Pages:
Author

Topic: How to sign a message?! - page 12. (Read 141621 times)

hero member
Activity: 728
Merit: 1006
BountyPortal Supporter & Hhampuz is my manager
March 06, 2018, 09:41:12 AM
~snip~

I import address and click on more options but its don't showing sign Message. It's showing Archive, Transfer, Spend.
Based my thread in my local sub https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/tutorial-sign-message-address-bitcoin-pada-blockchaininfo-wallet-2946861, I'll make this thread more completly with this, especially how to make sign messages bitcoin address at blockchain.info wallet


Question : If there is already a thread about that, why did you created this thread man? Are you wanted to spam or something?! Go away!
Answer : No dear, certainly I'm not. I did this because Shorena still didn't give detail a tutorial on how to sign a message with new version blockchain wallet.

-snip-

Just to make clear why I didnt add this to the post.

#1 I just now noticed it and lately I tend to be away from the forum for long periods of time.
#2 I think this tutorial is dangerous or at the very least I have no way to determine how safe it is.[1] It requires you to manually handle private keys and trust (or understand) source code that is not widely used as a wallet. I think the steps could be improved by not relying on the github repo, but rather on e.g. electrum. Then again, importing a key from electrum into bc.i would be pointless as you could just sign with electrum directly.

[1] Is the code sound? Is the entropy generation sound? Are the steps given in a language I dont understand good? Is focus drawn to the possible pitfalls of handling unencrypted private keys in your clipboard? Why this repo and not e.g. bitaddress or brainwallet, etc.?



Edit: I just tested it, addresses created with new wallets still can not be used to sign messages with.
#1. I'm waiting to discuss with you more than a week.  Smiley
#2. About the security, I totally agree with you.
I already warned about this, by posting this:
~snip~

EDIT:
For some reason, I'm not suggest you to use blockchain.info as your main wallet.
This is just tutorial, how to make signature message at b.info wallet.


Following your Dos and Don't
How can I sign a message in the new blockchain?It seems I can't find a sign button there,I've only seen the verify one.It's not in the manage options.
By blockchain I assume you are referring to blockchain.info

To sign a message, go to the "Settings" tab on left, Click on "Addresses", Click on "More Options" in front of your required address, Choose "Sign Message" .

Does the new version allow signing messages? My last info is only the old wallet version does.
~
I added an example how to post the signed message for the blockchain.info part here.

~snip~
Blockchain.info v2 2016.05.11
return to index

Update (2017.5.13): According to user apoorvlathey it is now possible to sign messages with the new version as it was in the past. User sHeRiLyN1618 reports that this is only possible for imported addresses, but not addresses generated with the service. For more information read the posts starting from here -> https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.18991565

Update (2016.5.11): It is now possible to sign messages with imported private keys.
Th0ur007 wrote a step by step here
-> https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/guide-how-to-signverify-message-in-new-blockchain-wallet-1467458

Note: Blockchain.info's new wallet does not allow you to sign a message, nor does it allow you to easily export the private key in order to sign with a different wallet. There is a crude work around here -> https://docs.google.com/document/d/1-2l6xOqcbjs9QWEqSh72RD1d8EEdvG_hQuEXw_f_o6w/edit
Use at your own risk!



~snip~

Luckily for me, I found this thread in my local board: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cara-mengetahui-private-key-di-wallet-blockchaininfo-2107937, this thread give a simple tutorial on how to find a private key of blockchain.info wallet address.
Firstly, I make a backup of blockchain.info wallet using wallet recovery phrase, then I write 12-16 "magic word" at notepad.
Two, I download this tools: https://github.com/iancoleman/bip39, then I went offline.
I run this tools in offline mode, I fill my 12-16 "magic word" to BIP39 Mnemonic form, and I get result privkey instantly.
Video mode: https://youtu.be/xwksiStDZD4 (with Indonesian subtitle)

After I have my private key, I follow this step https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.18991565

And yes, I can export the priv.key to electrum 3.0.6 too, and both of them have same result signature.


EDIT: at step 5, remove "colour address" and fill it with priv.key
Its works for me and some user at my local sub

Big thanks for this thread, shorena.
I'll translate this thread in my local sub if you dont mind and give me permission for this
And I'll big mark Dos and Dont for warning, then put additon from JeremyB's and me.

legendary
Activity: 2142
Merit: 1065
✋(▀Ĺ̯ ▀-͠ )
March 06, 2018, 09:30:02 AM
Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Today is 06.03.2018
This is to verify my BTT account sigmas55
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
1KAMUgqoTkUrziPJUdwziShcHFhKcAcPLn
ICC8Fsz//+Lqkwy1FNSufaZctZ1/Qk5WrRNAvqbK8NxZXa63139aLcSfzoh5Ju11QijLxzg9Z6LDJoHbqV25OdQ=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

Electrum Wallet with 2FA didn't work for me (I think because it has some sort of multi-sig functionality), I had to make a regular wallet, I also did not choose Segwit, I thought it might not sign messeges as well.

Thank you Shorena for the lesson, I might translate your topic and post it in the Arabic sub-forum if I have the time (& if you don't mind of course).

Verified
You can sign a message with segwit addresses, meanwhile address starting with bc1 can't be verified by other wallets except electrum afaik.
member
Activity: 658
Merit: 36
Telegram:@sigmas55
March 05, 2018, 07:43:58 PM
Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Today is 06.03.2018
This is to verify my BTT account sigmas55
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
1KAMUgqoTkUrziPJUdwziShcHFhKcAcPLn
ICC8Fsz//+Lqkwy1FNSufaZctZ1/Qk5WrRNAvqbK8NxZXa63139aLcSfzoh5Ju11QijLxzg9Z6LDJoHbqV25OdQ=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

Electrum Wallet with 2FA didn't work for me (I think because it has some sort of multi-sig functionality), I had to make a regular wallet, I also did not choose Segwit, I thought it might not sign messeges as well.

Thank you Shorena for the lesson, I might translate your topic and post it in the Arabic sub-forum if I have the time (& if you don't mind of course).
copper member
Activity: 1498
Merit: 1528
No I dont escrow anymore.
March 04, 2018, 03:48:03 PM
~snip~

I import address and click on more options but its don't showing sign Message. It's showing Archive, Transfer, Spend.
Based my thread in my local sub https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/tutorial-sign-message-address-bitcoin-pada-blockchaininfo-wallet-2946861, I'll make this thread more completly with this, especially how to make sign messages bitcoin address at blockchain.info wallet


Question : If there is already a thread about that, why did you created this thread man? Are you wanted to spam or something?! Go away!
Answer : No dear, certainly I'm not. I did this because Shorena still didn't give detail a tutorial on how to sign a message with new version blockchain wallet.

-snip-

Just to make clear why I didnt add this to the post.

#1 I just now noticed it and lately I tend to be away from the forum for long periods of time.
#2 I think this tutorial is dangerous or at the very least I have no way to determine how safe it is.[1] It requires you to manually handle private keys and trust (or understand) source code that is not widely used as a wallet. I think the steps could be improved by not relying on the github repo, but rather on e.g. electrum. Then again, importing a key from electrum into bc.i would be pointless as you could just sign with electrum directly.

[1] Is the code sound? Is the entropy generation sound? Are the steps given in a language I dont understand good? Is focus drawn to the possible pitfalls of handling unencrypted private keys in your clipboard? Why this repo and not e.g. bitaddress or brainwallet, etc.?



Edit: I just tested it, addresses created with new wallets still can not be used to sign messages with.
copper member
Activity: 1498
Merit: 1528
No I dont escrow anymore.
March 04, 2018, 09:07:50 AM
Hello shorena, I translated your post to Filipino, here : https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/ph-paano-mag-sign-ng-message-3062163

Thank you for this wonderful thread. By the way, I noticed that Coinbase "how to for now", I guess it is an article, already doesn't exist today. I think it should be remove to the OP since it has no importance now. Just my suggestion!  Grin

Thanks, added.
sr. member
Activity: 812
Merit: 270
March 04, 2018, 08:10:23 AM
Hi! I signed it using Electrum. Hope I did it correctly Smiley

Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
This is geverciss from bitcointalk.org and today is 04 march 2018
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
1MepqvfAXcLVP6pJhM1QjpRMGhYeg8mXcM
H6zR330fDtVGHBzMKnMs1RTlzb4I2au7Cm7HASn5x7yBV2mPXbDWN8SrfHRpqsiHioRVF9QNQuw6TIHoofMAlgo=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

You did it well Wink
Verified with BrainWallet
full member
Activity: 280
Merit: 100
March 04, 2018, 07:44:37 AM
Hi! I signed it using Electrum. Hope I did it correctly Smiley

Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
This is geverciss from bitcointalk.org and today is 04 march 2018
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
1MepqvfAXcLVP6pJhM1QjpRMGhYeg8mXcM
H6zR330fDtVGHBzMKnMs1RTlzb4I2au7Cm7HASn5x7yBV2mPXbDWN8SrfHRpqsiHioRVF9QNQuw6TIHoofMAlgo=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
full member
Activity: 812
Merit: 126
March 04, 2018, 04:30:50 AM
Hello shorena, I translated your post to Filipino, here : https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/ph-paano-mag-sign-ng-message-3062163

Thank you for this wonderful thread. By the way, I noticed that Coinbase "how to for now", I guess it is an article, already doesn't exist today. I think it should be remove to the OP since it has no importance now. Just my suggestion!  Grin
copper member
Activity: 1498
Merit: 1528
No I dont escrow anymore.
March 03, 2018, 03:02:32 AM
Hope I did it right! Signed a message using Electrum. Smiley

Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
This is uelque from bitcointalk.org and today is 2018.03.03
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
16Uh382NnXkCP1w7qGuEL6T9hufHKpbRcP
IJRlldK4NzLjoDS0rIcTDgLIJBZaOnS9s3jUxZb4tOAMMU2AAAnIpz3LAMPLMb6+W1mm6tL7DsOyW15tulY3664=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

Could verify it, well done.
full member
Activity: 812
Merit: 126
March 03, 2018, 02:36:24 AM
Hope I did it right! Signed a message using Electrum. Smiley

Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
This is uelque from bitcointalk.org and today is 2018.03.03
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
16Uh382NnXkCP1w7qGuEL6T9hufHKpbRcP
IJRlldK4NzLjoDS0rIcTDgLIJBZaOnS9s3jUxZb4tOAMMU2AAAnIpz3LAMPLMb6+W1mm6tL7DsOyW15tulY3664=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
copper member
Activity: 1498
Merit: 1528
No I dont escrow anymore.
March 02, 2018, 02:22:23 PM
Added a sentence to the chapter "Pay to script hash (P2SH) addresses":

With the addition of P2SH-P2WPKH addresses (SegWit, but starting with a 3) this did not change. At least it did not in bitcoin core, other wallets may still allow signing or verification.
sr. member
Activity: 812
Merit: 270
February 28, 2018, 07:29:42 AM
shorena thanks for your helpful post!
I translated it in French here: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=3022163.new#new, if you want to add the link in the translations.

I've added 3 sections you could be interested to add in the OP:
- Sign with a Ledger Nano S
- Sign with a Trezor
- BrainWallet BitCore signature verification
- Trezor signature verification





Ledger Wallet Bitcoin v.1.10.1
return toindex

Link to picture -> https://i.imgur.com/2h22aN6.png



Verified here.
Note: Ledger Wallet Bitcoin can't be used to verify a signature.


Trezor Wallet
return toindex

Link to picture -> https://i.imgur.com/mvg884g.png



Signature verified with Trezor here




(Bitcoin-QT) Correct Signature


Link to picture -> https://i.imgur.com/hlkBkji.png

(Bitcoin-QT) Incorrect Signature


Link to picture -> https://i.imgur.com/VEqKAeE.png

(Bitcoin-QT) Correct Signature & Missing address


Link to picture -> https://i.imgur.com/LefpKPC.png



Trezor
return to index

Correct Signature

Link to picture -> https://i.imgur.com/XgICUy7.png


Incorrect Signature

Link to picture -> https://i.imgur.com/Y3LIVPT.png




legendary
Activity: 3234
Merit: 1375
Slava Ukraini!
February 26, 2018, 05:48:10 PM
Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hi I am Rimon365.This is my message.Today is Fabruary 26, 2018.
------BEGIN SIGNATURE------
1PA6ohpFBB7n49DubLAynzrnMWqzoZmgAg
H4ASyjrVjA7Co3NO1KYeCENDHs5NRftec4bZOggEiIbsFi1lEYLR6B8jXS0Tt7ZbsCiVRZeKQbi+kK2Qm/SC5tA=
------END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE--------

Please quote and verify this message.
Quoted and verified
full member
Activity: 623
Merit: 100
CLEARSIGHT- THE #1 BLOCKCHAIN JOB PLATFORM
February 26, 2018, 03:39:40 PM
Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hi I am Rimon365.This is my message.Today is Fabruary 26, 2018.
------BEGIN SIGNATURE------
1PA6ohpFBB7n49DubLAynzrnMWqzoZmgAg
H4ASyjrVjA7Co3NO1KYeCENDHs5NRftec4bZOggEiIbsFi1lEYLR6B8jXS0Tt7ZbsCiVRZeKQbi+kK2Qm/SC5tA=
------END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE--------

Please quote and verify this message.
legendary
Activity: 2142
Merit: 1065
✋(▀Ĺ̯ ▀-͠ )
February 23, 2018, 12:54:36 PM
If it starts with a "1" and you have the private keys you can definitely sign a message using that address... it is probably just that Bitpay and CoPay don't provide the functionality within their wallets.

You would need to use another wallet like Electrum (https://electrum.org/#download) and import your private key and use the inbuilt tool for signing messages... Apparently b.info also offers this for imported keys, but I don't like b.info Tongue

Or you'd need to use an external tool like "brainwalletx" (http://brainwalletx.github.io/#sign)... NOTE: I DON'T vouch for the safety of using "brainwalletx" and I certainly wouldn't use their website to input a private key... At the very least you should create an "offline copy" of it (download .ZIP and run locally while OFFLINE etc).

Importing private keys to latest version of electrum is safe tho but i wouldn't recommend doing the same for brainwalletx nor for B.info even if it is proven to be safe for the last one.
Avoid online sites when you are dealing with sensitive informations.
HCP
legendary
Activity: 2086
Merit: 4361
February 23, 2018, 11:36:58 AM
If it starts with a "1" and you have the private keys you can definitely sign a message using that address... it is probably just that Bitpay and CoPay don't provide the functionality within their wallets.

You would need to use another wallet like Electrum (https://electrum.org/#download) and import your private key and use the inbuilt tool for signing messages... Apparently b.info also offers this for imported keys, but I don't like b.info Tongue

Or you'd need to use an external tool like "brainwalletx" (http://brainwalletx.github.io/#sign)... NOTE: I DON'T vouch for the safety of using "brainwalletx" and I certainly wouldn't use their website to input a private key... At the very least you should create an "offline copy" of it (download .ZIP and run locally while OFFLINE etc).
HCP
legendary
Activity: 2086
Merit: 4361
February 22, 2018, 08:32:15 PM
Anyone know if I can sign Bitpay or Copay address? I have the private keys but I wonder if it is possible to sign these wallets. THANKS
If it starts with a "3"... then the answer is no. You can ONLY sign from addresses that start with a "1".
hero member
Activity: 728
Merit: 1006
BountyPortal Supporter & Hhampuz is my manager
February 16, 2018, 11:42:55 AM
~snip~

I import address and click on more options but its don't showing sign Message. It's showing Archive, Transfer, Spend.
Based my thread in my local sub https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/tutorial-sign-message-address-bitcoin-pada-blockchaininfo-wallet-2946861, I'll make this thread more completly with this, especially how to make sign messages bitcoin address at blockchain.info wallet


Question : If there is already a thread about that, why did you created this thread man? Are you wanted to spam or something?! Go away!
Answer : No dear, certainly I'm not. I did this because Shorena still didn't give detail a tutorial on how to sign a message with new version blockchain wallet.
Lucky me, I've already tried it and it was successfully verified!
Hi, please verify my address

Code:
----BITCOIN ADRESS ----
1N41sxCmuHe2uWVmL29aJc5KkkCVAVZ5AK
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Today is 13.02.2018 bitcointalk account pandukelana2712 (u=1304130) belongs to this address
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
H+sS1GVZ0zmbcLq+qjRr6QIeMXWaTUFl2BfzOObkzEQqa0E6MCGFeGBNzNadoKBL7Ag2XKSYxBrXUBVtfFfKdQg=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----

Thanks.

Quoted and verified!

Step 1
Login to your blokchain wallet just as usual blockchain.info.
Make and copy your private key to notepad. Follow cissrawk tutorial on https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/cara-mengetahui-private-key-di-wallet-blockchaininfo-2107937

Step 2
After you got your private key, go to blockchain.info
choose menu ==> setting


Step 3
Choose address sub menu


Step 4
Click Import Bitcoin Address button


Step 5
Fill it with your private key, then click import


Step 6
After you've done succesfully don that, then your address will be shown just like in number (5), choose more option


Step 7
Choose sign message


Step 8
Make sure your adress and your message match with your account on bitcointalk, make sure to include the date when you sign it too


Step 9
If you've successfully done it, you will see something like this



EDIT:
For some reason, I'm not suggest you to use blockchain.info as your main wallet.
This is just tutorial, how to make signature message at b.info wallet.


legendary
Activity: 2142
Merit: 1065
✋(▀Ĺ̯ ▀-͠ )
February 10, 2018, 01:24:29 PM
-snip-

As you was told in the other topic, you made a mistake when copying the text, i found an extra space between "is" and "2018" but even removing it doesn't help. Try to verify the message then post it again.

Yes sir i Corrected This one. can you verify this one now.



Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hi I'm MKH. I'm Signing This Message As a Test Message.
------BEGIN SIGNATURE------
14xE7pNigaxGdH2WmCp5NA3PnpvDWTXbWx
Hw0w5BhNb9E5uN1PIR/quKEXqxcjeVtwpCkziE0D3UVuUliVwfXUy+3uUdxEa88cfUfK7dPNLkj8gIjNgTRkDlQ=
------END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE--------

Ok done . You only need to verify it once with the same Bitcoin address Smiley
MKH
copper member
Activity: 231
Merit: 15
February 10, 2018, 11:58:34 AM
-snip-

As you was told in the other topic, you made a mistake when copying the text, i found an extra space between "is" and "2018" but even removing it doesn't help. Try to verify the message then post it again.

Yes sir i Corrected This one. can you verify this one now.



Code:
-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hi I'm MKH. I'm Signing This Message As a Test Message.
------BEGIN SIGNATURE------
14xE7pNigaxGdH2WmCp5NA3PnpvDWTXbWx
Hw0w5BhNb9E5uN1PIR/quKEXqxcjeVtwpCkziE0D3UVuUliVwfXUy+3uUdxEa88cfUfK7dPNLkj8gIjNgTRkDlQ=
------END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE--------
Pages:
Jump to: