Author

Topic: [XMR] Monero - A secure, private, untraceable cryptocurrency - page 1016. (Read 4671497 times)

legendary
Activity: 1092
Merit: 1000
They've credited XMR sent without payment ID manually a lot of times. Many such cases were reported in this and other Monero threads, but you need to have the relevant information about the transaction.

The discussion is about unclaimed XMR, do we let them keep it or do we ask for an audit, make them keep an updated unclaimed amount public + introduce a new policy that allows them to redirect the funds to development group the community chooses (does not have to be the official dev team).
hero member
Activity: 794
Merit: 1000
Monero (XMR) - secure, private, untraceable
They've credited XMR sent without payment ID manually a lot of times. Many such cases were reported in this and other Monero threads, but you need to have the relevant information about the transaction.
legendary
Activity: 1092
Merit: 1000
I've sent coins to Poloniex without a payment ID a bunch of times (embarrassing, I know) and I've merely opened a support ticket, given them the relevant info, and they've manually processed the deposit for me.

Are you saying the dev team is not interested?
Perhaps prominent third-party app developers (xmr.to, jajotek, etc.) would accept if we got the unclaimed funds pointed their way...
donator
Activity: 1274
Merit: 1060
GetMonero.org / MyMonero.com
I've sent (on accident) coins to poloniex and they've 'disappeared' - never again.
4AqrzGPfEKeZrVXyPDNXUrNeKZZGNYiXMDoY49PvdffKNTRg6xp2Qz74SZ72gT5F9HH8Vaic99ndRg6 UBGcVijaNStQjwwf

This was a few months ago and i've learned my lesson with a painful loss.


I've sent coins to Poloniex without a payment ID a bunch of times (embarrassing, I know) and I've merely opened a support ticket, given them the relevant info, and they've manually processed the deposit for me.
G2M
sr. member
Activity: 280
Merit: 250
Activity: 616
Nice missive, I haven't used the GUI since a long time and am going to try it out again over the weekend.
hero member
Activity: 509
Merit: 500
I've sent (on accident) coins to poloniex and they've 'disappeared' - never again.
4AqrzGPfEKeZrVXyPDNXUrNeKZZGNYiXMDoY49PvdffKNTRg6xp2Qz74SZ72gT5F9HH8Vaic99ndRg6 UBGcVijaNStQjwwf

This was a few months ago and i've learned my lesson with a painful loss.
full member
Activity: 231
Merit: 100

Then why isn't it poloniex's coins? Everyone can claim them, and no one can claim them. Thus only the ones who control the keys can claim them. I am not stating, but moreso asking for the sake of getting that disscussion going. (I agree that they should/could instil community spirit and donate the coins to the development.)
 
Not spending them does not equal thievery as has been alluded to elsewhere.

Not spending them, says who ? Where's the current unclaimed xmr balance on polo, why isn't it public ?
Sure, they can keep them but we can all switch to some other exchange. 80% of their volume is XMR so yeah, there's that.


Point of a private and untraceable currency, neh?

How do you lose your customers (who buy and sell anonymous crypto currency on your exchange) quickest? By exposing information, or by withholding information?

If they start to reveal balances in any sort of way, they will lose so much business.
legendary
Activity: 1092
Merit: 1000

Then why isn't it poloniex's coins? Everyone can claim them, and no one can claim them. Thus only the ones who control the keys can claim them. I am not stating, but moreso asking for the sake of getting that disscussion going. (I agree that they should/could instil community spirit and donate the coins to the development.)
 
Not spending them does not equal thievery as has been alluded to elsewhere.

Not spending them, says who ? Where's the current unclaimed xmr balance on polo, why isn't it public ?
Sure, they can keep them but we can all switch to some other exchange. 80% of their volume is XMR so yeah, there's that.
full member
Activity: 231
Merit: 100

We as a community need to do something about POLONIEX keeping the unclaimed XMR for themselves.
Tens of thousands of XMR have been sent from pools to poloniex without the paymentID, these coins can never be claimed and we can't let poloniex just keep them! 

Lets first force them to publish total unclaimed XMR balance, then we push for a new policy - if not claimed within two months all unclaimed coins go to the DEV TEAM

At this point I consider poloniex straight out scammers, they have never addressed this issue.


See, what if they give them away to the devs, and later the rightful owners come claiming the xmr?

I have no affiliation with poloniex, but they did honour the btc stolen during the hack a while ago.

Doesn't work like that, coins sent from pools (txs) are public, no one/everyone can claim them.

Then why isn't it poloniex's coins? Everyone can claim them, and no one can claim them. Thus only the ones who control the keys can claim them. I am not stating, but moreso asking for the sake of getting that disscussion going. (I agree that they should/could instil community spirit and donate the coins to the development.)
 
Not spending them does not equal thievery as has been alluded to elsewhere.
legendary
Activity: 1092
Merit: 1000

We as a community need to do something about POLONIEX keeping the unclaimed XMR for themselves.
Tens of thousands of XMR have been sent from pools to poloniex without the paymentID, these coins can never be claimed and we can't let poloniex just keep them!  

Lets first force them to publish total unclaimed XMR balance, then we push for a new policy - if not claimed within two months all unclaimed coins go to the DEV TEAM

At this point I consider poloniex straight out scammers, they have never addressed this issue.


See, what if they give them away to the devs, and later the rightful owners come claiming the xmr?

I have no affiliation with poloniex, but they did honour the btc stolen during the hack a while ago.

Doesn't work like that, coins sent from pools (txs) are public, no one/everyone can claim them.

try this one address, moneropool.com/any pool
47sghzufGhJJDQEbScMCwVBimTuq6L5JiRixD8VeGbpjCTA12noXmi4ZyBZLc99e66NtnKff34fHsGR oyZk3ES1s1V4QVcB

All gone to polo, never to be claimed.
full member
Activity: 231
Merit: 100

We as a community need to do something about POLONIEX keeping the unclaimed XMR for themselves.
Tens of thousands of XMR have been sent from pools to poloniex without the paymentID, these coins can never be claimed and we can't let poloniex just keep them! 

Lets first force them to publish total unclaimed XMR balance, then we push for a new policy - if not claimed within two months all unclaimed coins go to the DEV TEAM

At this point I consider poloniex straight out scammers, they have never addressed this issue.


See, what if they give them away to the devs, and later the rightful owners come claiming the xmr?

I have no affiliation with poloniex, but they did honour the btc stolen during the hack a while ago.
hero member
Activity: 672
Merit: 500
Lets first force them to publish total unclaimed XMR balance, then we push for a new policy - if not claimed within two months all unclaimed coins go to the DEV TEAM

Good idea
legendary
Activity: 1092
Merit: 1000

We as a community need to do something about POLONIEX keeping the unclaimed XMR for themselves.
Tens of thousands of XMR have been sent from pools to poloniex without the paymentID, these coins can never be claimed and we can't let poloniex just keep them! 

Lets first force them to publish total unclaimed XMR balance, then we push for a new policy - if not claimed within two months all unclaimed coins go to the DEV TEAM

At this point I consider poloniex straight out scammers, they have never addressed this issue.
legendary
Activity: 1596
Merit: 1030
Sine secretum non libertas
If I read correctly, there was an effort to raise 200k USD for it? I really fail to see why this would require 200k USD (?)... Is it a "downsized" version? What am I missing?

Theymos hired a company to build a new forum for 1.5 million

The comparison is notable, but the association is one I would avoid.  FP's project seems considerably more ... useful.

IIRC devs generally cost about 600/diem, and produce about 20 lines in a day over the long-run.  But since we're talking about FP, we'll budget 1k/diem and demand 200 lines daily, so I would expect to pay 1.35mm for 270kloc of de novo code.  Probably the project uses a fair proportion of cutnpaste from elsewhere (legit, and adding value to the project, but not a large proportion of the labor) so that number should be derated -- for conservativism in valuation with large unknowns and no diligence budget, we'll derate aggressively, 50%.  Looks to me like it would cost at least 500k $US to reproduce that project.  If I were a coin investor,  and wanted my coin to see real economic use, I would feel very good about spending 200k and getting that in the process.
hero member
Activity: 672
Merit: 500
If I read correctly, there was an effort to raise 200k USD for it? I really fail to see why this would require 200k USD (?)... Is it a "downsized" version? What am I missing?

Theymos hired a company to build a new forum for 1.5 million
sr. member
Activity: 462
Merit: 500
Does anybody have  Jojatekoks donation address...BTC or XMR?

It's in his sig:

Code:
Monero  (XMR): 47hK4gehaMrFTQCiV5FEmM54hpqTrdHudb9nUBG88NicBDpxH4TGuh3TmW84Dc6dpMiEiBLGvJCuT3xC3LNHctmx7mG8NLM
Bitcoin (BTC): 14wHehBtFt321WTV15khon8Juaxh9drnfJ


Can check here:
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/xmr-monerox-a-cross-platform-graphical-account-manager-for-monero-683365

Thanks
legendary
Activity: 3164
Merit: 1116
Does anybody have  Jojatekoks donation address...BTC or XMR?

It's in his sig:

Code:
Monero  (XMR): 47hK4gehaMrFTQCiV5FEmM54hpqTrdHudb9nUBG88NicBDpxH4TGuh3TmW84Dc6dpMiEiBLGvJCuT3xC3LNHctmx7mG8NLM
Bitcoin (BTC): 14wHehBtFt321WTV15khon8Juaxh9drnfJ


Can check here:
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/xmr-monerox-a-cross-platform-graphical-account-manager-for-monero-683365
sr. member
Activity: 462
Merit: 500
Does anybody have  Jojatekoks donation address...BTC or XMR?
legendary
Activity: 3164
Merit: 1116
legendary
Activity: 2968
Merit: 1198
can someone explain to me what i am looking at?

An altcoin payment processor that settles on the back in BTC and/or XMR.

If I read correctly, there was an effort to raise 200k USD for it? I really fail to see why this would require 200k USD (?)... Is it a "downsized" version? What am I missing?

200k is hardly an excessive amount of startup capital for a business like this. Not only do you need to build the application, test it, and deploy it, but you to continue operating until you at least have a chance to ramp up the tiny per-transaction fee volume and begin covering operating expenses from revenue (and that is assuming you didn't operate for a while on a fee-free basis in order to sign accounts). If you went to VC investors with a business model like this and asked for much less than 200K (assuming no other source of capital) they should reject you with extreme prejudice because you have no idea what you are doing.
Jump to: