The math that is supposed to be supporting this coin is complete shit. Please explain your thoughts on the following.
a.) If 50 btc worth of loans are given out... that's 50,000 BNT as collateral or only 0.06% of supply. If we have a thought experiment and say none of these loans are paid back, and ALL of the collateral is burned, it would still leave 99.94% of the coins which can be dumped on Bittrex Exchange. The coin is not backed by the loans at all if the entire loan system can fail and have zero effect on the supply or the BNT/BTC market.
b.) There are 40 BNT mined per block, so miners can continue dumping for a long time. Selling pressure will remain high if whales do not come in and pump-N-dump it.
c.) Five percent interest is not a lot of revenue. If only a very small portion of loans fail to be repaid, it would more than negate all of the revenue from every other loan.
-- You loan 50 BTC out at 0.2 BTC per person. 250 people get a loan, and you hope to gain 5% on that 50 BTC which would be 2.5 BTC profit. For this system to work, you would need more than 95% of loans to repay in full, plus interest. If 96% of people repay their loans, you would only profit 0.5 BTC of the 2.5 BTC you originally were fighting for. The 96% number I also personally find impossible when looking at BTC loan competitor sites like BTCJam.
If less than 95% of people who receive a loan pay it back, you have zero revenue coming in to support the buying price and are also losing some of the 50 BTC originally budgeted. On a long term, either something is missing in this equation or the coin is doomed to fail. Please enlighten us devs?
@BantamSystems correct me if i am wrong but i will try to answer some of this question from what i saw:
a.) your math is wrong, here's why: in first round i did put 2000BNT collateral and need to keep min 1000BNT locked in wallet for 0.2BTC loan. let say you get for 10000BNT (probably 20000BNT+) and need to keep 1000BNT locked for 1BTC that makes 50BTC loan worth 550000BNT / 500000 collateral and 50000 locked / that's 70-80% of currently available supply if you don't count Bantam reserve..
b.) also wrong: there are atm 24033 mined POW/POS Blocks * 45BNT/block makes total 1081485BNTposible
but because of the POS eating POW blocks there are -30%+ less Coins mined.. currently at 726106BNT total meaning 355000BNT less than possible. as POS continues there will be even less coins mined. again if you don't count Bantam reserve.
c.) all depends how valuable BNT will become, it could be a good business for BantamSystem
-t