So you describe a problem, ask for help on solutions...
and the resulting 11 pages that follow are the same problems you describe: vendor hate, people calling people whatever, people talking off topic, with some genuinely trying to address the OP's issue, and etc.
I'm not trying to be sarcastic or condescending or any of that, just an honest question: If you really wanted to change this, why don't you just "moderate"? you know, like your title says. Use your common sense/best discretion. If someone starts bashing BFL in the KNC thread, tell them to stay on topic. If someone calls someone a whatever tell them to keep it civil. If Josh calls his customers a moron cuz they want their money back for an undelivered product, tell him to act professional. If people refuse, just ban them for a bit? I don't know...
Or don't. It's up to you. Just that most of the other forums I goto, this is what the "moderator" tends to do.
I personally like the forum exactly the way it is. I like reading all the bashing, all the useful information, all the drama, it's like watching reality tv almost. I like it when people go at it like Bitcoinorama and KS, within their exchanges you can glean useful info from both sides, and generally be more educated thanks to their efforts. You can find useful info in just about any posts here if you look for them.
I love this forum.
exactly. If even this thread can't be moderated to keep it on topic then what hope does the rest of the forum have?
Given the minimalist stance the mods take here it should probably just be left the way it is..better nothing than selective editing or what have you.