Well, please enlighten me about the definition of all rounder.
One is batting all rounder (green), who hardly performs with the ball and yet to win any matches with the bat when playing in away conditions, in contrast the next guy is bowling allrounder. Who has noteworthy performance with the ball and match winning, some would say match saving performance with the bat.
Who would you rate better? My money on the latter every single time. Doesn't matter the combination.
I would still say that Green is a better player. How many times did Shardul won a match for India, either with the ball or with the bat? He is extremely inconsistent. If he plays 5 matches then he will perform well in one match. Green on the other hand is consistent with the bat, and quite handy with the ball. He has taken wickets at crucial times, despite the fact that he doesn't get much of an opportunity to bowl. Anyway, both of these players are young and it will be difficult to make a judgement at this point. Shardul is 31, and Green is 24. Both of them have at least 8-10 years of test cricket ahead of them.
I agree Green is the future superstar and has potential but in general, his performances are not backing this claim at least with the ball.
Glad you asked about Shardul's performance. Well he played only 9 matches ( 10 technically but he got injured on his debut and only bowled a over).
- Gabba (Against Aus): He played his 2nd test there and scored 67 runs in the first inning, remember his 100 runs partnership with the Washington Sundar? He also took 7 wickets in that match.
- Kennington Oval (Against Eng) : Scored 2 50s in both innings and took 3 wickets, he was a MOM candidate and many argued that he should've received the MOM but Rohit got the award because of his ton.
- Wanderers (Against SA) : He singlehandedly kept India in the hunt when he ran through the South African batting lineup and picket 7 wickets. We should've won that match because of him but as usual, our batter shit the bed.
He also scored 50 in the WTC finals and picked 2 wickets. All these performances came away from home, where he has virtually no experience.