Author

Topic: Wall Observer BTC/USD - Bitcoin price movement tracking & discussion - page 9736. (Read 26630520 times)

legendary
Activity: 1442
Merit: 2282
Degenerate bull hatter & Bitcoin monotheist
My question to those who predict 100K within less than two years or so.
Why the discounting mechanism is not working?

If it is highly likely that 100K would be there by 2021, we should have mad buying of btc and its options right now.
That's my biggest beef with the S/F models.
Either the model is wrong/irrelevant OR the market is incapable of correctly pricing future expectations now.

Then you should address your question to the person who put this model together:

https://stephanlivera.com/episode/86/

Go to minute 29:00 onward, PlanB is going to answer to your question.

jbreher is right: People is simply not aware of the model and the halving effect on the stock to flow.

To be clear, I am not saying that the stock:flow model is definitive. I am saying that the eventual price is very high, due to the endemic properties of crypto as money. And that getting from a price of Zero to a price of FuckYou is bound to take significant time, and be very chaotic along the way.

The stock:flow model is simply an empirical model that seems to roughly explain the observed underlying reality. IMNSHO.

I expect anyone that trades with any expectation of fidelity to the S:F model will likely do well on average, but likely be wiped out at some point along the way where that fidelity breaks down completely.

We humans like things in neat little predictable buckets. But while markets are derived from human behavior, price predictions are not amenable to mere mathematical analysis.

This is fair.  Except fidelity does hold, albeit on an extremely macro level.

Year on year we have only once made a lower low in a following year, and then only by a whisker in the depths of cryptowinter.

legendary
Activity: 1862
Merit: 1530
Self made HODLER ✓

As for there being a "limited supply", is this not simply a variable, able to be changed at the discretion of the largest and most powerful network contributors?


"Changing" it would result in an immediate hard fork and considering the economic majority would not support it it would probably be rendered worthless (the hardforked chain I mean). It would be a chaotic event that would have some significant impact on price overall though. The one entity losing the most would be the one causing the hard fork and drop in price.

It is basically the same as if the richest people in the world decided to airdrop all their billions to the rest of the population. FIAT value would drop relative to other assets, but they would be the more directly impacted.

In other words, the most powerful network contributors have a very high economic incentive to just play by the consensus rules.
sr. member
Activity: 1197
Merit: 482
As for there being a "limited supply", is this not simply a variable, able to be changed at the discretion of the largest and most powerful network contributors?

No. It would require a consensus among 51% of the miners to change the protocol or a successful 51% attack, neither of which is likely to happen. It is hard to overstate just how incredibly improbable that would be. And should it happen then it would no longer be bitcoin.


Back to the primary motivation of fiat return (and potential loss), I see - is this how most people see bitcoin? A purely speculative asset and/or tool for gambling?


Sure a lot of them do. A lot of others see different/more reasons. I consider it a store of value not related to fiat return. That's an admittedly long (very) view. It's also a world computer. And a way to take control of your own financial power without middle men, with the concurrent responsibility of being very up to date on security.
jr. member
Activity: 37
Merit: 1
In seriousness I'll try and answer you a bit here:

I am compelled to follow up - why should anyone invest in bitcoin? Fiat return? Future potential for fiat return? Value retention? Acquisition of secure digital assets/property?

Why? Fiat Return, definitely the trend over the last five years has been a resounding yes, future potential is of course there, value retention definitely, and of course if you have the coins in a wallet that is yours (not an exchanges) your keys means your coins.

Thank you, kingcolex, for the clear response.

Although I'm not totally unfamiliar with SHA256 and the concept of sovereign ownership (I find these things quite interesting), I see that you've highlighted fiat return as a primary reason for financial investment into the bitcoin project.

I invest in Bitcoin due a to a few things, what I learned from dealing with Foreign investors who had strict government restrictions (China) on how much money they were allowed to bring out of the nation, wiring delay times, proof of funds, proof of ownership of funds and sourcing of funds. Bitcoin solves all of this without a company at the center that can freeze or control user funds, it can't go bankrupt and there is a limited number of coins that will never change.

Although I've heard these points made previously, I appreciate your restating of them, as I believe some of these innovations will have massive implications with regards to the way the global economy evolves.

As for there being a "limited supply", is this not simply a variable, able to be changed at the discretion of the largest and most powerful network contributors?

I believe JJG was trying to get at that when you own some (even a small bit) you could experience these things all for yourself, you can also sign messages with your wallet that proves that you are the one in control of the funds which is a neat way to prove who is who and who owns what and I definitely think it does help one understand the technology.

This is very intriguing - are there any guides or tutorials that explain exactly how to do this?

You can read all about stocks, but nothing helps you understand a market like owning a couple of shares yourself. That is all the same with Crypto and Bitcoin.

I'm still not sure that this is necessarily true.
I'm not even sure it's worth continuing to suggest investing, to be honest. Does it further the discussion regarding technical understanding? Does it do anything other than simply pressure others to join "your side"?

If you have an amount you can immediately peg it to a fiat amount you paid and in 1 month, 6 months, 1 year see how this crypto market really works and how it moves. No skin in the game leads to loss of focus and paying attention, I know I pay a lot more attention to markets where I am fiscally vulnerable.

Back to the primary motivation of fiat return (and potential loss), I see - is this how most people see bitcoin? A purely speculative asset and/or tool for gambling?

legendary
Activity: 3080
Merit: 1688
lose: unfind ... loose: untight
My question to those who predict 100K within less than two years or so.
Why the discounting mechanism is not working?

Either the model is wrong/irrelevant OR the market is incapable of correctly pricing future expectations now.

The latter.

We've seen this time and time again. The world at large has not yet awakened to the fact that they need a form of money that is not inflationary, and is free from intervening middlemen who can conspire to thwart or devalue their transactions.

You are so funny.
The world is going on the other direction. Boris, trump, marie le pen and all the others.

I don't see what your observation about so-called 'leaders' has to do with the price of tea in China. Want to explain yourself?
legendary
Activity: 3080
Merit: 1688
lose: unfind ... loose: untight
My question to those who predict 100K within less than two years or so.
Why the discounting mechanism is not working?

If it is highly likely that 100K would be there by 2021, we should have mad buying of btc and its options right now.
That's my biggest beef with the S/F models.
Either the model is wrong/irrelevant OR the market is incapable of correctly pricing future expectations now.

Then you should address your question to the person who put this model together:

https://stephanlivera.com/episode/86/

Go to minute 29:00 onward, PlanB is going to answer to your question.

jbreher is right: People is simply not aware of the model and the halving effect on the stock to flow.

To be clear, I am not saying that the stock:flow model is definitive. I am saying that the eventual price is very high, due to the endemic properties of crypto as money. And that getting from a price of Zero to a price of FuckYou is bound to take significant time, and be very chaotic along the way.

The stock:flow model is simply an empirical model that seems to roughly explain the observed underlying reality. IMNSHO.

I expect anyone that trades with any expectation of fidelity to the S:F model will likely do well on average, but likely be wiped out at some point along the way where that fidelity breaks down completely.

We humans like things in neat little predictable buckets. But while markets are derived from human behavior, price predictions are not amenable to mere mathematical analysis.
sr. member
Activity: 1197
Merit: 482
It was a genuine question, as I'm unfamiliar with the term - what does "Wall Observer" mean?

I wondered that at first too. I'm pretty sure it's just a reference to the queue depth at bid/ask prices.

sr. member
Activity: 1197
Merit: 482
I only buy bitcoin to up my WO street cred.

legendary
Activity: 1442
Merit: 2282
Degenerate bull hatter & Bitcoin monotheist
I'm not sure I believe that setting up an account on an exchange (and acquiring bitcoin) will do anything to further the individual's understanding of the technology itself.

Let me ask another question, what is YOUR understanding of the technology?

You won’t learn much until you buy some and use it. Log off this board and go buy some VPN services using Bitcoin and you will understand.
jr. member
Activity: 37
Merit: 1
Hi J1GGY !! Can you please tell me, what is the meaning of "Wall Observer", as in the title of this glorious thread?
No.

It was a genuine question, as I'm unfamiliar with the term - what does "Wall Observer" mean?

Usually it is good to 1) figure out your own situation and whether it allows you to reasonably invest in bitcoin 2) and if your situation allows you to invest in bitcoin, develop a plan, try to stick with the plan and tweak the plan from time to time.  Some form of dollar cost averaging, even if your are doing low amounts, such as $20 a week can pay off in the long term and from time to time, you may be able to invest more than your allocated amount.

Although I've expressed interest in understanding the application of cryptography, as has been done with bitcoin, I find it strange that your primary response is to encourage out-of-pocket investment in the project/experiment.

I am compelled to follow up - why should anyone invest in bitcoin? Fiat return? Future potential for fiat return? Value retention? Acquisition of secure digital assets/property?

Maybe a better way to follow up would be to ask why YOU'VE invested in bitcoin? Is it one of the above reasons? All the above reasons? Something completely different?

Once you own a bit of bitcoin, then it becomes a bit easier to actively engage in the topic.

Maybe I am naive, but I do not see why this would be the case; can we not have valid and insightful discussion on the subject without being financially invested?

Some no coiners have their bitcoin ignorant traits because they are not actively engaging with the topic by at least setting up accounts or whatever in order to get some better ideas about what bitcoin actually is.

I'm not sure I believe that setting up an account on an exchange (and acquiring bitcoin) will do anything to further the individual's understanding of the technology itself.

Let me ask another question, what is YOUR understanding of the technology?
legendary
Activity: 1442
Merit: 2282
Degenerate bull hatter & Bitcoin monotheist
It is physically painful to be slowly drip feeding, dollar cost averaging, into a very large, multi-year leveraged long right now on super low leverage.  It hurts to buy and every day see you have lost a little bit more.

The greatest long term trades are always incredibly painful to enter.  This helps me to keep going.  And the companionship of this board and your brilliant jokes !  And my dollar cost average keeps falling.  So carry on.
legendary
Activity: 3374
Merit: 4738
diamond-handed zealot
Robinhood...lol

Quote
Hi,


When you set a password for your Robinhood account, we use an industry-standard process that prevents anyone at our company from reading it. On Monday night, we discovered that some user credentials were stored in a readable format within our internal systems. We wanted to let you know that your Robinhood password may have been included.


We resolved this issue, and after thorough review, found no evidence that this information was accessed by anyone outside of our response team. Out of an abundance of caution, we still recommend that you change your Robinhood password.


We take matters like this seriously. Earning and maintaining your trust is our top priority, and we’re committed to protecting your information. Let us know if you have any questions–we’re here to help.


Sincerely,

The Robinhood Team​
 

Translated into non-pr english:



Hi,

We dun fucked up. Your password wasn't even hashed. lol. Woopsies.


Sincerely,

The Robinhood Team
legendary
Activity: 2716
Merit: 13505
BTC + Crossfit, living life.
^
Nominated troll posting Smiley

hero member
Activity: 1988
Merit: 593



BSV 14000 tps
Komodo 10000 tps
Xem 4000 tps
Eos 3000 tps
Xrp 1500 tps
legendary
Activity: 2716
Merit: 13505
BTC + Crossfit, living life.
Btw I thing my friend told me at 350-ish = he Said imagine this thing could rise crazy high with only a 10% chance of succeeding.... Then you must invest, and for him the % of success where much higher but nontheless imo you already should invest with thinking this.... might be b00ze talking now, and F*** mindrust go all-in bro, be more happy with your wealth in BTC as in crypto especially when there are no unexpected costs looking around the corner....

Goodnight!

HODL tight with me, be drunk with me on a F***ing Wednesday Cheesy lol

Looking forward to tomorrow have 2 big things on shedule, 1 requires a HAT change (only for a few hours, 15K Will be back same day Smiley ) !!!!!!   
legendary
Activity: 2716
Merit: 13505
BTC + Crossfit, living life.
BtF***ingw

Whats the price, did’t check that sh*t for hours..... made me think, I can eat a Peach for hours, from which movie did that line come from..... its a bit older but amazing movie Smiley
legendary
Activity: 2716
Merit: 13505
BTC + Crossfit, living life.
Thirty nine degrees
BBQ, salmon papillon, rosé wine!!!!
HODLers life I guess




Now into drunk and midweek HODLsleep...... b00ze and wine got me good! Roll Eyes


One day I Will master this haiku stuf.
jr. member
Activity: 527
Merit: 6
My question to those who predict 100K within less than two years or so.
Why the discounting mechanism is not working?

Either the model is wrong/irrelevant OR the market is incapable of correctly pricing future expectations now.

The latter.

We've seen this time and time again. The world at large has not yet awakened to the fact that they need a form of money that is not inflationary, and is free from intervening middlemen who can conspire to thwart or devalue their transactions.

You are so funny.
The world is going on the other direction. Boris, trump, marie le pen and all the others.
legendary
Activity: 3934
Merit: 11405
Self-Custody is a right. Say no to"Non-custodial"

If it is highly likely that 100K would be there by 2021, we should have mad buying of btc and its options right now.


I can speak for myself...

I am not going all in for the same reason I didn't go all in in 2015 or 2013.


Wasn't there some point in which you asserted that you became enlightened about bitcoin in 2017-ish, and you realized that your 2013/2015 skepticisms of bitcoin were partly due to your lack of knowledge, that you supposedly subsequently fixed...

In other words, unless you reverted, you should be more enlightened now, in regards to bitcoin than you were in those earlier times, no?


The tech is still new I am kinda afraid. It is not like in 2015 but this is more of a general fear. I am not doubting bitcoin itself. I don't have any suspicions about bitcoin's tech and its fundamentals. Some external factors are which give me fear. They are mostly governments and regulations and similar shit.

Of course, everyone should have some fear and skepticism because there are a multitude of factors playing on bitcoin..... the good, bad and the ugly.

Till 2016... I almost never invested in bitcoin from my own pocket. At least not any considerably big amounts.

Yeah, and you later asserted that your non-investment in those times had been short-sighted.

My fear barrier almost completely disappeared after the  $20k ATH but I started buying in early 2017 mostly. (from $2k-$3k era) As of today, without counting any profits I made from BTC, I invested %20 of my total networth into BTC. (of course that %20 became a bigger number now since btc's price is above my average cost) In 2015 that was %0. In 2016 that was like %1.

Usually I recommend that folks invest 1% to 10% into BTC, so 20% is a bit much, but hey, everyone has differing circumstances.

Whether you should reallocate or not, might be another question.  Perhaps since you started out with a high amount, there would be more justification for you to reallocate, if you had only invested a lower amount, such as 10%. 

Those reallocation decisions are personal in nature, and partly have to deal with whether the remaining of your investments (outside of BTC) are sufficiently stable and some of them might need some additional injection of your BTC appreciation to make you, overall, more stable financially... Financial stability should assist you in being more psychologically stable, too.


When Bitcoin went above $1200 and then went even beyond $2k that's when it hit me in the head.

This can go to $20k in that year, 2017.
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/we-did-it-it-is-20k-we-are-still-not-in-a-bubble-20k-is-incoming-1932892

It did.

You predicted it or wished for it?  Hahahahahaha.. I think that I understand, that you had presented ideas that $20k was possible... which is just a statement of what could happen, so maybe there is no need to read into that post of a statement more than it was?

Now I feel very similar.

This can very well go above $50k, and maybe hit even $100k.

The situation I am in now is quite comfortable.

Good that you are comfortable, generally.

If it goes down too much, I have the funds to strengthen my position (my DCA's will buy more coins) or the stomach to watch what'll happen next without losing my mind. This is all because I am not over invested.

You might be slightly over-invested.. but sure, I understand that sometimes people might invest a bit more than others and still be within a wide range of reasonableness.

If it goes up, well it is just party time.

I remember it like yesterday I was thinking about buying from $5k but didn't want to. (actually I bought quite a lot from $5k, but what I really mean, I could have bought a lot more) Of course I am not happy with that decision now.

Why am I not going all in? Risk management. I need my sanity too when it reaches $100k.  Grin

I'll just follow the plan I made when I started this journey. Not going to change plans constantly, from my experience, I can say It always ends badly.

I thought that you post began badly.. but overall, you seem to be in a pretty decent place, and perhaps, since you are somewhat over-invested, from my perspective, you will feel more comfortable not to have to FOMO chase the BTC price up.  On the other hand, you will still be kind of ready to buy more BTC in case the BTC price goes below certain price thresholds that you determine to be comfortable for yourself.
legendary
Activity: 2422
Merit: 1191
Privacy Servers. Since 2009.
My question to those who predict 100K within less than two years or so.
Why the discounting mechanism is not working?

If it is highly likely that 100K would be there by 2021, we should have mad buying of btc and its options right now.
That's my biggest beef with the S/F models.
Either the model is wrong/irrelevant OR the market is incapable of correctly pricing future expectations now.

Well there are peeps who are balls deep into BTC already (LFC, goose, Bob, your humble servant etc) whose bags are full and who don't buy anymore (or do buy small q-ties). Many don't buy because they got their coins really cheap (3 digits or less) and can't force themselves to buy at $10k+. Then there are guys who believe in BTC but can't afford to buy as it will make them homeless or worsen their quality of life significantly. Finally there are lots of naysayers, nocoiners and simply ones who haven't heard about BTC.

Anyhow, I wouldn't say that this mechanism isn't working as we're now at ~$10k which is not that bad.   Cool    
Jump to: