Topic: [XMR] Monero - A secure, private, untraceable cryptocurrency - page 1580. (Read 4670972 times)

Monero is the best coin I've seen in a while. I'm patiently waiting straight working GUI to tell it to my friends. They don't get it if it has only cmd mode wallet.

Oh I'm quite happy with the weekly Missive, and I had no intention of complaining at the communication efforts from the core dev team. They key point I wanted to get across, is particularly addressed at the global Monero community (my peers), and how we generally address newcomers. Repeating below, with selective emphasis:

I think that it is consensual that the average user has a bit of a learning curve to deal with when first getting into monero as it is, so I kindly ask that we all try to be as friendly as possible to any newcomers and newbies.

On the upthread points about development & usability, I'll just add that I have no doubt that the core dev team has their priorities in good order. I'm eagerly looking forward to each item on the dev diary reaching upcoming milestones. 

Keep up the good work!
~ Myagui

There's still a ton of work to be done till this is remotely feasible. Can you imagine if we had the world's most beautiful cross-platform wallet right now, but to use it you need several gigabytes of available memory, and it'll max out your 20mbps line?

Moreover, if Monero is to be treated by users as a private, secure, untraceable cryptocurrency, we need to be more certain of those three aspects. We are reasonably assured right now, but there is still a great deal of cryptanalysis and threat modelling that is lacking due to the inherited reference code. We cannot be lackadaisical with this, as it is other people's money we will be putting at risk.

Edit: that's not to say we aren't actively working on things that improve usability, but there are fundamentals that are more important before we can focus on - and drive - usability. I understand this may be at-odds with other cryptocurrencies who are given the silver platter of 5+ years of Bitcoin development by forking it, but we do not have that luxury.

+1 to this.

I feel Monero is rapidly heading into the "user-friendly" proportion of crypto users. Not everybody is comfortable with CLI wallets and we need to accept that. When a good 95% of other alts out there are Qt-based - with a nice shiny front-end GUI with logos and taskbar icons and cross-platform compatability for use on shiny MacBooks, Microsoft Surface tablets and desktop Windows units, which users know how to use and abuse - when these users are then confronted with Monero - a (at first glance) CLI-only wallet, I don't think anyone can blame them for being surprised. I was, when I first opened the wallet, and I use CLI every single day at work. I think the cries for an official GUI are warranted - those users who have no technical background and are only into cryptos for the trading aspect are not going to appreciate the CLI interface. The sad truth is there are a lot of users who come from this background. The high rollers with the huge BTC wallets are those users. Day traders and investors are often not technical - they come from banking, stocks and shares professions. They may not have the time nor the patience to get to grips with the CLI. They just want something that works and works well. Qt (for the most part) provides that and I think Monero is loosing out a bit in that regard.

This is my opinion, this isn't fact. Whilst we can say "learn to use the CLI" or "just go and get the unofficial .NET or Qt wallet" that won't stop people who don't have the time/don't want to use an unofficial client abandoning Monero. Usability is a huge factor in any product when it comes to uptake from the consumer. The wallet being CLI-only isn't a problem as such but it is something to discuss long-term. If we don't want to attract users that don't want to learn how to use the CLI then who do we want to attract? And does that then mean that Monero is only for a certain user group and not for everyone?

Points to mull over I suppose.

I think monero devs are doing quite good work with communication. The problem is the altcoin world, where 48 hours of no movement (meaning "rangebound +/- 10%") means that the coin is pronounced dead.

Of course communication can always be done better, like I also exhorted upthread, concernign the usage of donations.

Agreed, which is why we have the weekly Monero Missive so that nobody has to check the various github forks:)

Sure: we've published the view key for the donation wallet precisely so there can be transparency (although, admittedly, the tooling does not exist as yet for anyone to peek in). The core team all decide together when money has to be spent.

A typical example could be where a team member wants to spend 20 hours working on Monero in a week. This necessitates them not spending those 20 hours working on their "normal" stuff that makes sure they can pay their bills at the end of the month. In this event, they can indicate the minimum rate necessary for them to recoup this lost income, and it is paid out of the dev donations.

Similarly, the cost of bandwidth used to serve blockchain downloads is heavy. We are moving those to infrastructure on unmetered ports, but that infrastructure also carries a cost.

Of course, since the donations have been slow, 90% of this is typically paid by those of us in the core team that have funds on-hand, in the hopes of recouping them at some point in the future.

Every expenditure is noted. We will likely make this public in some form in the future, but that will be subsequent to us receiving legal and financial advice as to the tax and privacy implications in doing so.

Checking Github is all fine and good, but we should also take into account that not everyone will be able to understand progress by checking a dev repository. I think that it is consensual that the average user has a bit of a learning curve to deal with when first getting into monero as it is, so I kindly ask that we all try to be as friendly as possible to any newcomers and newbies.

Confession: I find it difficult sometimes to distinguish newcomers/newbies from the more elaborate/graceful FUD posters (if there is such a thing). The former deserve our inclusion efforts, the latter, well, we should just ignore them and appreciate the thread bump 

~ Myagui

Well, this springs to mind:

That to me seems like someone is a bit over-edgy about the status of this coin. I don't think anyone who wasn't paranoid would immediately jump to those conclusions.

I set up some guidelines in the donation thread, one is the accountability and transparency in the use of donations:
- who decides how money is spent
- who spends it
- how is it accounted for and monitored.

I kindly ask the devteam to write a few lines about this, so I feel much better to donate and promote others to do so.

EDIT: I don't have any distrust towards Monero devs, but there's a certain Forum that calls me Donator for the reason that I donated 10 BTC to them and none of it has been used for anything useful, as far as I know.

someone seems a bit paranoid

We have a Monero Missive once a week with updates. The last update was last week, the next one will be this week:)

Donations have been slow, which does make things tricky, but there has certainly been no lack of movement on things, as the Missive and the dev diary always do detail.

That would be smart.

First time to XMR community.It's a big and strong community,hope i can get sth

We dont need news in mainstream, in my experience as an underground DJ, i find it more effective when we explain things in person... Just like good music, u cant find it mainstream... More people try to do it that way, the more we all win... Mainstream can just polute the train of thoughts for some (network effect can be obtained in several ways)...

Just a thought from another perspective, market may not behave in this way...

All this effort expended by the trolls trolling Monero is very Bullish.  Encourages me to get more.

In case anyone wonders why am i newbie account posting here, i am long time lurker, BC bagholder, found out about XMR soon after launching, shy on interwebz, but decided to go out and share his thoughts with the crypto world.

My mind was blown by the Bitcoin idea in early 2013 (yeah, my country is centuries behind the world), and started researching, found about this forum, lurked some threads, and found about essential investment logic with which i can stick with. XMR felt so natural to follow.
Crypto is to stay, improve, and "rule" the next generations to come.

I believe crypto needs something like Monero (XMR) in the upcoming months (or any better anon candidate, but i dont see any other), watching the happenings around the globe, economy crash, wars all around, Gaza genocide, HAARP usage, all kinds off things...

My (substantial) mining investment will stay here with XMR until someone (like AnonyMint) comes up with something that blows our minds, again.


Sorry for my english, its not my native language.

PQ

Forgive me for my noobness, but isn't YAM miner CPU only?

I would strongly suggest yvg1900's (https://twitter.com/yvg1900) YAM miner.  1% fee (you can set the fee yourself, but not below 1%), and better performance then Claymore's (plus... has a linux version).

YAM Miner version M7v (link to post on twitter feed)

Contact Wolf0 (https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/wolf0-80740 he also has an unfinished OpenCL miner in progress.