I think CryptoKingdom needs its own 'discussion' thread separate from the main CK thread, and separate from the main monero ones. I don't want to clog up the CK thread with more 'speculation' on the CK economics, but it is VERY interesting to discuss, and probably one of the most promising 'killer' apps' for crypto (i.e. gaming). After drugs, porn etc, gaming seems like the most obvious growth market, and CK is a pioneer, and the economics inside CK are 'real' in a sense, and so deserving of serious discussion.
Previously I had doubts that 1000 XMR invested in CK property could ever outperform 1000 XMR in a wallet (CKG is another story), but now I am unsure. If CK property ever pays rent or dividends, then through compounding the 1000 XMR invested in property *might* end up outperforming wallet XMR. My initial reservation was due to XMR being locked inside Ck (i.e. no withdrawals), but if one assumes CK will thrive and prosper, and players can freely buy/sell property, then CK property becomes just another digital asset and store of value, similar to bitcoin, but unlike other PoW coins, XMR invested in CK property *might* earn interest or dividends, almost like PoS. I don't know if that is planned, but it would change the equation some what.
CK needs a speculation/discussion thread!
As I'm even less qualified to start a CKG speculation thread, so I'll just make one last post here, because i really wanted to respond to this post. While I was arguing about this earlier, I had to think of all of this as well, and I concluded that it's simply not sustainable.
land, etc, *might* be worth more now than they were when the game started. But that is temporary. YOu need many new players to feed this kind of a growth, i.e it's ponzi-like. Once the number of new players bringing in new money is less than a certain amount, the value of in game items will necessarily grow slower, stop growing completely, or even lose value. It's not exactly a ponzi-scam though, because it's a game; it's not supposed to give you profit. Very early-adopters might make some, but they are pretty much the only ones.
The game will only receive a total of X amount of currency in its lifetime, and that money will all slowly go to the main game content issuer, i.e the king. The money circulating in the game will necessarily decrease from X, until it reaches 0, unless this game continues forever, which is quite doubtful.
You are right, I also compared CKG to just another digital property, but it's not like bitcoin, it's more like Ripple, with a great insta-mine in fact, unless the game competely takes off (say 1 million players, quite doubtful), the insta-mine will be 99.99...% of the total supply for the forseeable future. In a sense, it's funny how people are so suspicious of darkcoin's "insta-mine" but support CK so much.
For me, I'm not necessarily against insta-mine. Devs deserve to be rewarded for their efforts. But I think we need to recognize accurately what something is, and not be deceived into thinking it's something different.