Pages:
Author

Topic: Pangolinminer & Whatsminer FAQs - page 9. (Read 25113 times)

full member
Activity: 350
Merit: 158
#takeminingback
March 03, 2018, 04:56:36 PM

From what I could dig up, it appears the original designer(Yang) of Bitmain's "technology", who now works for his own company (bitwei)
and wants the rights for his invention:

Now that's speculative...lol. He is not listed as one of the inventors on the patent. There are 5 other individuals who are. The only reason he filed to have SIPO review and retract Bitmain's patent is because Chinese law gives you the opportunity to do so when you are sued for patent infringement. He said he didn't file it by choice, but in response to their lawsuit.


I agree, it's ALL very speculative. I posted that link, to shed light on the other half of the different versions in Crypto Media.
full member
Activity: 265
Merit: 232
March 03, 2018, 04:40:52 PM

From what I could dig up, it appears the original designer(Yang) of Bitmain's "technology", who now works for his own company (bitwei)
and wants the rights for his invention:

Now that's speculative...lol. He is not listed as one of the inventors on the patent. There are 5 other individuals who are. The only reason he filed to have SIPO review and retract Bitmain's patent is because Chinese law gives you the opportunity to do so when you are sued for patent infringement. He said he didn't file it by choice, but in response to their lawsuit.
full member
Activity: 350
Merit: 158
#takeminingback
March 03, 2018, 04:17:21 PM

So, which is it? There is a lawsuit over the miner design, like you stated above, or the power supply circuit design?

Can you provide any source to these very speculative statements?

I said design, not miner design,


It's a bit odd that WhatsMiner has not sold anything directly for some time. You can only purchase from Pangolin and they are removing all branding from units and power supplies. They will not sell or ship to China, yet are located in China. Maybe the pending legal claims are why Kodak backed out of a purchase order if there is any truth to that either?


I apologize, beings that this thread is specific to the miner itself, I was under the impression that was the topic of your statement.

From what I could dig up, it appears the original designer(Yang) of Bitmain's "technology", who now works for his own company (bitwei)
and wants the rights for his invention:

Quote from:  from cryptovest
The technology, formerly created by Yang Zuoxing, former Bitmain director of design, is one of the keys making the Bitmain ASIC machines unique. But Zuoxing wants to revert ownership of the patent, and most probably use it to the benefit of his own company, Bitewei.

Reference to quote:

https://cryptovest.com/news/bitmain-patent-runs-out-will-this-change-the-face-of-mining/

Can't say that I blame Yang for wanting his work credited to him, nor would it be bad PR for his company.  Many mining companies
likely changed their business plans, because of the impending mining/electricity  restrictions coming out of China.
legendary
Activity: 2422
Merit: 1706
Electrical engineer. Mining since 2014.
March 03, 2018, 04:05:49 PM
Lawsuit was announced back in August 2017 and there are direct quotes from Yang where he mentions filing appeals and an application to revoke Bitmain's patent in response to their lawsuit:
https://www.coindesk.com/former-bitmain-chip-designer-seeks-to-revoke-mining-giants-patent/

Ah ok, I stand corrected. I can connect the dots now, so to speak.
I did little digging too and found this: https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/there-bitcoin-patent-war-going-initiative-could-end-it/

I don't know how trustworthy news media bitcoinmagazine.com is, but they mention Bitewei being the company that manufactures WhatsMiners.
full member
Activity: 265
Merit: 232
March 03, 2018, 03:42:47 PM

So, which is it? There is a lawsuit over the miner design, like you stated above, or the power supply circuit design?

Can you provide any source to these very speculative statements?

I said design, not miner design, however Bitmain's patent is here if you want to read exactly what's covered:
http://211.157.104.77:8080/sipo_EN/search/detail.do?method=view&parm=16b414c21a2f19d11b2c18401bcd1a5f183a19561ad91be11a581c4c04792b231f5c21ba22572195236c20482755275723ca24be2221222525702494250d26c0274025822c3f29092a7c29a02d6d2d6f28fa2ed62bd12c892f482c34330947932f5c2c0a2ac731b9333c316c366534e7318235ee337934f1360837f03747371b371a34e231bf38f13b04390c3e0d3f6f39ea3dc63c573d6d3e683e4c26d918c33ffe3c523c273e354334405c47c545774302408e4423458d47a04688462b46a846ca46b2436f47554bcc49784a2d
https://patents.google.com/patent/CN105045364A/en

Lawsuit was announced back in August 2017 and there are direct quotes from Yang where he mentions filing appeals and an application to revoke Bitmain's patent in response to their lawsuit:
https://www.coindesk.com/former-bitmain-chip-designer-seeks-to-revoke-mining-giants-patent/

I'm sure SIPO could give you the docs if requested.

It's a bit odd that WhatsMiner has not sold anything directly for some time. You can only purchase from Pangolin and they are removing all branding from units and power supplies. They will not sell or ship to China, yet are located in China. Maybe the pending legal claims are why Kodak backed out of a purchase order if there is any truth to that either?
legendary
Activity: 2422
Merit: 1706
Electrical engineer. Mining since 2014.
March 03, 2018, 03:18:54 PM
As far as I know, there are no lawsuits officially announced between Bitmain and WhatsMiner.

That's a high amount of pure speculation.


EDIT:
I was wrong, I stand corrected.
Lawsuit was announced back in August 2017 and there are direct quotes from Yang where he mentions filing appeals and an application to revoke Bitmain's patent in response to their lawsuit:
https://www.coindesk.com/former-bitmain-chip-designer-seeks-to-revoke-mining-giants-patent/

Ah ok, I stand corrected. I can connect the dots now, so to speak.
I did little digging too and found this: https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/there-bitcoin-patent-war-going-initiative-could-end-it/

I don't know how trustworthy news media bitcoinmagazine.com is, but they mention Bitewei being the company that manufactures WhatsMiners.
full member
Activity: 350
Merit: 158
#takeminingback
March 03, 2018, 03:15:56 PM

So the pending lawsuit with Bitmain over their serial power supply circuit patent ended? News to me cause I just read another article today that mentioned it.


So, which is it? There is a lawsuit over the miner design, like you stated above, or the power supply circuit design?

Can you provide any source to these very speculative statements?
full member
Activity: 265
Merit: 232
March 03, 2018, 03:01:05 PM
'Kodak KashMiners' are indeed just relabeled WhatsMiner M3 miners.

When Kodak first announced back at CES I saw different photos of them where one was a rebranded S9 and others looked like rebranded WhatsMiner units. They were different units in literature and what was at CES. You can tell by position of network port on the controller. If that's the case, I wonder why they also removed them from the power supply, which didn't appear to have any Kodak specific branding.

So the pending lawsuit with Bitmain over their serial power supply circuit patent ended? News to me cause I just read another article today that mentioned it.
legendary
Activity: 2422
Merit: 1706
Electrical engineer. Mining since 2014.
March 03, 2018, 01:54:39 PM
The M3's are actually "Kodak Miners" that did not sell at that company.
https://imgur.com/ed9HJLs

This theory about WhatsMiner M3 miners that have the technical specs label removed makes sense.

'Kodak KashMiners' are indeed just relabeled WhatsMiner M3 miners.
full member
Activity: 350
Merit: 158
#takeminingback
March 03, 2018, 01:39:45 PM
I believe the reason the stickers are being removed is due to a pending lawsuit with Bitmain over the design. Bitmain's former director of design started WhatsMiner after leaving Bitmain in 2016. This may also be why they are no longer limiting quantities, offering discount coupons, and trying to offload as quick as they can. Other reason for offload is due to more efficient miners coming on the market in Q2/Q3, which will make these even less profitable.

False. The M3's are actually "Kodak Miners" that did not sell at that company. Go back a few pages, and you'll see it's been
discussed here already. There is no pending lawsuit from Bitmain. However, you correct about the design engineer coming
from Bitmain. The availability, and lower prices is because, the price of btc has gone down. Also, the efficiency of 28nm is tapped
out at this point, making the last production of these miners a fire sale.


https://imgur.com/ed9HJLs
full member
Activity: 265
Merit: 232
March 03, 2018, 11:12:35 AM
I believe the reason the stickers are being removed is due to a pending lawsuit with Bitmain over the design. Bitmain's former director of design started WhatsMiner after leaving Bitmain in 2016. This may also be why they are no longer limiting quantities, offering discount coupons, and trying to offload as quick as they can. Other reason for offload is due to more efficient miners coming on the market in Q2/Q3, which will make these even less profitable.
newbie
Activity: 59
Merit: 0
March 03, 2018, 12:43:26 AM
For me power is reasonable inexpensive and I have access to ample capacity.  I was a little surprised at how much per circuit it cost me to build it though.  Unfortunately the building I am in has 480/276V so have to transform it to 3ph 208v.

I like now that I can buy the M3 with PayPal, much easier than BTC/BCH.  Unfortunately our exchanges in Canada are not that reliable right now for sending or receiving fiat.  I did just get verified on Kraken though and it seems to be working well.

i see, i do agree using paypal is more convenient for a start, but once you accumulated some bitcoins from mining, it could be use for the payment of more miners.
newbie
Activity: 6
Merit: 0
March 03, 2018, 12:39:32 AM
For me power is reasonable inexpensive and I have access to ample capacity.  I was a little surprised at how much per circuit it cost me to build it though.  Unfortunately the building I am in has 480/276V so have to transform it to 3ph 208v.

I like now that I can buy the M3 with PayPal, much easier than BTC/BCH.  Unfortunately our exchanges in Canada are not that reliable right now for sending or receiving fiat.  I did just get verified on Kraken though and it seems to be working well.
newbie
Activity: 59
Merit: 0
March 03, 2018, 12:30:34 AM
Glad you had good experience, yes the 48 hours delivery was a job well done by DHL or FEDEX, not Pangolin. The delay in handling the M3 to the freight company is main concern with some backlog as far at 15th Feb.

Have you sent in a support ticket??? You, and the guy posting above,  need to send one. Usually, they are really good about "on time" delivery. Sucks that it's happening, but I just wanted to assure you that, they indeed, have a good product. I've had mine "cooking" for
nearly 2 weeks,  with zero issues. I suggest sending a support ticket, and patiently see what happens. I know that's hard to do.


When you get the miner, and if you need help setting up, please post here. I'll give you a hand, if I can. Goodluck!!!

No issues for me either, received 4 M3's that I had ordered earlier than expected and very quick DHL delivery to Canada.  I just ordered 5 more but Paypal is holding my payment with the statement "Regulations require us to take a closer look at some transactions. Your payment is temporarily pending while we review it."  I suspect it has to do with the amount being over $10K CAD.

My first experience with ASIC miners and I was pleasantly surprised, they just work, and I am getting almost 12 TH/s on each one and sometimes more.  They sure do put out a lot of heat though!

Great to hear that, with Bitmain slashing prices on the S9 and T9, makes lesser sense to get M3 now.
newbie
Activity: 6
Merit: 0
March 03, 2018, 12:26:35 AM
Glad you had good experience, yes the 48 hours delivery was a job well done by DHL or FEDEX, not Pangolin. The delay in handling the M3 to the freight company is main concern with some backlog as far at 15th Feb.

Have you sent in a support ticket??? You, and the guy posting above,  need to send one. Usually, they are really good about "on time" delivery. Sucks that it's happening, but I just wanted to assure you that, they indeed, have a good product. I've had mine "cooking" for
nearly 2 weeks,  with zero issues. I suggest sending a support ticket, and patiently see what happens. I know that's hard to do.


When you get the miner, and if you need help setting up, please post here. I'll give you a hand, if I can. Goodluck!!!

No issues for me either, received 4 M3's that I had ordered earlier than expected and very quick DHL delivery to Canada.  I just ordered 5 more but Paypal is holding my payment with the statement "Regulations require us to take a closer look at some transactions. Your payment is temporarily pending while we review it."  I suspect it has to do with the amount being over $10K CAD.

My first experience with ASIC miners and I was pleasantly surprised, they just work, and I am getting almost 12 TH/s on each one and sometimes more.  They sure do put out a lot of heat though!
newbie
Activity: 59
Merit: 0
March 02, 2018, 09:56:03 PM
Glad you had good experience, yes the 48 hours delivery was a job well done by DHL or FEDEX, not Pangolin. The delay in handling the M3 to the freight company is main concern with some backlog as far at 15th Feb.

Have you sent in a support ticket??? You, and the guy posting above,  need to send one. Usually, they are really good about "on time" delivery. Sucks that it's happening, but I just wanted to assure you that, they indeed, have a good product. I've had mine "cooking" for
nearly 2 weeks,  with zero issues. I suggest sending a support ticket, and patiently see what happens. I know that's hard to do.


When you get the miner, and if you need help setting up, please post here. I'll give you a hand, if I can. Goodluck!!!

Thank you very much Bro, really appreaciate your effort. Yes, sent them a couple of tickets, they indeed reply me fast, but sadly, not able to pass the M3 to freight company just as fast. Hope all goes well by next week, thanks again Bro.
full member
Activity: 350
Merit: 158
#takeminingback
March 02, 2018, 09:39:56 PM
Glad you had good experience, yes the 48 hours delivery was a job well done by DHL or FEDEX, not Pangolin. The delay in handling the M3 to the freight company is main concern with some backlog as far at 15th Feb.

Have you sent in a support ticket??? You, and the guy posting above,  need to send one. Usually, they are really good about "on time" delivery. Sucks that it's happening, but I just wanted to assure you that, they indeed, have a good product. I've had mine "cooking" for
nearly 2 weeks,  with zero issues. I suggest sending a support ticket, and patiently see what happens. I know that's hard to do.


When you get the miner, and if you need help setting up, please post here. I'll give you a hand, if I can. Goodluck!!!
newbie
Activity: 59
Merit: 0
March 02, 2018, 09:23:17 PM
I, Personally,never had any issues with the shipment from Pangolinminer. In fact, it was much earlier than I expected. It literally took under 48hrs from their facility in china, to my door step
in Michigan. However, I was patient, and never asked about tracking, or inquired about my shipment date. I just let them do, what they do, and They did it well. I cannot speak of their
delays, as of late, but I've seen many with the same results as me. I'm sure that they are going to ship, but their customer support is a few days behind....or Ahead, depending the time zone.

Glad you had good experience, yes the 48 hours delivery was a job well done by DHL or FEDEX, not Pangolin. The delay in handling the M3 to the freight company is main concern with some backlog as far at 15th Feb.
full member
Activity: 350
Merit: 158
#takeminingback
March 02, 2018, 09:17:45 PM
I, Personally,never had any issues with the shipment from Pangolinminer. In fact, it was much earlier than I expected. It literally took under 48hrs from their facility in china, to my door step
in Michigan. However, I was patient, and never asked about tracking, or inquired about my shipment date. I just let them do, what they do, and They did it well. I cannot speak of their
delays, as of late, but I've seen many with the same results as me. I'm sure that they are going to ship, but their customer support is a few days behind....or Ahead, depending the time zone.
newbie
Activity: 59
Merit: 0
March 02, 2018, 09:16:19 PM
They so badly promisong i ordered in 28 septamber for feb  and they didnt send me tracking id yet.they should send me before march but no M3 delivered yet.is there any body delivered his m3 for feb batch?

They sent me a tracking a week ago, but nothing was picked by the freight company yet.
Pages:
Jump to: