Merit & new rank requirements - page 316.

dautay_crypto

member

Activity: 193

Merit: 11

Quote from: Tamak on January 24, 2018, 11:26:34 PM

So from now on, if I want to become a Senior Member I need other people to send me 250 Merit point?
Plus 240 activities?

Yes, I think that is what Theymos wanted from users. I am a little bit confuse and worried about that new rules for ranking too. I think only Hero and Legendary members ready to give others their merits as rewards for good, high-qualitied posts. With the new rules related to merit counts, it might be really hard to be upgraded to higher ranking levels.

Lutpin

copper member

Activity: 1876

Merit: 1874

Goodbye, Z.

Quote from: dautay_crypto on January 24, 2018, 11:27:14 PM

It seems to be hard to get merits from others. I think it is simply because users should keep merits for themselves in order to be ranked up. Quite hard to get rewarded merits, I guess.

You didnt understand. When someone gives you Merit, they lose sMerit, which is only used to be sent to others and has no purpose besides that.
Hoarding my sMerit doesnt give me any benefit. Likewise, I dont lose any of my Merit (defining my rank) when sending Merit to others, as sMerit are used for that.

Quote from: Lutpin on January 24, 2018, 07:02:01 PM

You have Merits, those you cannot send.
You also have sMerits, those you can only send, they have no other purpose.

When someone gives Merit to you they lose sMerit of the amount transfered and you gain Merit as well as sMerit (which in case you can send again).

Example: Should I send 10 Merit to you for a post, my sMerit would decrease by 10.
Your Merit would increase by 10 and your sMerit would increase by 5.

Merits are exclusively earned, but the sMerit part you also get keeps the circulation flowing.

(Ignoring merit sources here, for the sake of making an easy example.)

Quote from: coolws on January 24, 2018, 11:27:42 PM

If so, what if selling/ buying merits, how to prevent this?

Banhammer to the face.

Quote from: ruletheworld on January 24, 2018, 11:29:02 PM

I respectfully disagree with the first part. Someone who is a week away from becoming a legendary member, for example, will now have to compete for the same 500 Merit points as someone who just became a hero member, in order to reach the legendary member status.

I did start with 500 Cry

ruletheworld

legendary

Activity: 1386

Merit: 1045

Quote from: achow101 on January 24, 2018, 10:33:46 PM

Quote from: ruletheworld on January 24, 2018, 10:25:41 PM

Third, there should (personal opinion) be a fairer distribution of initial Merit than just the current forum level. Seems unfair otherwise, since there is a huge variation already just within a forum level. Perhaps a combination of current activity, time on the forum, how long the account has been in the current level, and other relevant variables.

The distribution of merit was only to provide the absolute minimum for people to have the rank that they currently have. Since merit isn't actually used for anything than determining that, I think this is fine. What matters more is the distribution of sMerit, the stuff that people actually give away. For that, the formula was based on both rank and activity in the past year.

I respectfully disagree with the first part. Someone who is a week away from becoming a legendary member, for example, will now have to compete for the same 500 Merit points as someone who just became a hero member, in order to reach the legendary member status. It is this distribution that seems unfair. At the very least, I'd distribute Merit based on Activity numerical values in a stepped manner, e.g. 500-700 activity = 600 Merit, 700-900 activity = 800 Merit, etc. or something along those lines. The bands for activity are too wide, in my opinion.

coolws

member

Activity: 126

Merit: 20

If so, what if selling/ buying merits, how to prevent this?

dautay_crypto

member

Activity: 193

Merit: 11

Quote from: QuestionAuthority on January 24, 2018, 11:24:32 PM

Quote from: ?? on ??

Quote from: suchmoon on January 24, 2018, 11:01:19 PM

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 10:57:43 PM

With this new function, i think that only member that are already member rank or higher before today get Merit point because it's free one time Merit point. and the other with lower rank will never get enough Merit point to up level.

From where I stand I'm equally likely to merit a noob or a legendary... as long as the post is worth it.

Quote from: Tamak on January 24, 2018, 11:00:05 PM

What will happen if use all the sMerit I have? Do I get more?

0.5 for each merit you get.

yeah a new function and you got 1000 Merit point without doing anything. cool

Don’t feel bad, Bruce Wagner has 250 merit, cablepair has 500 merit, cypherdoc has 1000 merit, MagicalTux (aka Mark Karpeles) has 500 merit, Inaba (aka EclipseMC, Butterfly Labs, his trust rating is the worst I’ve ever seen -9999: -15 / +4p) has 1000 merit.

I don’t think it matters what your merit is unless you want to jump ranks and be able to make signature money. This might help the mods out by cutting down on the meaningless posts aimed only at post count. Hopefully “merit” will succeed where “activity” failed miserably. It will be interesting to see how Merit is gamed. I can definitely see account sales increasing now.

It seems to be hard to get merits from others. I think it is simply because users should keep merits for themselves in order to be ranked up. Quite hard to get rewarded merits, I guess.

OWZ1337

member

Activity: 140

Merit: 17

BITCOIN===>THE DISRUPTIVE CYBERCURRENCY

Quote from: Vod on January 24, 2018, 07:05:37 PM

I already don't like the way clicking on +merit takes you away from the thread. Can you please have it open in a new window?

ot: Jesus!! ~ you are still here? :-D lmao

Tamak

full member

Activity: 182

Merit: 106

So from now on, if I want to become a Senior Member I need other people to send me 250 Merit point?
Plus 240 activities?

PoolMinor

legendary

Activity: 1843

Merit: 1338

XXXVII Fnord is toast without bread

Quote from: Lauda on January 24, 2018, 07:09:48 PM

Press your middle mouse button when trying to open a link to open it in a new window. Problem solved. Now you should have given me 200 merit. Tongue

Watching.

The middle mouse button only functions on whatever you previously set it up to do. For instance my middle mouse button is set to backward, like previous page, previous folder, etc.

-PoolMinor

DarkStar_

legendary

Activity: 2758

Merit: 3282

Quote from: stompix on January 24, 2018, 11:07:58 PM

Quote from: DarkStar_ on January 24, 2018, 11:00:53 PM

I think merit points should only stay if the post was deleted by a moderator, or the owner of a self moderated topic. If the post is deleted by the user, the sMerits should return to the person who gave the merits. If merit selling/trading was to get popular, it would be fairly easy to hide who you bought the merit from or traded with, as you could make a temp post, wait for them to "pay" the merit, and then delete it, hiding all traces of the "trade" from the general public. Thoughts?

I don't think it works like that.
The merit point will still show on your profile along with the username that gave it to you, just the link with the reference will point to an invalid post.
Lutpin was about to to test this...

I can only view my own merit page. I don't think those who buy merit are going to rat themselves out, as it would ruin the entire point.

Quote from: stompix on January 24, 2018, 11:07:58 PM

The merit page should indeed be public like the trust page:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=merit;u=xxxxxx

^^ This

QuestionAuthority

legendary

Activity: 2156

Merit: 1393

You lead and I'll watch you walk away.

Quote from: ?? on ??

Quote from: suchmoon on January 24, 2018, 11:01:19 PM

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 10:57:43 PM

With this new function, i think that only member that are already member rank or higher before today get Merit point because it's free one time Merit point. and the other with lower rank will never get enough Merit point to up level.

From where I stand I'm equally likely to merit a noob or a legendary... as long as the post is worth it.

Quote from: Tamak on January 24, 2018, 11:00:05 PM

What will happen if use all the sMerit I have? Do I get more?

0.5 for each merit you get.

yeah a new function and you got 1000 Merit point without doing anything. cool

Don’t feel bad, Bruce Wagner has 250 merit, cablepair has 500 merit, cypherdoc has 1000 merit, MagicalTux (aka Mark Karpeles) has 500 merit, Inaba (aka EclipseMC, Butterfly Labs, his trust rating is the worst I’ve ever seen -9999: -15 / +4p) has 1000 merit.

I don’t think it matters what your merit is unless you want to jump ranks and be able to make signature money. This might help the mods out by cutting down on the meaningless posts aimed only at post count. Hopefully “merit” will succeed where “activity” failed miserably. It will be interesting to see how Merit is gamed. I can definitely see account sales increasing now.

Ria Sakurai

jr. member

Activity: 251

Merit: 6

Quote from: achow101 on January 24, 2018, 11:14:45 PM

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 11:13:34 PM

I think only way to up Full member rank for you now is that buying Merit points Grin

Buying merit is prohibited and will get you banned.

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 11:13:34 PM

If not, may be next year 2019 you will have enough 100 Merit points

Or you can not shitpost and instead make quality posts. You'll get merit if your posts are quality.

I think that Merit points trade will surely happen. Maybe it'll not be public

Foxpup

legendary

Activity: 4326

Merit: 3041

Vile Vixen and Miss Bitcointalk 2021-2023

I like it. Now I can reward good posts instead of just reporting bad posts, which seems like all I ever do here nowadays.

achow101

staff

Activity: 3374

Merit: 6530

Just writing some code

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 11:13:34 PM

I think only way to up Full member rank for you now is that buying Merit points Grin

Buying merit is prohibited and will get you banned.

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 11:13:34 PM

If not, may be next year 2019 you will have enough 100 Merit points

Or you can not shitpost and instead make quality posts. You'll get merit if your posts are quality.

suchmoon

legendary

Activity: 3654

Merit: 8909

https://bpip.org

Quote from: bill gator on January 24, 2018, 11:06:27 PM

Quote from: suchmoon on January 24, 2018, 11:02:38 PM

There should be a public list of all merits given/received by a user, like the trust page.

I was thinking the same thing, but as Darkstar said if they delete the post/thread then what record would there be to look at other than just the +X amount? If it links a deleted post, it just won't be there to look at and observe. Unless there is a safe way to utilize archives without squandering forum security.

Yes, not seeing the target post is problematic, but if someone has a lot of merits for deleted posts - that would be suspicious in itself. Like spammy trust ratings with no reference.

TryNinja

legendary

Activity: 2758

Merit: 6830

Quote from: stompix on January 24, 2018, 11:07:58 PM

Quote from: DarkStar_ on January 24, 2018, 11:00:53 PM

I think merit points should only stay if the post was deleted by a moderator, or the owner of a self moderated topic. If the post is deleted by the user, the sMerits should return to the person who gave the merits. If merit selling/trading was to get popular, it would be fairly easy to hide who you bought the merit from or traded with, as you could make a temp post, wait for them to "pay" the merit, and then delete it, hiding all traces of the "trade" from the general public. Thoughts?

I don't think it works like that.
The merit point will still show on your profile along with the username that gave it to you, just the link with the reference will point to an invalid post.

Lutpin was about to to test this...

But is there is any way we can see the user's merit page like we do with the trust feedbacks?

How can someone like Lauda or Vod see if the user is using alts to give himself merit after he deletes his posts? (so they can neg trust him)

Edit:

Quote from: theymos_away on January 24, 2018, 11:29:37 PM

Quote from: CodyAlfaridzi on January 24, 2018, 11:23:03 PM

theymos need to make a public list of sent and received merit of a user, like a trust summary. This will easily solve that problem.

I will do this in the near future, maybe tomorrow. Also top merited posts/topics/users.

nc50lc

legendary

Activity: 2394

Merit: 5531

Self-proclaimed Genius

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 10:57:43 PM

With this new function, i think that only member that are already member rank or higher before today get Merit point because it's free one time Merit point. and the other with lower rank will never get enough Merit point to up level.

I see your point, but from Novice to Jr Member to Member, your Merit requirement is only 10 which is too easy to achieve if you're not a shitposter.

But to those who are a week or less to rank up, the timing is bad.
Me for example, I'm 5 days short of becoming a full member,
I got the default 10 merit because of my rank, now I need 90 more to rank up, that's the rock bottom.

Well, I'm confident with my activities.
Ranking up won't take that long.

Ria Sakurai

jr. member

Activity: 251

Merit: 6

Quote from: nc50lc on January 24, 2018, 11:10:22 PM

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 10:57:43 PM

With this new function, i think that only member that are already member rank or higher before today get Merit point because it's free one time Merit point. and the other with lower rank will never get enough Merit point to up level.

I see your point, but from Novice to Jr Member, your Merit requirement is only 10 which is too easy to achieve if you're not a shitposter.

But to those who are a week or less to rank up, the timing is bad.
Me for example, I'm 5 days short of becoming a full member,
I got the default 10 merit because of my rank, now I need 90 more to rank up, that's the rock bottom.

Well, I'm confident with my activities.
Ranking up won't take that long.

I think only way to up Full member rank for you now is that buying Merit points Grin

If not, may be next year 2019 you will have enough 100 Merit points

Stegobit

jr. member

Activity: 154

Merit: 1

Quote from: Jeex on January 24, 2018, 10:59:32 PM

I suggest additionally enter a negative Antimerit. To obtain a new rank, the Antimerit must not exceed 10% of all messages.
This will help self-cleaning the forum from spam messages - users will start deleting their bad messages.

Antimerit/demerit is very bad idea - it will punish people who have non-stardard point of view! Many people are fed up with "political correctness" imposed by government and stereotypes in society, so they don't want to see it on this forum!

achow101

staff

Activity: 3374

Merit: 6530

Just writing some code

Quote from: ?? on ??

yeah a new function and you got 1000 Merit point without doing anything. cool

You really don't get it, do you?

The whole point of merit is for establishing a requirement to obtain a rank. Those users you are complaining about who got merit "for free" only get the merit because they were active members of this forum for years. The only reason they get merit is so that they have enough to meet the new requirements for rank. Those members get the minimum requirement for their rank and will still need to earn merit to rank up, just like everyone else.

Having the merit does not give them any special privileges or powers that they didn't already have. It is literally only there to establish their rank.

Lutpin

copper member

Activity: 1876

Merit: 1874

Goodbye, Z.

Quote from: Ria Sakurai on January 24, 2018, 11:08:34 PM

Quote from: July1106 on January 24, 2018, 11:07:07 PM

Who can send Merit , anyone or higher rank people?

I think that anyone that has Merit points can send it.

No, you need sMerit to send. Merit cant be transfered, it is forever tied to your account.
(First reply, explanation for tl;dr persons: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.28856606)

Quote from: ?? on ??

Sure, and they have big motivation give it to some newbie and do not sell it for someone who pay, especially in our local tear.

Sadly, I am not allowed to sell any of my sMerit and source merit.

Quote from: nc50lc on January 24, 2018, 11:10:22 PM

But to those who are a week or less to rank up, the timing is bad. Me for example, I'm 5 days short of becoming a full member,
I got the default 10 merit because of my rank, now I need 90 more to rank up, that's the rock bottom.

I'm at 966 activity, well in the upper part of the window for legendary.
I got 500 merit, people with less activity than me got 1000 merit because they hit legendary by chance, sooner than I did.
500 merit. not 10, not 90, 500.

Topic: Merit & new rank requirements - page 316. (Read 166645 times)