Pages:
Author

Topic: Utopia P2P Ecosystem 💎 | Review Campaign 🔎| Get paid in BTC | Full members+ - page 24. (Read 14311 times)

legendary
Activity: 966
Merit: 1042
#SWGT CERTIK Audited
My Review:
i tested all the features and functions. i mentioned some of the minor issues below i hope by circumventing these platform will make more room to grow.  
fyi{ i already have some of CRP}

User Interface and UX:
--->At first glance it looks, a little bit old fashioned as new platforms in the market comes with better color grading, animation schemes to keep the UI attractive. just my own observation. i know good things take time but project seems to me very old concept so i think it's time to compete in better UI and break its own record. Overall this UI also looks fine. But make it little attractive too.
 

---> whenever i slide my cursor on it the lists do not open up automatically until i press one click on one of them. After clicking, it automatically opens all other. it would be more easy for users to access these option if the need of click will eliminate. One more thing there is not even a slight animation to confirm either you take your cursor on the button or not. But until i click any of them everything works completely fine. i hope u got my point.



---> This Box comprises of groups is very laggy. i don't know that it's on my end or is it a real problem it would be nice if scrolling down and up feels fast not lag. as i am mentioning these issues in User interface section because i think it's related to UI issues. and there is one more thing which i found annoying. If i set my status to offline i will not be able to join any groups here i know it's a online system working concurrently but i hope it could work as fine even i change my status to "offline"



Technical Issues i faced
People tend to use light things even in the era of fast technology. i can sacrifice my anonymity if i do not feel comfort in Utopia because it consumes a lot of memory and bandwidth. it's just my personal review so, As above UI feels old fashioned and back-end codes also consumes alot of memory so i checked that if i am not using mining bots than where my memory is going. as in the mining bot they said only "memory and Bandwidth will be used in mining" so, i hope making this platform light is possible.



---> I think it's a spelling mistake as there is space between meaning {mean ing} on the main website. as i was reading them and thought it would not look professional if these mistakes are find out. so i hope they may correct it soon. Just to avoid confusion. if it's not a spelling mistake then i am sorry as according to my context of interpreting the line space is additional there.



--->uMaps are not showing any background map. they only show locations of channels on clicking the "number" of "pin icon" and i thought that Utopia aims to provide total anonymity then why showing location or coordinates of channels creations. It should also be hidden as per anonymity. If its fine then maybe a background map would look good here as it's attractive. {I like the idea of showing channels on map but look outdated in UI}



---> idyll browser was not showing any website even the ones listed on the Utopia website in Merchant section. i do not know either browser is functioning or not but it wasn't working on my end.

Display problem on my main laptop:
i also faced some issue in viewing the full display of Utopia app on my HP Elitebook g4 laptop. when i set resolution from 1920*1080 to 1280*1024. i hope you got my point.
Here is the pic of my laptop from G4 where i face this issue Now i am on another laptop testing it. Here by default my resolutions on current working laptop are 1366*768. [ it would be nice to overcome this issue ]


Things i like in Utopia
1: Public key and uNS
Concept of public key and uNS to search friends is really awesome as it provides total anonymity and quickness of search friends or clients becomes more easy with uNS
2: 4 types of Themes
"Dark Theme, Classic  Dark Theme, Light and Classic Light" all of them are great themes in sense of cryptography and anonymity
3: Tab Settings:
we can add wallets, channels tab and channel manager in our tabs setting to quickly access it.
4: Crypto Cards:
Customizable Utopia cards to use in buying and selling things and services at merchants is astonishing.
5: Hotkeys option
Setting up of hotkeys according to needs is very relaxing as we have to type 2 or 3 keys and our required tool or option will open easily.

List of likeness is too long i hope my review about Utopia will help it to grow.

Conclusion: Overall idea of the Utopia platform is really unique and promising. They tools like ubrowser, uwallet, email, mining, etc. all of them are great products but need some tuning to keep them fresh and competitive. Changing the Layout from "view option is very great as it keeps the spirit up. Plus dark and classic mode are also great options. Overall Utopia is great in all fields and getting there.
legendary
Activity: 3010
Merit: 1280
Get $2100 deposit bonuses & 60 FS
UTOPIA P2P Ecosystem 💎 Review:

Launching the Apps:  No problem nor delay during the application launch.  Can log in easily and smoothly.  The welcome pop-up makes it easy for new users to get a hint about the application.  The presence of Help even makes it easier to understand and get familiarized with the application.

Language: By default, the Utopia Language is in English but you can change it according to the available translation.  The application needs to restart to be able to implement the changes.
Available languages are: English, Arabic, Bengali, Chinese, Czech, Dutch, Filipino, French German, Greek, Hindi, Hungarian, Indonesian, Italian, Japanese, Korean, Malayalam, Persian, Polish, Portuguese, Romanian, Punjabi, Russian, Spanish, Thai, Turkish, Ukrainian, Urdu, Vietnamese.


User Interface
Theme: The default application UI theme is white and green.  There are 4 theme choices you can select depending on your preference.  The 4 themes are:


Classic Light
legendary
Activity: 3010
Merit: 1280
Get $2100 deposit bonuses & 60 FS
Bitcointalk Profile Link: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/serjent05-230934
Bitcointalk Rank: Legendary
BTC address for payouts: bc1q0cxdq855d4y8k4220d0zk8jqr3ccc9uakg7raf
Utopia Public Key for CRP payouts: F4C105F903F3EE2812A3700C331A7E2DB56F36A43655CD724CCC8F0C05ABF648
legendary
Activity: 2086
Merit: 1282
Logo Designer ⛨ BSFL Division1
I installed Utopia P2P software on my computer and it's good to see there are so many things in one software, but this could be confusing and overwhelming for many new members who want to try it.
I recommend going through welcome tour first and selecting dark or light theme you like most, and tweak settings for more customization.
I like the look of classic Utopia mail style but I think this can't be used to send normal emails and it can be used only for communicating with other Utopia members.
They say everything is encrypted so Utopia can be used for encrypted text, voice and e-mail communication, but I didn't try testing this to see how it works.
There is no central servers and IP addresses are not revealed but I think this need to be more simple for people to use it.
I couldn't found on desktop how I can make voice calls to other members, so maybe this is available only on mobile, or it's hidden somewhere in this clunky interface.
Maybe this is IM, so I added few members from forum and sent them request and message, but I received no answer so far.
This could be great if it works well on mobile phones, as secure private alternative for WhatsApp, Viber or Telegram.
There is no central servers with Utopia so it could be slower and I want to see if it works for making voice calls with someone in other country without problems or breaks.
Utopia needed a lot of memory on my computer so maybe it needs some optimizations to work on older computers.

I created new card with 3 CRP but I didn't manage to spend this low amount on any of the websites I saw.
If I do this in next few days I will update this post with more details and how it worked for me.

I visited some channels and joined FIFA world cup Qatar 2022 that was more active recently, and it's similar like discord or telegram.
I can talk with other people, send files and I see there was prediction competition for winning 500 CPR if you correctly predicted world cup winner.

There is two games available chess and poker, and I can play this with other members if I select my contacts.
Maybe this could be useful for creating some competition tournaments in future.

Utopia is sometimes working slower, so it's better to close tabs that you are not using.
I want to see adding P2P exchange inside Utopia if possible but this would make it even slower, so maybe releasing as separate app would be good to have.
Maybe Utopia team can create light and full version Utopia, or add beginner and expert button, to hide all extra features that confuse even experienced users sometimes.

hero member
Activity: 1680
Merit: 787
Anyway, the Crypton currency of Utopia is already accepted at 1800+ online stores.

Yes, I know it. The most important job of the Utopia team right now is just Marketing, too many good projects out there have failed due to a lack of movement from the marketing side. We hope to see significant developments from the marketing side of the Utopia ecosystem in the coming months. I also intend to invest some of my money in the $CRP token.
sr. member
Activity: 2282
Merit: 470
Telegram: @jperryC
@joeperry, That's right the number of active users, right? If so, why didn't the Utopia team try to make more of it by creating an in-app program? I have a suggestion regarding this before.
I am not sure how many active users but I am sure that it is increasing and the Utopia were doing a great job in improving and promoting the project.  About the peers (Network Eye) they are around 14-18 as I logged in it keeps the system, all transaction, network activity, etc. to be safe. As for @Edwardard a 2FA in-app program is also a good idea.

Anyway, the Crypton currency of Utopia is already accepted at 1800+ online stores.
hero member
Activity: 1680
Merit: 787
The problem with Utopia P2P Ecosystem is very simple - there are not enough people, who use it. If there are let's say 300 - 400 active users, it's nothing. Even this forum have a lot more people. So the best way would be just finish Utopia project.
P.S. PM me for my Bitcoin address for reward.

You need to read the T&C first before participating, mate. Besides that, this review campaign is only intended for a minimum of Sr. Member and also Hero/Legendary. But about active users, I think I quite agree with you, even now online I see only 14 peers.


Source: Utopia Ecosystem App

@joeperry, That's right the number of active users, right? If so, why didn't the Utopia team try to make more of it by creating an in-app program? I have a suggestion regarding this before.

Another thing that caught my attention about the Utopia desktop version is that there are games, there are chess games and also poker, for poker games, I see that we need $CRP to play (for betting purposes), I think that it would be great if in the future there is a Utopia campaign on board Gambling to introduce this game, LOL.
jr. member
Activity: 66
Merit: 8
The problem with Utopia P2P Ecosystem is very simple - there are not enough people, who use it. If there are let's say 300 - 400 active users, it's nothing. Even this forum have a lot more people. So the best way would be just finish Utopia project.
P.S. PM me for my Bitcoin address for reward.
sr. member
Activity: 798
Merit: 253
Hello, I really liked your project. I would like to participate
Bitcointalk Profile Link: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/maximtitov-897260
Bitcointalk Rank: sr. Member
BTC address for payouts: bc1q26w5k834f4td40vf8eh0r97m7242qw2cs9f0uu
Utopia Public Key for CRP payouts: 9AF24820C0BCF40C8C10B0BC1A21DFF87ABCD32CC2E19F72864DD4B8F2F91B43
legendary
Activity: 966
Merit: 1042
#SWGT CERTIK Audited
Bitcointalk Profile Link: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/hamza2424-2811340
Bitcointalk Rank: SR Member
BTC address for payouts: bc1qj0c53t3flpfu6srhwce8er6elmv6fgplxnk4kq
Utopia Public Key for CRP payouts: E1B0C552BA727BCBDCE9F5560490E623748F671F178EE4EAE05EC6D44811CC2A
legendary
Activity: 2338
Merit: 1261
Heisenberg
Bitcointalk Profile Link: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/jerometash-1190631
Bitcointalk Rank: Hero Member
BTC address for payouts: bc1qye46xa893xjalp7jprl99evk27jmxlul3c4y77
Utopia Public Key for CRP payouts: CE68FE490EDD87BC4C4343DC319A17491C1CD3495B75CF0E67A2B44B8F7F685A
legendary
Activity: 2702
Merit: 3045
Top Crypto Casino
Bitcointalk Profile Link: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/khaled0111-1012655
Bitcointalk Rank: Legendary
BTC address for payouts: bc1q86rclrx6dme5zd9u4qnvl9e4p9wfnn4aj3pyka
Utopia Public Key for CRP payouts: D578515AC320A452182D41E4D3195D958810C460C8212BE31E17F68409B9A626
hero member
Activity: 3178
Merit: 977
www.Crypto.Games: Multiple coins, multiple games
Review:

- Downloaded and checked both the android and Windows versions successfully without any issues. I felt that the android version was lacking in many areas which is understandable considering the fact that it's still in beta mode at the moment. The Windows version on the other hand felt far more robust and packed with features in comparison.

- The welcome page in the Windows version explained everything perfectly in an easy to understand manner and the option to hide it is another plus point. It took sometime to synchronize everything, but it didn't take too long. Checked my profile right away and edited my avatar and message quickly. It was easy to find the public and private keys through the interface. I noticed that @suzanne5223 posted that an alternative to using the public key in order to communicate with other members would be helpful, but an alternate solution is actually already available. The profile section specifies primary uNS as an alternative to public keys which is very helpful.

- One thing that I didn't like about this software is that it consumes way too many memory resources affecting system usage. I have an i3 11th gen with 8GB DDR4 RAM and 512GB SSD which struggled a bit when running Chrome in the foreground and Utopia in the background. This issue needs to be addressed asap in my opinion.

- I used my 5 CRP to create a crypto card where 3 CRP for fees was pretty reasonable. Alternate card designs need to be added in further customise the card. However, I was disappointed by the high fees necessary to  customise certain aspects of the card which need to be lowered to a more reasonable amount.

- Didn't encounter any issues with uMail and it reminds me of Gmail in several ways which is a good thing. On the other hand, the idyll browser is completely idle since I couldn't access any site through it and the design needs some work too. I like the addition of games like Chess and Poker, but we should be able to play them solo against bots instead of depending on other people.

- Checked out the Crypton exchange which felt quite similar to Yobit in some ways. Registration was a breeze thanks to automatic authorization by the Windows Utopia Client. I switched to dark mode immediately which made the exchange look a lot better and I advise setting it as the default mode.

- Overall, I would like to conclude by saying that the Windows version of Utopia is in a great state at the moment, but it needs more optimizations in some of the areas that I mentioned in order to become more efficient and effective in the long-term.
legendary
Activity: 2086
Merit: 1282
Logo Designer ⛨ BSFL Division1
Bitcointalk Profile Link: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/notblox1-2015418
Bitcointalk Rank: Legendary
BTC address for payouts: bc1qa2jp8cl9qjlzqg6a0h4mv0fnaw9gw8clw23vp3
Utopia Public Key for CRP payouts: 39619732172D4D6C2B8F374C3FBAF46E1FFDA949D2618713EF2E7398A05B0127
sr. member
Activity: 2282
Merit: 470
Telegram: @jperryC
We are still accepting reviews, your honest reviews will be appreciated.
hero member
Activity: 2660
Merit: 651
Want top-notch marketing for your project, Hire me
Here is my evaluation of the desktop application and features of the Utopia ecosystem.


SITE

I like the site UI/UX, the intro, and the manifesto The project message and benefit are clear but lack the link to the project social media account link I don't know if its part of the project team plan at least 2 more social media accounts link will do.


THE APP CLIENT

I check the mobile app I can see that it is still in the Beta stage so, I try the desktop application and the installation was nice. I like the Welcome message which narrative almost every feature that will be found on the application. I try to register the account offline and I can see it's not possible because the response I get is "Make sure your computer is connected to the Internet or local network with Utopia peers". It will be nice if the team does something about this because of people that like to register an account offline.

After the installation, the first thing I check is how to back up the application fund and I can see that the Utopia application enable the use of Private key, seeds, and Encrypted container backup but there's no official documentation about private keys, and seeds importation. This need to be fixed since the project was said to be easy to use for tech and nontech savvy.

uMESSENDER and uMAIL
I believe the team needs to make communication more flexible by making it easy for people to contact/connect through the use of a username without the need for a public key just like how people connected with friends years ago through the use of BBM pin. In addition, the team needs to add features that will allow the message sender to know that the messages sent are delivered and read by the receiver.


uCHANNEL

Everything about this area is good except that there's no way users can edit, correct, or delete their sent message in Channel in case there's a typo.

MINING
The mining appears to be okay and I like the Utopia Mining Bots created by the team to facilitate good mining activities.

IDYLL BROWSER

The is nice and it was said to be an advanced Tor browser. I try to go to Google on the browser but it not going through and I later find out that some sites are not accessible on the browser but it will be nice if the browser enables users to browse the internet without the barrier of sites because there are some new launch privacy browser that enables this already and if Utopia wants their Idyll browser to be ahead of competitor they need to make the browser work for all site and there should also be a way to check the browser privacy level. For example, when I make use of a VPN I use ip2location and whoer to check the IP quality provided by the VPN.

API FOR DEVELOPER

I like the fact the project has features that support the API for the developer's benefit in case they wanted to integrate privacy payment on their web services, etc.

CRYPTON EXCHANGE

I like the exchange trading activities. No cap, the time span of the whole trading execution is world class but the exchange needs to list more cryptocurrencies and if it is possible, adding no registration features will be nice since some members of this forum like it.


TALK.U.IS
It will be nice if the activation of account donations is removed to increase the site traffic.


uWALLET

I like what I see in this section but the team can still add more features that will improve user experience though. Having said that, making a payment with the use of CRP coin through the listed merchants is not possible after following the instruction provided on the Utopia p2p website. This is what is shown on your site

But this is what Perfect Money provided when I am trying to pay with CRP.

SUMMARY
The idea of the project is good and I see it as one of the ecosystem people will use in the future for privacy but they need to amend the use of CRP as online payment, especially in the list of merchants, and make every website accessible through Idyll browser, add more coin to the Crypton Exchange, provide insight documentation about uWallet importation to prevent lose of user funds and add a feature that allows edit/delete of message send in the public uChannel.




hero member
Activity: 1638
Merit: 576
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
Overview
Having toured through the Utopia Ecosystem, from the app to the exchange, to the Utalk and more. I will not fail to commend the brains behind the Utopia Ecosystem. It is a project capable of leading the long awaited world of privacy even though many people have long sacrificed their privacy on the alter of ignorance.

Launch on system startup
I discovered that after installing the Utopia app and used it. The next time I started my system Utopia automatically launched and asked me for login. For a privacy centred Ecosystem I think it should be disabled. Not cool to be the first thing anyone would see on the computer .Though I turned it off myself.

Backing up seed phrase
I decided to backup my seedphrase and the process was easy going, but at a time the easy flow was disrupted, making me to cancel the process twice unintentionally. During installation, the next button is always at the right side while the previous/cancel at the left. But the reverse was done here.


Idyll having troubles finding name
On seeing this feature I felt I have seen something I would use instead of Tor. But on typing Google.com, it didn't work, I tried Bitcointalk.org and it didn't work.
I made further research to understand that idyll opens only websites hosted on Utopia Ecosystem.
I tried Crp.is and https:Utopia and it didn't work. Followed the proxy settings and got frustrated at a time.

Crypton vs UUSD
Two big projects at a time. Would have wanted cryptonto compete with Monero before UUSD comes. But both are doing well.

Access to API documentation is possible only after enabling the API option
After I got around this, I got a list of APIs, I thought it would return a promise I could use in my project and pay some crypton, but still getting around this although. But I don't think the API can be used outside the ecosystem.

Why crypto exchange not in the Utopia ecosystem?
Thought it would be a good idea to add it to the menu bar, such that a click on it will take one to the exchange. Thereby reducing the stress of having to sign up separately on the exchange. In the exchange, the live chat at the side bar needs a timestamp to track the conversations.

RECOMMENDATIONS

1. This ecosystem is too large and I believe since 2019, versions upon versions have been released. Because it's like to me that what would be even upto the next 10 versions are already incorporated.
2. Make video clips tutorials and give it a space at the header in the menu, such that anyone who clicks it will have a video tutorials on idyll browser, uwallet, Umining etc. Complexity resists adoption.
3. How about if all parts of the system didn't go private at same time, it could be little by little. I mean if idyll browser could work for bitcointalk, I would be sure of using Utopia Ecosystem everyday.
4. I have seen your arguments in FAQs on why Utopia isn't an open source software, in order to avoid a divided community through forkings. Well, in the future Utopia may decide to reconsider. With the level of privacy paraded in Utopia, closed source may be a shadow of the core value of the ecosystem.

I rest here for other reviewers to take on, I am now a member of the ecosystem.
hero member
Activity: 1050
Merit: 681
they will need the actual file (DB file) and should know the password in order to open the Utopia account and connect to the CRP.is exchange site.
Logging in into crp.is doesnt ask for a DB file or anything as such. Just pub. key and password for me.
I agree with BitDane, maybe we should add an additional layer of security like phone number verification whenever a new device attempts to sign in? But this will kill the whole idea of utopia's ecosysten being anonymous. Is it possible to sell out a private unique phone number for anyone interested and which can be just used on utopia ecosystem (just like what telegram is doing)? Or just google 2fa? Or Maybe utopia build their own 2FA app like google's authenticator? A new factor in the ecosystem 🙂
sr. member
Activity: 1372
Merit: 348
Even though the experience of using the exchange is great, I still think that we need more layer of security like 2fa because I still think that an account can be hacked if someone happen to know your public key and happen to guess the right password.
Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think even if the people knows your PK they won't be able to access your account as they will need the actual file (DB file) and should know the password in order to open the Utopia account and connect to the CRP.is exchange site.

In other words, people cannot hacked your account even if they know your PK or password but they can hack you if they get your DB file and open it with your password. I think the 2FA in UMail is a good option too.

You can log in on CRP.is even with the P2P ecosystem is offline.  It only needs public key and our password to log in, I just tried it now.


edit:

sorry for the late reply I was finishing my user feedback post
sr. member
Activity: 2282
Merit: 470
Telegram: @jperryC
Even though the experience of using the exchange is great, I still think that we need more layer of security like 2fa because I still think that an account can be hacked if someone happen to know your public key and happen to guess the right password.
Correct me if I'm wrong but I don't think even if the people knows your PK they won't be able to access your account as they will need the actual file (DB file) and should know the password in order to open the Utopia account and connect to the CRP.is exchange site.

In other words, people cannot hacked your account even if they know your PK or password but they can hack you if they get your DB file and open it with your password. I think the 2FA in UMail is a good option too.
Pages:
Jump to:
© 2020, Bitcointalksearch.org