in your words. But I would like to raise some counter points to provide a little balance and more info into the situation. For one, ShadyBay was overwhelmingly voted on as the next project by the devs, from what I read by ryno's posts. It seems like it was an agreed upon decision by the devs. Maybe they did bite off more than they can chew. I would think its a tall task for most dev teams, but I have seen results already in this project, which gives me more confidence in their ability to deliver. Ryno did mention he was finding it harder to get back in the groove of things, and I'm sure the devs are somewhat burnt out. Seems like CRZ for one has been working super hard on the marketplace design. On top of that many bugs have cropped up, which are acting as a bit of a roadblock. I agree its hard to move on, until the foundation is secured. But these delays happen, bugs happen with any new software. Its going to take time, and a lot of traders want it to happen overnight, which is definitely a little annoying. I think we can mostly all agree on these points.
One point I would like to make is that you said we should be focusing on attracting dev talent. I am not too knowledgeable about the entire dev team, but it sort of seems like different devs have different specialties. CRZ for example is doing great work on design. Other devs probably have their own specialties. Tecno is the cryptographer, etc. But I'm guessing possibly if there was no marketplace in the works then some of these devs would have nothing much to work on. They may even leave and find something else to do. So there is something to say for always having work on the table. Also maybe there are some other devs out there that could specialize in the skills needed for the marketplace. Well they will see Shadow already has the ball rolling, and be more likely to join the team than if the project was just shelved. I know that ryno mentioned they did take on at least one new dev recently. I think he said something about having to train them, so I would definitely agree with your point about the review helping to on ramp devs into the project. The further documentation being done on the system as mentioned by ryno, and requested by Isidor will also help in this regard.
Also I would like to make a point against the accusation that ShadowMarket is just a gimmick. I can understand this perspective, especially considering the pump and dumps of other projects with false promises. But this team has already delivered revolutionary tech proving they can deliver, and I think the value of a decentralized market in the wallet is hugely valuable to the Shadow economy. I guess NXT has the only decentralized market right now, but I have never checked it out, so I don't know how usable it is. I'm guessing not very usable as it has not gotten much attention. Open Bazaar also does not seem near ready for primetime. There seems like a real market need for this type of marketplace, and Shadow could be the first mover, with the added advantage of an anonymous token increasing the appeal to marketplace participants. If they can get the I2P going, or the market to work over Tor, and be easy to use, we could see a huge influx of new Shadow users as well as new dev talent.
Well I guess thats all I have to say, I hope I added some valuable perspectives. I am newer to this community, and L&S is a veteran, so much respect given. Hope you will come around and be more active in the Shadow community again, we could really use you here.