Author

Topic: Wall Observer BTC/USD - Bitcoin price movement tracking & discussion - page 32909. (Read 26620660 times)

full member
Activity: 205
Merit: 100

Price isn't driven by miners, but by traders and commodity speculation as has been amply demonstrated elsewhere.


This.

It's obvious that price is not driven by difficulty, but inflation does have an impact on price - at this stage inflation in BTC its non negligible, and its in fact built into the system to pay for the work and costs of mining during the early days of Bitcoin. Thus, looking at growing difficulty and expecting growing price is a fallacy (in fact its the other way around) - but nevertheless Bitcoin is currently inflating at a 12.5% yearly rate, and what miners do with those newly minted coints has inevitably an impact on price.

I believe that there will be lots of newly minted coins hitting the exchanges in late 2013, will just wait and see.

EDIT: in fewer words, wether miners decide to speculate (holding) or to pay for their fiat costs (selling the coins for good) has inevitably an immediate impact on price.

this is like concentrating on only one of your girlfriends butt cheaks, you know very well what the counter argument is.

Inflation rate of 12.5%, how is that even a point?

That's the fifth year in Bitcoin Survival= even if we assume linear and not exponential spread in bitcoin awareness, that's 20% more people using and storing value in BTC.

-7.5%

I love this bears latching onto a miners value case- they attribute psychological values wherever they please... when the price rose it was because everyone wanted to buy btc to buy asicminers, but asicminer wasn't selling his btc, even though 'asicminer is running it as a business' like they like to say whenever it suits them. suddenly asicminer and all the miners want to sell all their coins and only if the price dips, which is when they panic and drive the price further.

What about last year, when inflation rate was 25%, how come the price went up 1000%... and the year before when it was 40%, why did it go up 1000%? frankly if miners drive price I'm surprised it isn't at -0.1 cent

full member
Activity: 168
Merit: 100
Not much longer now. The 12 hour chart is unbelievably bullish. The bears in the low 100s are going to be massacred.

12 hour chart? massacred? really?

I agree, everything thing I have is screaming upward, that this is only just the beginning.

The short term chart does look like there may be a break out. There is a rising triangle, which is pretty bullish.

I'm still not convinced that the breakout will last, but I've bought a chunk of BTC again and may sell into the breakout, should it occur.

[It is also painful not holding much BTC. Holding so much fiat feels... dirty!]

After seeing how the day has developed, I've sold out again (for about the same price as I bought in!).

It still doesn't look like $100 is going to be breached and sustained (or $95 on Bitstamp).
full member
Activity: 238
Merit: 100
Bitcoin is currently inflating at a 12.5% yearly rate

I'm not sure where you got that figure.

Basic math.

This year (2013) aprox. BTC1,312,500 will be minted, those are being added to the BTC10,500,000 minted until the end of 2012, so at the end of the year you will have around BTC11,812,500

That's a yearly inflation of 12.5%

In 2014 it should be around 11%, in the following years it will decrease until aprox. 9% (2016) until it falls to 4% in 2017 because of the next reward halving.

Yes, surprise, Bitcoin the deflationary currency its in a heavily inflationary phase and it will be for the next decade. Good thing is that the inflation is predictable and immune to third party manipulation.

Gotcha. What you referred to as inflation, I see as increase in supply.

I tend to think of inflation as a function of value, as in how much of a currency is required to buy something.

With fiat currencies, inflation is usually measured by indices covering everything from wages to fuel prices. It takes more USD each year to buy a gallon of gas or hire a laborer for an hour.  Bitcoin is referred to as deflationary because it takes fewer and fewer coins each year to buy something, be it an ASIC miner, an American dollar or shitloads of herbs.

That's a reason to like bitcoin (of course there are some other reasons as well).
legendary
Activity: 1904
Merit: 1002
Bitcoin is currently inflating at a 12.5% yearly rate

I'm not sure where you got that figure.

Basic math.

This year (2013) aprox. BTC1,312,500 will be minted, those are being added to the BTC10,500,000 minted until the end of 2012, so at the end of the year you will have around BTC11,812,500

That's a yearly inflation of 12.5%

In 2014 it should be around 11%, in the following years it will decrease until aprox. 9% (2016) until it falls to 4% in 2017 because of the next reward halving.

Yes, surprise, Bitcoin the deflationary currency its in a heavily inflationary phase and it will be for the next decade. Good thing is that the inflation is predictable and immune to third party manipulation.

Gotcha. What you referred to as inflation, I see as increase in supply.

I tend to think of inflation as a function of value, as in how much of a currency is required to buy something.

With fiat currencies, inflation is usually measured by indices covering everything from wages to fuel prices. It takes more USD each year to buy a gallon of gas or hire a laborer for an hour.  Bitcoin is referred to as deflationary because it takes fewer and fewer coins each year to buy something, be it an ASIC miner, an American dollar or a pound of herbs.

You are talking about price inflation.

Rampion is talking about monetary inflation.

Both are correct uses of the term, and both talked about regarding fiat currencies.

Also, wages have not been keeping pace with food and energy price inflation, so it's hard to back up the claim that the price of labor is inflating.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 1823
1CBuddyxy4FerT3hzMmi1Jz48ESzRw1ZzZ
legendary
Activity: 4200
Merit: 4887
You're never too old to think young.
Bitcoin is currently inflating at a 12.5% yearly rate

I'm not sure where you got that figure.

Basic math.

This year (2013) aprox. BTC1,312,500 will be minted, those are being added to the BTC10,500,000 minted until the end of 2012, so at the end of the year you will have around BTC11,812,500

That's a yearly inflation of 12.5%

In 2014 it should be around 11%, in the following years it will decrease until aprox. 9% (2016) until it falls to 4% in 2017 because of the next reward halving.

Yes, surprise, Bitcoin the deflationary currency its in a heavily inflationary phase and it will be for the next decade. Good thing is that the inflation is predictable and immune to third party manipulation.

Gotcha. What you referred to as inflation, I see as increase in supply.

I tend to think of inflation as a function of value, as in how much of a currency is required to buy something.

With fiat currencies, inflation is usually measured by indices covering everything from wages to fuel prices. It takes more USD each year to buy a gallon of gas or hire a laborer for an hour.  Bitcoin is referred to as deflationary because it takes fewer and fewer coins each year to buy something, be it an ASIC miner, an American dollar or a pound of herbs.
legendary
Activity: 1148
Merit: 1018
Bitcoin is currently inflating at a 12.5% yearly rate

I'm not sure where you got that figure.

Basic math.

This year (2013) aprox. BTC1,312,500 will be minted, those are being added to the BTC10,500,000 minted until the end of 2012, so at the end of the year you will have around BTC11,812,500

That's a yearly inflation of 12.5%

In 2014 it should be around 11%, in the following years it will decrease until aprox. 9% (2016) until it falls to 4% in 2017 because of the next reward halving.

Yes, surprise, Bitcoin the deflationary currency its in a heavily inflationary phase and it will be for the next decade. Good thing is that the inflation is predictable and immune to third party manipulation.
legendary
Activity: 4200
Merit: 4887
You're never too old to think young.
Bitcoin is currently inflating at a 12.5% yearly rate

I'm not sure where you got that figure.

As for the supply of coins, it is fixed and at a virtually steady rate for another 3.5 years.

I'm of the opinion that unless miners are cash-strapped that they'll simply wait for the price to come back up before selling. That's if they're even selling and not simply hoarding as so many seem to do.

Remember that even at today's depressed prices, mining is still profitable. A year ago the block reward was 50BTC with a total value of $250. Today the reward is only 25BTC but the value is close to $2500.

The hardware rules may have changed but the economics are still the same. No, it's not worth buying up GPUs anymore, but if my BFL miner arrived today, it would still pay for itself in 12 days at today's price and difficulty. While that's a lot longer than the 2 days it would have taken in April, it's still pretty good. Even if it takes months longer and difficulty hits 9 digits, it'll still return a 100% profit  every couple of months at today's price. When the price bounces back up, the return will be even better, at least until the next reward halving. By then, who knows what the price will be?
legendary
Activity: 1372
Merit: 1000
Why do you keep saying XBT when almost everyone uses BTC?
lol, I'm an early adopter & an optimist. www.xe.com my go to for international convections uses that identifier.  

Yeah, honestly, I think it's pretty clear which one is used the most,

USD seems to be more popular the Bitcoin, but that isn't a valid reason to use it.
donator
Activity: 2772
Merit: 1019
Why do you keep saying XBT when almost everyone uses BTC?

XBT, BTC, Ƀ, these are all the same thing and you should understand them. The one that gets used most, will win in every day life. Some argue that XBT will win as the rule for non-governmental money is X… like in XAG and XAU.
My fav is Ƀ as it's easily typed once you know the code ctrl-u + 243. BTC is good, too. XBT it will be if the others insist in it. Just be easy with whatever and please don't insist in your choice being the best. Time will tell.

"mbit" will win Wink
legendary
Activity: 896
Merit: 1000
Why do you keep saying XBT when almost everyone uses BTC?

XBT, BTC, Ƀ, these are all the same thing and you should understand them. The one that gets used most, will win in every day life.

Yeah, honestly, I think it's pretty clear which one is used the most, so having all kinds of alternatives only helps to confuse newcomers.
And bitcoin is confusing enough already if you are new to it...

To be honest, I thought XBT was Ripple until now  Embarrassed
legendary
Activity: 1638
Merit: 1001
₪``Campaign Manager´´₪
Why do you keep saying XBT when almost everyone uses BTC?

XBT, BTC, Ƀ, these are all the same thing and you should understand them. The one that gets used most, will win in every day life.

Yeah, honestly, I think it's pretty clear which one is used the most, so having all kinds of alternatives only helps to confuse newcomers.
And bitcoin is confusing enough already if you are new to it...
legendary
Activity: 1148
Merit: 1018

Price isn't driven by miners, but by traders and commodity speculation as has been amply demonstrated elsewhere.


This.

It's obvious that price is not driven by difficulty, but inflation does have an impact on price - at this stage inflation in BTC its non negligible, and its in fact built into the system to pay for the work and costs of mining during the early days of Bitcoin. Thus, looking at growing difficulty and expecting growing price is a fallacy (in fact its the other way around) - but nevertheless Bitcoin is currently inflating at a 12.5% yearly rate, and what miners do with those newly minted coints has inevitably an impact on price.

I believe that there will be lots of newly minted coins hitting the exchanges in late 2013, will just wait and see.

EDIT: in fewer words, wether miners decide to speculate (holding) or to pay for their fiat costs (selling the coins for good) has inevitably an immediate impact on price.
legendary
Activity: 2380
Merit: 1823
1CBuddyxy4FerT3hzMmi1Jz48ESzRw1ZzZ
legendary
Activity: 4200
Merit: 4887
You're never too old to think young.

Price isn't driven by miners, but by traders and commodity speculation as has been amply demonstrated elsewhere.


This.
legendary
Activity: 1862
Merit: 1114
WalletScrutiny.com
Why do you keep saying XBT when almost everyone uses BTC?

XBT, BTC, Ƀ, these are all the same thing and you should understand them. The one that gets used most, will win in every day life. Some argue that XBT will win as the rule for non-governmental money is X… like in XAG and XAU.
My fav is Ƀ as it's easily typed once you know the code ctrl-u + 243. BTC is good, too. XBT it will be if the others insist in it. Just be easy with whatever and please don't insist in your choice being the best. Time will tell.
full member
Activity: 205
Merit: 100


Most of GPU miners didn't want ROI as soon as possible, as I explained earlier - they counted on reselling their GPUs, and they were mostly hobbyist. But I'm a miner myself, I know a lot of miners, I've seen in first person who are the customers of companies like KnC and how much they are spending, and you have to understand that this last media bubble exposed Bitcoin to a lot of new and uneducated people who run profit calculators at current difficulty (without having their miners yet), they do not even understand that difficulty is growing exponentially, and at the end of the day there is a "gold rush" in which a lot of new people is entering mining because they think they will get rich quick... So we have now a) a lot of individuals investing money they cannot afford to lose on BTC miners, and as you surely know there is a "get-rich-quick" feeling on BTC - they think they will recoup their investment FAST, and this is why they are putting in this game more money they should; b) there are more and more "professional" miners that are investing money in mining with the only intention of generating profit - they will run their operations as a business. That people has to pay for huge electricity costs, renting of industrial places where they will host their operations, etc. etc. etc. A lot of fiat expenses to cover.

During the GPU era, I rarely saw a) and b) miners, most were small-time hobbyist, running their rigs in their bedrooms. During this change to ASIC, I'm seeing a lot of both a) and b). This people needs to recoup fiat ASAP.

What a lot of rubbish. You haven't seen anything, you're just a bear and you've been jumping on bearish reasonings for ages.

In the GPU era, there was a ton of people buy dozens of graphics cards looking for ROI, just like there is now.

Price isn't driven by miners, but by traders and commodity speculation as has been amply demonstrated elsewhere.

What is of interest, though is that, despite bitstamp being easier to deal with than btc-e, btc-e is 4 dollars below bitstamp. And thats because exchanges with lower trading volumes, like btc-e are easier to manipulate. This was exactly what used to happen when MtGox went down on DDOS, there were absolutely massive collapses in prices and they successfully collected the spoils when MtGox would reopen.

legendary
Activity: 1638
Merit: 1001
₪``Campaign Manager´´₪
Why do you keep saying XBT when almost everyone uses BTC?
legendary
Activity: 1372
Merit: 1000

problem is, allot of those miners won't get ROI for many months. Knowing this, I would expect most (except for those who took out loans) to choose to wait for higher prices before getting their fiat back.

Exactly, I dont see why on this forums people seem to think that miners want to get ROI as soon as possible. I think 90% of them will just mine and hoard, for years

Well, if the price gets high, it would make sense to sell to lock in profits. But if that's what people were doing, the bubble would not have been quite so crazy.

I'm sure you know the bubble started more or less when block reward halved, which was a moment when nobody had ASICs yet, 99% of the network were GPU and FPGA miners... Those already had their rigs paid off long ago (no new GPU and FPGA miners for a while because everybody was expecting ASICs since last summer), so as soon as they saw their proceeds halved they started to hold like mofos, creating scarcity of coins, which made the price to grow - the growing price attracted speculators, speculators bought driving the price high, the media started to run stories about how Bitcoin price was growing, which attracted more speculators, etc... Wash rinse and repeat, speculative bubble in its purest form.

This cycle is about to invert when ASICs will be widespread. Same thing happened in 2011 with GPUS.

You really think people took loans to buy ASICs? I bet you most asic owners are early adopters from GPU times.

I surely don't know what's the %, but I surely know there are a lot of newcomers spending all their fiat savings (tens of k's of $) in miners because they think they will break even in one month and then they will have a x10 ROI in the first year... Loan or no loan I don't know, but you can be sure they are throwing at this more money they can afford to lose because they think this is a "no brainer" and they do not want to "miss the train".

I know for sure because I've been meeting/discussing with a lot of guys like that since March, both in cyber and meatspace.

There will be a lot of pain for miners very soon, you will see.

What I have learned from observation is most miners save the XBT, some spend X% and a few triad with X% but the majority are saved.

ASICMiner is a new type of miner they get about 900 coins a day and those coins go to "investors" not miners. (The new dollar extraction)


Not much Fiat is entering the system to buy ASIC's the ASIC suppliers who are delivering are charging XBT, and there is a long ROI on those purchases up to 3 years calculated when in XBT. (ROI in XBT = saving XBT)

The ASIC manufacturers (and Mining funds) on the other hand have hard expenses in fiat, so they are converting new XBT to fiat at the moment.  

If we stay in the $100 target, the ASIC manufactures do more of the same and difficulty increases exponentially, if the price dips the demand for high priced Asics will diminish and the manufacturers will have to innovate.  

We are approaching equilibrium with difficulty related to price, so we should expect change soon.  

legendary
Activity: 4200
Merit: 4887
You're never too old to think young.
It sounds like mr Market's manic depressive phase is on :p

Mr. Market? I thought it was Ms. Market.

Sometimes I think it's dirty old Uncle Market.  Cheesy
Jump to: