Wall Observer BTC/USD - Bitcoin price movement tracking & discussion - page 33344.

MickeyT2008

sr. member

Activity: 350

Merit: 250

This account was recently hacked

Quote from: Coinseeker on May 15, 2013, 07:45:01 AM

Quote from: Pzi4nk on May 15, 2013, 07:40:17 AM

Actually, business transactions ARE private. Only debts to the government are public. There is nothing stopping businesses in the US from legally accepting bitcoin.

Yes actually I have conceded that point. From the info provided I don't see the transactions being illegal but if the business were to not pay taxes on said transactions, that would be the violation. I think that's a fair understanding up to this point.

This is true, it's also one of the reasons that we like bitcoins!

Coinseeker

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: Pzi4nk on May 15, 2013, 07:40:17 AM

Actually, business transactions ARE private. Only debts to the government are public. There is nothing stopping businesses in the US from legally accepting bitcoin.

Yes actually I have conceded that point. From the info provided I don't see the transactions being illegal but if the business were to not pay taxes on said transactions, that would be the violation. I think that's a fair understanding up to this point.

crumbcake

newbie

Activity: 42

Merit: 0

Quote from: MickeyT2008 on May 15, 2013, 07:41:28 AM

Quote from: Stephen Gornick on May 15, 2013, 07:32:25 AM

So that doesn't mean using anything else to pay is illegal, it simply means I cannot force you to pay in anything other than the medium defined by law as legal tender. If you and I want to trade using seashells (which are anonymous, and can be traded anymously), that is not using legal tender but it most certainly is not prohibited by law.

Of course though if you declare seashells legal tender then you'd have a serious inflation problem due to their availability. This would make it necessary to pump so much acidic industrial waste into the sea that they all dissolve.

It's more than that. If all the fiat in country A bought one cow, and an agent within that country issued a new currency, the worth of which was claimed to be .2 cows, where does the extra .2 cows come from? Huh

Coinseeker

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: MickeyT2008 on May 15, 2013, 07:41:28 AM

Quote from: Stephen Gornick on May 15, 2013, 07:32:25 AM

So that doesn't mean using anything else to pay is illegal, it simply means I cannot force you to pay in anything other than the medium defined by law as legal tender. If you and I want to trade using seashells (which are anonymous, and can be traded anymously), that is not using legal tender but it most certainly is not prohibited by law.

Of course though if you declare seashells legal tender then you'd have a serious inflation problem due to their availability. This would make it necessary to pump so much acidic industrial waste into the sea that they all dissolve, thus re-valuing your currency.

Well that shouldn't be hard.

Pzi4nk

member

Activity: 70

Merit: 10

Move over clarinets, I'm getting on the band wagon

Quote from: el_rlee on May 15, 2013, 07:39:25 AM

Can't you sue the DHS? Some loaded early adopter should be able to afford an expensive lawyer, and that's what it's all about in USA, isn't it? [emphasis by Pzi4nk]

I wouldn't limit it to the USA.

MickeyT2008

sr. member

Activity: 350

Merit: 250

This account was recently hacked

Quote from: Stephen Gornick on May 15, 2013, 07:32:25 AM

So that doesn't mean using anything else to pay is illegal, it simply means I cannot force you to pay in anything other than the medium defined by law as legal tender. If you and I want to trade using seashells (which are anonymous, and can be traded anymously), that is not using legal tender but it most certainly is not prohibited by law.

Of course though if you declare seashells legal tender then you'd have a serious inflation problem due to their availability. This would make it necessary to pump so much acidic industrial waste into the sea that they all dissolve, thus re-valuing your currency.

Pzi4nk

member

Activity: 70

Merit: 10

Move over clarinets, I'm getting on the band wagon

Quote from: Coinseeker on May 15, 2013, 07:24:36 AM

Quote from: solex on May 15, 2013, 07:20:23 AM

Quote from: Coinseeker on May 15, 2013, 07:02:01 AM

Coinage Act of 1965, Section 102 states: “All coins and currencies of the United States (including Federal Reserve notes and circulating notes of Federal Reserve banks and national banking associations), regardless of when coined or issued, shall be legal tender for all debts, public and private, public charges, taxes, duties, and dues.” Only United States currencies (including Federal Reserve Notes) are currently legal tender in the US.

Keyword being LEGAL tender. Thanks for that BTW.

"An astute reader may note that legal tender only concerns the repayment of debt, taxes, duties, and dues."
Citizens are free to use any currency for an unofficial transaction.

Quote from: needmorecoins on May 15, 2013, 07:17:44 AM

Not familiar with any laws (or how to read them lawyer speak) so might a dumb question...but does the USD being legal tender in the US mean that other currencies are illegal? Or the other currencies can still be be used but just not legally obliged to be accepted?

That's your answer. Legal tender only matters where the government or judicial system is involved.
So you can't pay taxes in bitcoins. But you can pay your neighbor bitcoins for some vegetables.

You know, upon rereading that, that could be a really good legal loophole as long as transactions remained private. That still would prevent legal mass adoption by businesses I would think, as every legal business needs a business license issued by the government but that is an argument that could be made. Nice.

Actually, business transactions ARE private. Only debts to the government are public. There is nothing stopping businesses in the US from legally accepting bitcoin.

crumbcake

newbie

Activity: 42

Merit: 0

Quote from: Coinseeker on May 15, 2013, 07:29:25 AM

Quote from: MickeyT2008 on May 15, 2013, 07:22:54 AM

Bitcoin might be a currency but since it's only numbers in a computer and not a physical object can it even be said to exist? Anyway, surely it wouldn't be a crime for someone in the US to pay someone else in Euros or Stirling if they were both happy about it. If the US government start using a clause like that then it's obviously only because they're miffed about not getting to tax it, but they'd probably use some BS excuse like counter-terrorism, protecting kids, etc like they always do for things they don't like.

See these are all the questions no one really has answers to. There is all this grey area because of the internet. But if the government is not getting it's cut, they are not going to let that ride. Crypto certainly has it's challenges ahead. This online tax bill in congress is alot bigger than I think some people understand. The USG is looking to remove that grey area. I'm not saying any of this is right or fair...I'm just saying it is what it is.

There's no "gray area" if you consider fiat currency to be a sound system. Bitcoin dilutes the fiat economy, without introducing any value. Just like printing more money. If you are holding $$$, it's certainly not in your benefit for Bitcoin to succeed.

el_rlee

legendary

Activity: 1600

Merit: 1014

Can't you sue the DHS? Some loaded early adopter should be able to afford an expensive lawyer, and that's what it's all about in USA, isn't it?

Coinseeker

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: Stephen Gornick on May 15, 2013, 07:32:25 AM

Quote from: Coinseeker on May 15, 2013, 07:02:01 AM

Keyword being LEGAL tender.

You are misunderstanding the term "legal tender".

Quote

A medium of payment allowed by law or recognized by a legal system to be valid for meeting a financial obligation.

- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_tender

So that doesn't mean using anything else to pay is illegal, it simply means I cannot force you to pay in anything other than the medium defined by law as legal tender. If you and I want to trade using seashells (which are anonymous, and can be traded anymously), that is not using legal tender but it most certainly is not prohibited by law.

The transaction itself is not illegal. I concede that point. But not paying the taxes on the transaction is illegal.

Coinseeker

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: el_rlee on May 15, 2013, 07:25:51 AM

Are the Americans up already? Panic or not?

Yeah it's early. I'm going to be dead today. Just looking at the asks vs bids would tell me this thing is headed back down but, what do I know? I learned about Bitcoin some 6 weeks or so ago and it seems it does whatever it wants.

MickeyT2008

sr. member

Activity: 350

Merit: 250

This account was recently hacked

Quote from: Stephen Gornick on May 15, 2013, 07:32:25 AM

So that doesn't mean using anything else to pay is illegal, it simply means I cannot force you to pay in anything other than the medium defined by law as legal tender. If you and I want to trade using seashells (which are anonymous, and can be traded anymously), that is not using legal tender but it most certainly is not prohibited by law.

+1

crumbcake

newbie

Activity: 42

Merit: 0

Quote from: el_rlee on May 15, 2013, 07:25:51 AM

Are the Americans up already? Panic or not?

We're awake. Panic! Cheesy

Stephen Gornick

legendary

Activity: 2506

Merit: 1010

Quote from: Coinseeker on May 15, 2013, 07:02:01 AM

Keyword being LEGAL tender.

You are misunderstanding the term "legal tender".

Quote

A medium of payment allowed by law or recognized by a legal system to be valid for meeting a financial obligation.

- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legal_tender

So that doesn't mean using anything else to pay is illegal, it simply means I cannot force you to pay in anything other than the medium defined by law as legal tender. If you and I want to trade using seashells (which are anonymous, and can be traded anymously), that is not using legal tender but it most certainly is not prohibited by law.

Coinseeker

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: MickeyT2008 on May 15, 2013, 07:22:54 AM

Bitcoin might be a currency but since it's only numbers in a computer and not a physical object can it even be said to exist? Anyway, surely it wouldn't be a crime for someone in the US to pay someone else in Euros or Stirling if they were both happy about it. If the US government start using a clause like that then it's obviously only because they're miffed about not getting to tax it, but they'd probably use some BS excuse like counter-terrorism, protecting kids, etc like they always do for things they don't like.

See these are all the questions no one really has answers to. There is all this grey area because of the internet. But if the government is not getting it's cut, they are not going to let that ride. Crypto certainly has it's challenges ahead. This online tax bill in congress is alot bigger than I think some people understand. The USG is looking to remove that grey area. I'm not saying any of this is right or fair...I'm just saying it is what it is.

MickeyT2008

sr. member

Activity: 350

Merit: 250

This account was recently hacked

Quote from: el_rlee on May 15, 2013, 07:25:51 AM

Are the Americans up already? Panic or not?

7.28am in New York. Some will have reacted to this news last night but a lot of others will have gone to bed before the news broke. How significant the news is doesn't matter, what matters is how significant people think it is and how they react to it.

el_rlee

legendary

Activity: 1600

Merit: 1014

Are the Americans up already? Panic or not?

Coinseeker

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: solex on May 15, 2013, 07:20:23 AM

Quote from: Coinseeker on May 15, 2013, 07:02:01 AM

Coinage Act of 1965, Section 102 states: “All coins and currencies of the United States (including Federal Reserve notes and circulating notes of Federal Reserve banks and national banking associations), regardless of when coined or issued, shall be legal tender for all debts, public and private, public charges, taxes, duties, and dues.” Only United States currencies (including Federal Reserve Notes) are currently legal tender in the US.

Keyword being LEGAL tender. Thanks for that BTW.

"An astute reader may note that legal tender only concerns the repayment of debt, taxes, duties, and dues."
Citizens are free to use any currency for an unofficial transaction.

Quote from: needmorecoins on May 15, 2013, 07:17:44 AM

Not familiar with any laws (or how to read them lawyer speak) so might a dumb question...but does the USD being legal tender in the US mean that other currencies are illegal? Or the other currencies can still be be used but just not legally obliged to be accepted?

That's your answer. Legal tender only matters where the government or judicial system is involved.
So you can't pay taxes in bitcoins. But you can pay your neighbor bitcoins for some vegetables.

You know, upon rereading that, that could be a really good legal loophole as long as transactions remained private. That still would prevent legal mass adoption by businesses I would think, as every legal business needs a business license issued by the government but that is an argument that could be made. Nice.

MickeyT2008

sr. member

Activity: 350

Merit: 250

This account was recently hacked

Bitcoin might be a currency but since it's only numbers in a computer and not a physical object can it even be said to exist? Anyway, surely it wouldn't be a crime for someone in the US to pay someone else in Euros or Stirling if they were both happy about it. If the US government start using a clause like that then it's obviously only because they're miffed about not getting to tax it, but they'd probably use some BS excuse like counter-terrorism, protecting kids, etc like they always do for things they don't like.

Besides which, contrary to popular opinion the US is not the whole planet

Coinseeker

sr. member

Activity: 252

Merit: 250

Quote from: needmorecoins on May 15, 2013, 07:17:44 AM

Not familiar with any laws (or how to read them lawyer speak) so might a dumb question...but does the USD being legal tender in the US mean that other currencies are illegal? Or the other currencies can still be be used but just not legally obliged to be accepted?

From my limited understanding as well (so nothing dumb about it, my friend) a business can not accept a foriegn currency. It can only deal in US legal tender. It's not illegal to possess them, but to spend them in the US, on US goods and services is a clear violation of US policy.

So by that thinking, and as one stated earlier, owning Bitcoins is not illegal. Using them is or at least technically.

Topic: Wall Observer BTC/USD - Bitcoin price movement tracking & discussion - page 33344. (Read 26462970 times)