Is Sunday the day when everyone forgets what bitcoin is about?
the exchanges are in a far more leveraged position to sway the currency than any mining group even if they were mining all 3600 coins each day
Surely you aren't suggesting that if a centralised organisation controlled 100% of bitcoin network, things would work great? That a, let's call it, Central Bank, could be trusted to handle the network fairly for everyone and not manipulate it for easy gain, political reasons etc? That seems to 100% miss the point of why bitcoin was invented.
Where the machine is hosted doesn't matter... Selecting the appropriate pool will decentralize BTC mining.
If someone had a massive share of the network hashrate (which is bad), the best things they could do is spread it over "pools" - not "pool" - as many pools as possible. Certainly not putting all that power in the hands of an "appropriate pool" (singular). Although someone in it for the money would probably find the pool where they can make the most and point everything at that, just for sake of profit and damn the fundamental ideas behind bitcoin.
Pools are not a great idea, as they centralise and put too much power in the hands of a few. Why was there such a panic a few weeks ago when ghash got so big it looked like they were going to take 51%? Because it's a bad thing.
Maybe I've missed the point of what you guys were saying, but it seems to me the best situation for bitcoin is where a massive amount of miners all around the world are controlling the hashrate, not some centralised body, mining group or pool. The fact that very large pools and massive centralised mining monopolies have evolved is just the by-product of greed and not healthy for a decentralised crypto.
Nothing to disagree about there. But why then did KnC opt to build a miner that alone would need 15% more current than a US 20 amp circuit can handle. Since US circuits, plug-in, excepting specialized circuits for driers or ovens, take a max of 20 amps they put it out of reach without extraordinary measures, e.g. calling in a licensed electrician to rewire the home. They could have built 20nm miners of a size that draw one quarter the current. Such a design decision, typically won't work in a US home, works against decentralized mining. So, why did they go that way?
Come on, tell there's no Santa Clause.