Since
Ercoin is going to be distributed via BlackCoin burning, it would be interesting to know the date of the blockchain snapshot for the purpose of BlackNet distribution. If it happens during the burning period, then the two will interfere.
I see two possible outcomes:
1 BlackCoin = 1 Blacknet + 1 Ercoin
1 BlackCoin = 1 Blacknet or 1 Ercoin
In which one are you interested?
I would prefer NOT to see a reduction in the overall supply of Blacknet, therefore Blacknet snapshot before Ercoin/Blackcoin "swap and burn" opportunity.
"1 BlackCoin = 1 Blacknet + 1 Ercoin"
It's assumed here I think that Blackcoin won't need to be burned to receive Blacknet tokens.
Burning is inevitable
This is a major change from “Wait for a good opportunity to buy BLK, then wait for the snapshot.That simple”
I’m sure many would like to know why “Burning is inevitable.”
The problems I see with burning BLK for Blacknet or Ercoin are:
1. Trusted Third Party or Swap Software needed to facilitate the swap
a. People involved may be unreliable or have ulterior motives causing possible loss of Blackcoin with nothing in return.
b. Swap software may have bugs, or can be hackable causing possible loss of Blackcoin with nothing in return.
2. BLK holders are trading something that has present value and is tradable across several exchanges including shapeshift.io and flyp.me for something not tradable and which may or may not be tradable at some future time, at some value which may be higher or lower than that of the burned BLK.
3. BLK Proven peer to peer transfer network exchanged for new “untested in real world” networks
4. BLK total coin supply & market cap calculations become invalid.
5. Existing BLK supply gets more concentrated in the hands of centralized exchanges.
6. If any crash and burn occurs, both burned BLK and the new tokens are gone.
A snapshot avoids all these issues, requires no trust, and is pretty much invisible to BLK, except for the trading occurring before and after. If something goes wrong in the processes, no one is at risk of losing anything.
If coin holders are going to be asked to burn BLK in exchange for a new coin, they should have detailed information about the exchange processes, and enough information on the new coin networks to make an informed decision.
I really want to like Blacknet, but at this point, it’s just vaporware wanting to eat my Blackcoin.