With other coins a high orphan rate is typically linked to low difficulty + lots of hash. Blocks are easy to solve at low diff so the race to the finish line from different miners is much closer. Even UTC1 at Tumblingblock with 10% network hash is hitting blocks sometimes seconds apart now. With block intervals like that there is going to be orphans as one pool (or solo miner) beats the other to the finish line in a photo finish.
I don't see how consolidating hash power into less pools has a net positive benefit. It is more healthy to have more pools and solo mining with some orphans than a single dominant pool solving every block (thus no orhpans). You do not want all the hash in one pool. Quark for example has that issue with 90%+ hash at one pool and it used by FUDsters as an attack on the currency daily (regardless if it is an actual concern).
Consolidating all pools is solving one issue that is primarily cosmetic and creating another issue that is real (network centralization).
Thank you for that reasonable response. I agree with pretty much everything you just said, Hilux...
So right now there is one centralized force which is attacking UltraCoin through swings in difficulty. Is there denial here about that?
The way to combat it is to reward those mining UltraCoin consistently. The high fees are a deterrent from using the pool. The orphans are not only punishing the healthy, consistent miners, but they are actually rewarding the attacker. The attacker wins the spoils of the 'race' (30 UTC) while invalidating the work of the miners in the pool.
To be clear, my interest is mainly in YAC. But more than anything else, I need a race to the top and not a race to the bottom. There are only a handful of scrypt-chacha coins left now...